Music Trade Review

Issue: 1907 Vol. 44 N. 23

Music Trade Review -- © mbsi.org, arcade-museum.com -- digitized with support from namm.org
THE
WYttW
J1UJIC TIRADE
V O L . X L I V . No. 2 3 .
PabKshed Every Saturday by Edward Lyman BUI at 1 Madison Avc, New York, Jane 8, 1907
GERMAN TARIFF AGREEMENT.
The President Puts It Into Effect on July 1—Reductions of Duties on American Goods Placed at
$6,664,000 a Year, While Reductions in Favor of German Goods Amount to Only $208,168
Yearly—Some Items Bearing or Musical Instruments—Interesting Definition of "Market
Value" by the Secretary of the Treasury Will Interest Our "Small Goods" Friends.
(Special to The Review.)
Washington, D. C, June 1, 1907.
The president this afternoon issued his procla-
mation putting into effect on July 1 next the new
commercial agreement between the United States
and Germany. The agreement gives Germany the
advantages of section 3 of the Dingley tariff law,
in return for which the United States gets the
benefit of most of the present German conven-
tional rates.
In a statement issued by the State Department
concerning the agreement is a long list of articles
affected by the agreement. The statement then
continues:
"According to official German statistics, the
average annual value of imports of American
goods into Germany in the period 1903 to 1905,
inclusive, was $227,647,000, of which, it has been
computed, only 3.31 per cent, would be obliged,
under the new agreement, to pay the rates of the
general tariff where lower conventional rates ex-
ist. In other words, 96.7 per cent, of the total
importation of American products will continue
to enjoy in Germany the treatment of the most
favored nation, whether this be free entry or the
lowest rates accorded to the like products of any
other country.
"It is true that a considerable number of the
new conventional rates of the German tariff are
not included in the schedule annexed to the new
agreement, but fortunately the large majority of
these omitted items are products in which the
United States has no export trade to Germany,
or at least in which American exports are of rela-
tively slight importance.
"On the other hand, the total value of German
goods that would participate in the benefit of this
new agreement amounted in the fiscal year 1906
to only $1,861,285, or only 1.4 per cent, of our total
importation of German goods in that year.
"Considering the respective concessions from
the viewpoint of amount of duties to be remitted
by either government, the advantage is decidedly
in favor of the United States. According to
German statistics the reduction of duties on
American goods under the new agreement would
amount to $6,664,000 per annum, while, accord-
ing to our statistics, the remission of federal rev-
enue in consequence of the concessional reduc-
tions in favor of German goods would amount to
only $208,168 per annum, on the basis of the im-
portation for the fiscal year 1906.
"While it is regrettable that any articles of
American export to Germany should be subjected
after July 1 next to a higher duty than is im-
posed on like imports of any other origin, there
is every reason to believe that the concessions
obtained in the new agreement represent the ex-
treme limit to which the German government
would consent to go in return for the compensa-
tory concessions available to the president under
section 3. The alternative was therefore presented
to the Department of State either of safeguard-
ing the great bulk of American trade with Ger-
many by granting the full extent of the duty re-
ductions permitted in section 3 and making cer-
tain rational modifications in the customs regula-
tions of the United States in the interest of mu-
tual trade development or of permitting the ex-
isting modus Vivendi to lapse without renewal of
any of its features on July 1 next, thus exposing
American exports to Germany to the application
on and after that date of the entire general tariff
of that country in all its severity.
"In order to secure to American products the
entire German conventional tariff, as well as cer-
tain desirable reductions of duty not covered by
the present conventional tariff, it would seem to
be necessary for the United States to make sub-
stantial tariff concessions in return to Germany
beyond the scope of section 3 of our existing tariff
law. This can be done only by means of a treaty
of reciprocity, subject to ratification by the Sen-
ate and Congressional approval."
