Presto

Issue: 1920 1751

PRESTO
February 12, 1920.
results of the actual contact of genius—the red-hot sparks from the
anvil of inspiration. Nor is this the only great attainment of music
roll production in its highest, almost miraculous development.
It was true, a few years ago, that the player rolls were "cut from
printed or manuscript notes." Many of them are still so made. But
today the most inspirational or casual improvisations of the creative
pianist may be recorded in the music rolls direct, to be repeated again
just as the player sent them forth. It is even said that some of the
great song "hits" of recent publication were first recorded by the re-
producing piano.
It is clear to anyone who has knowledge of such things, that
often the very best work of the melodist and composer has been
lost before the fleeting inspiration could be chained by pen and paper.
So that to any musician who has also the creative gift, the possibili-
ties of the modern music roll are easily conceivable. And it is equally
clear that the musical world of the future will owe a debt beyond
computation to the genius of the present which has made the music
roll and its permanent results a part of the everyday life.
And yet, and nevertheless, the article of last week, on "Music
Store Changes," was in the main accurate. It displayed no lack of
understanding more serious than a somewhat unhappy mode of
expression at the point where player music roll cutting was referred
to.
JUST THE SAME IN THE PIANO TRADE
IN TIMES AHEAD
Let us take a look into the future. For a long time to come it
will be customary to tell of the past four years, and conditions in
trade as they now exist will be the basis of warning, exclamation and
comparison. But what of the future with respect to what it may
bring to the piano and kindred industries and trades?
So far as concerns the immediate future, nothing could be more
significant than the kind of comment that followed the publication
of Mr. C. G. Steger's announcement that there would be no further
advance in the prices of the products of the industry of which he is
the head. As might have been anticipated, adverse criticism of Mr.
Steger's article was frequent among piano manufacturers and travel-
ing salesmen. On the other hand, members of the retail trade were
warm in praise of the piano manufacturer's attitude. And why this
was so is clear enough. On one side was the fear that conditions
might force an advance, while on the other was the satisfactory assur-
ance, or intimation, that there already existed a sufficient margin of
profit for the protection of the factory end of it.
Consequently, Mr. Steger was the object of both criticism and
commendation. And in that alone what he said must have accom-
plished a good purpose. For it is what makes men think that exerts
influence, and the piano trade needs the stimulus of intellectual shock
to keep it alert and progressive.
Nor are the critics of Mr. Steger justified in attributing specially
selfish motives to what he said. It may be that the somewhat un-
usually frank declarations set forth may have a tendency to bring a
deeper kind of attention among dealers than the ordinary interview,
or discussion, could induce. But that fact doesn't, in itself, suggest
anything less than the utmost sincerity.
It has been said, by more than one letter-writer to Presto, that
Mr. Steger's article will make it more difficult for salesmen to apply
increased prices to customers who have been paying too little. We
fail to see the force of the argument. The piano trade is not unlike
other lines in the fundamentals. If a piano has been selling at whole-
sale for prices too low, the dealer is the very one who knows it. If
he is at all equipped to do the piano business successfully, he knows
when he is paying too little, and he very rarely pays too much. The
small margin of manufacturer's profit has been responsible for the
unsatisfactory condition of the piano business during all of the past
twenty years.
When the manufacturers were openly declaring that they were
selling on a margin of $5, the retailers were likewise making little or
no money. They came to regard the piano as an article of ordinary
commerce and sold it just as the grocer sold flour, sugar, or other
perishables. And the idea of cheapness was passed along to the
public, until it was common for a prospect to boldly offer to "pay the
cash" if he could buy at cost! And, not infrequently, the dealer was
foolish enough to show his bills to convince the customer of the sacri-
fice, and to invoke the utmost "confidence"—which was, of course,
violated before noon the next day!
The future will be the better because the prices have been forced
up. It is the tonic of bitter taste to the run-down constitution. And
should the producing cost of pianos soon begin to decline, it is to be
"•.V '^• r '*''*tr%." l s\
'"'•' ;•'-<"•»'- V ^^"'ii'^^'r^'''-'" 1 ;.-'--^''^^*^-^^^
m
'Now, gentlemen, when a customer kicks on the price of an article
don't forget our slogan: 'The next lot will be higher.' "
—The Milwaukee Sentinel.
hoped that the manufacturers will not hasten to tell the dealers, and
that when the dealers do find it out, they will forget to impart the
sweet wisdom to the public.
The future of the piano business is in the hands of the present.
We hope that the time will never again come when the men who
make the piano business will also be the ones to work its ruin, or
nearly 1 that. High prices in the essentials of life just now work hard-
ship. But in the piano business the increase prevents the elements of
betterment in the future. The dignity of the instrument is, in a meas-
ure, restored and the methods of the business have been proportion-
ately elevated. Let's keep it that way.
BAD FOR BRITAIN
The unreasoning demands of labor have brought a great loss
