Music Trade Review
Issue: 1912 Vol. 55 N. 8 - Page 4
Music Trade Review -- © mbsi.org, arcade-museum.com -- digitized with support from namm.org
TH
MUSIC TRADE
REVIEW
EDWARD LYMAN BILL - Editor and Proprietor
J. B. SPILLANE, Managing Editor
Executive and Reportorial Stall:
GLAD. HENDERSON,
A. J. NICKLIN,
H. E. JAMASON,
AUGUST J. TIMPE,
C. CHACE,
B. BRITTAIN WILSON,
WM. B. WHITE,
L. E. BOWERS.
BOSTON OFFICE:
CHICAGO OFFICE:
JOHN H. WILSON, 324 Washington St.
Telephone, Main 6950.
PHILADELPHIA:
R. W. KAUFFMAN.
E. P. VAN HARLINCEN, 87 South Wabash Ave.
Telephone, Central 414.
Room 806.
MINNEAPOLIS and ST. PAUL:
ST. LOUIS:
ADOLF EDSTEN.
SAN FRANCISCO: S. H. GRAY, 88 First St.
CINCINNATI, O.: JACOB W. WALTERS.
BALTIMORE. MD.: A. ROBERT FRENCH.
CLYDE JENNINGS
DETROIT. MICH.: MORRIS J. WHITE.
INDIANAPOLIS, I N D J STANLEY H. SMITH.
MILWAUKEE, WIS.: L. E. MEYER.
LONDON, ENGLAND: 1 Gresham Buildings, Basinghall St., E. C.
Published Every Saturday at 373 Fourth Avenue, New York
Entered at the New York Post Office as Second Class Matter.
SUBSCRIPTION, (including postage), United States and Mexico, $2.00 per year; Canada,
$3.50; all other countries, $4.00.
ADVERTISEMENTS, $2.50 per inch single column, per insertion. " On quarterly or
yearly contracts, a special discount is allowed. Advertising Pages, $75.00.
REMITTANCES, in other than currency forms, should be made payable to Edward
Lyman Bill.
and
aUU
Departments conducted by an expert wherein all ques-
t; o n s of a technical nature relating to the tuning, regu-
lating and repairing of pianos and player-pianos are
p
dealth with, will be found in another section of this
paper. We also publish a number of reliable technical works, information concerning which
will be cheerfully given upon request.
Exposition Honors Won by The Review
Grand Prix
Paris Exposition, 1900 Silver Medal. . .Charleston Exposition, 1902
Diploma
Pan-American Exposition, 1901
Gold Medal
St. Louis Exposition, 1904
Gold Medal. -Lewis-Clark Exposition, 1905
LONG DISTANCE TELEPHONES-NUMBERS 5982-5983 MADISON SQUARE
Connecting all Departments.
Cable address " "Elblll, N e w York."
NEW YORK, AUGUST 24, 1912.
EDITORIAL
I
REVIEW
I
N a letter recently received by The Review from a prominent
Western piano merchant, he complained vigorously of the
growing use, or abuse, of the guarantee in the piano trade, and
stated that many of the manufacturers of commercial pianos were
putting forth a guarantee with their instruments that was beyond
reason, and that many retail piano merchants are trying to outdo
themselves by issuing a guarantee of their own for an unlimited
number of years which on the very face of it is wrong and impos-
sible of performance.
He suggested that this entire matter of the guarantee should
be brought up for consideration at the next convention of the
National Piano Manufacturers' Association, some action taken in
a public way that would prevent this unlimited guarantee from
going beyond the grounds of reason and commonsense.
It is worth noting that the members of Jewelers' Associations
have expressed the sentiment in resolutions passed at recent con-
ventions that they are beginning to look with disfavor upon the
guarantee by manufacturers that an article will wear a certain
length of time, and it is suggested that guarantees by the manu-
facturer should refer simply to the question of the article giving
satisfactory wear, and that no period of time should be mentioned.
