Music Trade Review

Issue: 1908 Vol. 46 N. 18

Music Trade Review -- © mbsi.org, arcade-museum.com -- digitized with support from namm.org
THE
MUSIC TRADE
REVIEW
EDWARD LYMAN BILL - Editor and Proprietor
J. B. SPILLANE, Managing Editor
Executive and Reportoiial Staff:
W. II. DYKES,
F.H.THOMPSON,
J. HAYDEN CLAHENPON,
B. BRITTAIN WILSON,
I,. J. CHAMBERLIN,
A. J. NICKLIN.
OEO. R. KELLER,
L. E. BOWERS,
CHICAGO OFFICE:
BOSTON OFFICE:
ERNEST L. WAITT, 100 Boylston St.
PHILADELPHIA:
E. P. VAN HARLINGEN, 195 197 Wabash Ave.
TELEPHONES : Central 414 ; Automatic 8t>43.
MINNEAPOLIS and ST. PAUL:
ST. LOUIS:
It. W. KAUFFMAN.
ADOLF EUSTEN.
CHAS. N. VAN BUREN.
SAN FRANCISCO: S. H. GRAY, 2407 Sacramento St.
CINCINNATI. O.: BERNAKD C. BOWEN.
BALTIMORE, MD.: A. ROBERT FRENCH.
LONDON, ENGLAND: 69 Basinghall St., E. C. W. LIONEL STURDY, Manager.
Published Every Saturday at 1 Madison Avenue, New York
Entered at the New York Post Office as Second Class Matter.
SUBSCRIPTION, (Including postage), United States and Mexico, $2.00 per year;
Canada. $:i.">o : all other countries, $4.00.
ADVERTISEMENTS. $2,00 per Inch, single column, per Insertion. On quarterly or
yearly contracts a special discount Is allowed. Advertising Pages, $60.00 ; opposite
reading matter. $75.00.
REMITTANCES. In other than currency form, should be made payable to Edward
Lyman Bill.
Music Publishers*
An interesting feature of this publication Is a special depart-
Department ^ V ment devoted exclusively to the world of music publishing.
Exposition Honors Won by The Review
Orand l'rix
Paris Exposition, 1900 Silver Medal.Charleston Exposition, 1902
Diploma.Pan-American Exposition, 1901 Gold Medal. ...St. Louis Exposition, 1904
Gold Medal. . . .Lewis-Clark Exposition, 1905.
LONG DISTANCE TELEPHONES-NUMBERS 4677 and 4678 GRAMERCY
Connecting all Departments.
Cable a d d r e s s : "Elbill, N e w York."
NEW
YORK, MAY
2 , 1908
EDITORIAL
T
HE surprising success which has attended recent bond dealings
in this city proves conclusively that there is ample money
seeking profitable investment. There is an improved tone in the
bond market emphasized by the heavy over-subscription to the
Pennsylvania Railroad loan. Quieter conditions in business result
in one way—in larger accumulation of funds or cheap money.
This condition, too, presages healthful industrial recovery. There
is no mistaking the fact that general business conditions are im-
proving. Of course, pianos and musical merchandise are not mov-
ing quite as rapidly as most of us desire, nor do we believe that
there will be a pronounced activity until the fall. Merchants every-
where and of every class are now considering the problem, "how
long is the depression going to last?" "When will we recover
from the effects of the panic?" "How slow will the wheels turn—
how will readjustments affect my particular business?" and conse-
quently are buying to meet present requirements only. When we
speak of panic in the ordinary use of the word we mean the depres-
sion or economic crisis which is sure to follow. Now this crisis
may be turned to a man's advantage if he understands and will
apply the fundamental laws of business and credit to his own in-
terests. Credit and money which are directly and summarily
affected by the panic do not of themselves bring a man success or
failure. They are useful mediums, as they help and support trade,
but credit is the force on which the business of the world is done.
Trade is the exchange of one surplus for another. It is supplying
the needs of one man with the overplus of another. It is an ex-
change for mutual good. The keynote of trade then is service.
