Music Trade Review

Issue: 1921 Vol. 73 N. 15

Music Trade Review -- © mbsi.org, arcade-museum.com -- digitized with support from namm.org
THE MUSIC TRADE REVIEW
REVIEW
PUBLISHED BY EDWARD LYMAN BILL, Inc.
President and Treasurer, C. L. Bill, 373 Fourth Ave., New York; Vice-President,
J. B. Spillane, 373 Fourth Ave., New York; Second Vice-President, Raymond Bill, 373
Fourth Ave., New York; Secretary, Edward Lyman Bill, 373 Fourth Ave., New York;
Assistant Treasurer, Wm. A. Low.
J. B. SPILLANE, Editor
RAY BILL, B. B. WILSON, BRAID WHITE, Associate Editors
WILSON D. BUSH, Managing Editor
CARLETON CHACE, Business Manager
L. E. BOWERS, Circulation Manager
Executive and Reportorial Staff
EDWARD VAM HARUNGEN, V. D. WALSH, E. B. MUNCH, LEE ROBINSON, C. R. TIGHE,
EDWAKD LYMAN BILL, SCOTT KINGWILL, THOS. W. BRESNAHAN, A. j . NICKLIN.
WESTERN DIVISION;
BOSTON OFFICE:
Republic Bldg., 209 So. State St., Chicago.
JOHN H. WILSON, 324 Washington St.
Telephone, Wabash 5242-5243.
Telephone, Main 6950.
LONDON, ENGLAND: 1 Gresham Buildings, Basinghall St., D. C.
NKWS SERVICE IS SUPPLIED WEEKLY BY OUK CORRESPONDENTS
LOCATED IN T H E LEADING CITIES I H R O U U H O I T AMERICA.
Published Every Saturday at 373 Fourth Avenue, New York
Entertd as second-class matter September 10, 1892, at the post office at New York, N. Y'.,
under the Act of March 3, 1879.
SUBSCRIPTION (including postage), United States and Mexico, $J.UO per year;
Canada, $3.50; all other countries, $5.00.
ADVERTISEMENTS, $6.00 per inch, single column, per insertion. On quarterly or
yearly contracts a special discount is allowed. Advertising pages, $150.
REMITTANCES, in other than currency forms, should be made payable to Edward
Lyman Bill, Inc.
pinTTAi* Pi an A anil
Departments conducted by an expert wherein all ques-
r i a J v l ' • lallU allU
tions of a technical nature relating to the tuning,
Toohnloal
n » n » r t m o n t c regulating and repairing of pianos and player-pianos
i t X l U l l l d l I F e y a l U l i e i l l S are dealt with, will be found in another section of
this paper. We also publish a number of reliable technical works, information concerning
which will be cheerfully given upon request.
Exposition Honors Won by The Review
Grand Prix
Paris Exposition, 1900 Silver Medal. .. .Charleston Exposition, 1902
Diploma...«.Pan-American Exposition, 1901 Gold Medal
St. Louis Exposition, 1904
Gold Medal—Lewis-Clark Exposition, 1905
LONG DISTANCE TELEPHONES—NUMBERS 5983—5983 MADISON SQ.
Connecting all Departments
Cable Address: "Elbill, New York"
Vol. LXX1II
NEW YORK, OCTOBER 8, 1921
No. 15
SUPPORT FOR THE SALES TAX PLAN
S the argument on the revision of Federal taxes continues before
the Senate, there is considerable justification for the declaration
of officials of the Music Industries Chamber of Commerce and other
interests to the effect that all is not lost, but that there is still hope of
favorable action being taken upon the manufacturers' sales tax plan
as proposed by Senator Smoot, or at least on some similar plan that
will tend to relieve the present burden of excise and excess profits
taxes.
Certain it is that Senator Smoot is making a strong fight 'for
his amendments, and according to reports he has gained the support
of many Senators for his plan. It is generally agreed that some sort
of sales tax plan will probably be adopted as the way out of the tax
tangle, if not at this session of Congress then at some later session,
and it is with the hope of having such action taken at once rather than
seeing it delayed that the members of the music industry are urged
to bring pressure to bear on their Senators with a view to obtaining
immediate relief.
Although Senator Simmons, representing the Democratic side.
has composed a substitute tax plan that fails to provide considerab 1 y
for the repeal of excise taxes, it is felt that Senator Smoot, trailing
with the Republican majority, has the best chance of seeing his ideas
adopted provided there is any really radical remodeling of the tax
bill as recently passed by the House. In view of the situation as it
now stands there is every reason in the world for the music industry
to continue the fight against excise taxes and in favor of the manu-
facturers' sales tax to the last ditch.