The editor of The Jewelers' Circular-Weekly states that most
of the members of the associations in favor of abolishing the guar-
antee have taken the ground that it not only tends to put the
merchant who handles the goods on a par with the department store
and catalogue houses, but also gives the opportunity, particularly
to the irresponsible manufacturer, to get an advantage over the
maker of standard goods by putting on his products a guarantee on
which he never will or never expects to make good. He adds:
"There can be no doubt that the business of responsible manu-
facturers has been seriously hurt in the past, through the fact that
certain concerns have put out the cheapest kind of plated articles
and 'guaranteed' them to wear up to or more than the time that the
standard article is supposed to wear. What is more, the guarantee
system has been seriously abused by unscrupulous peddlers and
other people who have bought up old guaranteed articles for a song
and caused them to be either refinished or replaced with other
articles by the manufacturer and sold the same to the public in com-
petition with the legitimate jeweler.
''However, with all there is to be said against the guarantee,
there is 1 a question as to how the public is going to take the aboli-
, tion of this warrantee by the manufacturer as to the wearing quali-
ties of an article and whether or not people will continue to buy the
cheap trash, which is 'guaranteed,' as against standard articles not
guaranteed, should the legitimate manufacturers of the country re-
solve to act on the suggestions made by the retail jewelers' asso-
ciations.
"The abolition of the guarantee has worked well in Canada,
according to the reports made by a number of people who have
looked into the situation there, but in Canada a guarantee that an
article will wear a certain length of time is forbidden by law, and
the 'faker' and swindler cannot compete with the legitimate manu-
facturer there. Whether or not such a prohibition against the use
of the guarantee could be passed in this country, either by the
Federal Government or by the States, is a question on which legal
authorities have seriously disagreed, and even if it can be done
constitutionally there is also the question whether the public (until
buyers generally were thoroughly educated as to the worthlessness
of many guarantees) will not strongly oppose any legislation of this
character.
"Whether or not the guarantee be abolished, it is well for the
jeweler to educate his customers to the fact that, in the jewelry line
at least, the guarantee of an article to wear a certain number of
years is nothing in itself unless backed by the reputation of a re-
sponsible manufacturer, and should the responsible manufacturers
stop issuing the guarantee, the merchant must then show to his
customers on every possible occasion that the guarantee instead of
being indicative of quality is a sign that the goods are cheap and
worthless, and is but a bait to induce the public to buy lines which
could not be sold on their merits alone."
T would seem from present indications that the proposed Piano
& Organ Supply Trade Association will be formed within the
very near future. At least the comments concerning- this new move
have been favorable and promises of support have been ample so that
it is believed that its formation is now certain.
Fritz Dolge, who is at the head of the move, has been in con-
sultation with the heads of a number of prominent supply houses
and they have stated unhesitatingly that they favor the proposed
plan.
It is believed that a readjustment of credits in the supply trade
will work to the advantage of the industry and it is said that the
platform of the new association will define clearly its regulations
and objects so that the members will know precisely what they are
expected to live up to.
A preliminary meeting will be called some time during the
first part of September, and before the first meeting it is presumed
that more, members of the supply trade will pledge themselves to
the support of the move.
While discussing the proposed association last week, a well-
known member of the supply trade said: "The supply trade as a
whole has be'en blamed by many for encouraging and keeping alive
unfair competition. In other words, bolstering up a certain class
of manufacturers who have not been entitled to credit and who
have been a serious handicap to those who pay their bills.
"There may be something in this charge, but it is certain that
there have been in the past, and there will be in the future, many
deserving men who are entitled to credit by reason of their char-
acter and ability and who are not long on finances; but these men
if given a liberal credit will advance as others have in the p#st to a
commanding position, so that in my opinion credit should be given
to the deserving, but it should be withheld from men whose record
IFFICULT problems that occur from time to time in busi-
does not justify them to receive special financial favors.
ness are being solved daily by those who have the courage
to
face
them and the intelligence to seek advice and counsel from
"I heartily favor the new association and I believe it will work
J
those
qualified
to speak.
out for the good of the entire industry.'
