Music Trade Review

Issue: 1925 Vol. 80 N. 6

Music Trade Review -- © mbsi.org, arcade-museum.com -- digitized with support from namm.org
THE
8
MUSIC TRADE
REVIEW
St. Louis Better Business Bureau Uses
Newspapers to Combat "Bait" Publicity
Uses Quarter Page Space to Expose This Method of Selling Instruments—Theodore Maetten
Returns to Retail Force of the Kieselhorst Piano Co.—Other Notes of the Trade
C T . LOUIS, MO., February 2.—About the best
thing that can be said for January business
is that it was well behaved. Nothing impetuous
or hurried about it. Throughout the month it
moved with what might be called a stately pace,
slighly accelerated as the month advanced, but
H. Lere are two pianos.
One of them is advertised, but is
not for sale.
The other is for sale, but is not ad-
vertised.
. . . . Both instruments are pre-
cisely alike, and yet
many people are pay-
ing $260 more for one
than for the other.
A music store ad-
vertises a sale of the
X Grand Piano, at
the " r e m a r k a b l e
price of $318.50, in-
cluding s e a t a n d
floor lamp."
When you go to that store to see
the instrument, the salesman tells you
frankly that he cannot recommend the
X Grand, and urges you not to con-
sider it. Instead he steers you over to
another instrument, the Y Grand,
which he praises as a much finer piece
of merchandise.
The price? . . . . Oh yes, $578.50.
. . . . And he marshals all the
blandishments of selling to persuade
you to pay $260.00 more than the price
mentioned in his advertisement for a
piano precisely like the X Grand, save
c
the Globe-Democrat, because all St. Louis news-
papers were notified by the Better Business Bu-
reau, Inc., that copy and sales methods failed
to meet with the standards of truth and busi-
ness morality set by the Bureau." So thus the
controversy rests.
that his firm has had the name "Y
Grand" stenciled on it.
Or perhaps it will work this way:
Perhaps you will insist upon buy-
ing the X Grand as
advertised . . . . And
you'll deposit $100 on
it.
Within a day or
so, the salesman will
phone that unfortun-
ately the s o u n d i n g
board of your piano,
the last X Grand in
the warehouse, has
been broken.
. . . . But he has another piano,
the Y Grand for $578.50, etc., etc., as
we have heard him say before.
Be careful . . . .Go slowly. $260
is worth saving.
When the attitude of a merchant
leads you to suspect that he is unwill-
ing to back up his advertising offer, in-
sist upon your rights. Tell us about
it, if you will.
Help us protect all buyers against
"sharp" practice. Buy from reliable
dealers. Do not be guided by price
alone.
Uhe BETTER
BUSINESS BUREAU
of SAINT LOUIS, Inc.
St. Louis Better Business Bureau Advertising
A. T. Schuldes, treasurer of the Straube Piano
never by any chance simulating a scramble.
The acceleration toward the end of the month Co., Hammond, Ind., visited A. C. Thiebes, on
was the best thing about it. This was con- his way back to the factory from a trip to
sistent and fairly substantial. February starts Duquoin, 111.
A. C. Thiebes, president of the Thiebes Piano
off with business holding the advantage it gained
in January. All signs point to a gradually im- Co., has returned from Hammond, Ind., where
he attended a factory convention for three days
proving condition.
Now the Better Business Bureau is taking a at the Straube Piano Co.
Theodore W. Maetten, formerly for twenty
hand publicly in the controversy that has been
waging for weeks over the ethics of piano ad- years with the Kieselhorst Piano Co., who went
vertising, as exemplified in local newspapers. over to the Aeolian Co. nearly two years ago,
In a quarter-page space it tells "A Tale of Two is back with the Kieselhorst Co., beginning to-
Pianos," in a fashion that has aroused much in- day. William F. Davie, who has been advertis-
ing manager of the Aeolian Co., is also now with
terest. The ad is reproduced herewith.
Another angle of the controversy is a dispute the Kieselhorst Co.
E. J. Schuessler, formerly with Davidson's,
between the Globe-Democrat and the Star as to
gains in musical display advertising in 1924. Des Moines, la., and the G. A. Crancer Music
First the Globe claimed to be the only St. Louis Co., Lincoln, Neb., started with the Kieselhorst
newspaper which gained in musical display ad- Co. Thursday.
vertising last year. The Star denied the claim
E. C. Johnston, formerly with Sherman, Clay
and presented figures to show that it, too, had & Co., and Kohler & Chase, at San Francisco,
increased. The Globe's explanation is that the will join the Kieselhorst organization soon.
