Music Trade Review

Issue: 1915 Vol. 60 N. 18

Music Trade Review -- © mbsi.org, arcade-museum.com -- digitized with support from namm.org
THE
MUSIC TRADE REVIEW
REVIEW
EDWARD LYMAN BILL - Editor and Proprietor
J. B. SPILLANE, Managing Editor
Executive and Reportorial Staff:
SB. JiRiTTAiN WILSON,
A. J. iSiCKLiN,
CARLETON CHACE,
AUGUST J. TIMPE,
L. M. ROBINSON,
WM. B. WHITE,
GIAD HENDERSON,
L. E. BOWERS.
IIUSTO* O F F I C K i
CHICAGO O F F I C E :
E
i n m H WirsoN qoi Wash inert™ c;t
- P - V A N HARLINGEN, Consumers' Building,
J O H N H WILSON 3.4 Washmgton St.
2 , 0 SQ g t a t e S t r e e t
Tel
h
W a b a s h 5774 .
leleplione, Alain b9oO.
HENRY S. KINGWILL, Associate.
LONDON, KKGI.AND: 1 Giesliam Buildings, Basinghall St., E. C.
"NEWS S E R V I C E IS S U P P L I E D WKKK.I,* IIV OUR COKRESPOXDEXTS
LOCATED IN T H E LEADING C I T I E S I'HKOUGHOUT AMERICA.
Published Every Saturday at 373 Fourth Avenue, New York
Entered at the New York Post Office as Second Class Matter.
SUBSCRIPTION (including postage), United States and Mexico, $2.00 per year;
•Canada, $3.50; all other countries, $5.00.
AD VKKTISKJ] li!,\'l'S, $3.50 per inch, single column, per insertion. On quarterly or
yearly contracts, a special discount is allowed. Advertising pages $110.00.
HKMITTASIOKS, in other than currency forms, should be made payable to Edward
Lyman Hill.
Departments conducted by an expert wherein all ques-
tions of a technical nature relating to the tuning, regu-
lating
repairing of pianos and player-pianos are
Yl&nnrtmOnta d e a | t w and
i t h i w i u b e f o u n d i n another section of this
paper. We also publish a number of reliable technical works, information concerning
•which will be cheerfully given upon request.
TldllU allU
Exposition Honors Won by The Review
Paris Exposition, 1900 Silver Medal. . .Charleston Exposition, 1902
JJiptoma. ... Fan-American Exposition, 190! Gold Medal
St. Louis Exposition, 1904
Gold Medal. .Lewis-Clark Exposition, 1905.
LONG DISTANCE TELEPHONES—NUMBERS 5982—5983 MADISON SQ,
Connecting- all Departments
Cable address: "Eltoill, New York."
NEW
YORK,
MAY 1, 1 9 1 5
EDITORIAL
I
N The Review recently there was published a report from
London regarding- suggestions that the piano manufacturers
of Great Britain combine for the purpose of producing a cheap de-
pendable piano of the standard type for the export trade that could
be placed irt successful competition with the line of cheap pianos
with which the German manufacturers controlled much of that
trade before the war interfered.
The suggestions of the British manufacturers might be studied
with profit by piano men in the United States, not perhaps for the
purpose of bringing about a standard piano style for export, but for
the purpose of stimulating our own people to greater efforts in
capturing and holding the export trade in pianos., particularly in
South America.
The suggestions referred to also bring to mind the fact that
the efforts of those coveting the export business rest not so much
In meeting demands from that field at the present time as in pre-
paring to hold the trade thus captured after the present war is over
and the nations involved have again resumed their commercial
activities.
Take the case of Germany, for instance. It is predicted by some
economists that the end of the war will be marked by a tremendous
reduction in wages in that country due to the demands for employ-
ment made by a host of returning soldiers. Other economists
advance arguments to the effect that the scarcity of able-bodied
men following the ravages of war will serve to increase wages in
Germany and consequently increase manufacturing costs. Despite
all argument, however, the fact remains that when the war is over
Germany will sell her export types of pianos as cheap as before
'the war and probably much cheaper for the purpose of recapturing
her trade. At the same time England, while denying any com-
mercial considerations in declaring and prosecuting the war, is
nevertheless making every effort to profit by any commercial op-
portunity that may come to her through the medium of the strife.
The manufacturers in the United States, of course, have the
greatest opportunity to enter the export trade at the present time.
T h e opporunity is gradually being increased through an extension
of suitable banking arrangements with South American countries.
The question is, will American piano manufacturers go into the
