Music Trade Review

Issue: 1919 Vol. 68 N. 16

Music Trade Review -- © mbsi.org, arcade-museum.com -- digitized with support from namm.org
THE
MUSIC
TRADE
REVIEW
PUBLISHED BY EDWARD LYMAN BILL, Inc.
President and Treasurer, C. L. Bill, 373 Fourth Ave., New York; Vice-President
J. B. Spiilane, 373 Fourth Aye., New York; Second Vice-president, Raymond Bill, 37;
373
Fourth Ave., New York; Assistant Treasurer, Wm. A. Low.
J. B. SPILLANE, Editor
RAYMOND BILL, B. B. WILSON, Associate Editors
Executive and Reportorial Staff:
CARLETON CIIACE, L. M. ROBINSON, WILSON D. B U S H , V. D. WALSH, W M . BRAID W H I T E
(Technical E d i t o r ) ) , E. B. M U N C H , C. A. LKONARH. EDWARD I.YMAN BILL,
A. J. NICKLIN,
BOSTON OFFICE:
JOHN H. WILSON, 324 Washington St.
L. E. Bowi RS
CHICAGO OFFICE:
E. P. VAN HARLINGEN, Republic Building,
Telephone, Main 6950.
209 So. State St. Telephone, Wabash 5774.
LONDON, ENGLAND: 1 Gresham Buildings, Basinghall St., D. C.
NEWS 8ERVICE IS SUPPLIED WEEKLY BY OUR CORRESPONDENTS
LOCATED IN THE LEADING CITIES THROUGHOUT AMERICA.
Published Every Saturday at 373 Fourth Avenue, New York
Entered as second-class matter September 10, 1892, at the post office at New York, N. Y.,
under the Act of March 3, 1879.
SUBSCRIPTION (including postage), United States and Mexico, $2.00 per year;
Canada, $3.50; all other countries, $5.00.
ADVERTISEMENTS, $4.50 per inch, single column, per insertion. On quarterly or
yearly contracts a special discount is allowed. Advertising pages, $130.
REMITTANCES, in other than currency forms, should be made payable to Edward
Lyman Bill, Inc.
Departments conducted by an expert wherein all ques-
Ptonn anil
tions of a technical nature relating to the tuning,
regulating and repairing of pianos and player-pianos
f
are dealt with, will be found in another section of
this paper. We also publish a number of reliable technical works, information concerning
which will be cheerfully given upon request.
Exposition Honors Won by The Review
Grand Prix
Paris Exposition, 1900 Silver Medal Charleston Exposition, 1902
Diploma
Pan-American Exposition, 1901 Gold Medal
St. Louis Exposition, 1904
Gold Medal—Lewis-Clark Exposition, 1905
LONG DISTANCE TELEPHONES—NUMBERS 5982—6983 MADISON SQ.
Connecting all Department^
Cable address: "Elbill, New York"
Vol. LXVIII
NEW YORK, APRIL 19, 1919
No. 16
EDITORIAL^
N next Monday there will begin officially the drive for the
O
Fifth or Victory Liberty Loan, and, as has been the case with
every other Liberty Loan, the music interests are planning to show
that their money is back of the Government to the limit. There are
more or less definite assurances that this will be the last loan, and
this fact will probably aid materially in garnering subscriptions from
those who feel that the occasion is such that they should go the limit.
As has been announced, Carl C. Conway, of the Hallet &
Davis Piano Co,, has been appointed chairman of the Allied
Music Division, associated with the Rainbow Division, covering the
Metropolitan District, and he has gathered about him strong com-
mittees and sub-committees to reach into every branch of the in-
dustry and profession. Mr. Conway's known ability as an organ-
izer and his reputation as a man who does what he sets out to do
may be accepted as an indication that allied music will go "over the
top" by a wide margin. Although the quota for the industry has
not been announced, a high quota may be accepted as simply a chal-
lenge for extra effort.
HE Review is in receipt of a number of letters speaking in com-
mendatory terms of the editorial which appeared last week
T
bearing upon the tendency of a great many dealers to cut prices of
music rolls and otherwise depreciate the value of this very impor-
tant branch of our industry.
It should be evident by this time that the one-price policy is not
only safe and sane, but necessary to the successful development
of the piano business. If we turn to the average piano house of
any standing we find that this system is the only logical one, and
applies to music rolls as well as to pianos or players.
With the increased sales of player-pianos the music roll indus-
try is becoming quite an important one. and it is well to realize
that music rolls are not an adjunct of the industry, nor are they
manufactured to be "given away" as gifts, but should be sold for
their actual worth as a separate and distinct product.
It is difficult to understand why any business man should tend
REVIEW
APRIL 19, 1919
to undermine this industry by slashing prices or using other methods
