Music Trade Review

Issue: 1923 Vol. 77 N. 22

.
..

DECEMBER 1, 1923
THE
MUSIC
TRADE
REVIEW
11
What Is the Overhead Expense Limit
Overhead Problems in the Talking Machine Department of the General Music Store Much Less Complex Due
to the General Practice of This Branch of the Music Industries in Pricing Instruments on a National
Basis and Selling at a Discount From the Retail List to the Dealer
'r
J
~
.
Talkin g m ac hines an d records are sold as
widely in the general music store as are piano·s ;
in fact, the music merchant who handles th e
latter and not the former is a striking exception
in the trade. How ever, the problem of over­
head in the talking machine department differs
radically from that in most of th e other depart­
ments in the slor e, since national retail prices
prevail in that end of the t ra.de and the deal er
is sharply limited by the discount which he re­
ceives from the manufacturer and must adjust
his overhead within the limits of this margin.
A second fa cto r in this co ndition is that the
le ad in g lin es of talking nuchin es and records are
nationally advertised an d that a good proportion
of th e retail se llin g work, as a consequence, is
done by the manufacturer. ll ence th e overhead
expense in thi s (lepartment tends to range lower
than it doe s in most of the other departments
of the gen era l music stores.
The se facts were all clearly developed in the
investigation of overhead expense in retail music
stores recen tly conducted by The Review. The
rep lies of the dealers sho w ed lower overheads
here and developed clearly the difference in the
problems of this department. They showed that
the talking machine department manager is in
a fa vor ed position, since he has a definite pur­
chas.e price and a definite selling price, with
an exact percentage of mark-up between the
two. The problem here, therefore, is not to
mark th e goods to cover his o·verh ead and n et
profit, but rather to keep the overhead so far
within the mark-Up limits a s to allow for a
suitab le net pro fit in the final a naly sis.
T he qu estion for th e head of the ta lk ing
machine department is not so much whether
the di s count from the list price of the manu­
facturer is 40 or 40 and 10 or 50 pe r cent, as
it is how he ca n keep his distributing expense,
in cluding all overhead charges, wit h in a fi gure
th at will a llov,( him to retain at lea st 10 per cent
of the sellin g price, or perhaps more, as his own.
Average Figures Used
The fic:ures used in this table are, of course,
average ones. Th ere are talking machine de­
partments in general music stores the over­
head expense of which ran ge much higher than
those quoted h e re. Salaries were reported as
high as 16 per cent, delivery charges in some
cases went over 3 per cent, rent was r eported
as hi gh as 7 per cent and advertising as 9 per
cen t. But these were the except ional cases; in
fact, houses th at reported gen eral overheads of
ov e r 30 per cent were few an d far between.
Yct th ere was one of the larges t houses in the
country the average overhead expense of which
ran over this figure.
Althou g h th e he ad of the talkin,:; machine
department has th e advantage of fixed costs and
fixed selling prices in figuring his business ac­
co unt s, he is handicapped in a considerable
measure on that ve r y account, for, as pointed
o ut in this article al ready, he must keep his
JUNIUS HART OPENS NEW STORE
ADDS TWO STORIES TO BUILDING
Well-known New Orleans Music House Oc­
cupies New Four-story Building
KNOXVIL.LE, TE'IN., '\'ovemher 24.- -The J. V.
Led.'.;erwoocl 'lvIusic Co., of this cit y, ha s an­
nounced plans for the addition of two stories
[0 the building w hich the con cern now occupies.
This is the iourth ('xpansion of thi s firm.
)1,,\\. OR!.E.\,>,S, L.\., November 26.-The ne\\
Cjuartcc, of the Junius Hart Pi ano Co a t 123
('a rond e1c t str eet h ave just b een formally
op ened, and will afford the company spacioLl~
an d up-to-date showrooms befittin ;.~ their re pu­
t ~ltion
and prestige.
