Presto
Issue: 1927 2126 - Page 19
PRESTO-TIMES
April 30, 1927.
PIANO FACTORY M STORE SUPPLIES
PERKINS GLUE DECISION
Circuit Court of Appeals for Sixth Circuit Re-
verses All Previous Decisions and Finds
for Perkins Glue Co.
The Perkins Glue Company, patentees of Perkins
Vegetable Glue, South Bend, Ind., under date of April
12, makes an announcement to all users and pros-
pective users of vegetable glue, believing they will
be interested in an important development in connec-
tion with the Perkins Glue Co.'s patent rights on
vegetable glue:
"After our patent for vegetable glue had been sus-
tained as valid and infringed by several of the
United States Courts in various suits which we
brought, the Circuit Court of Appeals for the Second
Circuit (sitting in New York), rendered a decision
holding the patent not infringed in that case," says
the announcement. "Shortly thereafter the Circuit
Court of Appeals for the 7th Circuit (sitting in Chi-
cago) handed down a similar decision holding that
the Kane glue (glue made with the Kane vegetable
material) did not infringe.
"The Circuit Court of Appeals for the Sixth Cir-
cuit (sitting in Cincinnati) has, however, now handed
down a decision holding that such Kane vegetable
glue (glue made from the Kane material) is an in-
fringement of our patent. We enclose complete copy
of the opinion handed down by the Sixth Circuit
Court of Appeals which we believe you will be in-
terested in reading.
"The decision, you will see, gives the patent a broad
construction, and the reasoning of the Court is such
that under the decision the infringing glue need not
necessarily be made from the Kane glue material,
but may equally well be made from other brands of
so called "raw" cassava and still fall within the pat-
ent and be an infringement.
"We are confident that this decision of the Sixth
Circuit Court of Appeals, holding that such glues
are infringements of our patent rights, will be fol-
lowed eventually in all suits hereafter to be tried."
The suit before the U. S. Court of Appeals (Sixth
Circuit) sitting in Cincinnati was heard before Cir-
cuit Judges Denison, Mack and Moorman, and deci-
sion was handed down March 18. In the decision
which reversed the findings of the second and seventh
circuits, the closing paragraphs read:
"With the greatest deference to the opinions of the
Circuit Court of Appeals of the Second and Seventh
Circuits, we find ourselves unable to concur with
them. Even if we could agree that their interpreta-
tion of the intent of the court in the original Solva
opinion was right we would still think that we ought
not to reach the same result as they do, because in
that event we would feel constrained not to follow
the Solva decision.
"The decree below is reversed, and the cause re-
manded for further proceedings in accordance with
this opinion."
A. L. WHITE PRACTICE KEYBOARDS.
A big business in foreign music rolls and records
has been built up by F. Delizia & Co., Springfield,
Mass., which was established in 1912.
MOVING TRUCKS
for
PIANOS
ONE GRADE ONLY
The Wessell, Nickel & Gross action is a
guarantee of the grade of the instrument
in which it is found.
1\II7\JI7 Y H P I f
VV
I VAExlV
EXPERT PIANO REPAIRS.
P. B. Grojean, manager of the musical merchandise
department of the C. C. Baker Co., Columbus, O.,
has applied for a patent on a mute for trumpets.
PIANO ACTIONS
FACTORIES:
Arthur Chapman Cheney, of the fine old piano
action industry which bears his name at Castleton,
N. Y., has been elected president of the National Ex-
change bank of that city to succeed the late Harvey
H. G. Ingalls. Prior to his election Mr. Cheney was
vice president. Mr. Cheney had been a director in the
bank and his activities in the business of the city had
long given prominence to his abilities and forceful-
ness.
Mr. Cheney besides is president of the Castleton
Public library, secretary and treasurer of the A. C-
Cheney Piano Action Company, owner of Chenwold
Farm, famous for its registered Guernsey cattle, and
vice president of the Castleton Building and Loan
Association.
The A. C. Cheney Piano Action Co. is one of the
substantial and prosperous industries associated with
the piano business as all manufacturers in this line
of instruments know.
The reasonable prices charged for rebuilding and
repairing pianos and phonographs by the Piano Re-
pair Shop, 339 South Wabash avenue, Chicago, is an
additional inducement to the character of the place
for expert work. A busy shop is a recognition of the
company's admirable methods. Player actions are in-
stalled, actions and keys repaired and instruments re-
finished and remodeled and every job is guaranteed.
Write for details and terms.