Among the forty classes of articles on which
Germany makes substantial reductions we find
talking machines, which were formerly listed at
60 marks are now reduced to 40 marks per 100
kilos; music boxes without cases, formerly 25
marks, now 20 marks per 100 kilos (parts of
music boxes also come under the former ruling);
apparatus for mechanical repetition of musical
pieces, 25 marks per 100 kilos; organs, with
pipes, formerly 25 marks, now 20 marks per 100
kilos.
James B. Reynolds, acting Secretary of the
Treasury, issued a circular letter of instructions
to customs officers this week in regard to the new
German tariff. These instructions are general as
far as they affect the administrative features of
the new arrangement and are to be applied to
importations from all countries. The most im-
portant feature of- the circular letter relates to
the means of ascertaining market values upon
which duties are to be assessed. The circular
says:
"Market value, as defined by section 19 of the
customs administrative act, should be construed
to mean the export price whenever goods, wares
and merchandise are sold wholly for export or sold
in the home market only in limited quantities, by
reason of which fact there cannot be established
a market value based upon the sale of such
goods, wares and merchandise in usual wholesale
quantities packed ready for shipment to the
United States."
It was explained at the Treasury Department
that in cases where there is no wholesale mar-
ket in foreign countries for articles sent to the
United States, appraisers of customs in this coun-
try will take the export price as the basis of
valuation instead of trying to ascertain the whole-
sale market value. This export price is not the
purchase price. German export prices are from
10 to 20 per cent, less than the prices in that
country.
SINGLE COPIES, 10 CENTS.
$2.00 PER YEAR.
Evidence by German chambers of commerce
and exporters will be considered by American
customs agents as competent evidence, but not
as complete evidence of values. There is a wide-
spread impression that the evidence of the cham-
bers of commerce and exporters will be regarded
as conclusive by this government.
Another important change made by the new
German arrangement is that open hearings will
be given importers of foreign goods before the
Board of General Appraisers in New York in
cases of appeal, except when the government in-
terests might be injured by publicity. In such
exceptional cases the importers will be furnished
with resumes of the points brought out.
Still another important feature of the new ar-
rangement is that the confidential customs agents
of the Treasury Department abroad will have the
status of diplomatic officers and be attached to
embassies and legations. This will improve their
official standing.
CANNOT HIDE MORTGAGED PIANO.
Suit Brought by J. C. Martin & Co. Establishes
Important Point of Interest to Dealers Selling
on Instalments.
(Special to The Review.)
Dayton, O., June 3, 1907.
A case of interest to every piano dealer re-
cently came up in a local court. John Wuesten-
berg, the defendant, came into the possession of a
piano upon which J. C. Martin & Co., the local
piano dealers, held a mortgage. When Wuesten-
berg refused to divulge the location of the instru-
ment the piano company took the case to court,
where it was ruled that anyone secreting mort-
gaged goods was regarded as an accomplice in a
fraudulent act. The defendant thereupon paid
the costs of the action and the balance of the
mortgage. It is believed the above ruling will
do much to smooth the rugged path of the instal-
ment dealer in future cases.
ARTHUR E. WINTER ENTERTAINS
Entire Staff of Winter Music House at Dinner
—Chas. Jacob, of New York, Guest of
Honor—A Most Enjoyable Re : union.
(Special to The Review.)
Altoona, Pa., June 3, 1907.
Arthur E. Winter, of the firm of F. A. Winter
& Son, piano dealers, and one of Altoona's active
young business men, last week entertained the
entire staff of the music house at a dinner given
at his residence, 1428 Thirteenth avenue. A most
enjoyable evening was spent, the high esteem in
which the guests held their host being shown in
a number of ways. Impromptu speeches were
made by the majority of those present and made
an excellent finishing touch to the sumptuous re-
past. The special guest of the evening was
Charles Jacob, of Jacob Bros., piano manufac-
turers, of New York, with whom Arthur Winter
learned the business in all its branches.
Earl H. Hill, the piano dealer of Jamestown,
N. Y., has opened branch warerooms in Randolph,
N. Y. W. R. Johnston, formerly with the James-
town store, is in charge at Randolph.