REVIEW
volume of business, lower prices and curtailments of loans, must
curtail their accommodations. The merchant and manufacturer will •
be able to borrow for their legitimate needs, but it is well for them
to understand that a new law over which the banker has no control
will force the latter to curtail lines for new enterprises. The mer-
chant must shape his business to meet these new conditions of the
commercial and financial world.
In a time of contraction the first thing to do is to trim the
sails to meet the storm, let it be light or heavy. To do this the indi-
vidual must get ready to be reasonably independent of credit asking.
And under the present conditions can anyone expect the same ac-
commodations in the near future which he had in the past? Re-
adjustment means bringing living down to a basis of rational,
wholesome living. To meet this condition requires study on the
part of business men who deal with the masses. Success in spite of
panic comes to him who makes service his motto through all the
deviations of his business.
H P HERE is really no need for a man to get pessimistic in times
J.
like the present. There is always business to be secured if
we go at it right and there is more to business than the mere ac-
cumulation of dollars. Commerce is a great civilizer and the man
who has performed his task well in trade has helped humanity.
Dollars merely measure activity and good work for self and others.
Therefore, it is best for men to study the situation. To serve is to
help and the man serves best who studies the interests closely of
those with whom he comes in contact. There are some who never
look on the philosophic side of business. If they did they would
understand more. Industrial crises come and men in their
eagerness to get rich and enjoy wealth and power overstrain the
capacity of credit to serve and over expand the possibilities of com-
merce. The present condition is one which is the result of our
own over living and over spending. The consumer is the gauge
on the business of the world. When everything is flush all along
the line men are prone to have the best. When wages and profits
are reduced they may buy the same at a lower level and it is in-
evitable that they must select the needful and pass by the luxuries.
Here is the safety of those who are in ordinary lines of business
to-day.
W
E have accustomed ourselves to an expansive condition and
so we are prone to find fault with a trade reduction, but we
still have to endure these conditions whether we like them or not.
Business cannot go on at all times expanding. If it did even in an
unbroken way for a number of years and prices kept going steadily
up, what a fall there would be when the parting suddenly came.
There must be periods of depression and expansion and contraction
will come automatically, and no matter how carefully we may plan
we cannot avoid meeting them. They teach man after all, with all
his boasted power, that he can't control even temporary matters.
They teach us, too, to be more careful. A characteristic of the
present condition is the number of small orders placed. This indi-
cates a disposition on the part of merchants to keep stock down and
to purchase very guardedly for actual needs. While on general
principles this may seem the wisest policy, yet it entails necessarily
a good deal of expense upon the piano manufacturers who are com-
pelled to carry a complete stock on hand subject to the varying
whims of the trade. It seems to be up to the manufacturer to bear
the heavy burden in these times, and under present conditions there
seems to be no way out of it.
S
OME men are in the habit of saying that they do not buy ad-
vertised products because they do not care to pay for the
advertising. We have heard some piano salesmen state that they
sold certain instruments cheap owing to the fact that there were no
large advertising charges included in the price of the pianos. These
salesmen argued that because a piano manufacturer is not a large ad-
E do business not wholly with money, and it may be said now
vertiser, for that reason he can sell cheap. Some time ago Franklin
that when banks have gotten back to their normal condition
Hobbs, a well-known advertising expert, began an investigation, in
it will be no more a question of money that will affect trade. It will
which he made tests of various advertised and unadvertised goods.
be a question of credit. It is to this, through the banks that we are Full and complete comparisons were made of their respective quali-
to look for our mainstay. Credit makes the wheels turn. It fur- ties. This man priced goods and bought goods in stores which
nishes the sinews for new enterprises and carries us over hard times.
did not advertise and in stores which did advertise and compared
Credit will be a somewhat diminished quantity for the present year.
prices and qualities, and after all this he stated: If asked the
But this is one of the things we cannot control, since the banks
question, who pays for the advertising. I would answer the question
losing their volume of deposit—because of the reduction in the in a word. But as the cost of advertising is distributed among so
W
Music Trade Review -- © mbsi.org, arcade-museum.com -- digitized with support from namm.org
THE
MUSIC TRADE
many people I must needs go into detail, but when you buy an ad-
vertised article you do not pay for the advertising. When you buy
an advertised ham you do not pay for the advertising. When you
travel on a railroad you do not pay for the advertising of that rail-
road. * When you buy a pair of shoes you do not pay for the ad-
vertising. This applies to every conceivable article which enters
into the commerce of the world. Who pays for the advertising?
