Music Trade Review

Issue: 1925 Vol. 81 N. 6

Music Trade Review -- © mbsi.org, arcade-museum.com -- digitized with support from namm.org
THE
MUSIC TRADE
REVIEW
AUGUST 8, 1925
Sixteenth Annual Tuners' Convention
Draws Largest Attendance
Annual Gathering of National Association of Piano Tuners at the Hotel Statler, in Detroit, Brings Out
Greatest Attendance in the History of That Organization—Varied Program Holds Delegates' In-
terest from Beginning to End—Large Number of Exhibits Made at Meeting
ETROIT, August 6.—The
sixteenth
annual convention of the National As-
sociation of Piano Tuners opened this
afternoon at the Hotel Statler. When Presi-
dent Charles Deutschmann called it to order
at 2:20 p. m. the ballroom of the hotel was
packed and more than 250 people had already
registered. Before the first meeting was over
D
floor the President informed the meeting
that a question box had been opened and that
members or visitors desiring to ask professional
or technical questions might deposit the same
for discussion at a later meeting.
The President then addressed the meeting,
laying down rules for the observance of dis-
cussion, urging close and prompt attendance
at the meetings and at the exhibits after the
meetings. He paid a tribute to the exhibitors
who do so much to make the convention a
success.
The president then read a letter of greeting
from Wm. E. Delaney, president of the Winni-
peg Tuners' Association of Winnipeg, Canada,
and at 3:15 p. m. the meeting was adjourned
until 9:30 a. m. Tuesday morning.
Among the distinguished visitors already ar-
rived is A. K. Gutsohn, of the Standard Pneu-
matic Action Co., president of the National
Piano Technicians' Association.
At 7:30 p. m. in the evening, the Board of
Directors held its annual executive meeting.
Tuesday Session
Charles A. Deutchmann
the number of registrations had already passed
300.
Delegates were present from Nebraska, New
Hampshire, New York, Vancouver, Washing-
ton, Ontario, Florida, California, West Virginia,
Illinois, Michigan, Missouri, Pennsylvania,
South Dakota, Indiana, Wisconsin, Minnesota,
Maryland and other States.
An address of welcome on behalf of the city
of Detroit was made by John Atkinson, assist-
ant corporation counsel, for Mayor John
Smith. Mr. Atkinson spoke humorously and ef-
fectively of Detroit's amazing change from a
pretty residential town to a vast flivver-pro-
ducing industrial city; and welcomed the tuners
heartily. The national hymn "America" was
sung by the audience to the accompaniment
of the Knabe Ampico grand lent by the Ameri-
can Piano Co. Roll call followed, each dele-
gate rising and announcing his or her name
and address. Loud cheers greeted the an-
nouncements of the delegates from the far
western and far eastern points.
The following committees were then named,
to present their reports during the convention:
Ways and Means, the Board of Directors, Chas.
Deutschmann, President, C. F. Backus and E.
L. Seagrave, vice-presidents, W. F. McClellan,
secretary-treasurer, and seven regional direc-
tors; Auditing, George Steger, Chastain O'Har-
row; Resolutions, William Braid White, Chair-
man; George C. Johnston, Edgar L. Seagrave;
Credentials, C. F. Backus, Wm. F. McClellan.
In response to a suggestion from the
Highest
Quality
The Tuesday morning session was called to
order by President Deutschmann, who de-
livered his keynote address, which follows:
This has been the most eventful year in the
history of the National Association of Piano
Tuners, first because of the increase in its mem-
bership and, second, because of the prominent
part the Association took in the establishing of
a standard pitch.
You are all aware that last November we
launched a membership drive, as a result of
which our membership was increased somewhat
over fifty per cent. Our Secretary's report
will give you more definite figures.
This drive, as you can well imagine—know-
ing the handicap under which we labor—com-
pletely swamped the National Office with work,
and although several members made short trips
and your Secretary and President extensive
ones, the work is not yet finished. There are
still many applications filed and men waiting to
be examined who live in such remote regions
that I seriously question if we shall be able to
reach all of them for some time, which we very
much regret.
I have just returned from a trip through the
East and from my observations and investiga-
tions on that trip I have come to the conclu-
sion that we have a problem on our hands
which will tax the ability and energy of the
members of our Association as they have never
been taxed before. It means work, and then
more work and money to bring about the re-
sults that are desired by all of us.
Local Associations
There are springing up all over our country
independent organizations, and while this is a
most pronounced compliment to the N. A. of
P. T.—in fact, an acknowledgment that they
see and are taking notice of the good results
of our work—yet in defense of our institution it
is absolutely essential that we use our best
endeavors to bring them into our fold before
they lose their enthusiasm—owing to the in-
ability of their local organization to bring about
the things they are seeking—or go to pieces
and disband.
We have had some experience in this mat-
ter and we have discovered to our sorrow that
it is impossible to interest men of a defunct
local association in organization matters until
time has healed the sting of their failure.
My trip East was on a mission of this kind
and how well I have succeeded is too early to
predict.
Initiation Fees
The men who are in the field are one and
all of the opinion that it is well-nigh impossi-
ble to go into virgin territory and exact from a
