Music Trade Review

Issue: 1940 Vol. 99 N. 2

Music Trade Review -- © mbsi.org, arcade-museum.com -- digitized with support from namm.org
THE MUSIC TRADE REVIEW, FEBRUARY, 1M0
N.
Y.
Clinic
proved increasing interest in piano promotion
as nearly 300 dealers and salesmen
discuss trade problems
(The following is in part a running re-
port of discussions which took place at
the Piano Salesmen's Clinic. Owing to
limited space speeches that are not
herewith printed will be published in
future issues Editor.)
HE growing popularity of the
Retail Piano Salesmen's Clinics
which were inaugurated last year
under the auspices of the National Piano
Manufacturers Association was strik-
ingly manifested in New York on Jan-
T
Pleads for Better Merchants Association
Mr. Jacob, who was assigned the subject
of "Pride in our Industry," then said: "My
first knowledge of pride was gained at a very,
really very early age. I had a very lovely
old grandmother and whenever I thought I
was doing particularly well at anything she
cautioned me that "Pride goeth before a fall."
So, with your permission, I will just put off
the talk on pride for a little while and touch
en a few other things that I think are perti-
nent.
terest to music merchants that could be prop-
erly controlled by the officers of a strong mer-
chants' association. Whenever I get a chance
I make a plea for that.
"You have a president who is on his toes
and who would be just willing to go places
with the Merchants' Association. I think he
deserves the wholehearted support of everyone
in the retail part of our industry. To do this,
I think that the Merchants' Association has
to really adopt something that can be carried
on as a, what shall I say, a banner, that all
A striking picture of the Eastern Piano Salesmen's Clinic held in New York on January 15, 1940
uary 15th when nearly three hundred
dealers and salesmen from the eastern
section of the country sat down for an
all-day session at the Hotel New Yorker.
The meetings were opened promptly
at 9.30 A. M. by Lawrence H. Selz,
publicity counsel for the association,
who presided throughout the morning
and evening sessions. After a few well-
chosen words in which he stated the pur-
pose of the gathering and congratulated
the guests on the splendid attendance
he called in C. Albert Jacob, Jr., pres-
ident of the NPMA, after a brief intro-
duction and welcome asked the guests
to rise in a moment of silence as a trib-
ute to Ralph Hitz, president of the Hotel
Management Co. and head of the Hotel
New Yorker, who was slated as one of
the speakers, but who passed away sud-
denly two days previously.
"I find it difficult to stand here and not
talk about the National Piano Manufacturers'
Association. It is not a large group, but I
believe it is a very efficient group. We have
practically 100 per cent membership. We have
the active cooperation of all members, and
we have a real program of things that we
wish to accomplish for the betterment of the
industry, such as our publicity campaign, the
sales clinics and many other things.
"Now, as an association of manufacturers,
we really are only able to consider half the
problem. It strikes me that the dealers must
handle their half of it. There are retail dis-
tribution, retail advertising, retail service
problems, retail terms, retail allowances, and
matters of that sort, that should properly be
considered and controlled by the Merchants'
Association.
"I am a strong advocate of a strong mer-
chants' association. I think it is most desir-
able. The Merchants' Association should have
a much larger membership than it has. Its
plans should have a broader scope—they should
go beyond just conducting a convention and
acting as a glorified banquet committee. There
are many, many things that are of vital in-
merchants could be enrolled under. I would
like to see the adoption of standards of retail
merchandisers in the industry. I don't say a
"code of ethics."
"I started in the piano business in 1911,
and, as a youngster, attended conventions, and
I well remember there were several sanctimo-
nious old scalliwags that used to get up on
the platform and talk about ethics until the
word had a sort of an anemic look to me. It
was overdone. And these particular fellows
you know darn well, when the convention was
over, went back to start "puzzle scheme" ethics,
and so forth. So let's talk about a code of
ethics and make it some standard—standard
of advertising, standard of sale, service—that
would protect not only the dealer but would
protect the public from the unscrupulous dealer
and at the same time protect the legiimate
dealer from unfair competition.
"And if you do get such an organization to-
gether and get people signed up on the dotted
line, don't be afraid to kick somebody out if
he doesn't behave! It would be the best thing
for the Association.
"If this really can be accomplished, if the
dealers will get together and get behind it, ancj
Music Trade Review -- © mbsi.org, arcade-museum.com -- digitized with support from namm.org
