Presto

Issue: 1920 1794

PRESTO
PRESTO
PUBLISHED EVERY SATURDAY AT 407 SOUTH DEAR-
BORN STREET, OLD COLONY BUILDING, CHICAGO, ILL.
C. A. DANIELL and FRANK D. ABBOTT
Editors
December 11, 1920.
in the offending journal to satisfy the trade as to where the con-
testants actually stood with respect to the right and wrong of it.
Of late years Mr. Dutton had not displayed his old time en-
thusiasm in the business into which he had put his life. Naturally
of a delicate mold, and extremely sensitive in his affections, the death
of his wife, a year ago, quite overcame him and left his power of re-
sistance too much for him to bear. There have been few piano men
whose part in the industry have left a better example or influence
than the late W. Dalliba Dutton, and his going is a great loss to the
distinguished house of Hardman, Peck & Co., whose interests he
served so long and so well.
Telephones, Local and Long Distance, Harrison 234. Private Phones to all De-
partments. Cable Address (Commercial Cable Co.'s Code), "PRESTO," Chicago.
Entered as second-class matter Jan. 29, 1896, at the Post Office, Chicago, Illinois,
under Act of March 3, 1879.
Subscription, $2 a year; 6 months, $1; Foreign, $4. Payable in advance. No extra
charge in U. S. possessions, Canada, Cuba and Mexico.
Address all communications for the editorial or business departments to PRESTO
PUBLISHING CO., 407 So. Dearborn Street, Chicago, III.
Advertising Rates:—Five dollars per inch (13 ems pica) for single insertions.
Complete schedule of rates for standing cards and special displays will be furnished
on request. The Presto does not sell its editorial space. Payment Is not accepted for
articles of descriptive character or other matter appearing in the news columns. Busi-
ness notices will be indicated by the word "advertisement" in accordance with the
Act of August 24, 1912.
Rates for advertising in Presto Year Book Issue and Export Supplements of
Presto will be made known upon application. Presto Year Book and Export issues
have the most extensive circulation of any periodicals devoted to the musical in-
strument trades and Industries in all parts of the world, and reach completely and
effectually all the houses handling musical instruments of both the Eastern and West-
ern hemispheres.
Presto Buyers' Guide is the only reliable index to the American Pianos and
Player-Pianos, it analyzes all instruments, classifies them, gives accurate estimates
of their value and contains a directory of their manufacturers.
Items of news and other matter of general interest to the music trades are in-
vited and when accepted will be paid for. All communications should be addressed to
Presto Publishing Co., 407 So. Dearborn Street. Chicago, III.
SATURDAY, DECEMBER 11, 1920.
TO CORRESPONDENTS.
PRESTO IS ALWAYS GLAD TO RECEIVE NEWS OF THE
TRADE—ALL KINDS OF NEWS EXCEPT PERSONAL SLANDER
AND STORIES OF PETTY MISDEEDS BY INDIVIDUALS. PRESTO
WILL PRINT THE NAMES OF CORRESPONDENTS WHO SEND IN
'GOOD STUFF" OR ARE ON THE REGULAR STAFF. DON'T SEND
ANY PRETTY SKETCHES, LITERARY ARTICLES OR "PEN-PIC-
TURES." JUST PLAIN NEWS ABOUT THE TRADE—NOT ABOUT
CONCERTS OR AMATEUR MUSICAL ENTERTAINMENTS, BUT
ABOUT THE MEN WHO MAKE MUSICAL INSTRUMENTS AND
THOSE WHO SELL THEM. REPORTS OF NEW STORES AND
THE MEN WHO MAKE RECORDS AS SALESMEN ARE GOOD. OF-
TEN THE PIANO SALESMEN ARE THE BEST CORRESPONDENTS
BECAUSE THEY KNOW WHAT THEY LIKE TO READ AND HAVE
THE OPPORTUNITIES FOR FINDING OUT WHAT IS "DOING" IN
THE TRADE IN THEIR VICINITY. SEND IN THE NEWS-
ALL YOU CAN GET OF IT—ESPECIALLY ABOUT YOUR OWN
BUSINESS.
