Music Trade Review

Issue: 1912 Vol. 55 N. 21

Music Trade Review -- © mbsi.org, arcade-museum.com -- digitized with support from namm.org
THE MUSIC TRADE REVIEW
INCREASED PRICES AND THE DEALER.
ROW OVER PIANOS FOR SCHOOLS.
George H. Munroe, Thirty Years in the Retail Piano Business, Says Piano Dealers Should
Meet the Situation Gracefully—Just the Outcome of Natural Progress—Fall River Dealer
Started Selling Old Squares and Has Distinction of Founding the First Correspondence
School for Tuning—Tells of the Best Method of Getting and Holding Business.
Arthur J. Crafts Protests Against Awarding of
Contract to Cable Company That They
Finally Get It for Lowest Bid—Personal Ele-
ment Enters Into Debate.
"There is no doubt that the piano dealers all over
the country will accept the raise in the wholesale
price of pianos which seems to be inevitable with a
good grace," said' George H. Munroe, the well-
known Fall River, Masis., piano merchant, who was
in New York last week. "It cannot be expected
that the price should always remain the same. Take
in other lines when a man comes to market he
may find the price of goods up or down. There
is a constant fluctuation. But, in the piano business
there is none of that and the dealer has been
fortunate in knowing just what the price of the
instrument he is going to market to buy, will be.
"All dealers appreciate the fact that there must
now be an increase in the wholesale price and are
preparing to accept it as it comes along. There is
an opinion which prevails, however, in the minds
of the public that the piano dealer makes a tre-
mendous profit on the pianos and player-pianos he
sells, and that he can easily stand an increase in
the cost of 'bis goods without raising the retail
price. I have been in the piano business thirty
years and I fail to see how this can be done. Just
the same as it costs more to manufacture a piano
it costs more in proportion to sell one than it did
years ago.
"Even in conducting a small business it costs
nearly $100 before you have sold a piano and with
the small payments which are received these days
it is a long time before the real profit on a piano is
felt. After all this is the business which pays in
the long run and keeps t ; he business on an even
keel. I have found and I think that other dealers
will bear me out that it is not the patronage from
the wealthy classes which forms the basis of a
strong retail piano business, but that which comes
from the class who regularly pay their weekly
instalments."
Mr. Munroe had a unique start in the piano
business. It was thirty years ago, then a very
young man, that he learned piano tuning and 'regu-
lating. In this he built up quite a trade. At that
time square pianos were very popular. As an ex-
pert regulator and' tuner he came in contact with
instruments which were to be discarded. He would
buy them very cheap, put them in good condition,
then advertise them on a Friday night in the Fall
River daily papers and sell them out the next day
before sundown. In this way he would get rid of
four or five each week, and did a very profitable
business for those times. He continued this for
some time until the local supply of square pianos
gave out, then he went to Boston and purchased
others at auction. Later he took on the Newby
& Evans pianos, which he has handled ever since,
and gave up the other business except when a
square was taken in trade.
Mr. Munroe has the distinction of also starting
and 1 conducting for three years the first corre-
spondence school for tuners in this country. His
warerooms at that time were in the Horton building
on North Main street. During the thirty years of
his experience he has been away from Fall River
in business once for a period of two years. He
was then with the Hext Music Company, Denver,
Colo., part of the time, and Vose & Sons Com-
pany, in Boston, where he was head floor man.
At present his warerooms are at 183 North Main
street, Fall River, and he caters to and secures
the best class of business in the spindle city. He
believes in forceful publicity and square dealing.
"I find irhat the best method' of getting business
is first secure a representative line of pianos of
the highest quality, then display them in such a
way that persons will be attracted to your ware-
room by what they see through the window and
by systematic advertising. Cleanliness is another
asset, and- the more refined and artistic the sur-
roundings the quicker the people will come into
your wareroom, then don't let them get out with-
out making a sale."