Manufacturers of
45th St., lOthAva. & W4«lh. 1^1 d
Elected to Office as President of the National Ex-
change Bank of Castleton, N. Y.
With piano playing contests in process of promo-
tion in all p-arts of the country, the music dealer
should find a line of practice keyboards a source of
good profits. One of the specialties of the A. L.
White Mfg. Co., 215 Englewood avenue, Chicago, is
a line of practice keyboards developed to the highest
efficiency. The A. L. White keyboards are in use in
all sections of the country and are considered the
most desirable type by heads of many schools.
WESSELL, NICKEL & GROSS
HIGHEST GRADE
A. C. CHENEY HEADS BANK
Orthophonic Victrolas
Electric Refrigerators
OFFICE.
457 W. 45th Strict
vv r u e lur LdLciiUg diici prices ior JJ/IIQ j.ru.cKb, 0111
JULIUS BRECKWOLDT & SON, INC.
DOLGEVILLE. N. Y.
Trucks, Hoists, Covers and Special Straps.
Manufactured by
Self-Lifting PianoTruck Co.
Manufacturer* of
FINDLAY, OHIO
Piano Backs, Boards, Bridges, Bars,
Traplevers and Mouldings
J BRJZCKWOLDT, P r M .
W. A. BRECKWOLDT. Sec. & TreM.
THE O. S. KELLY CO.
IN/lartufaoturor* of High
PRESTO BUYERS 1 GUIDE
TELLS ALL ABOUT ALL PIANOS
Oracle
PIANO PLATES
SPRINGFIELD
-
-
OHIO
TH E CO MSTOCK, C HENET Y & CO.
IVORYTON, CONN •
IVORY CUTTERS SINCE 1834
*
MANUFACTURERS OF
Grand Keys, Actions and Hammers, Upright Keys
Actions and Hammer , Pipe Organ Keys
Piano Forte Ivory for the Trade
Enhanced content © 2008-2009 and presented by MBSI - The Musical Box Society International (www.mbsi.org) and the International Arcade Museum (www.arcade-museum.com).
All Rights Reserved. Digitized from the archives of the MBSI with support from NAMM - The International Music Products Association (www.namm.org).
Additional enhancement, optimization, and distribution by the International Arcade Museum. An extensive collection of Presto can be found online at http://www.arcade-museum.com/library/
April 30, 1927.
PIANO FACTORY M STORE SUPPLIES
PERKINS GLUE DECISION
Circuit Court of Appeals for Sixth Circuit Re-
verses All Previous Decisions and Finds
for Perkins Glue Co.
The Perkins Glue Company, patentees of Perkins
Vegetable Glue, South Bend, Ind., under date of April
12, makes an announcement to all users and pros-
pective users of vegetable glue, believing they will
be interested in an important development in connec-
tion with the Perkins Glue Co.'s patent rights on
vegetable glue:
"After our patent for vegetable glue had been sus-
tained as valid and infringed by several of the
United States Courts in various suits which we
brought, the Circuit Court of Appeals for the Second
Circuit (sitting in New York), rendered a decision
holding the patent not infringed in that case," says
the announcement. "Shortly thereafter the Circuit
Court of Appeals for the 7th Circuit (sitting in Chi-
cago) handed down a similar decision holding that
the Kane glue (glue made with the Kane vegetable
material) did not infringe.
"The Circuit Court of Appeals for the Sixth Cir-
cuit (sitting in Cincinnati) has, however, now handed
down a decision holding that such Kane vegetable
glue (glue made from the Kane material) is an in-
fringement of our patent. We enclose complete copy
of the opinion handed down by the Sixth Circuit
Court of Appeals which we believe you will be in-
terested in reading.
"The decision, you will see, gives the patent a broad
construction, and the reasoning of the Court is such
that under the decision the infringing glue need not
necessarily be made from the Kane glue material,
but may equally well be made from other brands of
so called "raw" cassava and still fall within the pat-
ent and be an infringement.
"We are confident that this decision of the Sixth
Circuit Court of Appeals, holding that such glues
are infringements of our patent rights, will be fol-
lowed eventually in all suits hereafter to be tried."
The suit before the U. S. Court of Appeals (Sixth
Circuit) sitting in Cincinnati was heard before Cir-
cuit Judges Denison, Mack and Moorman, and deci-
sion was handed down March 18. In the decision
which reversed the findings of the second and seventh
circuits, the closing paragraphs read:
"With the greatest deference to the opinions of the
Circuit Court of Appeals of the Second and Seventh
Circuits, we find ourselves unable to concur with
them. Even if we could agree that their interpreta-
tion of the intent of the court in the original Solva
opinion was right we would still think that we ought
not to reach the same result as they do, because in
that event we would feel constrained not to follow
the Solva decision.
