Music Trade Review

Issue: 1908 Vol. 46 N. 13

Music Trade Review -- © mbsi.org, arcade-museum.com -- digitized with support from namm.org
THE: MUSIC TRADE
REVIEW
ITHE
fflJJIC Tfy\DE
EDWARD LYMAN BILL - Editor and Proprietor
J. B. SPILLANE, Managing Editor
Executive and Reportorial Stall:
GEO. I?. Kiu.i.ioit,
L. E. r.(iwi:i;s,
\V. II. DVKKS,
F. II. THOMPSON,
J. HAYDEN CLARENDON,
I".. UUITTAIN WILSON,
L. J. CHAMKEKMN,
A. J. NICKLIN.
CHICAGO OFFICE:
E. P. VAN HARI.INGEN, 195-197 Wabash Ave.
TKLEI'HONES : Central 414 ; Automatic 8643.
MINNEAPOLIS and ST. PAUL:
ST. LOUIS:
BOSTON OFFICE:
KRNKST L. WAI-IT, 10(1 Itoylstou St.
PHILADELPHIA:
K. \V. KAUFFMAN.
Anoi.i' FASTEN.
CINCINNATI.©.: NINA PUGH-SMITH.
BALTIMORE, MD.: A. ROBERT FRENCH.
W. LIONEL STURDY, Manager.
Published Every Saturday at 1 Madison Avenue, New York
Entered at the New York Post Office as Second Class Matter.
SUBSCRIPTION, (including postage), United States and Mexico, $2.00 per year;
Canada, $3.5(>; all other countries, $4.00.
ADVERTISEMENTS. ?2.00 per inch, single column, per Insertion. On quarterly or
yearly contracts a special discount is allowed. Advertising Pages, $60.00; opposite
reading matter, $75.00.
REMITTANCES, in other than currency form, should be made payable to Edward
Lyman Hill.
Music Publishers'
An Interesting feature of this publication is a special depart-
Department *• y* rnent devoted exclusively to the world of music publishing.
Exposition Honors Won by The Review
Grand Prix
Paris Exposition, 1900 Silver Medal.Charleston Exposition, 1902
Diploma.Pan-American Exposition, 1901
Gold Medal. ...St. Louis Exposition, 1904
Gold Medal. . . .Lewis-Clark Exposition, 1905.
LONG DISTANCE TELEPHONES-NUMBERS 4677 and 4678 GRAMERCY
Connecting a l l Departments.
Cable address: "Elbill, New York."
NEW
YORK,
P
IANO business ought to be goo'd in Arkansas, for something
like two and a quarter million dollars will shortly come into
the hands of cotton raisers in that State. By a deal recently put
through, this sum will be loaned to farmers in that State through a
Memphis bank, and f>o,ooo bales of cotton now in storage will pass
into the hands of spinners in this country and abroad. The farm-
ers, through their Union, negotiated direct with the banks, with a
view to 1 the elimination of the middle-man, and the Memphis insti-
tution concluded that a loan at the rate of yy 2 to 8 cents per pound
was a by no means unfavorable proposition, seeing that the market
price of the staple is over 11J/2 cents. This arrangement should
prove eminently satisfactory to all concerned, including the retail
merchants of Arkansas, who will doubtless reap their share of the
benefit. Col. Hollenberg and the other good people can sit up and
take notice—and get busy.
CHAS. N. VAN BUKEN.
SAN FRANCISCO: S. II. GRAY, 2407 Sacramento St.
LONDON. ENGLAND : 69 Bastnghall St., E. C.
REVIEW
MARCH
28, 1 9 0 8
P
ROFIT sharing or the distribution among employes at fixed
periods of a fund set apart for that purpose—this amount
based upon the results achieved by the concern—is always an in-
teresting topic. Profit sharing is a move which makes for increased
interest and enthusiasm on the part of the help and has been
adopted by a number of manufacturing and retail concerns in
various sections of the country. Different methods are used by
different concerns and the problem of profit sharing with employes
is one which deserves careful thought. No doubt the profit sharing
plan helps all to watch for the best interests of the firm and try to
stop waste and increase the business, since they know if the busi-
ness is profitable they will have a share in it above their salaries.