The Hart conce rn,
31 th o u ~ h a Lo ui siana corporati on , is the Soul h­
e rn representative of W. W . Kimball &. Co., of
Chicago, alld the Kimball piano is handled ('x
elusively. The house dates b ack to 1872, when
it was fir st established at (a nal and BUfl';llndy.
FrolTl there the firm moved to other points in
the Cana l street zone, being cO lJlpelled to seek
more co mlTlodious quarters for it s incrC:lsing
business .
.'\ conside rabl e part of the front of the new
store is devoted to large display window o
capablc: of g-iving- a com prehen sive idea of the
~ tor e 's co nt ents. Flanking th e entrance passage
are the departillents subleased to thr Conn New
Orleans Co., rer:ional ag ent s for Conn band
instrulllent<, and the sheet music shor> of Frank
& yIcNall1a ra, who ga ined their experience
w ith Leo Feist, Inc., in )lew York. The sound­
proof booths for phonograph records and pla yer
rolls are equipped with an apparatus fo r private
demonstration, and are supplied w ith purified
ai r by a special vt;ntilation device.
The store in its completed form is one o.f the
finest in the South.
With thi s article is published a table of av er­
age overhead expenses in tlie talkin g machin e
departments of a large number of general music
~to-res, compiled from the results of The Re-
fllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllnlllllllllllllllllllllllllllll!IIIII1I1111U1I11II1lI!llIIlIIIIIllIIIIIIllIllUlllllllllllllllllii
~
Overhead in the Talking Machine ~
Department
~
i Salaries .... . ......... . l3perc en t I
~ Delivery ..............
2 per cent i
~ Repai r Department ... .
1 per cent ~
i Advertising ... .'....... 6 per cent i
~ Rent ........... ,. .... .
3percent ~
~ Depreciation ..... . ....
1 per cent ~
= Financing and carrying
i
trade-ins ............
.1 pe r cent
~
i
~
Total overhead expense
27 per cent ;
~llIltjllljlllll'lllllllllllilmllll.'UilUUillll lllllllllllllllllllllllllllllli l,1!1I1I11H1l"IIIIJJiI:LUllfllllllJllml(llJlJIIl! l l lil'lIlIllJlJ[llll~
view's questionnaire, and which strikin g ly con­
firm this analysis of the situation:
AMES BUVS OUT S. J. SLOANE
CAMF.1{() N, Mo .. November 26.-F. H. Ames, of
Jamesport. has purcha sed the m usic and jewelry
business co sts within the prescribed limI ts and
must do this adjusting by shaving here a nd
th ere, rather than as in the case with other
products, not na ti onally priced, increasing his
mark-up to allow for the n et profit margin. In
other words, if a department manager finds
that it is co'Sting him 3S per cent of his retail
price to move the goods, leaving him only 5
per ce nt net profit, he cannot increase that sell­
ing price to protect th e n ex t margin, for the
list price is the maximum price. His only
course lies in effecting economies in hi~ bu~i­
ness al ong lines that ar e at lea st lik ely to cut
down this disproportio.nate percentage.
The importance of providin g suffici ent ne t
p rofits through the mediuTll of econ o lilies, in
businesses \\here an u pward revision of resale
prices is not possible, has been realized by th e
united States Go·vernment itself, which, through
th e D epartment of Commerce, ha s called con­
ferences of business men to consider the ques­
tion of eliminating waste in th e distribution of
\ arious products. The president of the Nat ional
Assoc iation of Mu si c Merchants, with which a
lar !;e number of talking machine dealers are
affi li ated , ha s likewise taken cognizance of the
import a nce of this work by app ointing- a com­
mittee of repre;; entative trade m embers to con­
sider a nd report on the same problem.
Economies Through Better Selling Plans
By putting economies into effect it is not
lil eant that savings shou ld be made on equip­
ment, on stock or by hiring sa les people of low
caliber. The way out is more likely to be found
in rearranging the sales plan and th e advertis­
ing plan, including the covering of the mailing
li cien cy an d, consequently, greater re su lts. In
short, th e problem is no t so nlu ch that of do­
ing- the same volume of business at le ~s exp e nse,
but ratht'r of d etermining ways and m ea ns for
handling a larger volume of business at the
same expe ns e.
business of S. J. Sloane, who has been es tab­
lished h ere since 1907. The new proprietor is
already in c harge of th e s tor e. Mr. Sloane will
rpmain in Cameron and will be an officer in the
Citizens' State Bank.