Mr. Munroe handles the Henry F. Miller, Lud-
wig, Newby & Evans and Weser pianos, and the
R. S. Howard pianos and player-piano and the
Angelus. Associated in business with him is his
son, Louis R. Munroe.
MANUFACTURERS NEED WORKMEN.
of the opinion that the increase in demand has
come to stay. The result of the election has had
no effect whatsoever on the trade, and the retail
business must be good throughout the country ac-
cording to the orders which are pouring into the
New York manufacturers.
There has been some making up for lost time,
naturally, but most of that has been accomplished
and the overtime work which is in vogue in nearly
every piano factory in New York is being devoted
to getting out the orders which are coming in at
the present time, calling for immediate shipment.
Workmen in most every branch of the business are
needed.
Want Ad Columns of Daily Papers Show That
Business Is Picking Up—Scarcity of Them
in Many Departments in Various Factories.
That there has been a marked stimulation in the
piano manufacturing business in Greater New
York is manifested by the "Want Ads" for piano
workers, which are appearing daily in the metro-
politan newspapers. On Sunday last there were
over thirty in one paper alone; and, combining
them all, there were in the neighborhood of 100.
Most of the manufacturers are optimistic, and are
Steinway & Sons have 4 Lansdens
in Service with Another on Order
lANSDEM
Mmm^
ELECTRIC TRUCKS
(Special to The Review.)
Richmond, Va., Nov. 18, 1912.
The awarding of contracts for four pianos for
the public schools of this city by the Committee
of Buildings and Furniture of the School Board
resulted in a merry mix-up for a while when Ar-
thur J. Crafts, head of the Crafts Piano Co., ap-
peared before the committee to protest against the
awarding of the contract to the Cable Company,
on the plea that the bids of local piano dealers
had not received the proper consideration. Mr.
Crafts referred particularly to the fact that J. G.
Corley, head of the Corley Piano Co., and State
agent for the Cable Company's pianos, was chair-
man of the committee passing on the bids and
the debate soon took on a decidedly personal aspect.
Mr. Corley denied emphatically that the transac-
tion brought any profit to his company, either di-
rectly or indirectly. The matter was finally set-
tled by awarding the contract to the Cable Com-
pany for four Wellington pianos, which were of-
fered at a price considerably below the lowest bid
of the local dealers. Besides Mr. Crafts, both the
Walter D. Moses & Co., Fergusson-Lee Piano Co.,
and Ferguson Bros, also entered bids, but did not
make formal protest against the awards. It is ru-
mored that the charges and counter-charges will
lead to an investigation for the purpose of set-
tling the matter finally.
OPEN IN BIRMINGHAM, ALA.
Clark & Jones Occupy Handsome Building In
That City and Display Fine Line—To Give
a Series of Recitals During the Winter.
(Special to The Review.)
Birmingham, Ala., Nov. 16, 1912.
Clark & Jones, well known in the piano trade
of the South, with stores at Knoxville and Chat-
tanooga, opened their handsome new building in
the Graves block, this city, last week. The new
building is especially arranged for the require-
ments of the piano business and besides special
demonstrating rooms, there are ten studios and a
large auditorium on the upper floors.
A series of recitals will be given by the com-
pany during the winter. Clark & Jones handle the
Steinway, Weber and other makes of pianos, as
well as a good line of player-pianos. Local branch
under the management of H. S. Jones, junior mem-
ber of the firm.
Ben Feinberg, who has been connected 1 with the
sales department of the American Piano Co., has
been assigned to the Southern territory by the
Foster-Armstrong Co., and after a few days spent
at the factories in East Rochester, N. Y., will
leave on his first trip through that territory.
(F-
Are Your Horses
Up Your Profits?
Eating
H
ORSE and wagon delivery is an unnecessary
drain on your gross profits. Lansden
Electric trucks are 100 per cent, faster
and 15 per cent, to 30 per cent, cheaper than horses,
as electricity is the most inexpensive motive power.