The disadvantage comes in when for some reason the profits fall
off and then there is likely to be dissatisfaction because the divi-
dends have decreased. If there is an actual loss the employes will
not share in that, but, of course, they will have no dividends.
I
T has always seemed to us that while profit sharing plans in
theory were splendid, that in actual practice they have not
worked out in as satisfactory a manner as the employers have de-
EDITORIAL
sired. When there is dull business a godd deal of dissatisfaction is
evidenced because the annual profits are not forthcoming and em-
ployes do not always understand the true reasons why their divi-
HEERING spring weather will soon be here. Nature will
dends stop. One thing is certain, the man who pays his men as
brighten in gala garments as always in the spring, and there
well as the business can afford is discharging all of his duties to
is no reason why piano merchants should not rejuvenate their
his force at that time. The workmen over the country have very
establishments so that they, too, may present an attractive appear-
frequently resented any attempt on the part of their employers to
ance. Fresh paint will help out store fronts to an amazing degree
better their condition as being paternalism. Some employers who
and show windows can be made particularly attractive so that
have worked out very elaborate theories have been disappointed in
passers-by will be won over to the point of entering the establish-
the apparent lack of appreciation made manifest later an by their
ment. A cheery atmosphere is one of the helpful forces to a
men. Paternalism in any form is resented by the American people
business.
and the man who pays as he goes is not piling up future trouble
which may come through over-elaborate profit sharing plans.
URING the past week trade has shown a material improve-
ment and there is no mistaking the fact that we are, slowly
HE newspaper business, whether in general or special lines,
perhaps, but nevertheless steadily, emerging from the depression
cannot be learned in a day or a year, although there are some
into which we were plunged a few months ago. There is no
persons
who feel if they have published one issue of a periodical
remarkable increase in trade, but there is an improvement, and in
that
they
know all about it. The mere fact that a man is the editor
some sections of the country the betterment is emphasized quite
of
a
trade
paper does not give him license to publish anything he
strongly. There are certain sections of the country where business
pleases.
He
soon finds out, if he is intelligent and ready to learn,
has taken on quite an accelerated pace during the past fortnight.
that
there
are
some kinds of news that he must not print, even
Our records indicate a general betterment in most of the cities.
though
its
publication
might increase the temporary interest in his
Some dealers have sent in rush orders and others have ordered car-
journal.
He
must
remember
that he is in a certain sense the
load lots. It seemed for a while as if we had gotten entirely out
of the carload habit, but it is now being taken up again and pre- guardian of the interests of the trade which his paper is supposed
to represent. The trade editor who would make a permanent suc-
sumably the practice will grow with the advance of the season.
cess must therefore present to his readers news that is clean, whole-
some, educational, instructive and timely, but there is another
N the minds of many business men there is a fixed belief that
essential which ought not to be overlooked, and that is the moral
financial conditions will improve immediately upon the pass-
obligations resting upon a newspaper—to tell the truth impartially
age of the Aldrich bill at Washington. This bill has been dragging
its weary way through Congress for some time, and it now looks as and fearlessly. This does not imply that all news should be printed
no matter what results may follow, for there is not an editor in
if it would be adopted in a modified form and become a law ere
long. There is a widespread belief that a necessity exists for the this country who has not at one time or another suppressed the
publication of a story which, although true as to facts, might ruin
passing of some kind of a currency bill in order to relieve finances
the reputation of some or destroy the business moves of others if
should there be a recurrence of the conditions which existed
printed.
last fall. That a general desire exists for some sort of a remedial
legislation there can be no question, and if the amended bill receives
the sanction of Congress there is no doubt but that it will consid-
UT what shall we say of the editor who, because of malice or
erably facilitate the restoration of confidence, and help to bring
in order td get even, or through blackmailing proclivities,
about a better condition in the financial world.