10
THE MUSIC TRADE REVIEW, FEBRUARY, 19W
if there is anybody in this room whose or-
ganization is not a member of the Merchants'
Association, please, before you go out, see
that you sign up and get your shoulder to
the wheel.
Should Be Cooperation Between N. P. N. A.
and N. A. M. M.
Now, assuming that a stronger Merchants'
Association has been created, it will provide
for closer cooperation between the Merchants'
Association and the Manufacturers' Associa-
tion. You have seen what the manufacturers
are continually demanding something lower
to sell. They say the reason for it is because
the public demands it, but why does the public
demand it? The public demands it because
many dealers and some manufacturers who
operate retail establishments are continually
placing before the public ads that are ridic-
ulous to us who know what conditions are,
offering pianos, so-called, at ridiculous prices.
It is a vicious cycle all the way through. The
manufacturers, I think, as a whole, would like
to maintain their products up to a standard.
It is difficult if dealers are trying to maintain
or the fact that you did well last year.
has got to be in cash!"
It
A Little More Pride Needed
"Now, I think you gentlemen agree with
me in this, probably. The Association has
tried to keep our industry in the sunshine of
successful business, and you, as individuals,
are trying to do the same thing. However,
there are still some pianos that nobody could
manufacture. In fact, if we, as manufacturers,
are the parents, figuratively speaking, of pianos
that go out in the world here, I think that
Speakers at Eastern Sales Clinic—1. to r.—Ray Erlandson. J. A. McClanahan and R. A. Huff; L. H. Selz, S. C. Wolfe. Earl Rice, F. H. Galperan, C. Albert
Jacob. Jr., Ray Fagan and John H. Gettell
have been able to accomplish in the last few
years by concerted efforts, and there is no
question but what, if the efforts of the mer-
chants \i ire added to that, concretely, what we
could accomplish would be multiplied many
fold. There is no question about it.
As a result, there would come closer co-
operation between individual manufacturer and
individual dealer. The dealer always talks
about the effect that public demand has on the
way he does his business. For instance, I
have heard dealers recently bemoan the fact
that when Mrs. Jones comes in to buy a piano,
she wants the cheapest that she can get, and
she is always "chiseling" on price. Now, at
the risk of possibly hurting somebody's feel-
ings unintentionally, I will say this:
Chiseling
Believe me, the manufacturer runs up against
that same problem with dealers. The dealers
the same product down to a price. It is hard
to reconcile the two. In fact, the one stabil-
izing influence in our industry is the fact that
there is one outstanding and a few other man-
ufacturers who are conscientiously maintaining
their product up to a standard and not suc-
cumbing to the continual plea to build it down
to a price. Gentlemen, that is something that
we can be thankful for—that there are still
some manufacturers who are maintaining that
standard, because if it wasn't for that, there
would be chaos."
Getting back to his subject on "Pride in our
Industry," Mr. Jacob stated: "Pride itself is
static. It has no momentum and you don't
get anywhere with it. It is up to us to keep
up the effort so that we can continue to be
proud of what goes on in our industry in the
future. We can't cash in on pride in past
performance. You can't pay bills with pride
the sanctity is somewhat abused at times with
some of the pianos that I have seen. But
also, there are some retail methods thst we
can't be proud of. I don't think we can be
proud of some of the types of advertising—
"bait" advertising, these "balance due" letters
and crazy allowances. There are a whole lot
of things we can't be proud of, but still, there
are some things we can be proud of.
"There is no question but what, as an in-
dustry, we are giving probably bettor values
than we ever gave before to the public. We
can be proud of our publicity campaign, which
has created a getter public acceptance of pianos
than we ha^ve ever had before.
"Think back a few years before that pub-
licity work was started, and you will recall
that we could look through every magazine
published in the United States, practically ev-
ery newspaper, and never see anything relating
PIANO BENCHES
Made by fine Piano Makers.
Brimfull of Piano Quality.
Sturdy construction. Fine finish.
Limited, but attractive Quality Line.
Ask for illustrations and quotations.
Our Major Business:
THE WEAVER LINE OF PIANOS
Join the Company of those who are sell-
ing the Weaver Line and going places.
WEAVER PIANO CO
Makers of Fine Pianos
YORK, PA.

Download Page 9: PDF File | Image

Download Page 10 PDF File | Image

Future scanning projects are planned by the International Arcade Museum Library (IAML).

Pro Tip: You can flip pages on the issue easily by using the left and right arrow keys on your keyboard.