to the musical interests of Great Britain. As a result of the great
increase in the cost of labor, and the even greater reduction in the
amount of work done, one of England's greatest and oldest piano
industries has suspended and threatens to remain closed for all time
to come.
Following the statement that it now requires 26 high-priced
workers to produce a piano once created by six low-priced workers,
the house of Brinsmead of London has declared its purpose to quit.
The impossibility of manufacturing high-grade; pianos at a profit was
given as the cause of suspension. And so fades out the fame and
the experience of nearly a hundred years in the British piano industry.
The house of John Brinsmead & Sons was founded in 1836. The
Brinsmead piano has been regarded as/ one of the most representative
in all Europe, and vied with the Broadwood in its claims upon the
attention of great pianists. It has sold for good prices, and there was
a time when it had some sale on this side of the Atlantic. When
there was a serious attempt to form a "trust" of pianos in this country,
and the Steinways held out, there were two or three foreign instru-
ments considered with a view to their establishing American factories
for purposes of the "trust." One of them was the Brinsmead, and
another was the Bechstein. The latter had been about settled upon
when the "trust" blew up.
Is there any possibility of the Brinsmead incident having a coun-
terpart in the United States? We do not think so. Improved meth-
Enhanced content © 2008-2009 and presented by MBSI - The Musical Box Society International (www.mbsi.org) and the International Arcade Museum (www.arcade-museum.com).
All Rights Reserved. Digitized from the archives of the MBSI with support from NAMM - The International Music Products Association (www.namm.org).
Additional enhancement, optimization, and distribution by the International Arcade Museum. An extensive collection of Presto can be found online at http://www.arcade-museum.com/library/
PRESTO
8
ods of manufacture, the introduction of piano-making machinery and
other conditions on this side, serve as life preservers of the American
industry, even if other conditions, in finance and economic life, were
not so different. In our country the fine old pianos are often the
ones that display the greatest life and vigor. They are in such demand
that selling price has very little to do with the volume of output, which
is as great as factory facilities will permit. And, over here, so great
a name as that of Brinsmead is over there possesses a commercial
value as great as its influence in art. It could not be permitted to die
with no other reason than that of manufacturing cost.
Under this head it is interesting to recall that when the Decker
Bros, piano was withdrawn from the trade there were many offers for
the name and good will. Two of the offers were for $50,000 and
$60,000 respectively. And there are other famous pianos still active in
the trade, that have brought as much or even more for the great, if
intangible value of a good name.
There is no danger of any Brinsmead fate exterminating any
old American piano. But the condition by which the London in-
dustry is abandoned, nevertheless, is filled with suggestion. It may
not serve as any warning to labor—probably will not—but it should
in some degree silence the cry, sometimes heard even over here, about
what the piano manufacturers are doing to elevate the already high
prices. As a matter of fact, the prices are not too high, if high enough.
For they have always been too low.
PLAYER ROLL INNOVATION
In these quick-moving times, the makers of music trade history
have ample opportunities for the exercise of their initiative. And of
course the progress of the playerpiano presents the most interesting
phases of the changes in the trade, and in the introduction of new
things and new ideas of its development.
A booklet just put forth by a great playerpiano industry is sug-
gestive of what has just been said; in fact suggested the saying of it.
It is a book upon a new plan and presenting the subject of playerpiano
music in a new way. And the originators of the way are the publicity
directors in the industry of the Gulbransen-Dickinson Company. The
book itself was reviewed in a recent issue of this paper.
From time running far back of the oldest music dealer now living,
it has been customary to find catalogues of the various publications
for the piano. Every sheet music publisher has put them forth, and
at one time a giant volume came out in which the publications of all
the publishers were listed between two covers. Of course, too, since
the playerpiano came into popular use, the manufacturers of music
rolls have issued lists and catalogues of their productions.
But it has remained for the Gulbransen-Dickinson Company to
compile the first general classified and descriptive catalogue of
player rolls. And the compilation is doubly remarkable because of
its evident unconsciousness of anything like partiality to particular
lines of rolls, or other consideration than to supply a convenient help
and guide. From the standpoint of high-class promotion of the in-
strument itself, therefore, it would be difficult to point to any innova-
tion associated with the trade that is better, if equally as good.
It is, of course, the new things that attract attention and create
the impression. It is the helpful novelty that wins approval because
the public is always in neec of the kind of direction that can only come
of experience. To the average dealer and his customers, a list of titles
in a music catalogue means little except in the case of already famous
pieces. But a book containing an unbiased topical index, with enter-
taining comments upon the purposes and fitness of the music de-
scribed, can not fail of being helpful.
The Gulbransen booklet contains the names of thousands of