Star's calculation includes "a significant amount
E. Robert Schmitz, using a Mason & Hamlin
of other types of advertising which the Globe- piano provided by the Kieselhorst Piano Co.,
Democrat does not classify with the regular gave a recital Saturday night at Sheldon
sales display advertising of regular musical ad- Memorial.
vertisers," including "stunt" advertising offering
prizes for the names of prospective customers
Alberto Sciarretti, the eminent Italian pianist,
sent in to musical houses and lineage in a spe- has selected the Mehlin concert grand for his
cial theatre building section. Continuing, the tour of recitals. He will give a recital at St.
Globe says: "Again, the Star has tabulated the Elizabeth College, Convent Station, N. J., on
advertising of a large user of space whose ad- February 3; another at Aeolian Hall, New York
vertising, since the early part of December, City, on February 5, and a third at Jordan
1924, has been denied a place in the columns of Hall, Boston, Mass., on February 25.
KKRRWAKY 7,
1925
Fradkin Appointed Musical
Director of New Theatre
To Have Charge of Musical Program of the
New Piccadilly Theatre in New York—Exclu-
sive Brunswick Recording Artist
Frederick Fradkin, at one time concert mas-
ter of the Boston Symphony Orchestra and
now an exclusive Brunswick recording artist,
has recently been appointed to the important
post of musical director of the Piccadilly The-
atre, Broadway and Fifty-second street, New
York. This theatre is one of Broadway's newer
motion picture palaces, located in the heart of
the Great White Way, and is unique in that it
is the only prominent picture house on Broad-
way that gives a midnight performance.
An announcement of this new post for Mr.
Fradkin has just been sent to Brunswick deal-
ers throughout the country by the Brunswick-
r>alkc-Collender Co., Chicago, accompanied by a
complete list of violin recordings made by him
on Brunswick records. To further stimulate
the dealer's interest, a sample copy of Piccadilly
News, published weekly by the theatre, and con-
taining weekly comments on the motion picture
industry by Mr. Fradkin, lias been sent out
with the other announcements.
Death of Oscar H. Bollman,
St. Louis Trade Veteran
Founder of Bollman Bros. Piano Co. Passes
Away at Home of Son in Colorado Springs—
Was in His 73rd Year
ST. LOUIS, MO., February 3.—Oscar II. Holliuan,
one of the founders of the Bollman Bros. Piano
Co., and prominent in musical circles here for
years, died recently at the home of his son at
Colorado Springs, Col., where he had resided
since the death of his wife in November. He
was 73 years old. He is survived by two sons
and a daughter. Interment was at Colorado
Springs.
Philpitt Builds in Miami
MIAMI, FI.A., February 2.--A contract for the
rrcction of a one-story building at I In. 1 corner
of Lincoln road and Jefferson avenue has just
been let by the E. Ernest Philpitt Co., Florida
representative for the Steinway piano. The
building will have 50 feet frontage and a depth
of 105 feet, and will be built with a sufficiently
firm foundation to allow for the addition of two
upper floors at a later date. The estimated
cost of the structure will be $35,000. It will be
occupied by the Philpitt establishment alone.
New Marengo Building
QUINCY, MASS., January 31.—Completion of the
new building of the Marengo Music Co., of this
city, is looked forward to during the next
month. The structure is a four-story building
of brick and granite, of which the music com-
pany will occupy the entire first floor together
with parts of the second and third floors.
Hall Music Go. Chartered
AHILENK, TEX., January 31.—The Hall Music Co.,
of this city, has recently been incorporated with
a capital stock of $50,000. The officers are Mrs.
Ozia Hall, Emmett Hall and Elmon Hall. The
Hall concern will handle a general line of music
goods here in modern wareroonis.
Aeolian Go. Visitor
Among the visitors at the executive offices of
the Aeolian Co., New York, during the past
week was P. W. Stallsmith, of the Stallsniilh
Music Co., Gettysburg, Pa.