A
PRACTICAL CO-OPERATION
HERE is a good deal of talk at all times regarding co-operation
between music dealers in the same and adjacent cities with a view
to developing trade along lines that will enable all factors to profit. It
is a question, however, whether there exists in many sections the real
spirit of co-operation which moves the music merchant to see to it
personally that his neighboring dealer is put in direct touch with
T
OCTOBER 8, 1921
business' that he himself cannot handle rather than let the neighbor
find the opportunity for himself.
;•
This spirit of broad-minded helpLulness was displayed recently
by the Schmidt Music Co., of Davenport, la., in connection with the
company's exhibit at the Iowa State Fair. Of the 2,000 or more
visitors who registered on cards provided by the Schmidt company
several score whose answers indicated that they might be logically
considered as prospects were located in the territories of other dealers
in various cities. Instead of throwing these cards aside as useless,
the Schmidt company saw to it that the information thereon was
placed in the hands of music merchants who could use it- in going
after the sale.
In view of its action the Schmidt Music Co. is justified in
expecting that the same courtesy be extended to it by the dealers who
have been favored, without solicitation, when the opportunity for
reciprocating presents itself. The big thought, however, is to foster
this policy of passing on valuable sales information to neighboring or
even competing dealers, who can use it to the best advantage rather
than simply to forget about it.
THE INDUSTRIAL ACTIVITY IS REAL
A
N excellent summing up of the general business situation has
been made by the National Bank of Commerce in its latest
bulletin and there are some facts therein thai should prove of general
interest to the trade at large. The bulletin declares that the gams
thus far made in industrial activities are real and that there is steady
progress toward better business. There is no justification for any
world-wide rise in prices at this time, according to the report, owing
to the fact that the process of readjustment has already evidenced
itself strongly. Just how the readjustment has worked out is set forth
in the report as follows:
"Producers of raw materials, from the farmer to the metal mine
operator, have taken their losses. Those classes of labor which have
accepted wage reductions in keeping with the changed economic
situation have likewise taken their losses, while other large classes
of labor have done so indirectly as a result of unemployment. The
conclusion is clear. Retail prices cannot go up without promptly
curtailing buying. They must be reduced until they are in line with
raw materials.
"Because of uncertainty as to what the consumer can and will
buy, retailers generally are ordering with great caution, while many
wholesalers in turn are refraining from placing advance orders. The
adoption, at any stage from manufacturer to consumer, of a policy
directed toward generally higher prices to the consumer will not only
curtail buying but will result in slowing down the gratifying progress
already made. Domestic conditions do not entirely govern. There
are international conditions to be reckoned with. The only far-
sighted policy is the expansion of sales on a narrow margin of profit."
THE TRADE SERVICE BUREAU
T
HAT the Trade Service Bureau of the Music Industries Chamber
of Commerce, under the direction of C. L. Dennis, has finally
begun to function, even though in a small way, is a matter for con-
gratulation, and will be of direct interest to the National Association
of Music Merchants, in which organization the idea was born, and
the members of which are to receive the chief benefit.
It is hoped that the work of the Trade Service Bureau will develop
substantially, for such work is calculated to prove a strong factor in
maintaining the interest of the average music merchant in the associa-
tion and what it is doing. The average dealer has become a believer
in the benefits of trade associations, though at the same time the
average dealer is not in a position to judge at first hand of the benefits
that are calculated to accrue to him through association efforts. The
fact that the Merchants' Association, as a part of the Chamber of
Commerce, is aiding directly in the tax fight for the dealer's benefit
is, of course, more or less understood, but there is more than one
dealer who does not feel he is getting all the benefits he should by
simply attending the conventions each year and listening to some busi-
ness talks.
The Trade Service Bureau affords the means for giving each
member of the association something tangible and constructive for his
money. Even should he be not inclined to take advantage of the
opportunities offered, he at least feels that they are there for him and
that any lack of interest, therefore, rests with himself and not with
the association. It is an idea that deserves encouragement.