which are apt to disturb the confidence of the public in the music roll
as a product worthy of purchase at its face value. There must be
an awakening on this subject on the part of piano merchants. They
must get into line with the spirit of the times—with the spirit of cor-
rect merchandising.
interesting facts were revealed in the report issued by the
S OME
National Association of Manufacturers, which appeared in
last week's Review, regarding the canvass of its membership, com-
prising 4,400 firms engaged in practically every line of industry
with respect to post-armistice conditions and trade prospects gen-
erally for 1919. Of the twenty-five principal groupings of indus-
tries it is noteworthy that the makers of musical instruments were
among the five who reported satisfactory business conditions and
prospects at the present time.
It is interesting further to observe that the group classified as
musical instruments was the only one of the twenty-five in which
there were no replies received to the effect that business was poor.
Regarding present trade conditions 9 per cent, of the replies from
musical instrument men declared them to be fair, 72 per cent, good
and 19 per cent, excellent. As to trade prospects for 1919 the re-
ports were' 5 per cent, fair, 75 per cent, good and 20 per cent, ex-
cellent.
In the survey of retail stocks in hand, by groups, the associa^
tion report shows that in the musical instrument trade 75 per cent,
of the replies indicated that manufactured stocks on hand as com-
pared with pre-war supplies were low, 20 per cent, normal and 5
per cent, above normal. The reason for this condition is ascribed to
the war-time curtailment of production.
The chief obstacles now prevailing to prevent general business
activity are summarized as follows: (1) Delay in signing the Peace
Treaty. (2) General high cost of labor and materials. (3) Sudden
cessation of war-buying operations by the United States and foreign
governments. (4) Hand-to-mouth buying by jobbers, retailers and
consumers awaiting expected price reductions. (5) Continued Gov-
ernment control, management and operation of railroads, etc. (6)
Sudden imposition of heavy war revenue tax burdens on industry.
(7) Labor unrest, agitation and industrial strife. (8) High prices of
wheat due to Government guarantee. (9) Unemployment and poor
distribution of labor forces released from military or naval service.
(10) Delay in settlement by Federal Government of claims for pay-
ment under informal war contracts. (11) Partial shutting off of
important European markets due to import trade embargoes by
Great Britain, France and Italy.
This report of the National Association of Manufacturers is
entirely in conformity with the facts as set forth in The Review
from week to week and emphasizes that the music trade industry
is not only enjoying prosperous conditions to-day, but can look for-
ward with assurance to a still larger volume of business as soon
as supplies are more abundant and labor conditions improved.
HE recommendation that Congress give special attention to the
Sherman and Clayton acts, with a view to their amendment or
revision, as made by the Chamber of Commerce of the United States,
recently before the membership of that organization for a referen-
dum vote, is distinctly a move in the right direction, for to all intents
and purposes the anti-trust laws in the United States have failed
almost completely to accomplish the purpose for which they were
designed, and rather than proving effective in curbing the dan-
gerous monopolies, they have been invoked most generally against
industrial organizations that at best violated only the letter of the
law rather than its spirit.
Existing conditions and the necessity for co-operate effort on
the part of various industries openly encouraged by the Government
make it particularly necessary that the laws be so revised or
amended as to permit of certain industrial combinations when it is
apparent that such a move would prove beneficial to the industrial
fabric of the country, without in any sense being designed to open
the way for stifling competition. In brief, the Chamber of Com-
merce of the United States should receive the support of those in-
dustries represented in its membership in the movement now under
way to bring about the desired changes in the laws, in the belief
that such changes will be made in such a manner that they cannot
be taken advantage of for illegal purposes.
T
Music Trade Review -- © mbsi.org, arcade-museum.com -- digitized with support from namm.org
19, 1919
THE