Music Trade Review -- © mbsi.org, arcade-museum.com -- digitized with support from namm.org
FKBRUARY 7,
1925
THE MUSIC TRADE
REVIEW
The Weather and the Sales You Make
Weather Days, Seasons, All Affect the Volume of Sales of the Retail Music Merchant—"Shut-In" Weather
Usually Good for Business—Some Merchants Find Monday a Better Day Than Saturday
—Meeting the Seasonal Dullness by Better Methods—An Article by J. H. Duncan
UT of the wails and shrieks of Winter
winds, out of the long days and nights
of the silent sifting down to earth of the
ever-deepening snows, out of the reverberation
of thunder and the torrential downpours of
Springtime rains—out of all the capers with
which the elements grimly keep households
prisoner in the hours when pleasures abroad
beckon comes the call to the music store.
Strange idea, is it? You don't quite grasp it?
Then all you need to set you straight on the
psychology of it is to talk with almost any of
Baltimore's keen, observant music store sales
managers. Just broach the subject in any of
these stores along famous old Charles street or
Lexington or Howard. It's a business proposi-
tion with them and they are posted on all an-
gles of it. They are even ready to delve deep
into the psychological causes of the ups and
downs in their seasonal sales records. But
nearly all of them agree that bad weather
makes good music business, and the longer the
bad weather lasts the bigger the music business
that comes in its wake. And some of them
have discovered that right in the midst of bad
weather is one of the best times to set about
getting new business.
"There is no, doubt that people kept longer
than usual in their homes and cut off from
their customary diversion by ugly weather turn
more than ever to their musical instruments,
and if they have not one their thoughts turn
more than ever to the lack of it," said W. L.
Roberts, assistant sales manager of the Kranz-
Smith Piano Co. "We have had proof of this
again and again in the rush business that has
come to us after a spell of dismal weather.
Persons who had talking machines had used
their records so much that they wanted new
ones, and those families who had no talking
machine and wanted one had suddenly felt the
urge and found means to get one. Those who
had pianos wanted new music, and those with-
out one evidently had come to a decision long
deferred. Many of them were downtown on
musical missions bent almost before the rains
or the snows had dried on the streets. Some
of them even braved cold or rain or snow to
come down to the store for new records or
music. Most of them want dance music or jazz
or spirited airs. Few inquire for the senti-
mental pieces at such times.
"All this," continued Mr. Roberts, "is just
the psychological reaction of people to the im-
pression bad weather makes upon them. Most
people, whether home-bodies or votaries of the
night life, feel a restlessness of mind, a subcon-
sciousness of being thwarted by nature's ugly
moods when bad weather compels abandon-
ment of any thought of going out. They have
a sense of impotency against it and they want
distraction. The usual recourse of conversa-
tion or reading does not dim the sounds of rag-
ing elements without, the dash and patter of
rain against the windows or the moans and
shrieks of winds about the house. The conver-
sation grows fitful, forced, and somebody will
always stop to say: 'Ugh—just listen to that
wind!' Or the mind, trying too hard to hold
itself to. the printed page, can't help jumping
from it to visualize that last terrific gust that
swept past. Yet, on a calm evening in pleasant
weather this same home circle might not have
the least difficulty in making itself a contented
or even merry one with its own devices.
"But on those dismal evenings the human
soul cannot shake off a sense of depression.
Then, as most humans have ever done, they find
O
that deep down in their souls what they want
is music. If there is a musical instrument or
talking machine in the house, more often than
not it will be resorted to by the entire family,
or some member will ask another to play.
"Nor is there anything to be marveled at in
this quick turning of the human soul to music
for solace when the elements rage. Think of
some of those great tragedies of the sea. I
dimly recall one in which a troopship—British,
1 think—was foundering in a storm while bring-
ing home men who had been serving long in
some colonial possession. It was seen by all
that she must soon make her final plunge. Word
went through her that they would show they
could go down to death gallantly. The regi-
iment was massed before its commander. The
band was ordered to the quarterdeck, and with
the exultant strains of a spirited march, ded-
icated to this famous regiment, defying the
roaring tempest, they cheered until the waves
closed over ship and men. Helpless there, it
was music that susta ned them."
Good on Fair Days
Another thing peculiar to the music business
which Mr. Roberts has noted is that ordinarily
in fair weather business is better on Mondays
and Saturdays, and between the hours of 10:30
and noon and 3 and 5 in the afternoon.
T account for the days named being the
busiest," said Mr. Roberts, "by the fact that
over week-ends members of families can con-
fer more leisurely about their musical tastes
and needs and reach a decision, and on Monday
some member attends to the buying. The Sat-
urday buyers are those who neglected to carry
out the previous week-end's decision until the
next week-end's arrival spurred them to it. Just
the difference between prompt persons and pro-
crastinators. As for the hours mentioned, I
think this is merely a matter of convenient
shopping hours for most people.
