Music Trade Review

Issue: 1910 Vol. 51 N. 7

Music Trade Review -- © mbsi.org, arcade-museum.com -- digitized with support from namm.org
THE
MUSIC TRADE
REVIEW
"IMPROVING" THE PIANO.
LEASE FINE LOCATION.
Ernest Schelling's Remarks on the Curved
Keyboard Introduced in G:rmany Seme Time
Ago and Some Pertinent Editorial Comments
Thereon—The Piano Keyboard Coird and
Should Be Improved but It Is Doubtful if
It Will Be, Judging from Past History.
Montenegro-Riehm Co., of Louisville. Ky., Sign
Eleven Years' Lease for Atherton B u i l d i n g —
May Move May 1, 1911,
A hundred times, more or less, has the piano
heeii "revolutionized." We have had everything
from the "violin sound-hoard" of Driggs, famous
in the middle of the nineteenth century, to the
Janko keyhoard of later date and greater fame.
And still the inventors come and go, departing
with hardly a visihle trace of their activities he-
hind them. The piano goes on from age to age,
neither changing nor heing changed.
Still, one might feel more complacent about
these things if really there were no need for im-
provement. But there is sad need for much bet-
tering, unfortunately. The present accepted key-
board is about the most astonishing example ex-
tant of a mechanism singularly unfitted for the
purpose assigned to it, which yet persists from
year to year without eliciting an audible protest
anywhere. The Janko keyboard was a tremen-
dous step forward. It enabled the doing of things
utterly impossible with the ordinary clavier, while
everything at present possible was easier when
done through its means. The one thing the Janko
keyboard could not manage—a glissando in C ma-
jor (on the white keys only)—is surely no loss.
And yet the Janko clavier could not survive the
dead wall of bigoted conservatism which the piano
teachers presented against it.
These remarks are suggested by some recent
words of Ernest Schelling, the American com-
poser-pianist, uttered in the course of a talk with
an Kuropean representative of Musical America.
Mr. Schelling voiced his opinion of the curved
radial keyboard which was introduced in Ger-
many some time ago, and which certainly deserved
appreciation and a fair trial. Yet Mr. Schelling
could say nothing better of it than this:
"Its advantages are comparatively small, and,
considering the advance made in piano technic
these days, I see no necessity for the small advan-
tage which it endeavors to provide. Contrary to
what one might expect owing to the angle between
the keys, the action of the thing is not more diffi-
cult than that of an ordinary instrument. But its
fate will probably be like that of the piano with
the series of superimposed keyboards, invented
many years ago. That was devised so that in
playing a scale you would have to move diagon-
ally upward instead of in a straight line. No, it
will not be in any direction of this kind that fu-
ture advances in piano construction will be made."
Now, when one considers the very plain fact
that the conventional piano keyboard renders the
grasp of any interval larger than an octave quite
difficult, and anything more than a tenth almost
impossible, it does seem that there was something
to be said for the proposal to arrange the keys in
such a way as to permit of a longer reach and
more rapid progress from one to another remote
point. Certainly what has been found good for
the pedal clavier of the organ might be supposed,
by analogy, if for no other reason, to be equally
advantageous for the fingers. But apparently pian-
its don't think so. x^nd there you are!
Seriously, it is a pity that so little thought is ever
taken in this direction. The piano keyloarl is a
most shining example of how not to design a
mechanism for a specific purpose. It v/as oi'g-
inally no more nor less than a reduction to the
clavichord of the enormous and cumbersome ba-
tons of the ancient pipe organ, which were struck
by the fist of the player. It was never thought out
from any definite standpoint or with any specific
intention in view. Tt stands to-day an hetero-
geneous development of incoherent principles.
Of course, the piano keyboard could and should
be improved.
But it is exceedingly doubtful
whether it ever will be.
A. E. Van Bogart has purchased the interests
of his partner in the music house of Rhoadamer
& Van Bogart, Grinncll, la.
(Special to The Review.)
Louisville, Ky., Aug. 8, 1010.
The Montencgro-Riehm Piano Co. have leased
the Atherton building, at the corner of Fourth ave-
nue and Walnut street, this city, the lease running
for eleven years and calling for a total rental of
$:{DO,nO0. The location is considered one of the
best in the city, and it is expected that the piano
company will occupy the new quarters about May
1, 1!U1, when the lease becomes effective. The
building is five stories high and it is likely that
the piano company will rent out the upper floors
not needed for their business.
