Music Trade Review

Issue: 1911 Vol. 52 N. 1

Music Trade Review -- © mbsi.org, arcade-museum.com -- digitized with support from namm.org
THE
MUSIC TRADE
REVIEW
EDWARD LYMAN BILL - Editor and Proprietor
REVIEW
the mass of trade papers; some inconsequential—some abusive and
some good.
It is results that are most eloquent, and the work which we
are putting forth is being carefully noted by the leading men of
the trade, and they realize that a paper which can render exclusive
values—values which are steadily growing—is better to patronize
than the vapid—colorless—policyless sheets.
A straight-clean-cut-unique-individual service is our slogan for
1911, and it shall be our aim to produce a paper which shall be
sought with growing eagerness by all branches of the trade.
J. B. SPILLANE, Managing Editor
Executive and Reportorial Stall:
Gao. B. K I L U I ,
B. BRITTAIW WILSOK,
W. H. DTKBB,
A. J. NICXLIK,
BOSTON OFFICE:
G. W. HBNDBRRON, 178 Tremont 8 t
Room 12.
Telephone, Oxford 1159-2.
PHILADELPHIA:
R. W. KATTJTMAN,
R. W. SIMMONS,
AUQCBT J. TIMPB.
L. B. B o w n i ,
WM. B. WHITK.
CHICAGO OFFICE:
E. P. VAN HAELINQHN, 156 Wabash AT«.
Room 806,
Telephone, Central 414.
MINNEAPOLIS and ST. PAUL:
ST. LOUIS:
ADOLI 1 EDSTBN,
CHAS. N. VAN BURIN.
SAN FRANCISCO: S. H. GRAT, 88 First Street.
CINCINNATI, O.:
BALTIMORE, MD.:
JACOB W. WALTERS.
A. ROBERT FRENCH.
LONDON. ENGLAND: 69 Baslnghall St., B. C.
W. LIONEL STURDY, Manager.
Published Every Saturday at 1 Madison Avenue, New York
Entered at the New York Post Office as Second Clbss Matter.
SUBSCRIPTION, (Including postage), United States and Mexico, f2.00 per year;
Canada, $8.SO ; all other countries, $4.00.
ADVERTISEMENTS, f 2.00 per Inch, single column, per Insertion. On quarterly or
yearly contracts a special discount Is allowed. Advertising Pages, $60.00; opposite
reading matter, $75.00.
REMITTANCES, In other than currency forms, should be made payable to Edward
Lyman BUI.
An important feature of this publication is a complete sec-
ti o n devoted to the interests of music publishers and dealers.
And
Departments conducted by an expert wherein all ques-
auu
tions of a technical nature relating to the tuning,
Toohnioal
Honartmontc
regulating and repairing of pianos and player-pianos
l e t l l l l l t d l i r c p d l lllieill!». a r e dealt with, will be found in another section of this
paper. We also publish a number of reliable technical works, information concerning
Which will be cheerfully given upon request.
Exposition Honors Won by The Review
Grand Prim
Paris Exposition, 1900
Silver If edal. Charleston Exposition, 1902
Diploma..Pan-American Exposition, 1901
Gold Medal.. .St. Louis Exposition, 1904
Qold Medal
Lewis-Clark Exposition, 1905.
S
OME of the best posted business men of the country view the
New Year optimistically.
Some go so far as to predict a genuine boom, but we hardly
agree with such a prediction.
There are a number of important matters which perhaps will
hold up business somewhat.
The important cases which will have to be passed upon by the
Supreme Court may have, temporarily, an effect upon trade condi-
tions, but business cannot be permanently hampered, because the
directing minds behind the great corporations will quickly find a
way to readjust their corporations to new conditions.
The wheels of industry will continue to revolve and this big
country will move ahead.
Pianos will continue to be purchased in large quantities and
the men who have confidence and make their business plans with-
out undue conservatism will be the ones who will win substantial
advance during the New Year.
Conservatism in business is all right, but it can be overdone,
and every man who is running a business should figure just what
the effect of his over-retrenchment will have upon those lower down.