Music Trade Review -- © mbsi.org, arcade-museum.com -- digitized with support from namm.org
THE
MUSIC TRADE
EDWARD LYMAN BILL - Editor and Proprietor
J. B. SPILLANE, Managing Editor
Executive and Reportorlal Stall:
GKO. B. KELLER,
W. H. DYKES,
F. II. THOMPSON.
EMILIE FRANCES BAUER,
L. K. BOWERS, B. BRITTAIN WILSON, WM. B. WHITE, L. J. CHAMBEHLIN, A. J. NICKLTN.
BOSTON OFFICE:
CHICAGO OFFICE:
K. P. VAN HARMNGKN. 105-107 Wabash Ave.
TELEPHONES : Central 414 ; Automatic 8043.
MINNEAPOLIS and ST. PAUL:
ST. LOUIS:
KKNEST L. WAITT, 278A Tremont St.
PHILADELPHIA:
1J..W. KAUFFMAN.
A.W.SHAW.
CHAS. N. VAN BUREN.
SAN FRANCISCO: S. H. GRAY, 2407 Sacramento St.
CINCINNATI. O.: NINA PUGH-SMITII.
BALTIMORE. MD.: A. ROBERT FRENCH.
LONDON. ENGLAND:
69 Basinghall St., E. C.
W. Lionel Sturdy, Manager.
Published Every Saturday at 1 Madison Avenue, New York.
Entered at the New York Post Office as Second Class Matter.
SUBSCRIPTION. (Including postage), United States and Mexico, $2.00 per year;
Canada, $3.50 ; all other countries, $4.00.
ADVERTISEMENTS. $2.00 per inch, single column, per insertion. On quarterly or
yearly contracts a special discount is allowed. Advertising Pages, $60.00; opposite
reading matter, $75.00.
REMITTANCES, in other than currency form, should be made payable to Edward
Lyman Bill.
_.
Directory ol Plaao
The directory of piano manufacturing firms and corporations
found
on another page will be of great value, as a reference
Manufacturers
for dealers and others.
Exposition Honors Won by The Review
Grand Prix
Paris Exposition, 1900 Silver MedaJ.Charleston Exposition 1902
Diploma.Pan-American Exposition, 1901 0old Medal.. .St. Louis Exposition, 1904
Gold Medal. .. .Lewis Clark Exposition, 1905.
LONG DISTANCE TELEPHONE—NUMBER 174S GRAMERCY
Cable address: "Elblll N e w York."
NEW YORK, JUNE 8, 1907
EDITORIAL
REVIEW
will be found that from time to time frequent mention is made of
new department stores taking on pianos, so that far from diminish-
ing, the department store to-day is a stronger factor than ever.
Wanamaker, in New York and Philadelphia, disposes of more pianos'
annually at retail than any other single institution in the country.
Naturally other department stores are watching the operations of
the greatest store of its kind in the world,, and some of the smaller
ones are constantly adding pianos to their lines. They are not
important and are not heard of in a prominent way, because the
instruments they secure are not of the leading makes. Many of
them select special brands. There are, when we come to count
them, but few great pianos in existence, and all of these cannot be
secured by department stores, no matter how alluring the proposi-
tion which they put forth.
T
HE department stores are factors that are becoming more and
more pronounced, and it sometimes causes surprise how some
of the smaller dealers succeed when competing against them. Take
along Broadway for instance. There are scores upon scores of
furnishing establishments, the owners of which pay enormous rents
for position, and still the total of their sales is very small. It is a
problem how they pay their expenses and meet their obligations,
because people are more and more gravitating to the larger stores,
where everything can be procured under one roof. The department
stores have shown a desire to enter the piano manufacturing field,
and Wanamaker, naturally, with his expansive ideas, chafes at times
under a restricted territorial limit. It has been stated that Wana-
maker and a number of Philadelphia department store leaders have
been interested in securing control of the Schomacker piano interests
of that city. In New York.we have two or three department stores
interested in piano manufacturing, and it is probable that these inter-
ests will be duplicated in other sections of the country. The depart-
ment store as a factor is not decreasing in strength in this industry.
