Music Trade Review

Issue: 1912 Vol. 54 N. 4

Music Trade Review -- © mbsi.org, arcade-museum.com -- digitized with support from namm.org
THE
MUSIC TRADE
into the habit of glorifying the means rather than
the end. But it is not so much a question of how
you do a thing as of what you do. And if, with
the player-piano, the things which have been here
mentioned may truly be done, then that instru-
ment is one that can be "played." And it really
does not make the slightest difference whether the
statement pleases anybody or not. The facts are
the' facts, nor can they be gainsaid. The sole
matter wherewith we have to concern ourselves
relates to the one question of whether the kind
of thing which we have described as "playing" is
or is not possible with the player-piano.
An Affirmation.
And the answer must be yes! The player-piano
can be "played"—played in every meaning of the
word. Its defects as an instrument for the inter-
pretation of music are defects traceable to the
manner of producing the controlling music roll
rather than to any defects naturally inherent in
itself. Every single thing that can be done, so
far as concerns the obtaining of musical effect, by
the pianist may also be done by the player-pianist,
subject only to the limitations of imperfectly cut
or arranged music rolls. The statement is pos-
sibly bold; it is certainly true. And yet not one
person in ten who uses the player-piano is thereby
enabled to get from it what may be termed rudi-
mentarily good musical results. There is some-
thing wrong somewhere; something overlooked,
perhaps; something which we have not yet con-
sidered. What is that something and what are we
REVIEW
going to do about it? The question has a present
importance and needs an answer.
The Secret.
To put the matter in a nutshell, the whole diffi-
culty lies in the fact that no mechanism whatever,
any more than the ordinary keyboard itself, can
enable one to obtain good musical effect unless one
possesses something of musical taste and appre-
ciation. The mere touching of button and levers
is nothing. It is the conception behind the me-
chanical actions that counts. And, hard though the
truth may be, no means have yet been devised for
facilitating the playing of music half so powerful
as the human mind itself. Yet it is not by any
means needful to despair or repine. Anyone of
average intelligence can so quickly acquire the
knowledge necessary for musical appreciation that
the only wonder is so few take advantage of their
opportunities. Every possible conceivable means
for self-instruction in the understanding and ap-
preciation of art may be found at hand. But with-
out the willing spirit the best of facilities and
opportunities are useless. And if one is to make
one single criticism it is that people are altogether
too anxious to have things done for them and too
little ready to give of themselves. Too bad that
we do not all realize how true pleasure is to be
found only in that which costs some effort to ac-
quire. And that is the whole secret. Learn to
appreciate the inner meaning of the music you wish
to interpret, and lo! your player-piano is become a
true musical instrument.
that positively controls the speed of the governor
under all conditions. Pumping lightly or very hard
Of the Ludwig Player-Piano Being Exploited will not change the speed, no matter how large the
mus : c roll may be. The choker box is connected in
by the Firm.
a like manner in the bass end, both of which have
Ludwig & Co., 136th street and Willow avenue, thumb-screws conveniently located for regulating."
There will be a series of 10 cards mailed out
are sending to the trade a series of cards illus-
trating the various component parts of its unit which will be most helpful to dealers and tuners,
valve piano-player action, which employs two res- for they will describe minutely every part so that
one can easily adjust the mechanism at any time.
ervoirs, one for the treble and one for the bass.
SOME INTERESTING FEATURES
T H E LEDVV1G T U M P I N G
INVENTS TUNING DEVICE
For Pneumatically Operated Self-Playing In-
struments of the Violin Class.
(Special to The Review.)
Washington, D. C, Jan. 22, 1912.
A tuning device for self-playing instruments is
the basis of patent No. 1,014,925, granted this week
to Joseph Wauters, of Scranton, Pa., and assigned
to the Wurlitzer Co., of North Tonowanda, N. Y.
The invention relates to means for tuning the
strings of automatic instruments and particularly
those of pneumatically operated self-playing instru-
ments of the violin class.
The object of the invention is to provide easily
operated means for sounding pitchpipes or the like,
tuned to the proper pitch of the strings, so that the
latter may be readily brought into unison there-
with, and for simultaneously sounding the string so
that comparison with the pitchpipe is easily made
and the correct pitch of the string readily deter-
mined.
One of the three claims is as follows: "In self-
playing instruments a tracker board, a string-
sounding pneumatic, a pipe connection from said
tracker-board to said pneumatic, and a tuning de-
vice connected to said pipe, comprising a box, a