export trade with a view to righting tooth and nail in the commer-
cial battles that will follow the coming of peace or take what export
business come thtir way without effort? Export connections that
are built up now are in most cases the development of necessity
and not of choice, and the work of insuring the permanence of
these connections again>t European competition will mean the
heavy pruning of manufacturing costs and expert salesmanship.
Gathering the fruits of export trade is much like gathering fruit
of any other sort. If you want the pick of the crop you must go
it]) the tree after it. for the windfalls are generally inferior.
T the banquet of the Connecticut Piano Dealers' Association,
held in Bridgeport last week, Pierson R. dimming 1 explained
in a few words how the Connecticut organization has been of real
value to the dealers of that State.
He stated that late one night he received through a hanker
friend advice of legislation which it was proposed to put through
the Connecticut Legislature, which would have a very detrimental
effect upon the piano merchants, and which would have made it
difficult for the dealer to have secured regular financial assistance
from the bankers. Tt was pernicious legislation of the worst kind.
Mr. Gumming immediately called up the association's attorney
—Connecticut has the only trade association which maintains an
attorney—and together they immediately journeyed to Hartford,
where they appeared before the Judiciary Committee. The piano
dealers' attorney made a splendid showing of the case and demon-
strated how disastrously the proposed legislation would work out to
particular trades. As a result this legislation did not go through.
There is tangible evidence of the benefit of association.
The Connecticut dealers not only meet together and have a good
dinner once a year and talk over conditions, but they have an at-
torney who is ever vigilant to prevent legislation which may operate
disadvantageous^ to legitimate interests.
A
W
H E T H E R in manufacturing or sales' fields there is nothing
that counts for success like enthusiasm. It was, we believe,
Bulwer who said, ''Enthusiasm is the genius of sincerity and truth
accomplishes no victories without it."
Here is a sermon in a sentence. And all who are intent upon
making arguments bring results, whether in the factory, in the
wareroom Moor or in the office, should memorize it.
Real enthusiasm does not consist in making a lot of noise, run-
ning about like a headless chicken, or underscoring inconsequentials.
Xor in pretending that your proposition is the onlv one in the world.
That sort of enthusiasm may do for a short course, but it will not
last through a regular business, full-length race.
The real thing in enthusiasm means a constant, consistent be-
lief that what you have to offer is just a little better than what the
other man has—and you simply have to talk about it. Such enthu-
siasm not depending upon megaphones, posters or italics is the
"genius of sincerity." Xo piano man should overlook the fact that
Enthusiasm, Sincerity and Truth are a trio quite impossible to
improve upon in business.
T
HE department which was opened in The Review under the
caption of "Views of Our Readers" was started with the
idea of making a forum for the voicing of views upon any subject
of interest to members of the trade.
Short, crisp letters upon any topic will be given position. Read-
ers need not figure that thcv must prepare long and carefully edited
views. Correspondents who do not wish to have their own names
appear in the articles forwarded must, for the purpose of identifi-
cation, give their names and addresses when sending the matter in.
Otherwise, their communications will not be inserted.
There are so many topics upon which salesmen and dealers are
desirous of expressing their opinions, and they perhaps have some
fear that their communications will be too formal.
In this new department it is proposed to cut out all formality
and simply make it a general trade forum. Views may be expressed
upon any of the many trade subjects.
We feel that among the thousands of Review readers there
must be always a certain' percentage who have something to say—•
some suggestions to offer, and perhaps some criticisms, and this
new department affords the opportunity to express them.
A
Music Trade Review -- © mbsi.org, arcade-museum.com -- digitized with support from namm.org
THE MUSIC TRADE REVIEW
SOME CONTRIBUTING TRADE FACTORS.