deliberately attacks the reputation of reputable, honest, straight-
C
D
T
I
B
Music Trade Review -- © mbsi.org, arcade-museum.com -- digitized with support from namm.org
THE MUSIC TRADE
forward men and corporations? Such men are unworthy to bear
the title of journalists. They are using an honorable title as a mask
when wielding the bludgeon of the thug. It is, however, pleasing
to say that blackguard journalism does not exist in any industry
save in isolated cases, but unfortunately the last vestige is not
entirely swept out of music trade journalism, although it is known
that the kind of hold-up metho'ds no longer obtain to any great
degree. But it should be wholly extinguished, and it can be if
right methods are adopted. During the past few months there has
been a fixed purpose on the part of the chief exponent of black-
guardly music trade journalism to attack certain leading houses in
this industry. Carefully worded phrases, innuendos and cunningly
concocted slurs have been arranged in a manner with the hope of
producing an absolute surrender on the part of those who have
been attacked. However, there has been no surrender, nor will
there be, and the most amazing part of this whole proposition is that
any business firm should directly furnish a support to such a black-
guard by placing patronage in his paper, and without their
support he could not exist. It is inconceivable that business men
in 1908 should tolerate the presence of a miscreant who has exuded
a poison more deadly than that of the upas tree for more than a
quarter of a century. The only way to treat a man who adopts
blackmailing methods is to kick him out of business offices. Throw
out the men who represent him, because they are in sympathy with
his methods, else they would resign. Withdraw patronage from
them. Then they will come around like whining curs and will be
ready to grovel in the dust before their superiors.
HE demand for pianos in grand form is steadily increasing and
X
piano producing institutions which have made a specialty of
grands have been well rewarded in their efforts along the lines of
grand expansion. Take the house of Chickering for instance. We
all recall what a tremendous success was won by the Chickering
Quarter grand almost immediately upon its introduction to the
trade. Its graceful lines won applause from critics and this was
only the inceptive of a new grand era for the Chickering institution.
Then even a smaller grand was produced, so that every grand type
from that colloquially termed "infant grand" straight up to the most
imposing grand pianos created was included in the Chickering line.
In this connection it is well to state that before a Chickering grand
piano is ever put forth for trade criticism it has first undergone
the most severe tests in the experimental rooms of the factory.
Because these severe tests are applied and because experiments
which make for piano betterment never cease within the walls of
the Chickering factory, is one of the reasons why Chickering
grands have won such a universal praise. When the grand product
•.erf a piano concern exceeds that of its upright in annual output it
surely must be said that it has reached success in the'development
of grand pianos. And while they have been placing emphasis upon
grands the forces directing the Chickering institution have not
halted in their endeavors to improve their upright creations wher-
ever possible. Some of the most recent styles of Chickering uprights
have been mdst warmly received by trade critics.
D
V
URING the past few years the standard of commercial ad-
vertising has been raised to a remarkable degree. There
was a time when the average advertiser was satisfied with the work
of some amateur artist whose efforts he managed to pick up at a
nominal price. To-day, however, there are retail houses whose art
censorship compares favorably with that exercised by high-class
magazines. Some of our largest department stores have a corps
of experts and as a result their advertising always appears in an
attractive form. Of course it would not pay manufacturers in a
special industry to have a staff of advertising experts unless the
business was a very large one; yet the fact to be borne in mind at
all times is that the more artistic the advertising the more attention
it attracts, if placed in the proper mediums. There are plenty of
advertising experts who can be employed at nominal figures and
manufacturers and merchants should see to it that no sloppy adver-
tising of pianos or musical instruments is put forth. Good art in
advertising pays. This has been proven beyond the slightest shadow
of doubt and it should be the aim of every advertising man in the
music trade to use only illustrations that will reflect the good taste
and refinement he naturally desires to have identified with a.
product.