Advertising is an economy and not an expense.
I
N order to make this clear, Mr. Hobbs says let us suppose, for
example, that a clothing merchant on one corner does not
advertise, but he pays $100 per month rent, employs four clerks at
$75 per month each—pays $50 per month for his light, and $100 a
month for incidental expenses, bookkeeping, etc. On this total
expense of $550 per month he sells four suits of clothes per day at
a gross profit of $7.50 per suit. This business for twenty-five days
a month brings in a total gross profit of $750, and after deducting
his expenses of $550 leaves a margin of $200 per month as the
dealer's remuneration for his personal services and for interest on
his investment.
Another merchant on the next corner pays the same rent, a
trifle more for clerk hire, a trifle more for light and a trifle more
for general expenses, bookkeeping, etc., and finds that his total
expense for the month is $600-—but this merchant spends $500 a
month in advertising. Somebody pays that. Is it the man who
buys the suit of clothes? No. The customer has nothing to do
with it, and pays no part of it either directly or indirectly. These
two merchants handle the same grades of clothing and sell the same
goods at the same price. At the end of the month the advertising
merchant finds that he has sold eight suits of clothes per day—twice
as many as the merchant who does not advertise—and, making the
same profit on each suit, he finds he has a profit for the month of
$1,500. He deducts his expenses of $600, his advertising of $500,
and finds he has $400 left as remuneration for his own services and
interest on his investment. Who paid for the $500 worth of ad-
vertising? Well, in this case the owner of the building paid part of
it, because he received no more rent from the advertising mer-
chant who sold eight suits per day than he did from the merchant
who did not advertise and sold only four suits per day. That ac-
counts for $100 of the $500 which is paid by the landlord—and then
the electric light company paid $45 of it, because the light bill of
the non-advertising merchant was $50 per month, and of the ad-
vertising merchant was $55 per month, instead of being doubled
at the same time he doubled his sales. So the electric light com-
pany and the landlord paid part of it. Then the four salesmen
paid the other portion, and were glad to pay it. They had once
worked for a non-advertising merchant at $75 per month, and they
are now working for the advertising merchant at an advance of
10 per cent, in salary. They are now getting $82.50 per month
each, and each man sells two suits of clothes per day, while previ-
ously they received only $75 per month and sold an average of one
suit per day. So these four salesmen pay $270 of the advertising
bill, and by so doing gain an increase in salary of 10 per cenc. And
then the bookkeeper's salary was increased 15 per cent, and the
general expense increased 15 per cent., while the business doubled
so that an economy of $85 per month was effected. This amount
went toward the advertising fund of $500 per month.
N
OW there is a comparison of your advertising merchant and
your non-advertising merchant in the same business on the
same street, selling the same grade of goods and employing the
same grade of help. Two men, we will say, of equal ability—one
of them believing that if he advertises he must increase the price
of his goods, and the other knowing that the mere fact that he does
advertise will enable him to sell more goods for the same price, or
possibly at a less price.
Who pays for the advertising?
Get this point, then, fixed clearly in your mind. Advertising
is an economic saving and not an extra expense.
Who pays for advertising? The advertising bills are liqui-
dated by the landlord, the light company, the clerks and even by
the sprinkling wagon that passes before the front of the store.