W. DALLIBA DUTTON
The ranks of the "old timers'' in the American piano industry are
growing thin. With the death of Mr. W. Dalliba Dutton, the last of
the original leaders in the National Piano Manufacturers' Association
of America passed away. In the early days of the organization Mr.
Dutton exercised an influence scarcely exceeded by any of his con-
temporaries. He belonged to the group of serious reformers in the
industry who were determined that the doubtful methods which had
crept into the piano business should be eradicated. In this he was
one of the group dominated by the late Henry F. Miller, A. H. Fisher,
and a few others who had taken the initiative in the first convention
at Manhattan Beach, in 1897, and had consistently worked out the
problems of the association from that time forward.
Mr. Dutton was the fifth president of the piano manufacturers'
association, in 1902. He wrote the book on "stenciling'' which
was indorsed by the association and distributed among its members
many years ago. There was never a question of his sincerity or loy-
alty to the best ideals of the industry and trade, and his influence
was always for the higher things in the trade. In his earlier years
he was engaged in the retail piano business in Philadelphia, and his
experience touched every branch of the business.
There was a time when Mr. Dutton's activities as a critic of the
biased methods employed by some members of the trade and, even
more, bv one of the New York trade papers, led to a conflict with a
late well-known music editor who had transcended fair play in re-
ferring to the piano man's motives. As a consequence, Mr. Dutton
brought suit for libel and the case attracted wide attention, not alone
because of the amount of damages claimed, but equally because of
the custom of the complainant to refuse to recognize his critics and
to retain a dignified silence that disarmed them and left no doubt as
to what he thought of journalistic mud-slingers in general, and in
the trade paper business in particular. The trade paper attack was
silenced and the suit withdrawn, but not until enough had been said
PIANOS AND PURITANISM
In a remarkable address on the indifference of the average Amer-
ican, in matters of vital importance to national progress of the higher
kind, Professor Albert Parker Fitch, of Amherst College, recently
sounded a warning which seems to especially concern the music in-
strument industries. Speaking of progress as the world has it—or
rather has it not—Prof. Fitch asked how this country has profited,
morally and intellectually, by the awful price paid in the great war.
And he declared that the very order of Prussianism that thousands
and thousands of our boys died to destroy is gaining power right here
in our own country.
He meant the Prussianism that had so long kept a part of the old
world in a state of cringing subjection to a dictatorship which de-
nied to its subjects the right of free speech or the exercise of reason-
able personal liberty. He saw in existing conditions, right here in
free America, the bearing down of a medieval order of narrow-minded
paternalism in which the waving of the flag suffices for patriotism,
and the fear of discussion keeps men from thinking.
It is, said Prof. Fitch, the cry of three thousand years ago which
arose from the fear of the Israelites who called upon Moses to tell
them the law, but not to "let God speak with us lest we die." And
so the modern world fears to dig-into the meaning of things and will
not look behind the signs to find their significance. Prof. Fitch
charged the lack of progress, of any realization of the ideals for which
the world has suffered to inertia and the willingness of men who
should think to let things drift so long as they are themselves seem-
ingly prosperous.
And how does this condition more than ordinarily concern the
interests for the furtherance of which this paper is published? Does
the drifting by which free thought, even free speech may be denied,
and the innocent delights of life be threatened under pretext of a
bigoted order of Puritanism, carry any special message to the men
who make the things of music or sell them? Does any one believe
that the too obvious effort to return to the small customs and narrow
creeds of the long ago, in matters neither moral nor spiritual, but
really material and mephistic, will exempt the instruments of music
because they have always held a place among the things sacred or
celestial?
Isn't it plain that the gradual bearing-down of the sham moral-
ists, if permitted to spread, will eventually crush the life out of
a large share of the activity in the substantial side of the "art
divine ?"
