Music Trade Review

Issue: 1929 Vol. 88 N. 5

Music Trade Review -- © mbsi.org, arcade-museum.com -- digitized with support from namm.org
News Number
THE
VOL. 88. No. 5
REVIEW
Published Weekly. Federated Business Publications, Inc., 420 Lexington A?e., New York, N. Y. Feb. 2, 1929
10 Cent*
Year
The Richest Child Is Poor IVithout Musical Training !
By MRS. L. L. WILSON, Hamilton, Montana
Prize Slogan in Music Contest
Announced by Chamber
Award of $1,000 Goes to Piano Teacher of Hamilton, Mont., on
Unanimous Decision of Judges—120,000 Entries
Received From All Parts of World
"The Richest Child Is Poor Without Musical Training!"
Here you have the new slogan of the Music Industries. It was the unanimous choice of the
judges in the $1,000 prize contest, conducted through the offices of the Music Industries Chamber
of Commerce last Fall.
It is now the property of every manufacturer, jobber, dealer and organization within the entire
range of music and the music business, and according to the original thought behind the contest
immediate steps will be taken for its nation-wide exploitation.
Mrs. Linnie Lewis Wilson, of 247 State street,
Hamilton, Montana, mother of two grown to me that this slogan embodies that idea better
daughters and a teacher of piano, is the creator than any other submitted."
of the slogan and winner of the prize money. The
Real drama enters the awarding of the prize
winning slogan was picked from approximately to Mrs. Wilson. The check for $1,000 reached
120,000 entries which came from every State in her in time to ca,re for a mortgage on her home,
the union, from people in all walks of life, and and part of the money will be used to continue
in nearly a score of languages. The judges the education of her daughters. Mrs. Wilson's
were S. L. Rothafel ("Roxy"), nationally known story of her struggles to bring up her family
motion picture impresario and authority on and to teach good music in her neighborhood is
music; Frank Presbrey, head of the advertising clearly told in her letter acknowledging the
agency bearing his name and a t n international good news: She writes:
authority on advertising slogans, and Prof.
"I am just a struggling teacher of piano, and
George R. Agnew, head of the Department of an-artist who almost mortgaged her soul for
Marketing of New York University.
art, and as I really had hardly expected to win
Prof. Agnew indicates the consensus of the a contest where so many would compete I was
judges in his statement concerning the award amazed and delighted when I was given the
telegram that announced the fact that I am
of the prize money to Mrs. Wilson.
"There is one thing to be said as to why I winner of the National Music Slogan Contest.
prefer, 'The Richest Child is Poor Without
"I thank those who offered it with all my
Musical Training,'" he wrote to the Slogan heart. I had thirteen years' training in music
Contest Committee. "In order to appreciate the
from the best teachers in our home town, finish-
beauty of the stars, a little knowledge of as- ing at Carleton College, Northfield, Minn.,
tronomy is necessary; a little study of botany where I took piano lessons and studied har-
greatly increases the appreciation of one who mony. I have been organist in the Congrega-
loves flowers: So with music. I believe real tional, Presbyterian and Episcopal Churches and
appreciation of music can come only to those certainly love the church work.
who know something of the technique by which
"I have taught in the public schools and have
it is produced. And the man or woman who is learned the value of musical training there and
not able to appreciate music in its true sense teaching my own two daughters and many
is shut out of life's richest pleasures. It seems others.
"I have music classes here and in Darby,
Cowallis and Stevensville, so am doing my bit
in my small corner to help the good work.
"My pupils' recital programs, I think, prove
my zeal for the best class of music. In solo
work they have included The Erl King by Schu-
bert, Ballade op. 47 by Chopin, Rustle of Spring
by Linding, Whispering Winds by Wollenhaupt,
William Tell, Hungarian Rhapsody No. 2 and
many others. The rendering of these programs
has been approved by good musicians.
"My own daughters have appeared in these
recitals here from 1916 until 1928 inclusive.
"The older of the two entered the MacPhail
School of Music in Minneapolis in September,
1927, and studied pipe organ there until June
30, 1928, when she was obliged to discontinue
her work there on account of lack of funds, but
is in Valley City, N. D., where she can continue
her practice on a pipe organ in a theatre belong-
ing to the father of a friend and earn a living
at another kind of work. She wishes to become
a spotlight pipe organist.
"The other daughter is teaching school and
has helped her sister when at MacPhail. She
has not graduated from Normal School yet and
must save for that purpose or she cannot con-
tinue her work.
"My husband has held public positions of
trust and been in a milling and commission
business, but lost heavily during the war, hence
the struggle.
"This amount will help my daughter with her
studies, also will relieve a mortgage on our
home.
"Again thanking you sincerely,
"Linnie Lewis Wilson."
History of the Contest
The music industry has long sought a slogan,