TRADE NEAR JOME GROWS.
Our Exports to North and South America Show
Good Gains.
(Special to The Review.)
Washington, D. C, Aug. 8, 1910.
The export trade of the United States to South
America, North America and Africa during the
last fiscal year increased over the exports of the
previous year, while exports to Europe and Asia
declined, according to statistics furnished by the
Department of Commerce and Labor.
The increase in exports to North American
countries over the preceding year was 24% per
cent.; the increase to South America, 22 per cent.,
and to Africa, 9 per cent., while to Europe the de-
cline was about 1 per cent, and to xAsia and Ocean-
ica a little more than 1 per cent.
Detailed figures show the value of 1910 exports
to South America to be $93,250,000, as compared
with $70,500,000 in 1909; to North America, $385,-
500,000 in 1910, as compared with $300,500,000 in
1909; to Africa, $18,500,000, as compared with $17,-
000,000 in 1909; to Europe, $1,136,000,000, against
$1,140,750,000 in 1909, to Oceanica $111,750,000 in
1910, against $113,000,000 in the preceding year.
The chief growth in the exports of the country,
it is shown, has been with the near neighbors. To
Canada the value of exports in 1910 was $216,000,-
000, as against $163,500,000 in 1909; to Mexico,
$58,000,000, as against $49,750,000; to Cuba, $52,-
750,000, as compared with $44,000,000; to Central
America, $30,250,000, as against $25,125,000; to Ar-
gentina, $40,750,000, as compared with $33,750,000,
and to Brazil $22,750,000, as against $17,500,000.
AN INTERESTING DECISION.
Pennsylvania Judge Holds That Purchaser of
Piano on Lease Agreement Is Not Re-
sponsible if Instrument Is Destroyed by Fire
—Details of the Case.
A new ruling as to the responsibility of the pur-
chase of a piano on the lease plan when said in
strument is destroyed by fire and is uninsured has
just been handed down by Judge (larman. Wilkes-
Barre, Pa.
Dallas C. Shobert, who sold a piano to C. B.
Johnson on a lease agreement, sought to have the
latter continue payments on the piano after it had
been destroyed by fire, the instrument being un-
insured, and claimed that it was the duty of the
purchaser to insure the instrument while in his
possession.
The court held that the defendant, being in no
way to blame for the fire, which originated in an-
other building, occupied by another person, could
not be held responsible for the loss. He also held
that, according to the terms of the lease, said de-
fendant had not been negligent in not insuring the
piano, as the lease held no clause regarding the
condition in which it was to be returned, the final
payment completing the sale. Decision was there-
fore handed down for the defendant, and the deal-
ers of the State are wondering whether the case
will be appealed or what will the final result be.
Milroy & Nelson have moved into their hand-
some new double store in Hopkinton, la.
Add the Victor to
your piano business
and get a share of the
millions of dollars that
are spent yearly for
Victor goods.
Easy business to
handle and you don't
need nearly so much
capital as for pianos.
Victor goods are always
on the move and turn
profits quickly.
Less competition than
in pianos, and every
dealer who handles the
Victor is on an equal
fo o t i n g — fixed prices
with liberal assured
profits.
The amount of money
you make d e p e n d s
largely on yourself.
Some of the leading
piano dealers are making
more money on the
Victor than on all their
pianos put together.
Doesn't that make
you want to know all
about the Victor?
Write us to-day.
Victor Talking Machine Co.
Camden, N. J., U. S. A.
Berliner Gramophone Co., Montreal,
Canadian Distributor*.
To get best results, use only Victor Needles
on Victor Records.
Music Trade Review -- © mbsi.org, arcade-museum.com -- digitized with support from namm.org
THE
MUSIC TRADE
REVIEW
Conducted and Edited by Wm. B. White.
THE TONE QUALITY OF PIANOS; ITS NA-
TURE, CREATION AND REFINEMENT.
Article 6.
We are now prepared to consider the various
influences exerted on tone-quality by the resonance
?l paratus of the piano. By the term resonance
apparatus it should be understood that we refer
to the sound-board and its bridges, and also to
the iron plate with its bars. The term "resonance
apparatus" is used legalise it alone accurately ex-
picsses the functions of the sound-board and other
constructions cognate thereto. Their duty is to
resonate; that is to say, "re-sound" or sound again,
tones of which the vibrations have been impressed
< n them. The duty of a sound-board is not to
"intensify" sounds; that is to say, it does not,
because it cannot, increase the amplitude of vibra-
tion pertaining to the sounding strings, but it can
?nd does vibrate in sympathy with such sounds,
v hen their vibrations are conducted to it through
suitable bridges, and thus, through the delicacy of
its construction repeat the original string sounds,
with a specific color and intensity, determined by
and corresponding to the specific sort of vibra-
tion and vibratory material proper to it.