On the contrary, it is growing, but in such a way that the average
music trade man does not notice its encroachment upon domains
which were considered to be exclusive a few years ago.
T
HERE is no denying the fact that many small dealers in New
York have complained bitterly against department store com-
petition, and there is every reason to believe that this feeling will
T is a mighty good thing that a lot of piano men did not start
spread. The department stores are colossal aggregations of capital
in to make exhibits at the Jamestown Exposition, for it is and business ability, therefore with perfect system and with undimin-
doubtful if at any stage of our progress as a nation, less evidence
ished energy and constant alertness, it is natural to assume that they
of our capabilities and our achievements, has been offered friendly
will be increasing their operations all the 1 while. Every now and
and observant critics. Despite the fine array of American war-
then a great retail establishment is opened in some of our large
ships, the country, must in foreign opinion, have suffered from dis-
cities, and an organization of help, numbering one thousand or more,
order, unpreparedness and impotency which existed ashore. It is
is gathered together to distribute merchandise to the amount of a
difficult to imagine a greater error than the invitation, so recklessly
million or more in a building specially erected for wideawake retail-
extended to the fleets of other sea powers, to assemble on an anchor-
ing. It is true that the man at the head of such an undertaking
age where so little inherent attractiveness may be found, and where
must personally do but small part of the tremendous task he shoul-
the success of a visit must depend so much upon the thoroughness
ders, nor can money alone do it, though it is an important factor.
of preparations of artificial creation. No matter about the cost, it
would have been the part of wisdom to have postponed the opening
ONEY is of consequence in combination with ability to select
of the Jamestown Exposition until we were at least half ready to
able men to meet the myriads of details and to formulate the
invite other nations to be our guests.
policy along which the grand plan is to be pursued. Such a man
I
M
SUBSCRIBER to The Review writes: "I do not read as
many comments in your columns as formerly about the de-
partment stores in the piano field. Is it because they are dropping
out and are not to-day the great power that some predicted they
would become?" No, hardly that. The department store as a retail
distributing force in the music trade field is becoming generally
recognized, and the mere mention of a department store in connec-
tion with the piano business does not excite the comment nor call
f^rth the criticism that was quite natural when this new force in the
business was untried and its future problematical. For a while
after the department store made its first entree into the music trade
domain much speculation was rife as to the operations of this new
force, and many believed that it would be impossible for the depart-
ment stores as a business aggregation to successfully dispose of
pianos. Time and Wanamaker, however, have taught us many
things about piano business being conducted by department stores.
A
T
HE interest has worn off and it no longer becomes a matter of
serious comment when a department store adds pianos to its
varied lines. If the columns of The Review are scanned closely it
sees in trifles what the average person ignores, and yet elevates him-
self above the details that drive many an ambitious worker to
drudgery and oftentimes to death. Like the skilled mechanician
he scans every flaw and defect in his machinery. This man can put
his hand on the wheel of his organization and direct improvements
through his lieutenants.
T
HE brain that is harassed with details cannot cope successfully
with the unclouded one that grasps the broad situation. Step
by step the man building up large affairs must learn to unload on
trusty shoulders, usually very willing ones, the burdens which he
carries, securing these at a liberal salary, and thus the man increases
his own earning capacity by an unhampered view of the possibilities
which surround it. The splendid results of a central idea of this
kind is shown by the United Cigar Stores Co., operating a tremen-
dous number of stores throughout the country all as one, and yet
conducting each as an individual establishment. It must be admitted
that it is possible where one line alone is carried to work out a
general policy in a better way than where there is a multitude of
wares sold. It must be conceded, too, that piano branches as a whole
have not been successful. Some of those who entered enthusias-

Download Page 3: PDF File | Image

Download Page 4 PDF File | Image

Future scanning projects are planned by the International Arcade Museum Library (IAML).

Pro Tip: You can flip pages on the issue easily by using the left and right arrow keys on your keyboard.