Continuous repeat orders from America's foremost
business firms bear witness to the fact that the
Lansden is the most efficient and altogether satis-
factory commercial car in the field. We gladly
refer you, as a prospective customer, to any of the
2,500 Lansden truck owners, and will abide by
what they tell you.
Write Dept. "M" for specification^
bulletins of trucks suitable for the
Lumber Trade.
laoisdcn
Goinp&ny
K
P P ?c^ N e w a r k R J .
The Lansden is equipped with Edi-
son Storage Batteries and built in
all sizes of 750, 1,000 lbs-, and 1, 2,
3, 3 l /> and 5 tons capacities.
Music Trade Review -- © mbsi.org, arcade-museum.com -- digitized with support from namm.org
10
THE
MUSIC TRADE
REVIEW
NEED OF SALES TRAINING IN THE MUSIC TRADE INDUSTRY.
much in the nature of a real, life-size grievance to
each customer.
Writer Says That Every Customer to Whom an Instrument Is Sold Should Be and Can Be Made
But if you were to suggest to any of these
an Actual Assistant to the Sales Department of Any Business.
salesmen I have mentioned that he is in need of
sales training he would, in high dudgeon, assure
By FREDERICK E. PIERCE, New York Sales Manager of the Aeolian Co.
you
that he is "not an apprentice."
The intangible asset of good-will can be made If the salesman would misrepresent a competitor's
And that is the sad part of it. He isn't an
goods, why not his own?
worth more in the piano business than in almost
Still another asserts that he was promised some apprentice. He is an experienced salesman, well
any other mercantile industry. Yet I venture to
accessory which he didn't get. The manager ex- versed in showing goods and with decided ability
say few capitalists would value the good-will of
the average music house as proportionately any- plains that the salesman had no authority to prom- as a "closer," but he has never been given either
the suggestion or the incentive that would have
ise any such thing. But somehow the customer
thing like that of—for instance—a well-established
isn't interested in the question of authority. He made him a merchandiser as well as a salesman.
department store.
The net result is that both he and the house em-
wants what was promised him.
Superficially, the answer is that they do not offer
a fair comparison, since the customer of a depart-
Another customer has purchased a player-piano ploying him are realizing only about 50 per cent,
ment store is a steady and frequent trade, while and complains that the salesman "hasn't even of his possible efficiency.
the buyer of a piano is in the market but two or called up to find out how I am getting along in
Every customer to whom an instrument is sold
three times in a lifetime. Hence, superficially, the learning to play it." The salesman asserts that he should be, and can be, made an actual assistant
argument would be that in the case of the piano "sent out an instructor," and seems to think that to the sales department. This is not a Eutopian
was amply sufficient.
theory, but a simple fact of good business. Ninety
And so it goes—one small complaint after an- per cent, of the grievances which prevent this
other. "Small," did I say? Yes, small in the condition can be avoided and eliminated by ade-
eyes of the complaint-hardened veteran, but very quate sales training.
DEATH OF W. N. HOBART.
Director and Member of Executive Committee
of John Church Co. Passes Away.
(Special to The Review.)
Frederick E. Pierce.
buyer there can be no such thing as an estab-
lished habit of going to a certain store.
But neither habit nor precedent are the impor-
tant elements in the good-will of a music house.
Every purchaser of a piano, player-piano, or, in-
deed, any other musical instrument, should be so
handled and so served that he or she becomes an
actual business-getting asset.
Which leads directly to the subject of trained
salesmanship, for one of the functions of proper
sales training is to promote this good-will.
There are thousands of salesmen in the business
who are prepossessing in appearance, neat as to
their clothes, able to speak passable English, and
equipped with a tolerable tonnage of gray mat-
ter; they are closing a good volume of business;
yet the houses employing them would be, in the
long run, much better off without them.
They are good greeters, receive customers
suavely, and at the end of the month the sales
manager has a nice little handful of contracts as a
result of their efforts.
