Music Trade Review

Issue: 1912 Vol. 55 N. 10

Music Trade Review -- © mbsi.org, arcade-museum.com -- digitized with support from namm.org
THE:
MUSIC
TRADE:
Wl\W
EDWARD LYMAN BILL - Editor and Proprietor
J. B. SPILLANE, Managing Editor
Executive and Reportorlal Stall:
GLAD. HENDERSON,
A. J. NICKLIN,
H. E. JAMASON,
AUGUST J. TIMPE,
C. CHACE,
B. BKITTAIN WILSON,
WM. B. WHITE,
L. E. BOWERS.
BOSTON OFFICE:
CHICAGO OFFICE:
JOHN H. WILSON, 324 Washington St.
Telephone, Main 6950.
PHILADELPHIA:
E. P. VAN HARLINGEN, 87 South Wabash Ave.
ALBERT G. BRENTON, Assistant.
Room 800. Telephone, Central 414
MINNEAPOLIS and ST. PAUL:
ST. LOUIS:
R. W. KAUFFMAN.
ADOLF EDSTEN.
CLYDE JENNINGS
SAN FRANCISCO: S. H. GRAY, 88 First St.
DETROIT. MICH.: MORRIS J. WHITE.
CINCINNATI, O.: JACOB W. WALTERS.
BALTIMORE, MD.: A. ROBERT FRENCH.
INDIANAPOLIS, IND.: STANLEY H. SMITH
MILWAUKEE, WIS.: L. E. MEYER.
LONDON, ENGLAND: 1 Gresham Buildings, Basinghall St., E. C.
Published Every Saturday at 373 Fourth Avenue, New York
Entered at the New York Post Office as Second Class Matter.
SUBSCRIPTION, (including postage), United States and Mexico, $2.00 per year; Canada,
$3.60; all other countries, $4.00.
ADVERTISEMENTS, $2.50 per inch, single column, per insertion. On quarterly or
yearly contracts, a special discount is allowed. Advertising Pages, $75.00.
REMITTANCES, in other than currency forms, should be made payable to Edward
Lyman Bill.
will be cheerfully given upon request
Exposition Honors Won by The Review
Grand Prix
Paris Exposition, 1900
Silver Medal.. .Charleston Exposition, 1902
Diploma
Pan-American Exposition. 1901
Gold Medal
St. Louis Exposition, 1904
Gold Medal. .Lewis Clark Exposition, 1905
LONG DISTANCE TELEPHONES—NUMBERS 5982-5983 MADISON SQUARE
Connecting all Departments.
Cable address •• "ElbllL N e w York."
NEW YORK, SEPTEMBER
7, 1912.
EDITORIAL
W
HAT a sad commentary upon conditions in a particular
industry when a leading manufacturer advertises that he
will pay a large sum of money for information which will lead up
to the conviction of anyone using abusive matter for sales killing
purposes which has been published in a trade publication.
We have always contended that holdup journalism could only
exist through the aid given it by advertisers and we may add in
this connection that some time ago we asked that information be
supplied us concerning the sales killing use of any abusive matter
appearing in a characterless sheet against any particular manufac-
turer.
We have contended that the strength of the holdup forces in
trade journalism has been through the existence of fear on the part
of advertisers that possible damage will be done their wares by
competing forces exhibiting them as a deterring force in sales-
making.
We have held that the number of dealers or salesmen who
would stoop to such low, villainous practices is small and infini-
tesimal, and that where there was one man who would use an
abusive article, a thousand, if that number read the abusive sheet,
would consider the condemnatory article a compliment to the
product and to the house which was held up to ridicule and abuse.
We may say that notwithstanding the fact that we asked for
this information not one single case came to our notice and a great
number of readers wrote stating that never in their vicinity have
they met competition which would resort to such low practices.
Tt is good to know this because it draws the sting from the
journalistic thugs, and if we can base any predictions upon present
indications it would seem that a total annihilation of the journalis-
tic forces which have so long polluted the industry will take place
in the very near future.
The amazing part is how men have stood for low. villainous
abuse for such a time indeed. Tt is almost beyond human compre-
hension.
REVIEW
It may be explained in one word—fear—but at last these men,
emboldened by their successes of the past, have made just a few
moves too many.
They have been caught and are now in a position from which
it will be very difficult to extricate themselves.
These human cuttlefish will try to throw out the inky sub-
stance to disconcert their pursuers, but they can easiiy be located.
T
HE fall certainly is opening up in good shape for business
everywhere.
With crops worth more than ten billions as a basis for busi-
ness, it would seem as if the average manufacturer and merchant
should go ahead and make his business plans with the reasonable
belief that conditions would warrant taking fair chances.
Factories all over the country are busy and the call is every-
where for more workmen.
In Massachusetts the factories while not suffering are never-
theless feeling the drain upon their working forces occasioned by
those who are engaged in the expansion of manufacturing facilities
and building and public service construction.
In Pennsylvania the product of the steel mills is sold far ahead
and from the West there is coming a large demand for men to
assist in the harvesting of unusual crops.
Truly it may be said that anyone who wants work need not
worry about finding anything to do.
No pessimistic business situation prevails, as was the case in
1907 and 1908, when sad-eyed men had to be turned away from one
business house after another. No work was the answer to their
appeals and those who had to turn a deaf ear did so with heavy
