Music Trade Review

Issue: 1927 Vol. 84 N. 19

Music Trade Review -- © mbsi.org, arcade-museum.com -- digitized with support from namm.org
TECHNICAL^SUPPLY DEPARTMENT
William Braid White, Technical Editor
Design and Construction of a Miniature
Piano of But Five and One-Half Octaves
Some of the Problems Met With in Developing the Scale of an Instrument of This
Size—Scale, String Lengths, Bars, Bridge, Etc.
HAVE been carrying out a very interesting
experiment in the design of a very novel
miniature piano, which may interest those
readers who are looking out for novelties in the
piano industry.
For a number of years Joseph N. Vasey, for-
merly of Chicago and now of Los Angeles, has
been working upon miniature pianos. These he
has made in some cases of no more than three
octaves compass, light enough to be carried
about by a child.
Some of his smaller and
earlier instruments appear to have partaken of
the nature of what might be called large-keyed
hammer-struck zithers. But in his later work
he has been steadily approaching the piano
proper, with, however, the ideal of portability
always in his mind.
Some months ago the opportunity came to
lay out a scale for a five and one-half octave
piano, to follow Mr. Vasey's general ideas. As
the thing turned out to present a very inter-
esting problem, I shall give some technical ac-
count of it here. What follows has nothing to
do with the commercial aspect of the case, or
the question of merchandising such an instru-
ment. I am concerned here solely with the tech-
nical problems involved in the design.
1
Remember Us
Our large slock is very seldom
depleted, and jrour order, whether
large or small, will receive imme-
diate attention
In addition, you
get the very best of
Felts— Cloths— Hammers —
Punchings — Music Wire —
Tuning Pins—Player P a r t s -
Hinges, etc.
We have In stock a hill lino of
materials for Pianos and Organs.
The American Piano Supply Co.,
Mr. Vasey's construction is based upon his
invention of a simple down-striking action,
which rests immediately above the strings of the
scale. The action itself is extremely simple, con-
sisting merely of a spring, a hammer, a
knuckle and the usual stem, the latter being
horizontally placed on the key. The spring
bears against the knuckle of the hammer which
is curved so as to provide for escapement and
retraction at the end of the stroke.
Possessing this very individual type of action,
the piano can be built so as to take advantage
of its overall length for the strings. As every
one knows, a length of something like ten
inches must normally be given over to the keys
(if the piano, which project from the front of the
case. Speaking now of pianos in horizontal form
only, it is easy to see that, when coming down
to small lengths, this key space assumes con-
siderable importance. On the other hand, of
course, the scale which I am about to describe
has a compass only of five and one-half octaves,
which puts it in quite a class of its own, so
that no fair comparison can be made between
it and an ordinary small grand piano. With
this understanding, however, we can appreciate
the interesting nature of the technical problems
involved in the design of the scale.
Range of Scale
The scale of five and one-half octaves involves
a range from a point nine unisons above the
usual lowest note to a point an octave above
the usual highest note. That is to say, from F
above the usual lowest C to C below the usual
highest C or sixty-eight notes altogether. In
laying out the scale it was possible to place all
the strings quite straight, that is to say, all of
them at right angles to the hammer-line. In
fact, on account of the peculiar action used, this
was necessary. It was also necessary that the
upper striking surfaces of all strings should be
in the same plane, in order that the hammers
might each have the same length of stroke. This
meant that the thick bass strings must be fas-
tened on their bearing bars at levels slightly
lower than the level of the bearing bar for the
plain wire strings.
Place of Tuning Pins
In order to tune a piano equipped with a
down striking action, the tuning pins, as may
Magic Scratch Remover
110-112 East 13th St.
Campbell's Magic Scratch Remover in-
stantly eradicates scratches and scars
from wood finishes. Highly valuable-—
in fact, indispensable, wherever furniture
or musical instruments are handled. Used
by any employee. Quick, effective—and
very economical.
The cost of Magic Scratch Remover is
very small, indeed. Housewives gladly
pay a good price.
be understood, have to be placed at the end of
the case remote from the action, that is to say,
at the back of the case, as in the square piano.
This is satisfactory so long as the piano is not
too long, and with a compass of only five and
one-half octaves the length need not be too
great. Whether the idea could be extended to a
piano of full compass is, of course, quite an-
other matter.
Mr. Vasey wished to have his instrument built
in the simplest manner possible and among
other things had worked out a soundboard of
peculiar design with resonance boxes under it.
This he desired merely to lay upon the frame-
work, so that it should be held in place by the
pressure of the strings. In order to carry out
this idea it was determined to have the iron
plate cast in a shape which would make it also
the equivalent of the ordinary inside and out-
side rim of a grand piano. The soundboard
could be arranged in place inside this casting
and the outer cabinet or cover could then be
placed over the whole thing.
String Lengths
To lay out the scale was very simple, as I
have said, the only need being to run the string
lines at right angles to the hammer line
throughout. Normally a string of unison 76
would be about three and three-quarter inches
long. I made this first string three and one-
half inches long and then carried out the lengths
as far as they would go on the plain strings.
This gave me thirty-five unisons on the treble
stringing and thirty-three bass strings, the last
five of which were singles. I began with No.
13 wire and ran down with an average tension
of 120 pounds per wire, or thirty-six pounds per
unison.
The last bass string, F, came out at thirty-
six inches long. This brought the wire very
close to the edges of the plate at either end, but
we got over the possible difficulties very simply.