Some men will be frightened—that influences others 90 that
there will be retrenchments in all lines.
Now the quicker that one gets the idea of over-due conserva-
tism removed from his mind the better it will be.
W
E think that the subjoined is well worthy of serious con-
sideration by business men everywhere.
LONG DISTANCE TELEPHONES—NUMBERS 4677 and 4678 GRAMERCY
The Simmons Hardware Co., one of the greatest mercantile in-
Connecting all Departments.
stitutions in the Southwest, recently issued the following letter:
Cable address: "Elblll, New York."
"The business of the merchants and manufacturers of St. Louis
NEW YORK, JANUARY 7, 1911
for 1910 has been fairly good—quite up to the average of any ten
years in its history, by comparison with previous records—and in
no way could it be properly called a bad year, although far from
being all that we had hoped it would be when the year started out
EDITORIAL
with such bright promise. That prospect was dimmed quite soon
by many things, but particularly by political disturbances and by
the active efforts of demagogues and muckrakers, who have been
T the beginning of the New Year it is customary to make reso- quite in the limelight in helping to form public opinion in an un-
lutions, and the director of this trade newspaper institution
healthy way.
has firmly resolved to augment its value to advertisers and sub-
"The stocks of merchandise in the hands of the retail mer-
scribers during the New Year in every possible manner.
chants are exceedingly low. This is the result of doubt, fear or
On Tuesday a communication embodying the subjoined quota-
dread of 'something going to happen'—an indefinable 'something'
tion was received from a prominent piano manufacturer:
which they could not express. When a man hesitated or declined
"I wish to congratulate you upon The Review of Saturday.
to buy as freely as usual and was asked his reasons he would
It is a splendid publication and not merely is it a credit to your
promptly say he did not like the looks of things—that he wanted
newspaper organization, but to the music trade industry as well.
to keep 'near shore' and go slow—so that the orders this year have
The emphasis which you are placing upon the player department
been far more numerous than usual and smaller, but the aggregate
certainly makes The Review unique and gives it a distinct and
has been satisfactory,
leading position."
"Ohio, Indiana, Michigan, Kentucky, Tennessee, Alabama and
This is precisely what we have been working for and we have
Mississippi are in good shape and give promise of an increased
always claimed that there is just as much difference in trade papers
trade. Iowa is in unusually good condition, with a crop of three
as there is in individuals, and it has been our aim to make this paper
hundred million bushels of corn. Illinois, as a whole, is in good
individual in every particular and we have not hesitated to spend
condition and gives promise of a healthy increase in demand for
money in the development of plans to make it so.
merchandise.
That The Review has advanced to the leading position is con-
"Georgia, North Carolina and South Carolina have had a fair
ceded by many members of this industry.
crop of cotton—not a good one—but the prices of cotton have
Certainly we have been giving a greater service to the player
made the money value of that crop larger than usual. These States
industry than all of the other papers combined.
encourage us to believe that they will need more goods and buy
We may go further and say that our service in a single month
more for the first half of 1911 than they did in 1910.
equals that of all of the others for six months.
"In our own State—Missouri—the conditions are favorable for
Now, if the player-piano is a steadily growing factor in the an increase in business of at least ten to twenty per cent. the
industry, then this superior service rendered by The Review at once
majority of the reports indicating the latter. In the Central West
gives it the leading position and makes it clear and distinct from
including Colorado, Utah and Idaho, the prospects are quite as good
A
Music Trade Review -- © mbsi.org, arcade-museum.com -- digitized with support from namm.org
THE
MUSIC TRADE
for business for the first half of 1911 as for the corresponding
period of 1910.
"California is in better shape and bids fair to demand more
goods. The prediction is that the business there will increase about
ten per cent. In Nebraska they had a great drought; still, the crop
was not a bad one, considering its money value, and the people
there have had good crops several years previously, so that the
farmers are in excellent shape financially.
"New England, New York and Pennsylvania salesmen, to the
last man, state that they expect to do better business the first half
of the coming year than in 1910.