hearts and hated their job.
To-day the business skies are bright.
There will be a big demand for money from the interior to
harvest and finance the bumper crops.
Ten billion dollar crops for 1912 against eight and one-half
billion in 1911 means a pretty substantial increase.
Agriculture is the very backbone of our national welfare and
a country that can harvest a crop worth such a vast sum as we
have indicated is pretty well able to take care of three or four hun-
dred thousand pianos annually.
Of course it is, to say nothing of player-pianos and musical
instruments and a few other things.
S
ELLING goods right is an art and should so rank.
"The man who learns from yesterday profits to-morrow,"
5-o runs the proverb. This is especially applicable to the salesman
who watches the weak spots in his adversary's armor and attacks
them with shafts of judgment. In other words, the salesman who
keeps his eyes open may profit by the many lessons that intelligent
observation teaches.
For example, a keen salesman noticed that in the lobby of the
hotels each morning were congregated many salesmen, waiting for
the hour of 9 to arrive before commencing to call on their trade.
For years it has been the custom to start the day at that hour, taking
it for granted that buyers are not in their offices before that time.
This man, however, made it his business to ascertain the time
each of the buyers upon whom he called arrived at his place of
business, compiling a list for every town he visited. He soon found
that the men who arrived at 9 were in the minority. On his' next
trip he knew that the buyer of the Jones store arrived at 8:15, so
at 8:2o he called at the store in question, while the many men who
were to call on this buyer were yet sleeping. This plan worked out
in practice so well that he took notes during the next trip of the
usual luncheon time of his men. He also went out of his way to
learn when the different buyers went on vacation periods and out-
of-town buying trips.
It is needless to dwell on the value of this information. Is not
the advantage of the use of a little "gray matter" made clear by this
particular case? No lost motion, no calling after other men had
called and no wasted time calling when the buyer was away from
business. This incident only goes to show that the man who blazes
new paths in the woods of salesmanship will find the going profit-
able.
Another man 'phones from town to town a day ahead of his
calling, and while this plan is patterned after the old-style advance
postal cards, which as a rule get no further than the waste basket,
Music Trade Review -- © mbsi.org, arcade-museum.com -- digitized with support from namm.org
THE:
MUSIC TRADE
it brings different results. The telephone makes his engagement a
personal one, and/ except in a few cases, are always kept. This
salesman, of course, found his expense account increasing, but
eventually he was amply repaid. In many instances, too, the 'phone
call revealed the fact that the buyer was away, and in other cases
an order was the result without calling. The latter practice, gen-
erally speaking, is not good, but better by far than to call and to
find that someone else had '"beaten him to it." Opportunities
abound at every turn, but few find them.
HAT this paper is becoming a stronger power all the while
and is of greater benefit to manufacturer, dealer and sales-
man, is evidenced in the many communications which we are re-
ceiving from subscribers.
We have always contended that trade journalism should be
helpful and we receive letters embodying expressions similar to
the following, which is from the A. B. Smith Piano Co., Akron,
Ohio; it is naturally gratifying.
This company says: "The editorials for our salesmen are
worth much more than the price of a subscription."
There is nothing like giving good liberal value and The Review
is always interested in delivering heaping measure. Some time ago
we commenced a department wherein we published "Want" adver-
tisements relating to different departments of the trade free of cost
to advertisers.
We stated at the inception of the move that our object was to
bring the different departments of the trade in closer contact; in
other words, to make The Review universal want directory a trade
market place.
That this 1 move has been successful may be evidenced in the
fact that we are constantly receiving communications from mem-
bers of the trade who have been delighted with the replies received
from a small advertisement.
. One man received in a single day forty replies to a four line
advertisement, so it will be seen that this department is working
out successfully and is doing constructive work in the trade.
He further remarked: "I have been a subscriber to The
Music Trade Review for over twelve years and it is always read
with great interest and pleasure."
Legal Questions Answered for the
Benefit of Review Readers
have opened a Department wherein legal
questions, which have direct bearing on music
trade affairs, will be answered free of charge.
CflThis Department is under the supervision of
Messrs. Wentworth, Lowenstein & Stern, attor-
neys at law, of 60 Wall Street, New York.
T
HE preparation of advertising copy that will interest the aver-
age reader and bring results to the advertiser is one of the
great problems on which many brainy men are concentrating at-