SIOUX FALLS CO. BANKRUPT
SIO UX FALLS, S. D., NO\'embe t 26.-The Sioux
Falls Piano Co., throu gh its owner, George L.
Fish, has filed a petition in bankruptcy with
liab iliti es of $46,164 and assets of $22.
Florey Bros. Grand Pianos Are Distinguished
THEY are distinguished from all other brands for several
important reasons. Among these we might mention
. '.
f. ~ "
_._ 'c'l
~...J
~
t;~j:­
",.:1
,
Washington
Exceptional standard of mu sical tone, individual design and
unusual refinement in workmanship and finish. They are
manifestly superior in every detail, made by OLD SCHOOL
CRAFTSMEN, on a basis of Quality Standard rather than Quan­
tity Output.
Dealers whose customers discriminate
should write for our literature .
1J11orry 1!lr05.
New] ersey
THE
12
MUSIC
TRADE
REVIEW
DUO-ART FILM, "SONIA'S SONG," APPEARS IN ST. LOUIS
David Pesetzki, Pianist, Who Appeared in Conjunction W ith It, G ives Numbe r of R ecitals­
G. Spiekerman Returns to Lehman-Local Piano Trade Showing Consistent I mprovement
S1' Lons, ~Io., N ovember 27.-The piano busi­
n ess ente rs the November hom e stre tch goin g
sttady to strong. The s tead ine ss g rows out of
th e g rad uall y improvin g co ndition of the past
few weeks a nd the s tren g th co mes from' the
g rowin g volume of pre- Ch ri~tma s busine ss. Th e
s itu a tion is helped by la tc Aut umn weathe r with
whi ch nobody but th e coal men ca n find fau lt.
Llri g ht, c ri sp days lure thron gs to the business
di st rict, which increas es the number of drop-ins
and in quirie s, and salesmen have no difficulty
in ge ttin g p ro s pect s to· t he sto res, by day or
ni g ht. And sa les us ually result, because the
pri ces a nd the terms a re ri gh t and the people
have mo ney. Good "down" payments are being
sec ur ed an d th e tendency of purchasers is to
payoff, in man y instan ces, b efore the deferred
payme nt s have run th eir co ur se.
Sales for
Chri stma ' de li ve ry in crease f rom day to day.
Piano firms a re advert isin g more freely and
t hr piano sectio ns of the department stores are
ge tting a more liberal a ll otment of the adver­
tising spac e of their houses .
There a re some drawb ac ks to th e incr eas e of
advertising, as it is viewed at the Conroy Piano
Co. " \\ 'ho know s," t he firm asks in its own
a d ve rti s in g, " wh e re to bu y ·a pia no when furn i­
ture storeS, phono g raph s hop s, dr y goo ds con­
cerns , etc. , offer 'wonderful piano bargains' a nd
every adv ertis!'ment a ppears most promising'
But there is a way out. The way, as mi g-ht be
im ag ined, is to ;zo to Conroy's a nd buy "ins tru­
ment s of national reput at ion with a definite
gua ra nte e a nd ilctual resa le val ue. "
David l ' eset zk i, a pp ea rin g this wee k a t th e
Kew Grand Central in "S on ia's Son~," Duo-Art
fa nt a,y, s pen t a lso mo st of la s t week here and
appea red befo re a number of organizations, t he
Chamber of Com merc e, t he Sales M anagers'
bur ea u a nd the R(lsat i Kain Ch oral Cl ub at the
St. Louis Uni vers it y Auditori um. And to-mor-
CHARACTER
"Admirable Quality; Acknowledged Reputation"
-(Standard Dictionary)
PIANOS
Manufactured by
Smith, Barnes
==========and==========
Strohber C08
have for 33 years
justified their right
to be called
Pianos of Character
FACTORIES
Chicago, III.