"The conclusions are that the promises for the first half of
1911 are for a better business than for the corresponding period of
1910. The indebtedness of the farmer to the merchant and the
retail merchant to the jobber and the jobber to the manufacturer
is less than usual owing to the conservative policy of buying in
small quantities and buying often.
U n d e r TOE
The recent trials involving corruption in connec-
tion with the repair work of one of the railroad
systems of the Middle West call attention to the
utter uselessness of the legislation passed by a
number of States striking at all forms of gratuities
in connection with sales of goods. As a writer in
The Iron Age aptly says, it has long been recog-
nized that presents of money play no small part in
the transaction of business. A generation ago the
practice was more prevalent; better systems of
buying now make it more difficult. But the favor
of some employes, in positions both high and low,
still has to be secured by this dishonorable means.
In certain works and in isolated departments of
others the salesman finds it absolutely necessary if
he is to secure the business. The owner pays the
bill usually, for the price is made to include the
gratuity. Men who come in frequent contact with
subordinates assert that the custom is just as prev-
alent as it was five years ago, before the laws were
made providing a penalty of fine and imprisonment
for both the receiver and the giver of the induce-
ment. No necessity for concealment exists, ex-
cepting from the owners, for the law became prac-
tically a dead letter from the moment of its pas-
sage.
*
* «
The fault lies with the employer. If he were
anxious to get at the reasons for the existing cor-
ruption he could discover the offender with no
great amount of trouble. Usually the condition is
well known to many salesmen. A reputation is
made, knowledge of which spreads quickly. The
owner, by ridding himself of this form of parasite,
would reduce his costs, for corruption means ex-
pensive buying. The great majority of employes
are honest men, in the piano as in other trades,
but occasionally among them is a rascal who sees
no wrong in enriching himself whenever and how-
ever possible. If a man is dishonest the trait will
express itself in other ways should the occasion
offer. Those who looked to see the terror of the
law bring an end to "grafting" in the works now
realize, if . they have-given the subject thought,
that the remedy must be one of discipline, admin-
istered after watchful investigation.
REVIEW
"There are three things of great importance necessary to bring
back to us the fullest possible measure of prosperity.
"The first is new and better currency laws, which shall oblit-
erate all fears of a panic; the second is a clear and favorable con^
struction of the Sherman Anti-Trust law, and the third that pros-
perity should return to the railroads. We need in the Southwest
and in the section distinctly tributary to St. Louis at least ten
thousand miles of new railroad."
So cheerful were the reports of the Simmons salesmen in the
company's houses at St. Louis, New York, Toledo, Minneapolis,
Sioux City and Wichita that other mercantile agencies were asked
for information. The result was the same.
It should be understood that this communication was based
upon the reports of many hundreds of salesmen, and it makes
pleasant reading when the head of a great business institution like
E. C. Simmons predicts an increase of ten per cent, to twenty per
cent, in business activity over that of the past year.
TALL TOWER
know I live out of the city, and in going home
the other night I met H. Paul Mehlin, of Paul G.
Mehlin & Sons who has, as you know, a beautiful
home out in my section. I noticed a bundle of
papers under his arm, and recognizing the leading
trade journals from the names on the wrappers, I
remarked in a jocular way: 'Why, Mr. Mehlin,
what in the world are you carrying those papers
with you for? Don't .you see enough of them at
your office?' 'Well,' replied Mr. Mehlin, 'that is
just the trouble. I somehow cannot find sufficient
time to go through them as I should, therefore I
always take them home to read them more thor-
oughly, and I invariably take them up before read-
ing the daily papers. I have found from my ex-
perience that the only way to keep posted on trade
affairs and keep in touch with developments is to
read trade papers, and to read them regularly.