D
TH
MUSIC TRADE
REVIEW
EDWARD LYMAN BILL - Editor and Proprietor
J. B. SPILLANE, Managing Editor
Executive and Reportorial Stall:
GLAD. HENDERSON,
A. J. NICKLIN,
H. E. JAMASON,
AUGUST J. TIMPE,
C. CHACE,
B. BRITTAIN WILSON,
WM. B. WHITE,
L. E. BOWERS.
BOSTON OFFICE:
CHICAGO OFFICE:
JOHN H. WILSON, 324 Washington St.
Telephone, Main 6950.
PHILADELPHIA:
R. W. KAUFFMAN.
E. P. VAN HARLINCEN, 87 South Wabash Ave.
Telephone, Central 414.
Room 806.
MINNEAPOLIS and ST. PAUL:
ST. LOUIS:
ADOLF EDSTEN.
SAN FRANCISCO: S. H. GRAY, 88 First St.
CINCINNATI, O.: JACOB W. WALTERS.
BALTIMORE. MD.: A. ROBERT FRENCH.
CLYDE JENNINGS
DETROIT. MICH.: MORRIS J. WHITE.
INDIANAPOLIS, I N D J STANLEY H. SMITH.
MILWAUKEE, WIS.: L. E. MEYER.
LONDON, ENGLAND: 1 Gresham Buildings, Basinghall St., E. C.
Published Every Saturday at 373 Fourth Avenue, New York
Entered at the New York Post Office as Second Class Matter.
SUBSCRIPTION, (including postage), United States and Mexico, $2.00 per year; Canada,
$3.50; all other countries, $4.00.
ADVERTISEMENTS, $2.50 per inch single column, per insertion. " On quarterly or
yearly contracts, a special discount is allowed. Advertising Pages, $75.00.
REMITTANCES, in other than currency forms, should be made payable to Edward
Lyman Bill.
and
aUU
Departments conducted by an expert wherein all ques-
t; o n s of a technical nature relating to the tuning, regu-
lating and repairing of pianos and player-pianos are
p
dealth with, will be found in another section of this
paper. We also publish a number of reliable technical works, information concerning which
will be cheerfully given upon request.
Exposition Honors Won by The Review
Grand Prix
Paris Exposition, 1900 Silver Medal. . .Charleston Exposition, 1902
Diploma
Pan-American Exposition, 1901
Gold Medal
St. Louis Exposition, 1904
Gold Medal. -Lewis-Clark Exposition, 1905
LONG DISTANCE TELEPHONES-NUMBERS 5982-5983 MADISON SQUARE
Connecting all Departments.
Cable address " "Elblll, N e w York."
NEW YORK, AUGUST 24, 1912.
EDITORIAL
I
REVIEW
I
N a letter recently received by The Review from a prominent
Western piano merchant, he complained vigorously of the
growing use, or abuse, of the guarantee in the piano trade, and
stated that many of the manufacturers of commercial pianos were
putting forth a guarantee with their instruments that was beyond
reason, and that many retail piano merchants are trying to outdo
themselves by issuing a guarantee of their own for an unlimited
number of years which on the very face of it is wrong and impos-
sible of performance.
He suggested that this entire matter of the guarantee should
be brought up for consideration at the next convention of the
National Piano Manufacturers' Association, some action taken in
a public way that would prevent this unlimited guarantee from
going beyond the grounds of reason and commonsense.
It is worth noting that the members of Jewelers' Associations
have expressed the sentiment in resolutions passed at recent con-
ventions that they are beginning to look with disfavor upon the
guarantee by manufacturers that an article will wear a certain
length of time, and it is suggested that guarantees by the manu-
facturer should refer simply to the question of the article giving
satisfactory wear, and that no period of time should be mentioned.