poor tuner the $25.00 initiation which our Con-
stitution calls for, and then on top of that $10.00
for dues, making $35.00. He just simply has
not got the money. I would suggest that the
national body in its Constitution set a minimum
fee and leave it to the individual divisions to
set their initiation at that figure, or raise it,
as they may decide.
Membership
There is considerable agitation in some quar-
ters that the national body admit as associate
W. F. McClellan
members such men as have proven themselves
in sympathy and accord with our principles,
the object being to increase our revenue.
Apprentices
One of our duties, and one which is coming
closer to us every day, is the educating of men
in our art to take our places when we are called
to the great beyond. Many times the question,
How about apprentices? is hurled at us. My
opinion on this matter is this: the N. A. of P.
T. has not as yet reached/ that point where it
Highest
Quality
Music Trade Review -- © mbsi.org, arcade-museum.com -- digitized with support from namm.org
AUGUST 8,
1925
would be assured of the combined co-operation
of the entire music industry. This co-operation
is absolutely essential to make a success of
such a proposition.
Service
It is with great pride that I report that for
the first time in its history the question of serv-
ice was put on the convention program of the
National Association of Music Merchants. It
was ably presented by one of our members,
Brother Wm. Braid White, and it brought on
a little discussion. Unfortunately, the time
limit was too short to get in a real punch, but
at that one prominent music merchant pro~
claimed, "Well, I guess they are right." We
at least made a good start.
Publicity
It is the earnest hope of your National Of-
ficers that the necessary funds will be forth-
coming to inaugurate a national educational
news campaign and broadcast through the press
of the whole country the nature and care of
the piano. Also to put before piano manufac-
turers and piano merchants an outline of our
plans to make satisfactory, efficient and paying
departments out of the service end of their
business.
Committee on Pitch
. At the final conference, to which all parties
interested in pitch will be invited, and which
probably will be held this Fall, a real standard
pitch will be adopted and firmly anchored for
a number of years. The National Association
of Piano Tuners, which presented the original
resolution, will then receive the commendation
and praise of the entire musical world for the
good thereby accomplished.
In conclusion, fellow members, we have a
wonderful organization, and we have accom-
plished some wonderful things, but there is a
great deal more to be done to bring to fulfill-
ment our ideals. I therefore plead with every
one of you to give us your earnest and faith-
ful assistance and co-operation, not only by
paying your dues promptly, but by personal
effort to induce every competent tuner you
know or come in contact with to become a
member of the National Association of Piano
Tuners, Inc.
Report of the Secretary
W. F. McClellan, secretary and treasurer of
the Association, then presented his annual re-
port which follows:
"Reviewing the activities and achievements
of the N. A. of P. T., for the past twelve
months, it would appear as though the phenom-
enal increase in the number of members through
the membership drive is the greatest single
feature or objective accomplished since the
Milwaukee Convention.
Perhaps we should
consider it as such as we are now well over
500 members stronger to-day than we were
this time last year, an increase of nearly 50
per cent. With the addition of 500 new mem-
bers, the N. A. of P. T. becomes the largest
and strongest (in point of numbers) unit in
the Music Industries Chamber of Commerce,
all of which is without a doubt a source of
great satisfaction and encouragement to the
officers and members in general and to the old
guard in particular who have worked so hard
and done so much for the Association and for
the piano tuning profession.
"However, notwithstanding the fact that such
wonderful progress has been made in the way
of increasing the membership and building up
a strong and powerful organization of qualified
efficient piano tuners throughout the country,
the progress of the Association along other
lines is still more wonderful and of much great-
er importance than the increase in members
and local divisions. And, in order that every
one may understand and appreciate the more
important though less conspicious features of
the progress of the N. A. of P. T., let us
step down and consider the all too glaring fact
that there are a million out-of-tune pianos in
the United States, and while trained and ex-
perienced business prognosticators estimate a
reasonable and possible fifty-million-dollar an-
THE MUSIC TRADE
REVIEW
nual turnover business for the piano tuning
fraternity, the fact remains that the piano
tuners of this country, independent and em-
ployed, are dragging down something less than
eight million net, just a little over one-tenth
of the amount the tuning business could be
made to yield, a condition which is due to the
lack of organization on the part of the piano
tuners and the method or policy of misrepre-
sentation of the true facts concerning the na-
young and tender plant which will require the
careful attention of the gardeners for some
time to come at least, as it is only in a few
isolated spots throughout the country that the
business aspect of piano tuning is commencing
to take real effect, for in some sections of the
country piano tuning is as dead as it ever was.
Perhaps the best illustration of the true con-
ditions of piano tuning as it was, and as it still
is in many localities throughout the country,