general use of which by all branches of the
business would stir public consciousness and
tend to further the interest of the country in
the playing of musical instruments as a popular
pastime. The idea was first suggested by
{Concluded on page 4)
Music Trade Review -- © mbsi.org, arcade-museum.com -- digitized with support from namm.org
The Music Trade Review
Music Committee Meets to
Discuss Piano Instruction
FEBRUARY 2, 1929
E. R. Fenimore Johnson
Resigns From Victor Co.
Son of E. R. Johnson, Founder of Victor Talk-
ing Machine Co., Retires From Executive
Vice-Presidency
CAMDEN, N. J., January 25.—At the regular meet-
ing of the Board of Directors of the Victor Talk-
ing Machine Co., held in Camden to-day, it was
announced that E. R. Fenimore Johnson, Ex-
ecutive Vice-President, had resigned as an active
officer of the company but would remain as a
director and a member of the Executive Com-
mittee and retain a keen interest in the future
OLLOWING the resolution passed by the Music Teachers' National Association last month of the business.
endorsing the principle of piano class instruction and authorizing the Music School Com-
In discussing his resignation, Mr. Johnson
mittee of the Association to adopt a program for supporting that movement, a meeting of said that he had expected to sever his connec-
the committee was held at the Republican Club, New York, on January 24.
tion with the company in January, 1927, at the
If the first session is any criterion of the active manner in which the committee will operate, time his father, Mr. Eldridge R. Johnson, the
then much can be expected in the future, for at the meeting it was decided first to circularize music founder ajid first president, sold his interest and
teachers throughout the country, if funds for
withdrew as active operating head of the indus-
the purpose should be available, and second, to now being organized for the first time. He try which he had developed from a small be-
prepare a booklet on group teaching methods said he had been studying the movement for ginning to the largest manufacturing organiza-
addressed specially to the profession and de- several years. One of the reasons for his in- tion of its kind in the world. On account of
signed the words of the resolution: "To make terest was that the group method would educate the retirement of many of the older executives
clear the underlying principles of class piano the parents away from mere interest in tht at that time, Mr. Johnson's services were
instruction and how the private teacher can technical progress of their children and get needed, for the company was actively engaged
them to understand that the primary objective in the production of a complete new line of
adopt it beneficially to his own work."
The booklet will be drafted by the National of the instruction was arousing joy in music for musical reproducing instruments. Therefore he
Bureau and submitted to the members of the its own sake and desire to participate in produc- felt under obligation to continue. Now that a
committee for revision, after which the com- ing music as a means of self-expression and as definite solution to many of the major prob-
mittee will meet again for approval of the pub- an asset to be retained through life.
lems then confronting the company have been
All the members were agreed that the piano found and since the executive personnel has
lication in its final form.
One of the most significant developments of class movement held great possibilities for the been greatly strengthened and augmented, Mr.
the meeting was the emphatic endorsement of private teacher who was progressive enough to Johnson feels entirely free to carry out his
the class instruction idea by Harold Bauer, look into it and relate himself to it. They original plan.
known throughout the country not only as one pointed out the increasing number of classes
of the foremost pianists of the day, but also as and the demand for trained teachers in the
a highly successful teacher and investigator of schools, as well as the pedagogical advantages Prize Winning Music
pedagogical methods. He called attention to to be derived by use in the private studio.
Slogan Is Announced
the fa,ct that most of the great teachers of the They were equally unanimous, however, in the
(Continued
from page 3)
instrument, including Liszt, Rubinstein and opinion that the technique of teaching groups
William
J.
Haussler,
president
of the National
Leschetizky, gave few individual lessons and re- differs greatly from that of the individual lesson
Musical
Merchandise
Association.
garded their group instruction as giving their and that unless a teacher was equipped with a
Details of a national slogan contest were
pupils a more valuable experience. The same knowledge of school pedagogy, classroom pro-
worked
out by a committee consisting of C.
advantage is obtained in the so-called "master cedure and discipline, as well as musicianship,
M. Tremaine, director of the National Bureau
classes" now so popular in the prominent music she was likely to fail, however successful she for the Advancement of Music; Alfred L. Smith,
schools and conservatories. Add to this the might be in individual work. In its publications general manager of the Music Industries
