Music Trade Review

Issue: 1910 Vol. 50 N. 24

Music Trade Review -- © mbsi.org, arcade-museum.com -- digitized with support from namm.org
THE
EDWARD
MU3IC TRADE
REVIEW
ILYMAW'BILLP
- Editor and^Proprietor
J. B. SP1LLANE, Managing Editor
Executive and Reportorlal Stall:
GBO. B. KELLHB,
W. H. DYKES,
R. W. SIMMONS,
L. E. BOWHRS,
B. BRITTAIN WILSON,
A. J. NICKLIN,
AUQOBT J. TIMPE.
CHICAGO OFFICE:
BOSTON OFFICE:
E. P. VAN HARLINGEN, 156 Wabash Ave.
G. W. HENDERSON, 180 Tremont St.
Room 806,
Room 18.
Telephone, Central 414.
Telephone, Oxford 2936-2.
PHILADELPHIA:
MINNEAPOLIS and ST. PAUL:
ST. LOUIS:
R. W. KAUFFMAN,
ADOLF EDSTEN,
SAN FRANCISCO:
CINCINNATI, O.:
BALTIMORE. MD.:
LONDON. ENGLAND:
CHAS. N. VAN BUREN.
S. II. GRAY, 88 First Street.
JACOB W. WALTERS.
A. ROBERT FRENCH.
60 Basinghall St., E. C.
W. LIONEL STURDY, Manager.
Published Every Saturday at 1 Madison Avenue, New York
Entered at the New York Post Office as Second Class Matter.
SUBSCRIPTION, (Including postage). United States and Mexico, $2.00 per year;
Canada, $3.50 ; all other countries, $4.00.
ADVERTISEMENTS, $2.00 per Inch, single column, per insertion. On quarterly or
yearly contracts a special discount is allowed. Advertising Pages, $60.00 ; opposite
reading matter, $75.00.
REMITTANCES, in other than currency forms, should be made payable to Edward
Lyman Bill.
^ n important feature of this publication is a complete sec-
tion devoted to the interests of music publishers and dealers.
Exposition Honors Won by The Review
Grand Prix
Paris Exposition, 1900
Silver Medal. Charleston Exposition, VM2
Diploma..Pan-American Exposition, 1901
Gold Medal. . .St. Louis Exposition, 1904
Gold Medal
Lewis-Clark Exposition, 1905.
LONG DISTANCE TELEPHONES-NUMBERS 4677 and 4678 GRAMERCY
Connecting all Departments.
Cable address: "Elblll, New York."
NEW YORK,
JUNE 11,
1910
REVIEW
it proposed to interfere with their plans regarding the advance of
freight and passenger rates.
W
E do not believe that the railroad chiefs will rush in with
cancellations of orders which have been placed for mate-
rials for road improvements.
The pressure is so great to-day on the American railroads by
reason of the growing needs of the vast population that they are
actually compelled to increase their facilities to keep pace with the
growing demands.
It would be simply suicidal on their part not to follow this
policy, and while they may threaten and bluster, yet as a matter of
fact they are not going to strike a vital blow at themselves.
That is not reasonable or rational.
The railroads are going to meet the necessary expansion of the
business interests and there are more crops and produce of all kinds
as well as manufactured goods to transport than ever before and
because of this vast increase it is not clear to a good many people
why it is necessary to raise the freight rates.
The railroads occupy a different relation to the people than
other corporations.
They are vital to the needs and necessities of millions of citi-
zens.
As time rolls on the relation between the public and the great
railroad companies will become more and more irritating until in
the end either the railroads will own the people or the people the
railroads and we are rather inclined to think that in the end the
ownership will be on the side of the populace.
The decreased number of idle cars reported recently indicates
a large volume of traffic, and bank clearings largely in excess of a
year ago tell the same story of sound monetary conditions. Good
crop prospects, improving foreign trade, and investors abroad buy-
ing our securities—all the basic elements of prosperity are at present
in evidence, and without doubt the railroad situation, which has
now been cleared by the action of President Taft, will not, for the
present at least, hold back business. The present irritation has
been reduced, but we shall have to stand an increase in the freight
rates in the near future.
T T NDOUBTEDLY this country will have a big World's Fair in
v_J 1915 to celebrate the opening of the Panama Canal.
EDITORIAL
Whether San Francisco or New Orleans will secure Govern-
ment aid in the furtherance of this enterprise is yet to be decided.
HE slump in stocks occasioned by the Government's attitude
Perhaps both cities may run shows of their own, but it is
towards the railroads has not had an enlivening effect upon
pretty certain that the American people will have another World's
trade. Neither has it helped out collections, and it only shows how
Fair to celebrate the completion of the big ditch which for centuries
keenly susceptible after all we are to depressing things.
has been the dream of man to accomplish.
We may proclaim loudly that we have reached the point where
The wedding of the Atlantic and Pacific will actually have
a panic is impossible, and yet when the first cloud appears on the taken place by that time, and the Straits of Panama will be ready
horizon numbers of people will rush to unload stocks with such
to carry the commerce of the world.
haste that it has a tendency to weaken the confidence of others in
Certainly that is an event worthy of a national celebration, and
securities of any kind, and as a result freedom of purchases becomes
it will have a far reaching effect upon the trade of the world.
seriously impaired.
The American flag has been practically wiped off the com-
This is the superficial side purely, and if stocks do go down a