Their news reports, correspondence from every-
where, their editorial and general comments, invite
close study, and not infrequently I find much food
for serious reflection and deep thinking. This is a
custom I have followed for years, and if I speak
only from a commercial standpoint, it pays, but I
must say there are higher considerations besides,
as the trade papers are both informing and in-
structive.' " These remarks of Mr. Mehlin so im-
pressed our informant as to their sound philosophy
and good sense that he at once subscribed for The
Review to be sent to his home address, in addition
to the one now sent to his office. Take a copy of
The Review like last week's, with its interesting
and highly educational Player Section, and it cer-
tainly contains ample food for thought, and sugges-
tions of real value to manufacturers, dealers and
salesmen alike, apart from the merits of the paper
proper. Hence, those who find it difficult to get an
opportunity of looking over its columns carefully
in warerooms or offices should follow Mr. Mehlin's
example and make it a point to get it in their
homes.
*
*. •?
One of the essentials in a successful business is a
courteous reply to all letters received. Within re-
cent years a great indifference has been displayed
to giving attention to correspondence, and when at-
«* * *
tended to letters are often so abruptly written and
It is a noteworthy fact that all progressive manu- so lacking in warmth as to chill the recipient.
facturers in this and in every other industry are Brevity in business letter writing is excellent. It
close readers of their trade papers. When you saves the time of the recipient in writing, as well
come across a piano manufacturer or dealer, for as the time of the sender. But no matter how
that matter, who tells you that he hasn't time to brief or. inadequate, it is better to write some sort
read his trade paper, you can easily arrive at the of letter in acknowledgment of another than to
conclusion—and it will be a safe one, too—that he ignore it, as is commonly done. It is to be assumed
is not a man who is going ahead—that he is a man that when a man writes to another that his com-
who will never be more than a mere mediocrity. munication will be deemed worthy of respectful
Curtness and indifference can be
This, apropos of the remarks of a member of the consideration.
trade who said to the writer a few days ago; "You as apparent in correspondence as in personal inter-
course. This is particularly true of communica-
tions with business men in Europe, who are ac-
customed to indulge in much polite verbiage in
business letters. When they receive a brief, cold
letter from Americans it is not as apt to produce
as favorable an impression as if it contained a
few introductory and closing courteous lines. As
one of those wise men of ancient Rome—was it
Lucullus?—had it, "a kind word is better than a
fat pie," and there is no better foundation for
agreeable business relations than the policy of an-
swering letters and writing in a spirit that conveys
sentiments of warmth and sincerity.
H * K
When Charles H. Wagener, European repre-
sentative of the Melville Clark Piano Co., Chicago,
was in New York on his arrival from England, he
expressed himself as being greatly interested in
the development of foreign trade on the part of
American manufacturers and merchants, especially
the piano industry. Mr. Wagener had been read-
ing the various articles on the subjects which had
appeared in The Review and also the steps taken
by the National Association of Piano Manufac-
turers in aid of establishing more direct communi-
cation with Latin America and the development of
the merchant marine. In referring to the subject
he said: '"The American manufacturer has neg-
lected the foreign markets, and it is time he should
become alive to the situation and not let the Euro-
pean nations walk away with the great profits lying
at his very door. The manufacturers here think—
judging from their action—that the Spanish-
American buyers will come their way for the ask-
ing. I really believe the majority of the South
American people and the Mexicans are predisposed
to buy the products of the United States, but they
must be carefully cultivated. Now, tha American
manufacturers, in times of financial stress, will
dump their goods on the foreign market at any
old price in order to raise money. This is all
wrong. These methods disturb trade, which should
be steady to be profitable. About every seven years
there is a panic here, with the way business is done,
at such high pressure and along impulsive lines.
The export business, when once secured, will tide
over these periods, and its benefits are not to be
measured."
*
* *
A strong commercial point is to conduct business
on a one-price basis. Mark the price on the goods
in plain figures and never deviate; sooner lose a
sale and keep your reputation as a one-price house.
People will soon become acquainted with the fact
of the store selling goods at one price only, and
trade will thereby increase, simply because the
customers realize that their money will buy no
more nor less than another customer's.

Download Page 4: PDF File | Image

Download Page 5 PDF File | Image

Future scanning projects are planned by the International Arcade Museum Library (IAML).

Pro Tip: You can flip pages on the issue easily by using the left and right arrow keys on your keyboard.