OFFICE
1872 Clybourn Avenue
Chicago, III.
I , 1923
sen t by express and this order will stand until
after Ch ristm as
G. Spiekerman, formerly with the Lehman
1 'iano Co., but for th e past few months looking
after hi s personal in tcn;s ts, is back with t ha t
firm.
Mr. :Mu lca h y, of the Schubert Piano Co., New
York, was h ere las t week, as were W. J . Eden,
of the Gulbr anse n-Dickinson Co., Chicago, an d
vViIliam A ll en, of the Chicago office of t he
Kohler Industries.
A. H . Groves, formerly with the Ki ese lhors t
Piano Co., has taken a positio n wi th the Wllr­
litzer Co.
~
7
AMPICO IN DAILY CONCERTS AT PACIFIC EXPOSITiON
G. F . Johnson Piano Co., of Portland, Makes Fi~e Exhibit o f Ampico in the Chickeri n.g -Seiber­
ling-Lucas Piano Co. Takes Pease Agency-Business Reported Good by Local Trade
P O~Tl.\NI), OIlE., No ve mher 17.- Th(; Japanese
gover nm e nt this week, thro u gh th e Jap a n ese
a mba ssa d or at Washington, D. c., placed a n
ord er for ap p rox im ately '100,000,000 feet of lum ­
be r to b e u sed by the Japanese governmen t in
it s r econs tru ction policy. The val ue of th e deal
wa s $3,000,000. App r ox imately a third of thi s
lumbe r wi ll be shi pped thro u gh the Port of
Portland and th e bulk of the order, it is an­
no un ced, will b e su pplied by the mills of Orego n
and So uthw es te rn \;1" a ~hington. The delive ry is
to start at on ce a nd the wee kly report of the
1I1 ills for last w ee k shows prod uctiun to be
27 per ce nt above norm al. Thi s condition is
1 eflec ted in a ll lines of busin ess an d, with un­
emp lo yme nt a thin g of the past, the music dea l­
ers co ntinue th eir optimism and look forw a rd
with the u tmos t confidence .
During the week of "'Iovemb er 3 to 10 the
~, nnu a l l 'acific Intern tion was he ld in Port la nrl a nd th e reg ist ra tion
showed tha t oV<' r 125,000 perso ns passed th e
turnst iles durin g the week. T h e G. F. John so n
Pia no Co. took advantage of the occasion to
present a n artistic ex hib it at the expos ition fea­
turing the Ampico in the Chickerin g. E very
af ternoo n and evening during th e week Ampico
con cer ts were g iven to enthusiastic audie n ces.
Sherman, Clay & Co. fea tur ed the Duo-Art twice
daily over the Oregonian broa dcasting s ta tion,
KG \Iv, a nd th e numb ers were greatly enjoyed
by th e exposition crowds. This fea ture was
und er the direc tion o,f Alex R ei ll y, of the Duo­
/\rt department, who was assiste d by th e young
ladies of the s he et music department, an d
among the numbc:rs feat u red were the Sherman,
Clay songs, "The Wes t, a Nest an d You, "
"Slee p," " Just an O ld L ove Song" and "I Cried
for You."
Th e Pea se piano ha s bee n adde d to t he line
of th e Seibe rlin g-Lucas Musi c Co. and the fir st
shipment has been re ceiv ed and placed on the
disp lay flo or . At thi s time only th 'e upright
models will be ha ndl ed. Frank Lucas says that
bu siness co n ti nu("s to be v ery good and says
th a t th e dema nd for the Gulbransen piano is
s o grea t th a t t hey are una ble at thi s tim e to
keep a supp ly on hand.