mercial thoroughfares of the world, yet our coast carrying trade is
few points that does not affect in the slightest the real wealth of
enormous and without doubt the trade of the two coasts between
the country.
North and South America will be revolutionized.
Paper values may go tumbling hundreds of millions, but that
Freight rates, too, must be adjusted, and we can rest assured
does not mean that the real fundamentals have depreciated, but it that most of the pianos which are shipped to far Western points
does injure trade movements and curtails the volume of business
will be sent through the Straits of Panama rather than overland.
transacted throughout the country.
It will be a great triumph of American skill to have success-
There is no denying that fact for it is. apparent to all who fully completed this great engineering feat, but the commercial
give the subject even a cursory examination.
value of a World's Fair to the country is somewhat problematical.
Now, why is this?
So far as awards are concerned their value has greatly de-
Why should we tremble the moment there is a rush to unload
preciated.
stocks in Wall street?
They serve, however, to show that anyone receiving awards
The fundamentals of the country were never in better condition
from World's Fairs had sufficient business enterprise as well as
and in the agricultural sections there is little reason for complaint.
faith in their own products to make an exhibit to which the critical
Crop reports are excellent and business should move along
attenton of the world was drawn, but so far as the real value goes
smoothly.
it stands somewhat in the light of an artistic endorsement of a
It is said that the railroad corporations have cancelled a good
particular piano.
many contracts placed for railroad betterments and that they pro-
pose to limit their expenses to actual necessities.
HE great international fairs to-day do not have the depressing
Some of the railroad leaders threaten to reduce wages.
effect upon the cities where they are held that they did in
This, however, is viewed as a purely superficial statement rep-
former days.
resenting the wrath of the railroad men at the Government because
It took Chicago a long time to recover from the depression
T
T
\
Music Trade Review -- © mbsi.org, arcade-museum.com -- digitized with support from namm.org
THE
MUSIC TRADE
REVIEW
5
N
which immediately followed the Columbian Exposition, but St.
O matter how parliamentarians may differ as to the vote taken
Louis moved steadily on in its business development after the gates
at the piano dealers' Convention at Richmond, the fact ire-
of the Louisiana Purchase Exposition had closed.
mains that there is nothing on the records of the association to
The smaller fairs at Portland, Norfolk and Spokane have
show that it has adopted any of the rules by which legislative
had no depressing effect upon those cities.
organizations are governed.
Without doubt a World's Fair in New Orleans would be of
The fact stands out clear and distinct that every member knew
great advantage to-day to that city.
what he was voting for, and the vote discountenancing the use of
It would call the attention of the world to its wonderful possi-
certificates and coupons in piano selling was overwhelming.
bilities and presumably new capital in large sums would go into the
Three to one is a significant voting record and it does not
city for investment.
matter whether the votes were taken according to Cushing or
So far as San Francisco is concerned it would call the attention
Roberts, or according to any other manual which deliberative bodies
of the world to what has been accomplished by American skill and
have a right to adopt as governing rules.
> ]
spirit, undaunted by fire and earthquakes.
The vote taken showed an overwhelming sentiment against th£
The rebuilding of San Francisco at once constitutes a great
coupon-certificate-prize system of piano selling, and probably the
triumph to the unconquerable spirit of the men whose history has
men who will continue the use of this form of piano selling would
been linked with the marvelous development of the Pacfic Coast.
not give a rap how the association stood because they would refuse
CONDITIONS are steadily changing in the music trade and it
> does not take a close student to see how some manufacturers
are relying more and more upon their own branches to absorb their
entire factory output.
If this course is pursued in a large way it will in the end elimi-
nate the dealers who will have to become manufacturers or else be
snuffed out.
Now, why is this?
A manufacturer was asked by The Review to express his
opinion regarding the establishment of branches.
He replied he did not care to go into the matter exhaustively,
beyond making the statement that it was not his policy to establish
branches where he had dealers.
He did not hesitate to say that he would rather have dealers
represent him than to put in his own branches, but he did not pro-
pose to do practically no business in territory from which he figured
that he could get good returns.
Probably others have been influenced by exactly those same
motives, and because there is an unmistakable trend in the direc-
tion of making wasted territory live and profitable should cause
dealers to sit up 'and take notice.
Manufacturers are not going to see wasted territory all about
them; neither are they going to have certain dealers retain the