Music Trade Review -- © mbsi.org, arcade-museum.com -- digitized with support from namm.org
OCTOBER 8,
1921
THE
MUSIC
TRADE
REVIEW
PRAISES MUSIC MEMORY WORK
SELLING CONTESTS HELP BUSINESS
CONCENTRATIONJN TAX FIGHT
Director of Music of University of Indiana in
Special Article in School Music Pays High
Tribute to National Bureau for Advancement
'. of Music for What Has Been Done
Piano Department of the L. Bamberger Store
Shows Increase in Business Over Last Year
—Due to Contests Between Salesmen
Chamber of Commerce Urges Members of Indus-
try in Indiana to Present Arguments for
Proper Tax Legislation to Senator Watson
NEWARK, N. J., October 3.—Sales at the piano
Edward B. Birge, director of music in the department of the L. Bamberger store, in this
University of Indiana, in a long article in the city, are exceeding those of last year. This is,
current issue of School Music, stresses the im- iti a great measure, due to the fact that the mem-
portance of the music memory contest in the bers of the sales force are constantly stimulated
life of a community and pays his respects to by clever sales contests. A large outside sales
the National Bureau for the Advancement of force is also covering territory in the city, rural
Music of the Music Industries Chamber of Com- districts and villages, and during the Summer
merce for the part it has played, in the promul- months two branch stores were operated at
Plainfield and Summit, N. J., to afford persons
gation of this form of music growth.
"A project which enlists and secures the sus- in those communities the opportunity of select-
tained interest during many successive months ing instruments without going to the trouble and
of both children and parents and which quickens expense of coming all the way to the headquar-
visibly the musical life of a community is worthy ters in Newark. These auxiliary stores have
of our serious consideration," writes Professor been discontinued, but it is probable that they
Birge. "These qualities are inherent in the will be reopened next year.
music memory contest. It is a game, and one
One of the clever stunts put into effect by the
which requires no special skill except that of re- Bamberger salesmen consists of a horse-race. A
niembering tunes; yet next to the spontaneous large track, blocked in squares, has been placed
community sing, where everybody takes part on the wall of the office in the piano depart-
and which, it may be said, is more or less de- ment. Each salesman has his own cardboard
pendent upon just the right mood, this game in- horse, with his photograph pasted over the face
terests a greater number of people than any of the jockey. On the first of each month the
musical project yet. suggested. It is superior sales force starts on an equal footing. Each
to the community sing in that it is not depend- square represents a certain amount of money,
ent at all upon mood or being able to use the and a salesman may jump ahead several squares,
voice. As a game it has every advantage of according to the value of the instrument sold.
individual effort, coupled with that of group At the close of the race the winner is awarded a
interest.
gold button and a substantial bonus, based on the
"The National Bureau for the Advancement total value of his sales. He retains the button
of Music has done much for musical growth, and until he loses a future race. This race has
I am personally grateful to the executive, C. M. aroused the sporting instinct of the sales staff
Tremaine, for his lucid and persuasive explana- and keen rivalry exists between them. Last
tion of the educational benefits which the music month W. F. Brockhaus, floor manager, was the
memory contest will bring to the schools and winner.
the home.
Each month, too, parties are held, wliich are
"My own experience will be confirmed by attended by all the members of the staff. Each
many who have used this project that it is worth salesman contributes a stipulated amount and
doing, not only once, but every year."
the entire force attends the theatre or a dinner
In the same issue of School Music appears the and dance. These parties have been of value in
increasing co-operation between members of the
•following editorial:
*'The National Bureau for the Advancement staff.
.of Music has just issued a newly issued, revised
Among the high-grade instruments handled
aftd enlarged edition of the music memory con- here are the Behning, Hardman, Peck & Co. and
gest' descriptive folder. The new booklet in- Estey pianos. W. J. Connelly is buyer for the
cludes some of the latest developments in the department, his brother, M. J. Connelly, is sales
idea and the increased prize offers now being manager.
made by this Bureau in initial contests. Besides
giving helpful suggestions and detailed informa-
GRIFFITH BUSINESS BOOMING
tion about the management of a contest the
National Bureau donates a prize to cities under- Fifty Per Cent Increase in Sales During Last
taking a memory contest for the first time.
Two Months Over Similar Period in 1920—
Cities may choose either medals, banner, money
Extensive Redecorations Under Way
prizes or pins.
NEWARK, N. J., October 3.—Business during
. "There is also a list of the Bureau's other
publications on this subject. Mr. Tremaine writes August and September at the Griffith Piano
that the Bureau will be glad to send all the Co.'s store was 50 per cent greater than the same
readers of School Music any of the literature in months last year, according to Harry Griffith,
which they may be interested. The address is manager of retail sales. The company has suc-
ceeded in keeping ahead of last year's sched-
105 West Fortieth street.
'"Over 200 towns and cities have already con- ule during the greater part of the year and ex-
ducted music memory contests and most of them pects, when the term is ended, to be able to
show a greater sales volume than in 1920.
are making it an annual event."