partition therein, a pitchpipe in said partition, a
valve controlling said pitchpipe, an exhaust tube
leading from said box, and means for moving said
valve to sound said pitchpipe."
IMPROVEMENT IN GRAND ACTION.
Melville Clark, of the Melville Clark Piano Co.,
Chicago, 111., was this week granted patent No.
1,014,949 on an improvement on an interior player
action. The purpose of the invention is primarily
to provide a grand piano with automatic playing
devices adapted for independently playing two
parts of a piece of music, as a solo or melody and
an accompaniment, and comprising for that purpose
two pneumatic actions and tracker devices having
ducts in different groups for connection with said
actions respectively.
DEVICE.
This cut shows the complete pumping device and
the concern makes the claim that "this has proven
to be the most successful system ever placed on
the market, because of the carrying of a reserve in
both ends of the piano the pressure is absolutely
equal at all times throughout the system of pneu-
matics, which produces wonderful effects when
playing softly or under light pressure. In the
right-hand or treble end of the piano, connected
with the reservoir, is the controller box of the mo-
tor, or governor. This is constructed in a manner
We herewith illustrate
Style P, one of the leading
in the Ludwig player-piano
line which contains all the
special Ludwig features.
This instrument has won a
large measure of popularity
among dealers and users,
based upon its satisfaction-
giving qualities as a player
and as a piano.
Ludwig Player-Piano
Style P.
The Master Player-Piano
is now equipped with an
AUTOMATIC TRACKING DEVICE
Which guarantees absolutely correct tracking of even the most imperfect music rolls
W I N T E R & CO., 220 Southern Boulevard, New York City
Music Trade Review -- © mbsi.org, arcade-museum.com -- digitized with support from namm.org
THE: MUSIC TRADE
T
HE progress in popularity of the player-piano has brought
about many striking phenomena in the way of trade develop-
ment. One of the most interesting of these has been the accept-
ance by one section of the theory that a pneumatic action is best
made by specialists who design a standard type and provide with
it all who wish to use it, while the other holds that the house which
makes a fine piano and desires for its player product the same repu-
tation that the original instrument had should produce, no matter
at what cost in time, labor and expense, a mechanism entirely indi-
vidual in itself.
It is not our place to compare the relative excellence of the two
schools, but rather to mention their existence as a fitting prelude
to some comments on one of the most remarkable of the individual
pneumatic developments, the Artistano, of the A. B. Chase Co.,
Norwalk, O.
It was the recent privilege of the Technical Editor of this
newspaper to inspect the plant of the A. B. Chase Co., at Nor-
walk, O., and there to see something at first hand of the actual
making of a mechanism for piano playing which had long been
familiar from its musical side and as a complete structure, but
which was now to be inspected, for the first time, in process of
building.
The Artistano player mechanism has always had a fascination
for the technical observer, if only because of its utterly individual
and unique character. It is not at all like any other mechanism.
It stands quite by itself in all the essentials of construction and
design. There is nothing just like it elsewhere.
These considerations alone would mark as exceedingly inter-
esting any mechanism built in accordance with them. And when
we add that the musical results therefrom proceeding are also in
certain ways almost unique, we have said enough to prepare the
reader for something more than ordinary.
Leaving aside further consideration of the Artistano itself,
however, for the moment, it is proper to remark that the plant of
the A. B. Chase Co. is in most respects quite a model. He who is
accustomed only to the cramped quarters and poor light of factory
buildings in crowded sections of great cities is at once struck with
the abundance of space, the excellent light and the remarkable
cleanliness that one perceives throughout the whole plant. Not
only is this so, but it is safe to say that at least one-half as many
men again could be provided with bench room without crowding
the plant beyond the limits generally assigned.
This is, of course, a very great advantage, since it renders
possible the turning out of delicate work in the most advantageous
conditions. The men, too, appreciate the abundance of light and
room which in itself is an exceedingly important thing. In fact,
the A. B. Chase Co. is noted for the high class of mechanics
attracted to its works and for the loyalty and contentment of these
men, who not only take a genuine pride in what they are doing,
but almost invariably settle down to become permanent citizens of
the town.
A further important and noteworthy feature of the factory is
seen in the very excellent arrangement of departments, whereby
one principle of scientific management—economy in the procession
of work—is strikingly emphasized. From the moment that the