, • .. •
-
REVIEW
IN LIGHTER VEIN
No man who has borrowed from his employer's money drawer ever
paid up in full.
Fortune is not likely to bother the man who isn't ready to seize
the opportunity when it presents itself.
Tardiness may do in society, but it don't fit in business. Be prompt
and above all be prompt in the morning.
Politeness should not begin with the customer who spends a dollar
cr $5, but with anyone who enters the door of the store.
To unload a poor piano upon a confiding customer who desires a
good piano is a crime. To brag about it afterwards is adding to crime.
Bluff may be popular and successful as a means of winning at poker,
but as a business making quality it doesn't stand particularly well.
Don't go around with a chip on your shoulder. The man who is per-
petually looking for trouble generally is successful in finding what he
is seeking.
There is a powerful lot of difference between sticking to a thing
until you succeed and being so pigheaded that you will never admit that
you are wrong and change before it is too late.
Contentment is a good thing, but sometimes it's too much of a good
thing. It does not pay the business man to be contented because that
after a while may lead to a form of trade degeneracy.
"Are you guilty or not guilty?" asked the magistrate of the man
accused of theft.
"What's the use o' me sayin' 'not guilty?' I said that last time an' you
wouldn't b'lieve me."
Miss Scraper.—Did you see that old man crying while I was playing
my sonata?
Friend—Yes. He said your playing reminded him of old happy days.
Miss Scraper—'What was he, a violinist?
Friend—No; he was a piano tuner.
A BARGAIN.—"What!" exclaimed the husband. "You drew your
savings from the bank, went to a broker's office, and bought Z., X. and Y.
stock at 14, when it has been dropping like a rock?"
"But, my dear," argued the wife. "It was such a bargain. Why,
during the short time I was in the office I saw the man mark it down
to 14 from 45!"
POLITICAL ECONOMY.—"My choice of candidates for next year,"
said the copy reader, "is Taft, Root, Shaw or Knox. I don't care which
they nominate, but I want one of the four."
"Why?" demanded the foreman of the proof-room.
"Because," thundered the copy reader, "I can work one of those names
into a headline a blamed sight easier than 'Fairbanks' or 'Hughes!'"
ABOUT TIME.—At last the drammer recognizes the importance of
the toiler, as witness the following:
"Nellie, the Beautiful Cloak Model."
"Edna, the Pretty Typewriter."
"Bertha, the Poor Sewing Machine Girl."
"Elaine, the Elegant Cook Lady."
Others in preparation.
Did you ever notice how a piper prances up and down as he pipes?
He never sits, he never stands still, but up and down, round and round,
to and fro, he struts continually. A little boy, listening to the weird skirl
of the bagpipes of a street performer, once said to his father: "Father,
why does the piper keep on the move all the time he plays?" "I can't
say, my boy," the father answered, "unless it is to prevent anyone getting
the range with a cobblestone."
ACTING THE PART.—The curtain had just gone down on the second
act, leaving the heroine in the villain's clutches. Up in the balcony a
sentimental woman burst into tears.
"Don't cry, dear," said her husband. "Remember, it's only a play.
Act like a man!"
"Very well, John," said the lady, smiling through her tears. "You'll
excuse me for a moment, won't you? I must run out and send a telegram."
WANTED IT SUPPRESSED.—"John," said Mrs. Lighthead to her
husband as that gentleman settled down to his evening meal, "I have
been corresponding with authorities on the subject, and I find I am
descended from some of the oldest families in the country."
"What good is that going to do us?" asked the piano dealer en-
quiringly.
"Why, I think it is perfectly lovely to be well connected!"
"Maybe it is, but don't tell the grocer. He is charging us enough
for everything as it is."

Download Page 4: PDF File | Image

Download Page 5 PDF File | Image

Future scanning projects are planned by the International Arcade Museum Library (IAML).

Pro Tip: You can flip pages on the issue easily by using the left and right arrow keys on your keyboard.