"The decree below is reversed, and the cause re-
manded for further proceedings in accordance with
this opinion."
A. L. WHITE PRACTICE KEYBOARDS.
A big business in foreign music rolls and records
has been built up by F. Delizia & Co., Springfield,
Mass., which was established in 1912.
MOVING TRUCKS
for
PIANOS
ONE GRADE ONLY
The Wessell, Nickel & Gross action is a
guarantee of the grade of the instrument
in which it is found.
1\II7\JI7 Y H P I f
VV
I VAExlV
EXPERT PIANO REPAIRS.
P. B. Grojean, manager of the musical merchandise
department of the C. C. Baker Co., Columbus, O.,
has applied for a patent on a mute for trumpets.
PIANO ACTIONS
FACTORIES:
Arthur Chapman Cheney, of the fine old piano
action industry which bears his name at Castleton,
N. Y., has been elected president of the National Ex-
change bank of that city to succeed the late Harvey
H. G. Ingalls. Prior to his election Mr. Cheney was
vice president. Mr. Cheney had been a director in the
bank and his activities in the business of the city had
long given prominence to his abilities and forceful-
ness.
Mr. Cheney besides is president of the Castleton
Public library, secretary and treasurer of the A. C-
Cheney Piano Action Company, owner of Chenwold
Farm, famous for its registered Guernsey cattle, and
vice president of the Castleton Building and Loan
Association.
The A. C. Cheney Piano Action Co. is one of the
substantial and prosperous industries associated with
the piano business as all manufacturers in this line
of instruments know.
The reasonable prices charged for rebuilding and
repairing pianos and phonographs by the Piano Re-
pair Shop, 339 South Wabash avenue, Chicago, is an
additional inducement to the character of the place
for expert work. A busy shop is a recognition of the
company's admirable methods. Player actions are in-
stalled, actions and keys repaired and instruments re-
finished and remodeled and every job is guaranteed.
Write for details and terms.
Manufacturers of
45th St., lOthAva. & W4«lh. 1^1 d
Elected to Office as President of the National Ex-
change Bank of Castleton, N. Y.
With piano playing contests in process of promo-
tion in all p-arts of the country, the music dealer
should find a line of practice keyboards a source of
good profits. One of the specialties of the A. L.
White Mfg. Co., 215 Englewood avenue, Chicago, is
a line of practice keyboards developed to the highest
efficiency. The A. L. White keyboards are in use in
all sections of the country and are considered the
most desirable type by heads of many schools.
WESSELL, NICKEL & GROSS
HIGHEST GRADE
A. C. CHENEY HEADS BANK
Orthophonic Victrolas
Electric Refrigerators
OFFICE.
457 W. 45th Strict
vv r u e lur LdLciiUg diici prices ior JJ/IIQ j.ru.cKb, 0111
JULIUS BRECKWOLDT & SON, INC.
DOLGEVILLE. N. Y.
Trucks, Hoists, Covers and Special Straps.
Manufactured by
Self-Lifting PianoTruck Co.
Manufacturer* of
FINDLAY, OHIO
Piano Backs, Boards, Bridges, Bars,
Traplevers and Mouldings
J BRJZCKWOLDT, P r M .
W. A. BRECKWOLDT. Sec. & TreM.
THE O. S. KELLY CO.
IN/lartufaoturor* of High
PRESTO BUYERS 1 GUIDE
TELLS ALL ABOUT ALL PIANOS
Oracle
PIANO PLATES
SPRINGFIELD
-
-
OHIO
TH E CO MSTOCK, C HENET Y & CO.
IVORYTON, CONN •
IVORY CUTTERS SINCE 1834
*
MANUFACTURERS OF
Grand Keys, Actions and Hammers, Upright Keys
Actions and Hammer , Pipe Organ Keys
Piano Forte Ivory for the Trade
Enhanced content © 2008-2009 and presented by MBSI - The Musical Box Society International (www.mbsi.org) and the International Arcade Museum (www.arcade-museum.com).
All Rights Reserved. Digitized from the archives of the MBSI with support from NAMM - The International Music Products Association (www.namm.org).
Additional enhancement, optimization, and distribution by the International Arcade Museum. An extensive collection of Presto can be found online at http://www.arcade-museum.com/library/
Future scanning projects are planned by the International Arcade Museum Library (IAML).