fact that class instruction in violin and the the committee will bring out the essential dif- Chamber of Commerce; Max J. deRochemont,
other instruments of the orchestra and band is ferences of work in the two fields, as well as Edward C. Boykin, executive secretary of the
making steady progress, and the advent of the the increased opportunity for the music teacher. National Piano Manufacturers' Association;
The members of the committee present were: William J. Haussler, president of the National
piano classes becomes almost an inevitable out-
J. E. Maddy, chairman, Harold Bauer; George Musica,! Merchandise Association, and Henry C.
growth of existing conditions.
Mr. Bauer's endorsement went far beyond H. Gartlan, Director of Music in the New.York Lomb, president of the Musical Instrument and
mere reasons of timeliness and practicability. schools; Mrs. Addyc Yeargain Hall, and C. M. Accessories Manufacturers. Dewey M. Dixon,
"I am strongly in favor of class instruction," Tremaine, Director of the National Bureau for assistant to the general manager of the Chamber
lie informed the committee. "It is not only the Advancement of Music, secretary. Rudolph was in active charge of carrying out the
that participation with a group gives the child Ganz, the eminent pianist and teacher, Russell program.
an interest and incentive not found in individual V. Morgan, Director of Music in the Cleveland
The contest was first announced through na-
itudy, and that his parents are pleased because schools, and Will Earhart, Director of Music in tional newspaper publicity in September, with
the
Pittsburgh
schools,
have
all
accepted
mem-
he likes to practice instead of having to be
the closing date fixed for December 1, 1928.
driven to it, but that class work offers the bership but were unable to be present.
Music dealers, jobbers, manufacturers, as well
In addition to the committee the meeting as musical clubs, women's clubs, civic clubs,
teacher a better opportunity to present al!
phases of music simultaneously, or as the occa- was attended by Miss Ella H. Mason, director teachers' organizations and other groups, were
sion arises. She will be far more likely to make of piano classes in the schools of Rochester, N. circularized, with the request that they obtain
real musicians out of her pupils, with trained Y.; Franklin Dunham, educational director of the widest possible distribution of the small
ears as well as trained fingers, and with im- the Aeolian Co., Kenneth S. Clark.
contest leaflet, giving the rules and containing
agination and intelligence in performance, not
a blank for entry of a slogan. Window cards
merely ability acquired by painful effort to ad- Edison Launches New
and advertising accessories were also provided.
vance from one grade of technical difficulty to
440,000 leaflets were ordered
Advertising Campaign by Approximately
another. In my observation of teaching in the
the above groups for distribution to the
conservatories I have frequently noticed a lack Large Space to Be Used in Newspapers in Key public. Thousands of direct inquiries were re-
of co-ordination among the branches of study,
Cities to Feature the New Edison Radios and ceived by the Chamber, as a result of newspaper
pupils often being unable to transfer to execu-
Radio-Phonograph Combinations
and magazine publicity. The rule giving per-
tion at the keyboard what they can work out on
mission to send more than one slogan was
paper away from it. The well-equipped group
On Thursday of this week there was fired the thoroughly taken advantage of, some entrants
piano instructor teaches music rather than per- first gun of an extensive newspaper advertising submitting a score of variations.
formance, or sight reading, or any particular campaign launched by Thos. A. Edison, Inc.,
Of the 120,000 slogans entered, by far the
branch of music. The result is that the subject and which will cover the key cities of the greater number came from women, many of
becomes a< living experience to the children, country. The advertising copy, which is of the whom obviously were teachers of music. Radio
something in which they can take part with distinctive sort, occupies close to half a news- announcements of the contest by various sta-
zest, and in which new problems come up and paper page running across the bottom, and, in tions throughout the country were also an in-
are mastered as they would be, say, in litera- addition to featuring the various Edison radios centive to competition, many djrect inquiries
ture."
and radio combinations, emphasizes the new having reached the Chamber as a result of them.
Mr. Gartlan told the committee something of Edison radio slogan: "The Set the World
Comparatively few of the entrants took ad-
his plans for developing piano classes in the Awaited." The campaign will continue at regu- vantage of the privilege of combining words
schools of New York City, where the work is lar intervals over an extended period.
with symbols or designs.
At Notable Meeting Held in New York Plans Are Adopted to
Prepare Booklet and Circularize All Music
Teachers on Class Teaching
F

Download Page 3: PDF File | Image

Download Page 4 PDF File | Image

Future scanning projects are planned by the International Arcade Museum Library (IAML).

Pro Tip: You can flip pages on the issue easily by using the left and right arrow keys on your keyboard.