The large warerooms of the company, which
are
located in the heart of the business district,
•i ASK HY EILERS TO DELIVER FUNDS
are undergoing extensive redecorating. The
/"
color scheme of the interior will be old ivory
Petition Requests Delivery of $58,647.37 to Estate and gold. The addition to the main floor has
been completed and the new demonstration and
*.;.
of Bankrupt Eilers Music House
PORTLAND, OFE , October 1.—A petition asking that display rooms have been opened to the public.
Hy J, Eilers deliver $58,647.37 to the estate of Separate demonstration rooms are devoted to re-
the bankrupt Eilers Music House was filed by producing grands and electric players, and there
H. W. Sitton, acting trustee of the firm, in the is a handsomely furnished room where deals are
bankruptcy court. The petition states that Eilers closed.
previously had been directed by United States
A complete line of high-grade instruments, in-
Commissioner Cannon to account for this sum cluding Steinway, Sohmer, Krakauer and
and-to turn it into the bankrupt company, but Kranich & Bach is handled by the firm.
that he has not done so. The petit'on states also
that $40,000.70 is held by Eilers and Used in the
Frank A. Martin, of the Milton Piano Co., and
Oregon Eilers Music House and that, $18,644.67- J, A. Coffin, of E. Gabler & Bro., New York,
•is held under the trame of Ann Eilers.
were recent visitors to Philadelphia.
Continuing its policy of concentrating its ac-
tivities in the campaign for tax revision in dis-
tricts where they will be most effective the
Music Industries Chamber of Commerce wrote
on September 29 to all members of the industry
in. Indiana urging them to write or wire Sena-
tor James E. Watson, of that State, one of the
strong men of the Senate Finance Committee,
that his constituents want no delay in the pas-
sage of constructive tax legislation.
In a recent issue of the New York American,
which, with the other Hearst publications, has
consistently and vigorously supported the sales
tax principle, Senator Watson made the" fol-
lowing statement:
"I am for the sales tax plan. For the' last
twenty years I have believed that the sales tax
is the only fair system of taxation, and I firmly
believe that the sales tax is more urgently needed
to-day than ever before.
"I am for the sales tax plan, and always will
be, simply because it offers substantial and fair
aid to productivity and at the same time it is
equitable.
- j
"I believe in taxing consumption and not pro-
duction. When you place a burden upon pro-
duction, as our present system of taxation does,
you automatically decrease consumption. Take
care of production and consumption will take
care of itself. That is fundamental.
"We will have to come to the sales ta# very
soon. Modifying our present system of taxation
may help, temporarily, but for permanent relief
we have only one way to turn and that is to-
ward a simplified system of taxation such as the
sales tax plan would bring about."
STIEFF BRANCH IN PHILADELPHIA
New Store on Chestnut Street, Under Manage-
ment of H. H. Conner, Meeting With Success
PHILADELPHIA, PA., October 3.—The handsome
new branch store of Chas. M. Stieff, Inc., Balti-
more, which was opened recently at 1717 Chest-
nut street, this city, is already finding a definite
place for itself among local piano establishments.
The new showrooms are supplied with a com-
plete line of grand, upright and player-pianos,
as well as reproducing grands. The window dis-
plays particularly have served to attract public
attention, especially the exhibition of a Petit
grand piano in Adam design of solid mahogany
and handsomely carved.
The new store is under the management of
H. H. Conner, piano man of wide experience, who
was formerly identified with the Cable Piano Co.
at Chicago, and more recently with the Percy S.
Foster Co. and the Arthur Jordan Piano Co.,
Washington, D. C.
A VISITOR FROM NEW ZEALAND
E. J. Hyams, of Wellington, Visiting the Trade
in New York and Other Cities
E. J. Hyams, of E. J. Hyams, Ltd., Welling-
ton, N. Z., with branches in Auckland and
Christchurch, has been sojourning within our
gates for the past week, getting in clo.9e touch
with trading conditions in New York. Mr.
Hyams is the sole distributor in New Zealand
for the Gramophone Co., Ltd., manufacturer of
"His Master's Voice" records and machines,
London, England. In American musical instru-
ments he handles the Gulbransen players and
C R S rolls. Late last week he left for a trip to
Canada and the West, stopping off at Chicago
and other cities. On his return to New York,
which will be in about a couple of weeks,, he
will leave for Europe.

Download Page 4: PDF File | Image

Download Page 5 PDF File | Image

Future scanning projects are planned by the International Arcade Museum Library (IAML).

Pro Tip: You can flip pages on the issue easily by using the left and right arrow keys on your keyboard.