Music Trade Review

Issue: 1906 Vol. 43 N. 9

Music Trade Review -- © mbsi.org, arcade-museum.com -- digitized with support from namm.org
REVIEW
THE
COPJKS, 10 CENTS.
VOL. XLIII. No. 9 . Published Every Saturday by Edward Lyman Bill at 1 Madison Ave., New York, September J, 1906. SINGLE
ts.on PKR YEAR.
SOME TRADE GLANCES IN EUROPE.
News from Over the Sea—Review Man Reports Trade Conditions from London—Eldridge R.
Johnson Will Not Be Back Until October—Growth of Talking Machine Business in London
—Views of the Head of Broadwood & Sons Upon the American Trade Situation—What Geo.
Rose Saw in the Factories in the United States During His Recent Visit—Compares Ameri-
can and English Wages—Popularity of Instalment System in the States—Movement to
Change English Laws.
(Special to The Review.)
Review Office, 69 Basinghall street, E. C,
London, England, August 23, 1906.
Trade conditions in London are improving
materially, and the dealers and manufacturers
are evidently looking forward to a brisk season.
I do not learn of any Americans in town at the
present time, although there have been many
here during the summer months, which are now
drawing to a close.
Eldridge R. Johnson, of the Victor Talking
Machine Co., will probably not return before the
first of October. Mr. Johnson has temporary
private offices in the West of London.
London is headquarters for a wonderful talk-
ing machine trade, and all of the great American
houses are well represented here. The Gen-
eral Phonograph Co., whose head is James H.
White, wifl have records on the market shortly.
Mr. White has many friends throughout the
British Isles, who predict for him a brilliant
success in his new position. Mr. White was re-
cently honored by a banquet given in his honor
by all the leading talking machine factories of
the National Phonograph Co. This was held at
the Midland Hotel, Manchester.
I presume by the time this reaches you Dr.
Michaelis, inventor of the Neophone, may have
arrived in New York. He will come in connec-
tion with business for his concern, who recently
opened up larger quarters in Canada.
Ml{. itONK TALKS OF CONDITIONS IN THE STATES.
The music trade is not particularly brisk just
at the present time, for London weather is still
hot. Mr. George Rose, the managing director
of the famous house of Broadwood & Sons, has
recently returned from New York, and his views
presented by your London namesake will be of
interest to Americans, showing how an English-
man at the head of a great music trade institu-
tion here views an industry—one that he is
connected with in another land. Mr. Rose said:
"The state of the music trade in the United
States appeared to me to be very prosperous,
and to promise even greater results in the fu-
ture. There are evidences of expansion every-
where, and it is a remarkable fact that nearly
every factory is in full swing. In every other
phase of life this tremendous activity is appar-
ent. The factories, in fact, all businesses, seem
to be run with a smoothness and evenness which
is well-nigh impossible to attain in England.
The many carefully worked-out systems and
methods of doing business speak volumes for
the keen intelligence with which all affairs are
tackled—nothing is left to haphazard guesswork.
The Americans love business for its own sake,
not merely for its reward.
"The result of this single-hearted devotion to
business is the excellent quality of workmen em-
ployed at the piano and kindred factories. The
difference in appearance between the American
and English workman must strike the intelligent
observer very forcibly. The former seem to take
a much greater pride in their outward appear-
ance and their work. They are encouraged by
their employers to think for themselves and to
take an active and personal interest in their
labors; they are not merely human machines. If
any one of them has an idea which might im-
prove the working of a department or benefit in
any way the manufacture of an article, he is
invited to put his views before his principals, not
merely before his immediate foreman. If the
idea is favorably received, he can always count
upon suitable promotion or reward. Hence a
good workman need never know what unemploy-
ment is, and it must be admitted that the rela-
tions between master and man are more inti-
mate and friendly in the States than in this
country. Of course, I do not infer that such
kindly feeling is unknown here, but I think it
is far more general in the United States."
WAGES 1IKJIIKR IN AMEHICA.
"How do American wages of factory hands
compare with the wages usually obtained in
England?"
"In a comparison of American and English
wages the difference of the cost of living must
not be overlooked. A 'bellyman,' for instance,
who works on fairly cheap pianos, receives for
piece work $25 a week ( £ 5 ) . His expenses are
greater, but even so, his remuneration is higher
than it would be in England.