Being a manufacturer, you say that this does not apply to
your business particularly, and fits only the retail business. This
applies to the manufacturer and the jobber, to the retailer, and to
REVIEW
the mail order house. The manufacturer has a certain fixed over-
head expense which will not increase more than 10 per cent, with
the doubling of his output. I know factories that are closed from
one to three months each year, the major part of the overhead ex-
penses continuing while no goods are being made. Advertising
would keep these factories open twelve months in the year, would
enable the manufacturer to work a night shift in the same building
with the same machinery, thus materially decreasing the cost of
his product and enable him to sell his product more profitably and
at a less price.
Who pays for the advertising ?
The man who doesn't advertise.
IN LIGHTER VEIN
Do not waste valuable time in waiting for big things to roll along
your way.
Do you know that a little tact and a little talk will frequently sell
a customer more than he came in to buy?
The salesman who lies about the quality of the goods he sells will
soon find himself doubted when he tells the truth.
Some men are like the parrot that talked too blamed much.
tell tales out of school and they tell tales in school.
They
When business is dull and customers are few it is hardly the time
to sit down and dream. There is no money In that.
We have never known a man to make a success out of a job that he
persisted in considering only as a "filler" until he got something else.
Hogan—Hov ye hear-rd me daughter Mona sing lately?
First—Both lately an' earlier, behad! 'Tls th' fine Insthrumlnthal
music she do make.
Hogan—Ye ignoramus. Shure, singin' ain't insthruminthal music!
Dugan—Begorry, thin, Keegan towld me it wuz insthruminthal in
causin 1 him t' move two blocks away frum yer house.
The boy of the family, the smart little son of an editor, had just
passed his ninth birthday, and delighted in stirring things up whenever
he found a chance. On his way to school one day he popped into a hard-
ware store.
"Say, mister," he called out. "do you keep knives?"
"Oh, yes," replied the storekeeper, "we've kept them for years."
"Well," returned the boy, starting for the door, "just advertise, and
then you won't keep them so long."
Young Hankinson (making a call)—You have had that parrot a long
time, Miss Laura.
Miss Laura—Yes, we have had him several years.
Young Hankinson—Quite intelligent, is he not?
Miss Laura-i—Very. He can imitate almost anything.
Young Hankinson—They have a remarkably clever parrot over at the
Casterlins', Miss Laura. It can imitate the sound of a kiss to perfection.
Is that among the accomplishments of our feathered friend here in the
corner?
Miss Laura (indignantly)—No, sir. He does not attempt an imitation
of a sound he is not accustomed to hear, Mr. Hankinson. Of that I can
assure you.
The Parrot—Wait, George, dear, til] I take this bird out of the room.
A BUDDING NAPOLEON.—Youthful Capitalist (aged seven) : "Doing
any good?"
His Partner (aged eight): "Naw; I don't seem t* be able t' place
dls lemminade."
"Jimmy Jones selling any pop?"
"He's gettin' rich—took In fifty cents since noon."
"What's our assets?"
"Chair, table an' tumbler, belongin' t' your maw; bucket an' dipper,
de property of my maw; two gallons of sweetened water an' one lemon,
wld de groceryman makin' bad talk about de fifteen cents we owe him—
I tells yer, we're on de ragged edge of bust."
"Any outstanding contracts?"
"Me brudder said he'd buy a drink t-morrer if de Yaller Legs win."
"Good! I'll tell you what we'll do. We'll form a new company, take
over this stand, merge Jimmy's, get out a prospectus and circulate it all
around de street, issue bonds on the equipment, capitalize the indebted-
ness, issue $1 stock, half-preferred, and
"
"Den what?"
"Sell the stock to Jimmy."
"Schucks! Jimmy ain't such a darn fool as to bite at dat kind er
bait."
"Ain't he? You just watch me hypnotize him!"
And It was even so, and the next day Jimmy woke up. They all do.

Download Page 4: PDF File | Image

Download Page 5 PDF File | Image

Future scanning projects are planned by the International Arcade Museum Library (IAML).

Pro Tip: You can flip pages on the issue easily by using the left and right arrow keys on your keyboard.