agency for their instruments and do nothing with them.
Then, too, there is a plain policy adopted by some dealers to
secure the agencies of leading pianos and hold them for purposes
of attraction only and not for sales.
In other words, they are used to attract piano purchasers to
the store while the "just-as-good" instruments are praised in the
strongest possible terms.
Why?
Simply because the "just-as-good" instrument perhaps bears
the dealer's own name and trade mark, which is purchased at a
very low price and affords him frequently an abnormal or dis-
honest profit, whereas the high grade instruments give him only
a legitimate profit.
It is the lure of the gold which causes this, but it is quite time
that some dealers considered these matters seriously.
Manufacturers will not sit calmly by and see their instruments
worked on the stool pigeon basis.
Certain territory must pay them reasonably well, else why
should they not establish their own branches?
Then, there is the reverse side to the medal.
There are some manufacturers who are also won over by the
lure of gold and they establish branches directly under the noses
of some dealers whom they undersell and through their adver-
tisements they emphasize the fact that by buying from the factory
direct they can save the dealers' profit.
Now, that kind of a policy in the end can have but one result.
It will compel the manufacturer who adopts such policies to
market his entire output, through his own branches, because these
things percolate swiftly through trade channels, and dealers will
not be inclined to push the product of manufacturers who are using
their "factory-to-fireside" arguments to undersell them
That's not human nature and we could hardly expect that such
a policy would be enthusiastically applauded by dealers throughout
the country.
C
to be governed by rules which the association might put forth.
It cannot be denied, however, that the Dealers' National Asso-
ciation has gone on record as officially condemning the certificate
form of piano selling and to deny that is quibbling of the smallest
order.
It beats peanut politics.
IN LIGHTER VEIN
The famous Doctor Johnson was discovered one day, by Mrs. Johnson,
kissing one of her serving-maids. "Why, Doctor Johnson," said the wife,
"I am surprised." "No," said the recreant husband, "that is not exactly
right, dear. / am surprised; you are astonished!"
• '
"Phwere hov yez been this avenin?" asked O'Tunder of O'Toolei
"Sure, I've been playin' Bridget whist." "Bridget whist? An' how dd
yez play thot?" "I sit in the kitchen wid Bridget an' ate pie an' cake an'
chicken, an' whin Bridget hears th' missus comin' she says 'Whist!' an' I
hide in th' panthry."
1
EDITORIAL WORK.—Former Employer—And so you are a newsi
paper man now, Thompson?
*
Thompson—Yes, sir; I'm the editor of the job department.
j |t
Former Employer—Editor of the job department?
< :
Thompson—Yes, sir; I carries in coal and scrubs the floor and
cleans the windows and all such editin' as that, sir.—London Graphic.
ARTISTS' JEALOUSY.—First Hurdygurdyist—Lumme, 'Orace, don't
it make yer heart bleed to hear of that Paddywisky chap gettin' thahsands
o' pahnds fer thumpin' o' his pianner?
'
Second—Not 'arf it don't. An' 'e don't 'ave ter bloomin' well lug his
pianner abaht wiv 'im neither!—London Opinion.
A small boy who had recently passed his fifth birthday was riding
in a suburban car with his mother when they were asked the customary;
question, "How old is the boy?" After being told the correct age, which
did not require a fare, the conductor passed on to the next person. The
boy sat quite still as if pondering over some question and then, conclud-
ing that full information had not been given, called loudly to the con-
ductor, then at the other end of the car: "And mother's thirty-one!"
,
MUTUAL COMPLIMENTS.—At a certain church it is the pleasing
custom at a marriage for the clergyman to kiss the bride after the cere-l
mony. A young lady who was about to be married in the church did not
relish the prospect and instructed her prospective husband when making
arrangements to tell the clergyman that she did not wish him to kiss her.
The bridegroom did as directed.
"Well, George," said the young lady when he appeared, "did you tell
the clergyman that I did not wish him to kiss me?"
"Oh, yes."
"And what did he say?"
"He said that in that case he would charge only half the usual fee."
—Tit-Bits.
RESOURCEFUL.—The teacher had. called upon Freddy to tell the
.'lass a story in fifty words. Accordingly, Freddy rose and began as
follows: "I have a little sister. Her name is May. May likes pussies and
dollies. One day May saw a pussy in our garden and she said: 'Here,
pussy, pussy, pussy! Here, pussy, pussy, pussy! Here, pussy, pussy;
pussy, pussy!' "
And Freddy sat down with much satisfaction. There was a moment's
silence, and then a voice (evidently that of the class mathematician)
called out from a rear corner of the room, "That's only thirty-eight
words."
i
Up stood Freddy again, unperturbed, and continued: "Here,
^
pussy, pussy! Here, pussy, pussy, pussy! Here, pussy, pussy,
and then he sat down.—Harper's Weekly,
• —

Download Page 4: PDF File | Image

Download Page 5 PDF File | Image

Future scanning projects are planned by the International Arcade Museum Library (IAML).

Pro Tip: You can flip pages on the issue easily by using the left and right arrow keys on your keyboard.