Obviously, then, since the function of the sound-
board is to act as a true vibrator, and not as a
mere reflector or intensifier, we must study its
make-up and capacities if we are to understand
how it vibrates, and what sort of partial tone pro-
cession may be expected from it. But before we
do this, it will be necessary for a moment to con-
sider the prime cause of the resonating or re-
sounding qualities themselves.
This prime cause arises from the property which
vibratory bodies possess of impressing their vibra-
tions on other bodies suitably brought into com-
munication with them. We call this property, gen-
erally speaking, "sympathetic vibration." The ex-
istence of this property may be demonstrated in a
variety of ways. For instance, if we have a tun-
ing fork on a sound-box and another one not at-
tached to any resonator we can demonstrate the
existence of sympathetic vibration very easily.
The tuning fork which is connected with the sound-
box may be excited, and while it is sounding the
second fork is brought into contact with the sur-
face of the sound-box. Then the first tuning fork
may be damped with the fingers, and the second
one will be heard sounding, when it will be at
once evident that the second fork has been thrown
into vibration by the vibration of the first fork,
conveyed to the former through the agency of the
sound-box. Obviously the .sound-box itself has
been vibrating in precisely the same way as the
tuning fork originally did. Indeed, if the sound-
box attached to a tuning fork be well and truly
proportioned it will be found to have a natural
sound of its own which can be excited by blow-
ing into the orifice of the sound-box. Sometimes
this inherent sound is almost exactly that of the
tuning fork, sometimes considerably different. Of
course, when the tuning fork is thrown into vibra-
tion its weight and power over-balance any inher-
ent vibratory tendency possessed by the sound-
box.
In the same way the piano sound-board has a
note of its own, which may be discovered by
striking its surface, when it has been ribbed and
bridged and is ready for the strings to be put in
place. But in the same way as before its natural
sound is over-blanced by the heavy vibrations of
the piano strings.
Plainly the piano sound-board is a true vibrator.
TUNERS BUY ON SIGHT
Bridle Ribbon Inserter
PlUnt tpplied for.
No olh«r tool will K
«nu«trfallT or qu'ek
ly iDMrt brldl. rlb
b o u without mnoT
\uf the hunrar hM
or batt. Our c i u l o
will »how you many
inch iDTtotlonl and
o w prloM will In
Unat 700.
DOLAN'S BOSTON
TUNERS' OUTFIT CO.
D e p t . M. R.
Common & Washington
Streets. Boston, Mass.
The strings impress upon it their own vibrations
and it repeats these throughout the whole extent
of its surface with an intensity corresponding to
the intensity of the original vibratory amplitude of
the former.
]f a string, after being sounded, be damped,
while the rest of the strings are allowed to re-
main free, the. sound-board, which originally took
up the vibrations of the one string, will continue
for some time to repeat these, in spite of the fact
that their original cause no longer exists. There
is a reason for this to be found in the fact that the
sound-board is connected with all the strings
through the bridges, and whatever vibrations it
received must naturally be transmitted to any
other vibratory bodies in contact with it. 1 f these
latter be free they will in turn accept such com-
ponents of the original compound sonorous wave
generated by the first string and re-sounded by the
sound-board as correspond with any inherent fre-
quencies of their own. If any of these latter
strings has a natural partial tone corresponding to
the fundamental or a partial of the original string
the correspondence of frequency will result in an
agitation of the secondarily agitated string as far as
regards such partial or partials. Hence the whole
set of strings will, each in its own manner, con-
tribute something to the general body of re-sounded
tone, and will produce that extraordinarily rich and
highly colored effect which we are accustomed tn
associate with skilful use of the damper pedal in
piano playing.
It is clear that the practical conditions of sound-
hoard building, if the result is to achieve in the
highest degree the resonating powers here de-
scribed, must be founded upon a thorough know'
edge of the facts noted above, and of the acoust-
ical laws which govern these. The ideal sound-
board must be constructed of a material which
will vibrate freely. It must be capable of trans-
mitting sonorous pulses with great rapidity, and
uniformly throughout its entire structure. At the
same time it must possess sufficient strength to
preserve its originally given capacities throughout
a considerable period of time against the very
great strains imposed on it by the stretched
strings.