If the puritanical crusade against all of the things in life that
suggest anything but hysteria and indulgence in intellectual inqui-
sition, and usurpation of public rights by self-appointed bashaws
grows far enough, there will be little use for pianos, and even less
for the smaller musical instruments. We may have a return to the
ram's horn for martial music, and the timbrel may suffice for lovers of
the jazz. Nor will it do to passively protest that such things can not
possibly be. That is what the people of Cincinnati said years ago when
a small-minded mayor ordered all piano playing and singing to cease
promptly at 10 p. m. Did he mean it? Well, it is on record in the
Cincinnati police annals that many refined ladies were actually ar-
rested for violating Mayor Davis' order. And, then, if it can be
seriously suggested that smoking and the picture shows may fall
under the ban of prohibition, what will protect the poor piano—even
in the family parlor? According to Edgar Saltus, in the days of Peter
the Great, "nobody smoked, for tobacco was heathen." There is
an anti-smoking crusade on in this civilized age, the leaders of which
also believe tobacco is heathen, or more. And in the olden days
"nobody danced.'' It, too, was prohibited. The world revolves. So
does time and its intolerance. In the "ascetic orthodoxy of the Rus-
sian church, gaiety was sinful, instrumental music forbidden." Bos-
ton, the center of all reforms, narrow and broad, is only now calmly
considering the height of heels on the ladies' shoes. A ponderous
statesman at the Hub proposes to make it a crime for any shoe-
Enhanced content © 2008-2009 and presented by MBSI - The Musical Box Society International (www.mbsi.org) and the International Arcade Museum (www.arcade-museum.com).
All Rights Reserved. Digitized from the archives of the MBSI with support from NAMM - The International Music Products Association (www.namm.org).
Additional enhancement, optimization, and distribution by the International Arcade Museum. An extensive collection of Presto can be found online at http://www.arcade-museum.com/library/
December 11, 1920.
PRESTO
maker to turn out a Cinderella with more than an inch-and-a-half
rear elevation. When will some equally inspired Rostonian con-
sider that more than six octaves are too many for an upright piano,
and when will he be ready to declare that the player-piano is an
emissary of evil because it will play all kinds of secular music without
the aid of a moral director?
The Music Industries Chamber of Commerce is busy in many
ways. A recent chart, resembling- the genealogical table of some
royal family, and designed to clear up any confusion covering the
Chamber's ramifications into all departments of the art and trade,
displays the far reaching ambition of the organization. But whether
the Chamber, in any of its departments, is watching the possibilities
of the spread of the activities of the mock moralists or not we do not
know. It is clear, however, that what Professor Fitch, of Amherst
College, said about the kind of Prussianism that persists, and prom-
ises to spread over free America, contains some thought that is new
to most people.
And there is a good deal in it that should interest the men who
are directly concerned in the manufacture and sale of musical in-
struments. For every restriction of the rational pleasures of the
people must curtail the possibilities of the music trade by lessen-
ing the uses and purposes of music.
One or two of the trade papers, with ill-placed exuberance, or
eagerness to present the "last news first," published a story of the
technical and, no doubt, temporary entanglements of the R. S. How-
ard Company. It is a complication due to the war-time emergency
by which Mr. Howard's factory was taken over for special purposes.
At least so we understand it. No one who knows Mr. R. S. Howard
and his circumstances can doubt that he will quickly "come back"
with colors flying. We expect to make that announcement in the
near future. Meanwhile what some term "trade journalism" is a
mysterious process too often played with by the kind of inexperience
and shallowness that hurts where it should help.
* * *
Methods of taxing and the things taxed will be subjects consid-
ered by our legislators within the next few months. The music trade
and industry recognize taxation as necessary, but they do not admit
SUMMING UP PROBLEM
OF CANCELLATIONS
Department of Chamber of Commerce of the
United States Points to Causes and
Suggests Remedies.