*

TRADE
REVIEW
ANNUAL MEETING OF LINDSAY, LTD.
POUND VISITS FORT WORTH TRADE
PROFIT-SHARING PLAN ADOPTED
Prominent Canadian Music House Reports a
Most Prosperous Year of Business—All Di-
rectors and Officers Re-elected
Spends Few Hours in That City, and Meets
Members of Local Music Trade—Is Guest at
Luncheon and Makes Interesting Talk
Melville Clark Piano Co. Helps Employes to
Earn More Money—Workers Divided Into
Three Classes, According to Service
April 12.—The annual meeting
of shareholders of C. W. Lindsay, Ltd., was held
at the head office of the company on April 8,
and was largely attended, with President C. W.
Lindsay in the chair.
The annual statement presented to the meeting
showed that the corporation had experienced the
most prosperous year in its history. In view of
the fine showing the directors voted a 10 per
cent, cash bonus to the staff at all branches pay-
able May 1 next to all employes who have been
in the continuous service of the company since
March 1, 1918, and are still in its employ on May
1, 1919. The usual dividends were declared, viz.:
7 per cent, on the preferred shares and 8 per
cent, on the common shares, and a large amount
carried to reserve account.
The directors of the old board were re-elected,
viz.: C. W. Lindsay, Alfred McDiarmid, A. E.
Brock, J. A. Hebert and E. Hamilton, with C.
W. Lindsay as president and general manager;
B. A. Edward, secretary, and W. A. H. Robin-
son, treasurer.
A dinner was held in the evening at the Wind-
sor Hotel, at which the directors, officers ar^
branch managers were present, and at which the
president again expressed his gratification at
the splendid year's business, and announced that
in the event of next year's profits equaling the
year just past he would support a motion to
pay the staff a 20 per cent, bonus.
FORT WORTH, TEX., April 12.—Although G'eorge
W. Pound, general counsel of the Music indus-
tries Chamber of Commerce, was, owing to the
limitation of his schedule, able to spend only a
few hours in this city on his coast-to-coast
speaking tour in the interests of the advance-
ment of music in this country, the local commit-
tee, of which L. J. Wortham was chairman, man-
aged to bring together over eighty music deal-
ers, their wives and their friends, to hear Mr.
Pound's address.
To give the occasion fitting importance Mr.
Pound was the official guest of the Fort Worth
Lions' Club at its weekly luncheon on Tuesday,
although the great majority of those present
were members of the Fort Worth Music Indus-
tries Association.
Mr. Pound presented facts already familiar to
the local men, to some extent, regarding the
great impetus given to music by the war, the
favorable attitude of the Government officials
toward the music interests, during the times of
great stress and the opportunities now before
America for assuming a supreme position in mat-
ters musical, both professionally and industrially.
lie told of how before the war the United
States had been importing annually from Ger-
many musical instruments to the value of $800,-
000, and from France to the value of $(>00,000,
but that since the beginning of hostilities we
have begun making those instruments here, and
making them better than the imported product.
As a result of Mr. Pound's earnest talk regard-
ing the aims and ambitions of those standing
sponsor for organized trade effort for the spread
of musical interests, a goodly number of applica-
tions were filled out for membership in the Na-
tional Association of Music Merchants.
In addition to the talk by Mr. Pound short
addresses were made by B. Heyer, of Dallas,
president of' the newly-organized Texas Mer-
chants' Music Association, H. D. Gupton, of
Dallas, secretary of that body, and O. A. Field,
of the Field-Lippman Piano Stores, of St. Louis.
DE KALB, III., April 14.—The Melville Clark
Piano Co. has perfected and submitted to its
entire force a new bonus system by which all
employes will profit by faithful service. Em-
ployes are divided into three classes, according
to length of service. All who have been with
the company less than six months are in class
C and will receive a bonus of 5 per cent, on
their regular pay.
Service over six months places an employe in
class B and the bonus is 7 per cent. On Octo-
ber 1 classes B and C will be advanced, becom-
ing A and B, and the bonus becomes 10 and 7
per cent, respectively. The bonus is paid in
the form of a bonus check as an addition to the
regular pay.
The added bonus system is really a form of
profit-sharing and the employes seem to ap-
preciate what the Melville Clark Piano Co. is
doing for its workers.
MONTREAL, CAN.,
.
MUSIC
.
GEO. C. WILSON APPOINTED MANAGER
Now Heads the City Piano and Player Sales
Department of the Knight-Campbell Music Co.
DENVER, COLO., April 14.—Geo. C. Wilson has
been appointed manager of the city piano and
player sales department of the Knight-Campbell
Music Co., of this city, succeeding C. E. Wells,