Chicago Delegation to Tuners' Convention
ture and care of the piano by piano dealers
and salesmen in the past.
"Prior to the inception or beginning of the
Tuners' Association, or even up to as late as
the year 1922, piano tuning was not considered
as a business by piano manufacturers, dealers,
salesmen, the public or even the piano tuners
themselves. Piano tuners were not credited as
business men, neither were they rated or recog-
nized as professional men, and they were not
listed in business or telephone directories.
"Therefore, after considering the light in
which piano tuning was held by the public, and
how it was regarded by the piano trade, not as
a business to be engaged in for profit, but
simply as an accessory to the sale department;
a necessary evil and an expense account, that
must be curtailed and eliminated if possible,
we would ask you to consider the attitude of
the piano trade, wholesale and retail, towards
piano tuning and the piano tuner to-day. Also
consider, if you will, the number of large and
powerful piano concerns throughout the coun-
try which are co-operating with the Tuners'
Association in the important work of educating
the piano-owning public in the nature and care
of the piano and otherwise assisting the N. A.
of P. T. to lift piano tuning out of the dead
issue class, thereby creating a business where
no business existed and furnishing the piano
tuners of the country an opportunity to carry
on their work with a certain degree of assur-
ance that their efforts will yield a reasonable
income with a little profit besides.
"More members of the right kind mean a
stronger and more powerful organization along
with all the advantages and benefits that are to
be obtained through such an organization. But
the co-operation of the piano industry means
the development of the piano tuning business,
which in turn means more tuning orders with
better prices and more money for tuners, inde-
pendent and employed. Taking a broad view
of the piano tuning situation, we find the pros-
pects for the future very encouraging.
"Try to guess how much money will be spent
in connection with this meeting of tuners and
technicians. Then consider, if you will, all the
news and trade paper publicity that has been
given this and other conventions, and the num-
ber of educational news articles that have ap-
peared in newspapers and magazines through-
out the country in the past few years pertain-
ing to the care of the piano and the tuning bus-
iness, and it should not be a very difficult
proposition to get a fairly good idea of the
progress that is being made in the way of
elevating the profession and putting piano tun-
ing on a business basis.
"However, it is well for us to understand
that the new piano tuning business is as a very
came from our old friend William Braid
White, when he said that it did not seem to
make any difference to the piano tuners
whether times were good or bad, whether bus-
iness was good and money plentiful or whether
business was bad and money scarce, the piano
tuners went about their work in the same old
way, doing about the usual amount of tuning
and repairing and the reason for this was that
the piano tuners were working on a hard time
basis all the time. This statement was made
some fifteen years ago, and as it was a true
summing up of conditions at that time, it fits
the situation to a greater or less extent to-day
in many parts of this, the wealthiest and most
prosperous country in the world.
"Nevertheless, we are pleased to report that
in certain localities there seems to be some
improvement as there is a much larger number
of successful independent tuners operating
throughout the country than ever before and,
while tuning prices are ridiculously low and
unprofitable in certain sections of the country,
on the whole it may be truthfully said that
tuning prices have advanced in the last year,
and that fair prices are being maintained in
a number of localities where the Association is
strong and the members active. These same
conditions will apply to the salaried tuners,
as it appears that in a general way there has
been some slight increase in salaries but on
the whole the tuners, as a class of skilled work-
men, are very much underpaid, as the average
income of employed tuners is not as high as
the income of a milk wagon driver and many
other unskilled workers.
The tuners, them-
selves, are to blame for this condition, as the
remedy is at hand, and if the tuners have not
the courage, brains and energy to take ad-
vantage of the opportunity offered them by
the N. A. of P. T., Inc., then they are not
entitled to as much pay as the milk wagon
driver, for the milk wagon driver knows what
he must do in order to make more money, and
does it. When the employed tuners wake up
to the fact that there are certain things to be
done, certain conditions that must be pro-
duced or brought about before they can com-
mence to drag down the salary of a milk wagon
driver, make up their minds to quit their fool-
ishness, join the Association and help to ele-
vate the profession, then and only then can
they expect to receive the pay that a specialized
workman possessing the skill, ability and ex-
perience of a piano tuner should receive.
"To increase the membership of an organiza-
tion such as the N. A. of P. T., Inc., to a figure
somewhere close to five hundred, and do it in
seven or eight months, is a wonderful feat in
itself. To secure the goodwill, co-operation
(Continued on page 16)

Download Page 4: PDF File | Image

Download Page 5 PDF File | Image

Future scanning projects are planned by the International Arcade Museum Library (IAML).

Pro Tip: You can flip pages on the issue easily by using the left and right arrow keys on your keyboard.