An exhaustive study of the practice of cancella-
tion of orders and repudiation of contracts in almost
every division of business has been made by the
Fabricated Production Department of the Chamber
of Commerce of the United States, as a result of
which study it groups opinions as to possible causes
under these three heads: That the practice is the
result of war-time irregularities and will pass as
we return to normal basis. That we are now reap-
ing the results of the loose business practices in-
augurated before the war, when many lines were in
a state of over production and the measures taken
to unload this surplus were demoralizing, and that
we have been drifting away from the fundamentals
of sound business and the "Golden Rule,," and that
we must return to a stronger belief in the rights of
others and a higher regard for our own integrity
if the change is to be permanent.
Terming the cancellation practice a "serious mat
ter," the bulletin goes on to say that "earlier in the
year when cancellations began to trickle in they
were almost welcomed by those having more orders
than production, but as prices began to crumble am!
the tide of refusals to perform set in, the seriousness
of the situation was manifest, for it brought with iv
a curtailment of production in lines which had not
reached the volume of normal requirements.
"The retailer cancelled to the jobber and whole-
saler and they in turn to the manufacturer, and he
to those supplying his raw materials—a literal 'pass-
ing the buck' and shirking of responsibility regard-
less of consequences," says the report.
''Sellers
had encouraged buyers by misleading paternalism in
assuming many of the natural responsibilities in
herent of their customers' functions as merchants.
'We will take care of you' or 'you may return the
goods' are examples of some of the undermining- fac-
tors when the pinch came. Last but not least, it is
claimed that banks favored concellations as a rapid
means of house cleaning and bringing business back
that the methods of taxing put in force within the past few years are
fair. Taxes that serve to impede industry and halt commercial
progress and harass trade generally because of the unwisdom in un-
fair apportionment, call for the revision which news from Washington
promises this week. The business world is sick of governmental sug-
gestions to economize so that the economizers would be better able
to dig up the billions for the spending orgy.
* * *
The best proof that the public is interested in music in a great
degree is that the newspapers are featuring music in a particular way.
The newspaper without a music department will soon be as great an
oddity as a newspaper without a baseball page. The newspapers re-
ilect the thoughts and tastes of readers. If public interest in music
were to cease tomorrow the newspapers would quit featuring music
the day after. The editors supply the daily ration of music matter
because the public appetite calls for it.
>|:
*
*
These are times when it behooves all men who think at all to do
some of it. And, still more, it is the part of good judgment to dig in
and sell pianos. Get out and do business instead of hanging around
the store talking about what may never happen—and certainly will
not if everyone attends to his own business and does it well.
* * *
A wise manufacturer said to a Presto representative that it. is
his plan to put a larger proportion of his profits into publicity next
year than ever before. "When a few are frightened is a good time
in which to show that you are not afraid but fully alive." The scheme
will work well.
According to an item in one of the sources of trade information,
"some of the shrewdest trade experts in Washington are freely pre-
dicting a big trade revival to begin not later than next Spring." No
doubt about it, and the piano business should come in for its full share.
Look out for the expenses, but don't saw the limb off so close to
the trunk that it will carry you down with it. Economy in business
doesn't mean drawing in all of the lines that are baited to bring sub-
stantial results.
more quickly to a normal state. If the latter con-
clusion has any merit the fact should not be lost
sight of that somebody paid the bill, for between
May and November the failures both in manufac-
turing and among merchants increased rapidly.
"The apparent lowering of business standards has
made doubtful the value of business written and
placed upon the books for future shipment. Pro-
duction schedules could not be definitely worked out
because of this increasing doubt."
In suggesting the possible remedy for this evil,
the bulletin says: "There is a strong feeling that
this thing must not happen again and to that end many
trade organizations have met and formed committees
and bureaus to deal with it. And the Credit Co-op-
erative and Credit Methods Committee of the Na-
tional Association of Credit Men have met twice
to consider the cancellation of orders problem, and
they suggest one remedy as a safeguard against the
unscrupulous: That each line of trade should at
once examine its contract making and order tak-
ing methods to bring them strictly within legal lines.