who formerly held that position, and who has re-
cently disposed of his interests in the company
for the purpose of engaging in business for him-
self. Mr. Wilson, whose appointment became
effective on the first of the month, is well
equipped for his new responsibilities, having
been assistant manager of this department for
many years past, and he is assured of the heart-
iest co-operation from his staff in the further-
ance of the policies of this house.
Mr. Wells' leaves the Knight-Campbell Music
Co. with the best of wishes for success in his
new undertaking.
RHINE RIVER NOW OPEN
Shipments From the United States to Switzer-
land May Now Be Made
TO GREET POUND IN PORTLAND
WASHINGTON, D. C, April 14.—The War Trade
Board announce that they have been advised
that, by decision of the military authorities of
the associated governments, the Rhine River
has now been opened for traffic with Switzer-
land, and shipments from the United States may
be forwarded JLO Switzerland via that route.
Local Dealers Preparing to Hold a Great Meet-
ing to Welcome Visitor
AN INDIANA INCORPORATION
April 11.—Letters advising local
dealers of the contemplated visit of George W.
Pound to this city have been sent out and ar-
rangements will be made to have a big repre-
sentative crowd of piano men in attendance at
the meeting which will be held in Portland on
April 24.
Piano dealers in this section are very much in-
terested in the campaign being made by Mr.
Pound on his tour, and what he has said and
done in other cities has been read with much
interest. It is the consensus of opinion that
organized effort is of the greatest importance,
and there is no doubt that Mr. Pound will find
a fertile field for his propaganda on the North-
west Coast.
PORTLAND, ORE.,
The Rowlands Co.,-Fort Wayne, Ind., has been
incorporated to deal in pianos and musical in-
struments with capital stock of $100,000. The
incorporators and board of directors are as fol-
lows: Charles H. Rowlands, Mansfield, O.; A.
D. Rowlands, Columbus, O.; J. P. Colopy, De-
fiance, O.; R. J. Sturtz, Zanesville, O.; Paul A.
Moore, Huntington, Ind.; Mary C. Rowlands,
Columbus, O.; and Estella Rowlands, of Mans-
field.
McCoy's Music House, Inc., Hartford, Conn.,
has been incorporated by Alvia P. McCoy,
Franklin V. McCoy and Charles D. Nye, all of
Waterbury. The capital stock is $100,000 and
the new concern will begin business on $40,000.
LOUISVILLE MERCHANTS AFFECTED
Decreased Revenue Due to Prohibition Makes
Additional Taxes Necessary—The Proposed
Tax on Musical Instruments Not Fair to All
Branches of Industry, Say Local Dealers
LOUISVILLE, KY., April 14.—One of the many
problems brought about by the sudden descent
of prohibition is the question of how the deficit
which will be caused by the loss of revenue is
to be met. In this city there will be an annual
loss of more than $600,000, and it is proposed
to make up part of this by an additional tax on
the musical intrument trade.
At the present time there is before the city
council an ordinance regarding a licensing sys-
tem which will be a burden to dealers and sales-
men. If the proposed ordinance is adopted it
will be necessary for all factories, professional
men and business firms to pay for licenses. It is
claimed that the new tax system is not fair to
all, and if it goes through will place Louisville
manufacturers under a disadvantage, in that they
will find it difficult to compete with men in other
cities.
In the case of musical instrument concerns
it is proposed to levy a tax of $20 for each $10,-
000 in gross sales annually, and manufacturers
will have to pay a tax based on the number of
men in their employ. It may easily be seen that
in some cases where large retailers handle many
different lines they will be hard hit by this new
tax. In consequence of this music dealers are
trying to offer some other form of taxation
which would be evenly distributed among the
people of the city.
SOME IMPORT STATISTICS
The value of musical instruments imported
into the country of Maracaibo during the year
of 1917 was $7,702, as against $8,522 for 1916.
The figures show that the greater part of the
imports came from the United States, for the
total value of musical instruments imported from
all countries was $7,921 for 1917, and $9,043 for
1916. The total value of pianos imported from
the United States by the trade in South Aus-
tralia during 1916-17 was $48,000.
The Trio Music Co. has been incorporated in
Los Angeles, Cal., by R. H. Hart, V. E. Des
Autels and C. E. Cronkite, with a capital of
$50,000.
For over 25 years Specialists
in high grade Piano Cases
Paterson Piano
Case Co.
PATERSON, N. J.

Download Page 4: PDF File | Image

Download Page 5 PDF File | Image

Future scanning projects are planned by the International Arcade Museum Library (IAML).

Pro Tip: You can flip pages on the issue easily by using the left and right arrow keys on your keyboard.