Although many experiments have been made
from time to time with other materials, it has been
conceded finally that a suitable wood provides the
very best and most efficient resonating apparatus.
Wood is not so elastic as metal, and therefore does
not re-sound so easily the higher and more feeble
partials of a compound string tone. But its flexi-
bility and capacity for being more profoundly af-
fected gives it a greater susceptibility to the im-
pressions of fundamental vibrations upon its sur-
face and their subsequent re-translation into audi-
ble sounds. Hence the wooden sound-board is a
necessity for a piano, where the compound tones
of strings are so rich in dissonant partials, any
undue prominence of which would render piano
tone-quality intolerably harsh and biting.
Long experiment has proved beyond doubt the
superior qualities of spruce for resonating pur-
poses. Both in America and Europe some kind
of spruce or fir has always been used. Exam-
ination of ancient key-board instruments shows
that the old masters had also discovered the same
secret by purely empirical methods, while the same
fact is noticeable in the manufacture of bowed in-
struments like the violin and the various members
of that family.
Unfortunately, however, flexibility and high sus-
ceptibility to vibratory impression cannot well be
found in the same material as is required to have
great resisting power against torsional and vertical
strain, with high natural tension. The spruce wood 1
is well suited for the reception and reproduction
of vibrations, since it is a fibrous wood, consist-
ing in its structure of long fibrous strips separated
by soft, resinous, sappy, material. But the very
softness which gives it this desirable susceptibility
to vibrational impression, also renders it incapable
of sustaining such impressions and reproducing
them with any strength. Rigidity of construction
and considerable resistant power of the material to
tension are needed. These requisites are obtained
through the well known process of ribbing, where-
by strips of the same material are glued across the
back of the spruce sheet. These ribs are slightly
curved on the surface which is to come into con-
tact with the main sheet, so that when fastened
down by gluing they draw up the sheet, as it were,
to themselves and impart to it a curvature similar
to that which was effected on their own surfaces.
By such curvature the surface of the sound-board
is rendered more rigid and a tension is imparted
to it which is highly desirable for the purposes out-
lined above.
(To be continued.)
An
Occasion
of Great
Import.
As these lines are being written, the member?
of the American Guild of Piano Timers are gath-
ering together in New York for their first anrma'
convention. A report of the opening proceedings
appears in another part of this paper, and will be
supplemented by a more detailed account next
week. My present purpose is to bespeak the best
wishes of all readers for the success of the Guild's
deliberations and for their achievement of useful
results from their important business.
Communications for the department should I.e
addressed to the Editor Technical Department.
The Music Trade Review.
PUSHING THE MASON & HAMLIN.
Cable Piano Co. Carrying on Live Campaign
jn Birmingham, Ala.
The Cable Piano Co., Birmingham, Ala., <>f
which B. li. Burton is the manager, have been
featuring the Mason & Hamlin piano in the strong-
est possible manner in their newspaper announce-
ments recently, dwelling particularly upon the high
favor in which that instrument is regarded by
many of the greatest American and foreign artists
and referring to a number of local musicians of
recognized ability who pin their faith to the Mason
& Hamlin. As a result of the campaign, it is
stated, the sales of Mason & Hamlin pianos in
Birmingham and vicinity have steadily increased in
volume even during the summer months.
BIG ORDER FOR HALLET & DAVIS CO.
Yeager
Piano Co. of Hartford, Conn., Place
Order for 350 Pianos.
The Hallet & Davis Piano Co., Boston, Mass..
through C. C. Conway, recently secured an order
from the Yeager Piano Co., Hartford, Conn., for
350 pianos, to be delivered before Dec. 15, 1010, at
regular intervals and in carload lots. This is the
largest single order ever placed by the Yeager
Piano Co.. who operate eleven branches in the
State of Connecticut; and the fact that the order
was placed with the noted Boston house may
be accepted as a high tribute to the product of that
Hammer Head
and
Butt Borer
Send for descriptive
catalog Frttt.
TUNERS SUPPLY CO.
Winter Hill District
BOSTON

Download Page 7: PDF File | Image

Download Page 8 PDF File | Image

Future scanning projects are planned by the International Arcade Museum Library (IAML).

Pro Tip: You can flip pages on the issue easily by using the left and right arrow keys on your keyboard.