tention these days. It is a rather fascinating topic how best the
buying public may be reached, its curiosity aroused to the extent of
opening its pocket or check book, and making a purchase. Many
well-known specialists and writers, including Charles Austin Bates,
believes that "live" or humanized "copy" is an absolute essential
to secure results, and in discussing this matter recently in Printer's
Ink he put it this way:
To get human interest into advertising copy the writer must
first feel the human interest. He must write from the reader's
standpoint. He must know the desirability of the thirtg he adver-
tises—not as the maker knows it, but in its appeal to the user. In
other words, he must know the human side of his merchandise.
A woman buys a silk gown not because it is silk—not because
of its mechanical perfection as a fabric, but because of the way she
thinks she will feel when she wears it.
A man buys a player-piano not because it is made of wood
felts, ivory and metals, but because of the pleasure it will give in
operation. If the same music could result from an instrument
made in some other form and of entirely different materials, the
buyer would be as well satisfied.
So the human interest advertisement appeals to the mental im-
pressions of the reader—to his senses, his aspirations, to his pre-
conceived ideas of desirability. Technical description of the thing
to be sold is mere corroborative detail.
We want to know what it is good for, what it will do, before
we care very much of what, or how, it is made.
The writer must first determine why anyone should want an
automobile, or a tin horn, or a can of beans—then he must tell just
why his particular beans, or horns, will most completely satisfy that
want. It is really the want we write about and not the material
thing itself.
T
REVIEW
^Matter intended for this Department should be
addressed plainly, Legal Department, The Music
Trade Review.
And no writer can reach every reader. He can interest only
those whom he understands, for only those will understand him.
We respond to kindred vibrations. The man whose mental
wireless is in a different key will never get my message.
Advertising doesn't create a demand. It only locates it.
The author is great who agrees with us. The comedian whose
sense of humor coincides with our own is the one who "gets it
over."
Each of us has a certain audience which will respond to him.
The more we know, really know, about people—many kinds of
people, the more we know of their lives, hopes, troubles, triumphs
and desires, the greater our audience and the more human intrest
we can put into our work.
We can put nothing into our advertisements that we have not
already in ourselves. Imitation is canned stuff, preserved from
putrefaction by benzoate of soda.
Sincerity is the keynote, and extreme formality seldom seems
sincere. The difficulty is to avoid cold formality and at the same
time keep away from a degree of colloquial familiarity which may
easily be offensive.
But, again, each writer's audience is limited. No one can
reach one hundred per cent, of the readers of any publication, and
so we must at the outset decide which class of reader we shall
appeal to. We imagine an individual typical of that c 1 ass and
address him personally.
We mentally visualize that individual. We know his age, tem-
perament and domestic life, and whether he stays at home at night,
or g-oes down to the club. We know his attitude toward the chil-
dren and whether, or not, he carries life insurance.
If we know enough about raw human nature we will always be
able to create a very real man who lives, breathes and buys goods.
Then we write to him and use words, phrases, similes and argu-
ments that we know will fit him.
In any million of readers our man appears an uncertain num-
ber of thousands of times. We reach him positively and convinc-
ingly. He knows we are sincere and he knows we are "talking
sense," for we speak his language and voice his thoughts. In a
less effective degree, we reach his sisters, cousins and aunts and the
fellows who belong to the same lodge.
r
I ^HERE are some firms which we can mention who are out of
A touch and out of sympathy with their representatives. Now,
when co-operation is lacking the business languishes. There is no
other way out of it, and a salesman who can see, understand and
explain the reasons behind certain printed statements of his firm
in its local advertising will be able to work more effectually for
his house than otherwise. To do business more suctessfully a firm
must have certain clean-cut 1 principles running through all its
transactions. The observance of certain basic principles at all
times and under all conditions constitutes the policy of a house.
Every man can broaden his business horizon if he will study the
subject which will make him acquainted with what are regarded as
the best standards in the world of business, and to-day, if we
analyze the conditions which surround successful business men of
our times, it will be discovered that they have always kept close to
the subject.

Download Page 4: PDF File | Image

Download Page 5 PDF File | Image

Future scanning projects are planned by the International Arcade Museum Library (IAML).

Pro Tip: You can flip pages on the issue easily by using the left and right arrow keys on your keyboard.