player rolls of different manufacturers—song rolls included. And the
variety and scope of the lists is a significant proof of the place already
gained by the playerpiano in the world of music. It is such evidence
of up-to-dateness and skill in the application of ideas to the needs of
the times that insures progress and compels respect for a growing
line of industry.
DAYLIQHT=SAVINQ FOR DEALERS
Several of the cities of the United States have taken action,
through the initiative of their chambers of commerce, providing for
daylight-saving plans; so it would not be surprising if Congress should
reconsider the question and re-establish national daylight saving.
The Pennsylvania Railroad Company is considering the adoption of
the daylight-saving plan, which has been adopted by New York,
Philadelphia, Baltimore and other important cities, for the reason
February 12, 1920.
that it would be impracticable to provide train service based on two
standards of time.
More than 300 communities in New Jersey have gone on record
in favor of daylight-saving. Philadelphia, Hartford, Conn., and other
cities are effecting the change the last Sunday in March, and con-
tinuing until the last Sunday in October. Pittsburgh will hold to the
daylight-saving rule from the last Sunday in April to the last Sunday
in September. South Bend, Ind.; Cincinnati, Ohio; St. Joseph, Mich.,
and Erie, Pa., are among the cities that will adopt daylight-saving
as an all-summer rule.
Retail piano dealers and their salesmen, so far as a Presto repre-
sentative can learn after inquiring of several of them, favor the day-
light-saving plan. Many of the salesmen like the earlier quitting-
time in summer, as it gives them time to make garden, to play golf,
to go rowing or walking, to take a motor trip, or even to go far out
in the suburbs to see a customer whose remote residence had been a
cause of worry.
Trade press representatives in New York last week were amazed
at the activities of some mysterious individual whose name appeared
in the "flimsy" as "Mr. Blank." Sometimes the only method of
identification was in recognizing the speaker's style, and then, some-
times, Mr. Blank became some well known and fluent orator of the
convention. But the reporting was otherwise perfectly good and, in
the excitement of such a week, it could not have been expected that
accuracy would come first. It was a wonderful week and one that
all who participated in will never forget. And the trackless blizzard
must add to the remembrance of it.
*
:j;
*
It is cause for more than usual regret that a progressive piano
industry should be the victim of fire at this time, when the demand
is so great as to be impossible of fulfillment. Such was the fate of
the Chute & Butler Company's fine plant at Peru, Indiana, which
was destroyed on Saturday last. But the pluck of the Chute & Butler
management will soon overcome the disaster and the fine Chute &
Butler pianos and players will soon again be forthcoming. Presto
extends its sympathies to President R. A. Edwards and Vice-Presi-
dent-Manager R. H. Bouslog, upon whose shoulders will rest the
responsibility of the rehabilitation.
* * *
The number of genuinely artistic American pianos increases
with the passing of time. And the West is gradually contributing
to this satisfactory condition. Today the city of Rockford, 111., has
a standing musically because the Haddorff piano is manufactured
there. The Haddorff presents one of the illustrations of the influence
of a really fine piano upon the fame of even a good-sized city. And
the Haddorff piano is now recognized by the trade everywhere as a
representative instrument of the first class. It has passed its experi-
mental period.
* * *
Nothing in connection with the Convention was more elabo-
rately impressive than the week's program of the American Piano
Co. and the Ampico. From a great display at the Music Show to a
special play by the late Dr. Cyrus Townsend Brady, the scene of
which was laid in "an Ampico salesroom" to several fine concerts
and a banquet of many guests, the American Piano Co. filled large
space in the week's events.
* * *
The carillon, which rang in the Music Show, added zest to the
occasion. The idea of elaborate bell chimes was proposed by the
late John McTammany, of player contention fame, for the San Fran-
cisco Exposition. But the carillon and its solemn suggestiveness is
almost as old as religion and dates back almost to the casting of the
first bells.
* * *
Some of the fine exhibits at the Music Show are described in
another place this week. Last week others had attention. The enter-
prise of the Kohler Industries, and associate enterprises, was on so
large a scale as to amaze visiting piano men. With such support as
the large piano industries extended the Show could not have been
short of a great event.
*
*
*
We believe that it is fair to say without danger of being charged
with boastfulness, that Presto was the first trade paper to give an
account of the convention and music show in New York last week.
And the paper was not delayed a minute past its publication hour.
Enhanced content © 2008-2009 and presented by MBSI - The Musical Box Society International (www.mbsi.org) and the International Arcade Museum (www.arcade-museum.com).
All Rights Reserved. Digitized from the archives of the MBSI with support from NAMM - The International Music Products Association (www.namm.org).
Additional enhancement, optimization, and distribution by the International Arcade Museum. An extensive collection of Presto can be found online at http://www.arcade-museum.com/library/

Download Page 7: PDF File | Image

Download Page 8 PDF File | Image

Future scanning projects are planned by the International Arcade Museum Library (IAML).

Pro Tip: You can flip pages on the issue easily by using the left and right arrow keys on your keyboard.