E. J. Meyers, mana ger of the music a l m e r­
cha ndi se de pa rtm ent o f the B ush & L ane Pi ano
Co. , says that the] erry R eed Orchestra of th e
Hotel ~lu l tnomah an d th e Blu e Mouse Theat re
is practically a Holton orga ni zat ion and is prov­
ing a g ood a d ve rtisin g ca rd for that line. An ­
other orches t ra to prefer the Holton is Bill
Darby's O rch es tra a t the Cotillion Dan ce H a ll.
EFFORTS TO SECURE TAX REFUNDS
se nt out a qu es tionnaire to all co rpor a te mem­
bers of the va riou s assoc iation s.
V-' h en the q ues tionnaires are returned a char t
wi ll be prepa red show in g a com po site of the
returns of all co rporate members without indi­
ca tin g the ide ntit y of the mem bers repo rti ng,
and it i~ believed t hat an average fi gu re w ill
be sec ur ed t ha t will ena bl e a numb er of con ­
cerns to sec ur e rei un ds under the law as it is
at present cons titut ed .
In se ndin g out t he questionnair e th e Cham­
ber urges promptness in r eplyin g in o rd er that
action m ay b e tak e n before being barred by th e
,t a tute of li mitat ions on relief claims.
Chamber of Commerce Points Out Way Whe re­
by Co rporations in the Trade May Secure a
Re fund on Excess and War P rofi t s Taxes
.D
North Milwaukee, Wis.
row night h e appea rs b efore the St. Loui s Ad­
vert isin g Club.
1\ udolph Ganz, director of the St. Louis Sym­
phony Society, made his only app earance for
the season as a pia nist at th e Odeon Saturday
ni gh t, u s in g the Steinway Grand Duo -"\rt.
Manager Chrisle r, of the ,'\ eol ian Co. of :M is­
souri, has pla ce d a ,tand in g orde r for an y
Stei nw ay ~ th a t ca n be sh ipp ed to h im to be
DECEMBER
The Music Ind ustries Chamber of Commerce
ha s take n s teps to secure for various members
of t he tr ade where po ss ibk a refund of taxes as
p rovi d ed for unde r cel-tai n con ditions of the
F ederal T ax Law whic h s tates that co rporations
may have refun ded to th em such excess a nd
war profits taxes as Illay have be en paid, whe n
the total of s uch ta x is in excess of the average
lax paid b y re pres entative, co mparative con­
cerns engage d in the same or simi lar business.
T o illustra te: If the exee~s or war pro fit s tax
paid b y a company is equ al to, say, 10 per cen t
of its taxab le income for a certain year, an d it
is d etermine d th a t t he average of su ch ' tax pay­
m ent b) repr('sentativ~, compara ti ve conce rns
is on ly 5 per c(' nt , th en, under certai n con­
ditions, a com pan y rn a} file a re lief claim a nd
secu re a refund of the tax paid in exce" of
l he averag<'.
In order th a t any co rpo r ation m ay determine
w h et her or not it s pe rce nta ge o f cxcess or war
profits tax, as pa id , was relatively hi gh or lo w,
ill compa ri so n with t hat pai d by other concerns,
it will b e necessary to as certai n th e ave rage
pe rce n tage paid b ,' ot he r co n cernS. In orde r
to sec ure this informa tion the Chamber has
AInerican
Piano Wire
"Perfected"
"Crown"
H ighest acoustic excellence dating back to the
days of J onas Chickeri ng. T oo k prize ove r who le
world at Pari s, 1900. For generation s th e
sta nda rd, and used on the greatest number of
pianos in the world.
Services of our Acoustic Engineer always available -- Iree
illustrated books-free
Alllerican Steel & Wire
ACOUST IC CEPARTMENT
Company
20e 5 . LA SALLE ST. , CHICAGO
M ore Cunningham pianos are found in Philadelphia homes than
any other and you can accomplish the , same results in your
city.
Ask for our plan of selling Cunningham pianos.
y

Download Page 11: PDF File | Image

Download Page 12 PDF File | Image

Future scanning projects are planned by the International Arcade Museum Library (IAML).

Pro Tip: You can flip pages on the issue easily by using the left and right arrow keys on your keyboard.