"It is noticeable also that the fifteenth of
1 lie month, or thereabouts, brings a certain in-
crease in business, which I attribute mainly to
the fact that families which have been discuss-
ing among themselves the purchase of an in-
strument usually know about that time what
their budget for the month's necessities will
be, and a musical instrument being in the na-
ture of a luxury they can make up their minds
as to whether they will purchase or not.
Busiest Months
"On the whole I may say that our busiest
months, outside of the Christmas season, are
September and October and March and April.
During the first two people are settling them-
selves for the Winter and providing for home
entertainment. During the latter two they are
planning for entertainment at their Summer
places, such as country houses, camps and
shore-houses. With each seasonal change of
abode they think of getting new music or they
fancy some new instrument.
"The Summer months are really our dullest
period. Then we turn our attention to pushing
specialties as a means of developing business,
such as cleaning devices for instruments and
special attachments. By this means we also en-
deavor to have our salesmen ascertain what
households are without musical instruments of
any kind and what kind they would like. All
this information is filed and 'prospects' are
listed and worked upon then or at any time.
Tt all helps to get business and get the most
possible out of the dull season."
Harry H. Juelg, manager of the Lexington
Talking Machine Shop, Inc., dealer in general
musical merchandise, firmly believes that the
music business wouldn't be nearly so enormous
a part of the nation's commercial and industrial
life if it were not for all the worst stunts that
Old Boreas, Jupiter Pluvius and Mother Goose
can pull singly or in concert as the unrivaled
joy-killers.
"Why, think of it," he said, "if the stingiest
man that ever made his wife have to ask him
for a dollar to buy herself rouge and lipsticks
with were tied up in his home by a storm for
three nights, and couldn't sit in the little penny-
ante game with the boys, he would be likely to
tell her to step to it if she suggested that a
talking machine or player-piano would be nice
to have in the house on such a night. This
kind of a man would be just that irritated and
uncomfortable at having to sit and talk to his
wife alone on such evenings that he would leap
to the suggestion of something that would
make him forget they were alone. And she—
wouldn't she be tickled at the prospect of not
having to sit and talk to the old bear, but just
turn on the music and let it find its way into
the void where his soul ought to be?
"That's one kind of a home that suddenly
gets filled with the sound of music in the eve-
nings after several rapidly recurring spells of
bad weather. Just think then of the thousands
of other homes that one after another want
music in them, but for happier reasons, when
the weather howls. At least that's the way I
look at it when I see how brisk business gets
after a lot of bad weather."
Killing the Dullness
In addition to joining with other executives
in the view that bad weather and lots of it,
with occasional intervening fair days, makes
business vastly better for the music stores than
would long stretches of good weather, Leo J.
Driscoll, manager of the Peabody Piano Co.,
dealers in general musical lines, expressed the
opinion that the dull period of late Spring and
Summer can be made to yield good business by
the employment of original methods.
"Last year," said Mr. Driscoll, "I hit upon
the idea of using the school teachers of the
entire State to start a campaign for good 'pros-
pects.' Through the Board of Education we
got the names and address of all of them.
We* sent a nice letter to each one and asked
her to accept the accompanying song book as
a little present from us. Then we reminded
her that music is a refiining influence in the
home, and that such a home influence makes
better school children. We concluded by ask-
ing her if she would not, at her convenience and
in her own way, learn which of her pupils'
homes were without musical instruments of
any kind and send us a list of them. Of course
all the teacher had to do was to ask the ques-
tion of the class and have the children whose
hands shot upward give the names and ad-
dresses of their parents.
"The result was we received nearly four hun-
dred lists of such homes. With these we
started salesmen to working each town. The
business we got far exceeded our expectations.
In one small town alone our salesman sold
twenty talking machines right around a local
music store that had been in the business
twenty years. During this campaign we also
secured a considerable number of additional
'prospects' which we are turning into sales from
time to time.
"Really," concluded Mr. Driscoll, "these dull
periods are just fine times to do some vigorous
brain-cudgeling. It is likely to pay."

Download Page 8: PDF File | Image

Download Page 9 PDF File | Image

Future scanning projects are planned by the International Arcade Museum Library (IAML).

Pro Tip: You can flip pages on the issue easily by using the left and right arrow keys on your keyboard.