(Continued jrom page 3.)
their plans after the outbreak of the war, but went ahead with the determined resolution to win out.
They would have shown great wisdom if they had devoted a generous appropriation to adver-
tise their really attractive Exposition in South American cities. If, like a great many other Americans,
however, they have forgotten that South America exists, it is still time to get busy immediately in a
campaign to lead the wealthy South Americans to their gates, and an inflowing tide of wealthy South
Americans would do more to build up commercial relations with South America than any other move
that could be made. The direct contact of those people with our systems—our people—our
physical resources, would be stimulating to future business. And, when
peace smiles once more upon the war-torn world, the South American
markets will be opened wider to us than they would be through purely
business relations. The better the feeling existing between the two
countries, the greater opportunity there will be for future business.
How Distinctive Window Displays Pay a Profit.
S
OME retailers of pianos are so overcome with their ideas of the
extreme refinement of the business that it hurts. Others, on
the contrary, are so lacking in sense of relative importance that
they handle pianos on the same basis that the second-hand clothing
dealer in the Ghetto does his merchandising. These are the ex-
tremes between which are to be found the bulk of conservative
piano merchants who have come to realize that, despite its artistic
values, its standing as an instrument of culture, the piano never-
theless is a piece of merchandise that is made to be sold, and that
the rules of clean selling apply to piano retailing quite as much as
they do to merchandising of haberdashery.
Many piano men, for instance, evidently hold to the belief
that "according to Hoyle" piano displays should consist solely of
one or two instruments; a grand or a player, for instance, placed
in the show window, with a talking machine in the background, if
that line is handled. Tn other words, there is nothing distinctive
about the great majority of piano displays. The pedestrian travel-
ing along the usual Piano Row sees two or three pianos in the
window of the first store, and perhaps stops to admire them. He
sees practically the same display, only with instruments of different
names, in the second store, and in the third, fourth and fifth stores,
and is naturally not inclined to stop and study the exhibit. Once
in a while, however, there comes a manager who believes that the
piano window can be made attractive without being unduly sensa-
tional or violating trade ethics, and the results obtained are always
so satisfactory that one wonders why all the managers do not
follow suit.
:
In Brooklyn, N. Y., recently, for instance. L. TT. West, mana-
ger of the F. G. Smith retail store on Flatbush avenue, g'we the
show window over to a display of "Music in the Home" that served
to keep the crowds so interested that they missed homeward bound
trains. Some stores in arran^.ng such a display would have ob-
tained wax figures of a woman, a little girl or some men, placed
them in the window with a supply of furniture and let the exhibit
take care of itself. Probably some people would have stopped to
look and fair results would have been obtained.
Manager West, however, placed an imitation brick front across
the show window, with suitable openings left to represent the small
windows looking into the well-furnished parlor of a home. On
one day an attractive young lady represented the mother and
played the piano and talking machine, while a charming little girl
played about the room with a nonchalance which served to keep
the crowds interested throughout the day and until close to the mid-
night hour. Another day half a dozen young fellows dressed as
college students played cards, told stories and listened to player-
piano and talking machine music in a typical college boy's room.
Tn other words, the display represented life. Real people were
doing real things in a real way to the accompaniment of a real piano
or player, and gazing through the small windows the crowds could
not but be impressed with the homelike atmosphere. Although the
display was sufficiently sensational to hold the attention of busy
people bound for their work or to their homes, there was not one
item in it that tended to detract from the dignity generally asso-
ciated with good pianos.
-."-...
The number of piano houses who use special window displays
to illustrate the use of their instruments for accompaniment to
dances, to mark some special local or national celebration or to
typifv some particular season is increasing steadily and is a good
sign. Window space costs real money, a substantial amount per
square foot, and it should be made to pay a profit. Bringing sales :
from the street into the store through unusual displays is one of
the means of securing that profit.
Expansion Rather Than Retrenchment the Policy.
T
HE following is an excerpt from a communication received
from one of the progressive men of the industry:
"We are very pleased with the manner in which our business
interests have been exploited in The Music Trade Review, and the
results up to date have been more than satisfactory. We believe
that if every house were to adopt a policy of expansion rather than
of retrenchment and patronize the right mediums, the plan would
unquestionably act as an aid to their business enterprise."
There is a point made in this connection which is well worthy
of consderation by the timid ones.
Close economy in some ways is an absolute necessity, but the
exercising of too rigid rules means a serious interference with busi-
ness efficiency.
A good many of our clients realize fully that this is the time
for the exercising of discrimination in their trade paper patronage.
As a result of that, this publication instead of being decreased in
size has been constantly expanded.
We have been publishing weekly from 60 to 80 pages of matter
covering every department of the trade. That fact alone presents
eloquent evidence in favor of Review superiority. Instead of re-
trenching, this trade newspaper institution has gone on increasing
—not merely in size, but in the quality and originality of contents,
with a view to a broader value and interest to every branch of the
industry.
This organization is better to-day than ever before, and keen
advertisers are beginning to realize the advantage of using discrimi-
nating intelligence in thier trade paper patronage. And it is
worthy of note that the papers which are rendering service to ad-
vertisers and subscribers are the ones which are receiving increase^
patronage.
.
.
'>•

Download Page 4: PDF File | Image

Download Page 5 PDF File | Image

Future scanning projects are planned by the International Arcade Museum Library (IAML).

Pro Tip: You can flip pages on the issue easily by using the left and right arrow keys on your keyboard.