"We feel, however," is the statement, "that perhaps
the most effective remedy must be the one that will
call us back to 'first principles,' to where we can
'point with pride' to our house as one that 'fills its
orders and keeps its contracts.'"
F. S. SPOFFORD'S TRADE GROWS.
While F. S. Spofford, piano dealer in the Republic
Building, Chicago, is no longer agent at Chicago for
Hardman, Peck & Co., of New York, that agency
having passed to the Cab'e Piano Company, he is
still selling Hnrdman pianos and he has the agency
for the Hazelton pianos, of New York. He is also
selling talking machines from New York and he says
that trade is growing livelier every day now.
F. D. WIGGINS WITH STARR CO.
F. D. Wiggins, formerly well known in the piano
trade, is back at the business once more, having be-
gun as a retail salesman at the Starr Piano Com-
pany's store in Chicago last Saturday. Mr. Wiggins
was at one time buyer and assistant factory manager
at the M. Schulz Company in Chicago. Later he
traveled out of Chicago for about fifteen years for
the Starr Piano Company, of Richmond, Ind. He
has recently been in the furniture business at Green-
vi'le. Pa. Greenville is 90 miles north of Pittsburgh
and 28 miles northeast of Youngstown, Ohio.
NEW COMPANY SUCCEEDS
FIELD=LIPPMAN IN FORT WORTH
The Conkling-Grimes Piano Co., Incorporated for
$50,000, to Continue Policies of Old Concern.
The new Conkling-Grimes Piano Co., Fort Worth,
Tex., which succeeds the Field-Lippman Music
Store, is a strictly Fort Worth enterprise and it is
well known that the strongest business men in the
city are associated with Ernest I. Conkling and B.
A. Grimes in the new company, recently incorporated
with $50,000 capital stock. The business will be con-
tinued at 500 Houston street, where the Field-Lipp-
man Music House was moved last May. The new
heads of the concern say the well-known policies
of the Field-Lippman Music House will be con-
tinued.
Ernest I. Conkling, the president of the new or-
ganization, has been with the Field-Lippman Music
House for over twelve years and has an experience
of thirty years in the piano business.
Mr. Grimes, vice-president, has also been asso-
ciated with the Field-Lippman Music House for
several years. He has a wide acquaintance among
musical people in the Texas city and is prominently
active in all public events of a musical nature.
TRADE PRESS MEETING.
The annual meeting of the Chicago Trade Press
Association was held on Monday evening of this
week at the City Club, Dinner was served at $1.50
a plate. New officers were elected and new plans
enunciated. C. S. Richardson was on hand and told
ihe association how to use charts for business pro-
motion. He is an expert well known to business ex-
ecutives. His talk was followed by a round table
on business conditions, postal service and other mat-
ters of business interest.
CHRISTMAS CLUBS.
Christmas clubs will distribute to the more than
3,000.000 member^ throughout the country approxi-
mately $110,000,000. This is an increase over the
amount distributed a year ago of about $10,000,000.
Another phase of the thrift of the peop 1 e is the
Christmas Piano Club, the approximate total for
which would be interesting.
Enhanced content © 2008-2009 and presented by MBSI - The Musical Box Society International (www.mbsi.org) and the International Arcade Museum (www.arcade-museum.com).
All Rights Reserved. Digitized from the archives of the MBSI with support from NAMM - The International Music Products Association (www.namm.org).
Additional enhancement, optimization, and distribution by the International Arcade Museum. An extensive collection of Presto can be found online at http://www.arcade-museum.com/library/

Download Page 4: PDF File | Image

Download Page 5 PDF File | Image

Future scanning projects are planned by the International Arcade Museum Library (IAML).

Pro Tip: You can flip pages on the issue easily by using the left and right arrow keys on your keyboard.