The plate was designed, as I have said, with an
iron rim running all round in just the shape of
a very small grand piano. The wrest plank at
the further end of the plate was enclosed be-
tween this rim and another iron bar cast in
with and as deep as the outer rim. The strings
coming to the tuning pins passed over this first
or inside iron bar, which was made just high
enough to give a bearing. At their nearer ends
(Continued on page 30)
William Braid White
Associate, American Society of Mechanical
Engineers; Chairman, Wood Industries
Division, A. S. M. E.; Member, American
Physical Society; Member, National Piano
Technicians' Association.
Consulting Engineer to
the Piano Industry
Tonally and Mechanically Correct Scales
Tonal and Technical Surreys »f Product
Tonal Betterment Work in Factories
Reference*
Your price, y 2 dos., $2.50; doz.,
$3.50. Postpaid. 5f«< on approval.
THE M. L. CAMPBELL COMPANY
1008 West Eighth Street
Punchings
Washers
Bridle Straps
5814-37th Are.
George W. Braunsdorf, Inc.
Direct Manufacturer* of
Kansas City, Mo.
For particulars,
mddrtss
209 South State Street, CHICAGO
Piano
Also—Felts and
Cloths, Furnished
In Any Quantity
to manufacturer! of unquestioned
position la industry
Tuners
and
Technicians
are in demand. The trade needs tuners, rejru-
lators and repairmen. Practical Shop School.
Send for Catalog M
Y. M. C. A. Piano Technicians School
TUNERS' TRADE SOLICITED
Woodside, L. I., N. Y.
29
1421 Arch St.
Philadelphia, Pa
Music Trade Review -- © mbsi.org, arcade-museum.com -- digitized with support from namm.org
30
The Music Trade Review
MAY 7, 1927
The Technical and Supply Department—(Continued from page 29)
where they were hitched there was space
enough for the greater number of the strings
to be hitched on to an iron plate cast in the
usual position behind a bearing bar of the same
design as the tuning pin bearing. The longer
bass strings, however, had to be carried down
as nearly as possible to the edge of the pate, and
so were hitched by being carried over the bear-
ing bar, which here was the front edge of the
plate, and hitched to pins cast in this front bar
on its front face and not on its top.
Bars
The reader will have noted that so far I have
said nothing about compression bars. The plate
as so far described consists of an iron bar or
rim bent to the shape of a small grand piano,
and cast in one piece all around. Additional
bars are cast in where needed, at the rear end to
accommodate and fasten the wrest plank anil
near the front edge to form a hitch pin bearing
for the treble strings. The hitch pin bearing
for the bass strings is, as I have said, right
on the main outer rim itself.
Compression bars nevertheless are needed and
are cast in under the soundboard. I used only
two in this scale, for the sides of the casting
are very stiff and the straight pull of all the
strings makes the stress-resistance problem very
simple. The bars are as deep as possible and
therefore quite narrow.
Bridge
It was necessary to provide a rather elabo-
rate extension bridge to give the soundboard a
chance to vibrate freely when set into vibration
by the longer and heavier bass strings. T h e
bridge in a construction of this kind would, of
course, approach extremely close- to the edge of
the wrest plank and b e a r i n g bar and so it was
necessary to m a k e an apron or extension run-
ning t h r o u g h the whole bass and si>nir d s t a n c e
up in (he treble section. This, however, made
no difficulty. Bass and treble bridges are in
one.
It was verv interesting to work out the string
dimensions and loadings, and to find out that
they ran very much the same as they would
have run on a larger piano. Of course tin- bass
in a scale of the size within which the design
had to be limited presented some difficulties, but
the problem yielded to a little m a t h e m a t i c s and
some testing work done on the Richie tester.
Certainly one has to get along without the close
adaptations allowed in easier circumstances, but
at that the results were quite good.
of a really revolutionary nature are needed and
every attempt made towards novel and in-
genious embodiments of the piano principle are
to be welcomed.
I have held pretty constantly to the idea that
there is a limit of size below which a good piano
cannot be made. But constant -work in scale
designing has brought me gradually to see that
if the public taste is going to set in towards ex-
tremely small instruments, we shall have to
make them, and that means that we technical
men shall have to learn to make them tonally
right. The evolution may be slow. It may all
come about very gradually, but surely enough,
if public demand is insistent, the very small
grand and the still smaller upright will be here.
And we technicians shall have to find some way
of designing and building good ones.
Farewell to Intolerance
It is all very well for some one to say that it
cannot be done. At one time I should have been
intolerant enough to say this myself, and some
of my friends may think that I am still in-
tolerant about it. But that is wrong. There is
no sense in being dogmatic about what is
actually going on. The present tendency is to-
wards smaller pianos, and it is difficult to see
how far that tendency may carry us. At any
rate, there are now on the market two four-foot-
six-inch grands, which are selling well, and
another reliable manufacturer is announcing a
four-foot-four-inch grand. An English maker
has built a four-foot-two-inch grand and
shown it this year. There is a German four-
foot-two-inch grand. A Chicago maker is get-
ting out a still smaller one, less than four feet
long, with regular action, not like the Vasey
piano, which is of short compass and has a
special simplified action.
Well, there we are. The question then is,
what shall we do about it? Evidently the thing
for us to do is to get at our drawing boards,
think the problem out again, devise combina-
tions of wire, soundboard and action which w'll
given us reasonably adequate results, and then
work the new data up into suitable instru-
ments. We cannot make the people live again
in large rooms, and it begins to look as if in
time only the wealthy will have big rooms to
live in. That means either small pianos or no
pianos at all. And there is absolutely no way
rm
of getting around it.