But he also has something else—likewise as a
result of their efforts. In fact, he has a long,
steadily-flowing stream of "something elses." One
customer has been sold an instrument that is too
expensive and the payments are a burden. He is
unhappy. The salesman "lifted" him to the high-
priced instrument—more than he could afford—
and really thinks he deserves a medal for putting
it over. And indeed he does deserve one—a large
one, twelve inches in diameter and made of genu-
ine oak-tanned leather.
Another customer has discovered that the sales-
man told him a constructive falsehood about a
competing instrument, and he has already begun to
look with suspicion on the one he has bought.
was its head for many years. The deceased was
identified in substantial financial ways with vari-
ous companies in this city. In honor of his death
the offices of the two corporations were closed
yesterday morning during the hours of the
funeral.
Cincinnati, O., Nov. 19, 1912.
W. N. Hobart, director and a member of the
executive committee of the John Church Co., OPENS BRANCH STORE IN CHICAGO.
whose critical illness was noted in this column
The Wulschner-Stewart Music Co., of Indian-
some weeks ago, was laid to rest yesterday morn-
apolis, has opened a retail branch store at 432 East
ing in beautiful Spring Grove Cemetery, the serv-
61st street, Chicago, under the management of T.
ices being attended by the officials of the cor-
R. O'Connor. The Jewett piano will be featured
poration which he helped to make a success, as
as the leader.
well as those of the Church-Beinkamp Co.
The deceased passed away at his home on
PIANO MAN DROWNED.
Winslow avenue, Walnut Hills, shortly after mid-
night last Friday morning. Ever since last sum-
While on a fishing trip recently, Richard Eber-
mer, when he complained of the excessive heat,
:
Mr. Hobart, who was 76 years old, was a sick hart, v ce-president of Reichardt & Son & Eber-
hart,
piano
manufacturers of Ludington, Mich.,
man. Death was due to a complication of dis-
eases. Mr. Hobart became interested in the together with J. W. Barry, a Chicago varnish
affairs of the John Church Co. some twenty years salesman, was drowned in Pere Marquette River.
ago, and in all these years, until some months ago,
never failed to attend the weekly meetings of the OCCUPY NEW MUSIC ROLL FACTORY.
executive board, held in the office of President
Frank A. Lee. He took a keen interest in the
The Royal Music Co., manufacturers of music
affairs of the company and his suggestions were
rolls, Buffalo, N. Y., now occupies its new factory
always well received. Some years ago Mr. Ho- at Main street and Hurtle avenue. The new build-
bart broadened his interest in musical affairs ing is two stories high, built of brick and steel and
through the noted May Festival Association and
measures 125 x 160 feet.
Popular In 1854
THE BRADBURY PIANOS
A Continued Favorite in 1912
The Bradbury pianos after more than a half century OF CONTINUED SUCCESS
yet remain the dealer's preference and the musician's choice.
ACTIVE AGENTS WANTED IN UNOCCUPIED TERRITORY
Send fop Catalogues and Prices to
F. G. SMITH,
Manufacturer
Main Offices, 774-6-8 Fulton Street, Brooklyn, New York
The Satisfactory Grade of the
WEBSTER PIANOS
At their moderate prices, pleasing designs and SUPERIOR construction make them a
VALUABLE agency to any active dealer. ADD to this
THE HENNING AND VVHITTIER PIANOS
We certainly are furnishing a most desirable line OF PROFIT-MAKING PIANOS.
Correspond with the
.
WEBSTER PIANO CO.
Factory, LEOlVflNSTER,
MASS.
Main Office, 774 Fulton Street, Brooklyn, New York

Download Page 9: PDF File | Image

Download Page 10 PDF File | Image

Future scanning projects are planned by the International Arcade Museum Library (IAML).

Pro Tip: You can flip pages on the issue easily by using the left and right arrow keys on your keyboard.