The editor of The Jewelers' Circular-Weekly states that most
of the members of the associations in favor of abolishing the guar-
antee have taken the ground that it not only tends to put the
merchant who handles the goods on a par with the department store
and catalogue houses, but also gives the opportunity, particularly
to the irresponsible manufacturer, to get an advantage over the
maker of standard goods by putting on his products a guarantee on
which he never will or never expects to make good. He adds:
"There can be no doubt that the business of responsible manu-
facturers has been seriously hurt in the past, through the fact that
certain concerns have put out the cheapest kind of plated articles
and 'guaranteed' them to wear up to or more than the time that the
standard article is supposed to wear. What is more, the guarantee
system has been seriously abused by unscrupulous peddlers and
other people who have bought up old guaranteed articles for a song
and caused them to be either refinished or replaced with other
articles by the manufacturer and sold the same to the public in com-
petition with the legitimate jeweler.
''However, with all there is to be said against the guarantee,
there is 1 a question as to how the public is going to take the aboli-
, tion of this warrantee by the manufacturer as to the wearing quali-
ties of an article and whether or not people will continue to buy the
cheap trash, which is 'guaranteed,' as against standard articles not
guaranteed, should the legitimate manufacturers of the country re-
solve to act on the suggestions made by the retail jewelers' asso-
ciations.
"The abolition of the guarantee has worked well in Canada,
according to the reports made by a number of people who have
looked into the situation there, but in Canada a guarantee that an
article will wear a certain length of time is forbidden by law, and
the 'faker' and swindler cannot compete with the legitimate manu-
facturer there. Whether or not such a prohibition against the use
of the guarantee could be passed in this country, either by the
Federal Government or by the States, is a question on which legal
authorities have seriously disagreed, and even if it can be done
constitutionally there is also the question whether the public (until
buyers generally were thoroughly educated as to the worthlessness
of many guarantees) will not strongly oppose any legislation of this
character.
"Whether or not the guarantee be abolished, it is well for the
jeweler to educate his customers to the fact that, in the jewelry line
at least, the guarantee of an article to wear a certain number of
years is nothing in itself unless backed by the reputation of a re-
sponsible manufacturer, and should the responsible manufacturers
stop issuing the guarantee, the merchant must then show to his
customers on every possible occasion that the guarantee instead of
being indicative of quality is a sign that the goods are cheap and
worthless, and is but a bait to induce the public to buy lines which
could not be sold on their merits alone."
T would seem from present indications that the proposed Piano
& Organ Supply Trade Association will be formed within the
very near future. At least the comments concerning- this new move
have been favorable and promises of support have been ample so that
it is believed that its formation is now certain.
Fritz Dolge, who is at the head of the move, has been in con-
sultation with the heads of a number of prominent supply houses
and they have stated unhesitatingly that they favor the proposed
plan.
It is believed that a readjustment of credits in the supply trade
will work to the advantage of the industry and it is said that the
platform of the new association will define clearly its regulations
and objects so that the members will know precisely what they are
expected to live up to.
A preliminary meeting will be called some time during the
first part of September, and before the first meeting it is presumed
that more, members of the supply trade will pledge themselves to
the support of the move.
While discussing the proposed association last week, a well-
known member of the supply trade said: "The supply trade as a
whole has be'en blamed by many for encouraging and keeping alive
unfair competition. In other words, bolstering up a certain class
of manufacturers who have not been entitled to credit and who
have been a serious handicap to those who pay their bills.
"There may be something in this charge, but it is certain that
there have been in the past, and there will be in the future, many
deserving men who are entitled to credit by reason of their char-
acter and ability and who are not long on finances; but these men
if given a liberal credit will advance as others have in the p#st to a
commanding position, so that in my opinion credit should be given
to the deserving, but it should be withheld from men whose record
IFFICULT problems that occur from time to time in busi-
does not justify them to receive special financial favors.
ness are being solved daily by those who have the courage
to
face
them and the intelligence to seek advice and counsel from
"I heartily favor the new association and I believe it will work
J
those
qualified
to speak.
out for the good of the entire industry.'
D
Future scanning projects are planned by the International Arcade Museum Library (IAML).