lumber takes its place in the mill room the work makes a steady
progress from floor to floor, from department to department, grow-
ing in complexity at each step, but never being turned back, and
never doubling on its tracks.* It might be added that a spur of
the Lake Shore Railway comes up to the doors of the plant, so that
no transshipment of boxed pianos or supplies is necessary, every-
thing being unloaded from the freight cars right on to the factory
floors.
One is likewise struck with the general appearance of order
and cleanliness. The floors are always clean; so are the workmen
themselves. Such details as the aggregation of women workers in
REVIEW
the player department within a separate room, the provision of
excellent factory arrangements, and the general breadth and sweep
everywhere apparent, are further admirable features. A visit to
the A. B. Chase plant is an eye-opener in more senses than one.
The A. B. Chase piano has been known for what it is these
many years. Its high rank among the artistic musical instruments
of the country, no less the lofty purposes which have inspired its
makers, have more than once furnished themes for description and
appreciation. And it is therefore not only interesting, but apposite
that the Artistano should prove to be a mechanism of precisely the
same rank, or, rather, of .exactly parallel rank; a mechanism
entirely worthy of the piano in which alone it is placed.
It is unnecessary to go into minute detail regarding the con-
structional features of this instrument for playing the piano. It is
sufficient to say that in principle it is of the double valve type, with
sensitive bellows. Its control consists of two levers operating a
divided action, the exhaust chest being in two compartments and
the levers operating tension switches through the medium of ex-
pression governors. The motor is of unusual design in that its
units connect with the crank shaft through rolling contact, without
bearings, while its slide valve covers are of glass.
But the most interesting thing about the Artistano mechanism
lies in the manner of its housing within the piano. In the uprights
the whole mechanism is disposed below the keybed in unitary form.
Not only is the whole pneumatic action thus kept entirely distinct
from the piano itself, but it is fastened on a hinge in such a way
that when desired the whole structure may be swung outwards.
In this latter condition the action remains an unit, no part of it
being dissociated from the rest. Thus foi purposes of examina-
tion or test, the action may be operated as it stands outside of the
piano. The value of this to the tuner, whether for the rapid loca-
tion and remedying of trouble or for access to the bottom board
and trap-work of the piano, need hardly be mentioned. When we
add to these facts the further fact that the tracker box, containing
the control levers, slips easily forward in front of the key-slip, with
the same motion that brings forward the foot pedals and that no
part of the piano above the keybed is in any way required to house
parts of the player mechanism, we have said enough to make it
understood that the Artistano mechanism is indeed quite different
from anything else of the kind.
Equal ingenuity characterizes the disposition of the mechanism
in the grand. In this case the same features are preserved in the
housing of the tracker, while the rest of the mechanism is disposed
on a frame which slides below the posts of the piano frame and is
adequately concealed by a two-inch moulding. The pedals fold
into the lyre and the whole action may be removed by the extrac-
tion of a few thumb nuts and a gentle pull forward.
In the end, of course, the things that a player action will do
are the important things. It was the privilege of The Review's
Technical Editor, after his inspection of the plant, to spend some
time in the warerooms playing an Artistano grand. It was not his
first experience with the instrument by any means. But one always
turns back to the Artistano grand with a sense of delighted antici-
pation. The perfect intimacy of the union between piano and
player pianist, the easy position in a comfortable chair, the mar-
velous delicacy and responsiveness of the mechanism; all these
elements go into the making up of an experience which is always
delightful and which one remembers for long afterwards. The
Artistano is an instrument for the master player-pianist. It is the
eternal honor of its makers that they have never been lured by the
fascination of commercial aggrandizement from their steady pursuit
of the straight path of continual struggle to attain that goal of ideal
perfection which is ever in the vision, if not in the realization of all
true workers in art. To voice an appreciation of a house like this,
and of its wonderful work, is not merely a" duty; it is the highest
of pleasures.

Download Page 7: PDF File | Image

Download Page 8 PDF File | Image

Future scanning projects are planned by the International Arcade Museum Library (IAML).

Pro Tip: You can flip pages on the issue easily by using the left and right arrow keys on your keyboard.