The Solution
" ? ~^
That is why I say that I am declining any
longer to be dogmatic about the thing. If the
public wants grand pianos shorter than our
present ones, then we shall have to make them,
and do our best. The real solution will be
found, I think, in working away from our tra-
ditional ideas to quantity of tone, and quality
too. It is not at all impossible that the home
piano of the future will have a tone beautiful
inside a room and inaudible from the other side
of a closed door. Along such lines we shall find
our solution. In other words, we shall be fac-
ing a completely new set of conditions and it
will be quite absurd to attempt to obtain-tonal
results like in quantity and quality to those
which we have had under different conditions.
And there is no doubt that the solution can
be found. Certainly I do not think that the
larger piano will ever be superseded. It will be
merely a case of developing the smaller one
because there will be a demand for it. The
larger one will still be the piano which only it
can be. And there will always be a place for
those superb instruments of five feet six inches
up to seven feet in length in which the art of
the piano maker comes to its fullest fruition.
As for the future, I shall certainly not worry,
provided only that our technology is kept up
to the mark and is not afraid to adapt itself to
changing circumstances.
Correspondence
is solicited and should be addressed to William
Braid White, 5149 Agatite avenue, Chicago.
Consult the Universal Want Directory of.
The Review. In it advertisements are inserted
free of charge for men who desire positions.
Tuners Carrying Case
LIGHT—COMPACT—SERVICEABLE
Reflections Suggested by the Above
All of which, of course, suggests still further
the question w h e t h e r pianos can be revolution-
ized either in size or in style. My own opinion
is that he will be wise who will keep to the safe
side and m a k e his revolution slowly, by work-
ing along accepted lines and attacking the ques-
tion of improvement from sides which do not
involve too sharp a break with tradition.
I
mean, that is to say, that a tiny piano like the
one I have been describing is, after its fashion,
a piano still, and may have a considerable place
for itself. But a piano which should make a defi-
nite break with accepted ideas as to shape
might have a harder time.
Yet, in spite of all that, i m p r o v e m e n t s even
FAUST SCHOOL
OF TUNING
Standard of America
Alumni of 2000
Piano Tuning, Pipe and Reed
Organ and Player Piano
YEAR BOOK FREE
27-29 Gainsboro Street
Weighs Only 6 Pounds
Outside measurements 15^2 inches long, 7
inches wide, 8 inches high.
No. 150—Covered with seal grain imitation
leather. Each $13.00
No. 200—Covered with genuine black cow-
hide leather. Each $20.00 F.O.B. New York.
When closed the aluminum
trays nest together over the large
compartment, which measures
13%" x 6" x 4". The two left hand
trays measure 13%" x 2%" x ty%
and the two right hand trays 13%"
x 334" x iy & \ The partitions in
right hand trays are adjustable or
may be removed. Case is fitted
with a very secure lock and solid
brass, highly nickel-plated hard-
ware.
We have a separate Department to take care of special requirements
of tuners and repairers. Mail orders for action parts, repair materials,
also tuning and regulating tools are given special attention.
BOSTON, MASS.
Tuners
and Repairers
Our new illustrated catalogue of Piano and"
Player Hardware Felts and Tools is now
ready. If you haven't received your copy
please let us know.
OTTO R. TREFZ, JR.
2110 Fairmount Ave.
Phila., Pa.
Hammachefy~Schlemmer & Co.
Piano and Player Hardware, Felts and Tools
New York Since 1848
4th Ave. at 13th St.

Download Page 29: PDF File | Image

Download Page 30 PDF File | Image

Future scanning projects are planned by the International Arcade Museum Library (IAML).

Pro Tip: You can flip pages on the issue easily by using the left and right arrow keys on your keyboard.