"As regards the hours of labor customary in
American factories, 54 hours per week are the
average. Office hours are usually 46 1/ 1 > hours."
"How do the average retail prices of Ameri-
can pianos run, Mr. Rose?"
"Pianos of a medium grade fetch about £67.
If a medium player is bought with the piano,
the price will be about £97. Should a high-class
player be required, £130 would have to be paid.
A first-class piano is sold for £115, and when
fitted with a player of the same quality. £190.
"The instalment system is very popular in the
States, and, considering the prices of pianos, the
monthly payments required are very low, the
minimum monthly payment being about 16s."
BRITISH
PIANOS
IN
AMERICA.
"What chance have British-made pianos in
America?"
"Well, the import duty of 25 per cent, on pianos
makes it very difficult for British manufacturers
to gain a footing in the States. I think, how-
tier, that there is a fair opening for pianos made
in this country, provided they are of a good
tjUKlity, and not too high in price."
"You also visited Canada, did you not?"
''I spent a very short time only in Canada, and
so I am not in a position to say much about the
music trade in that colony. But from what I
could gather, the trade there seems to be in a
very healthy condition in consequence of the
extraordinary financial and intellectual progress
of the country- I noticed that several American
firms have started factories in Canada, no doubt
with a view to avoiding the duties."
"Now, Mr. Rose, do you mind telling our read-
ers the real reason why you undertook this
trip?'
"Not at all. I went over to the States chiefly
to examine the systems on which American fac-
tories— not enly piano factories—are being fun."
FACTORIES
RK.MOV1NC
FROM
LONDON.
A number of manufacturers have removed or
are contemplating removal from London in con-
sequence of the high taxes imposed through the
extravagance of the municipal authorities. Fol-
lowing the lead of railways in other countries
the Great Eastern Railway and London and
North-Western Railway have, offered induce-
ments to manufacturers to move their plants to
couniry districts. Musical houses are also con-
cerned in the movement.
It is feared that the removal of so many firms
will throw a great army of unemployed upon the
charities of London.
Quite a stir has been created in the talking
machine trade over the invention of a well-
known expert in talking machines. Mr. Pr.
Haussmann (Langenzalza), has recently pat-
ented a sound box made of wood. Its tone is
said to be purer and softer than that produced
by a metal sound box, and it seems to have been
especially successful in the reproduction of vocal
performances. As it is lighter than a metal
sound box, it glides over a record almost inau-
dibly. The records, of course, last much longer,
and it is said that the price of a wooden sound-
box is exceedingly cheap.
l'OK CIIANUE IN
HIRE-PI'IUIIASE LAWS.
A strong movement is on foot among London
traders to have certain laws affecting the hire-
purchase business amended or changed. As the
laws stand now there are many ways in which
a trader may he cheated by the customer without
being able to obtain redress. For instance, as a
married woman is not subject to the bankruptcy
laws they may not be held personally liable for
debts contracted by them, and this clause is
frequently taken advantage of. One of the
traders' associations has adopted resolutions to
make husband and wife equally liable for debts,
and to render the wife liable to bankruptcy pro-
ceedings as an individual, and have her income
controlled by the court. These laws are of espe-
cial interest to the music trade, as the extent
to which they indulge in the hire-purchase sys-
tem make them heavy and frequent losers. There
is also a clause inserted in the contracts here
providing that should the instrument be re-
turned within twelve months the purchaser is
liable for the full year's instalments.
All in all, the hire-purchase system as exist-
ing here means a great deal of trouble for the
trader, who is kept almost continually before
the courts in various cases, especially where ig-
norance of the obligations assumed causes the
purchaser to try and cancel his agreement.
Music Trade Review -- © mbsi.org, arcade-museum.com -- digitized with support from namm.org
THE MUSIC TRADE
6
EDWARD LYMAN BILL, - Editor and Proprietor
J. B. SPILLANE, Managing Editor
Executive and Reportorlal Stall:
Quo. B. KELLEK.
W. N. TYLKK.
F. H. THOMPSON.
EMILIE FHANCBS BACKS.
L. B. BOWEBS. B. BHITTAIN WILSON, Wsf. B. WHITE. L. J. CHAMBERLIN. A. J. NICKLIN.
REVIEW
well as those of the dealers will be protected by the establishment
of one price, and that price by the manufacturer.
We have received a number of splendid contributions, and
while there is not the slightest obligation on our part to offer a
second prize, because this was not mentioned in our offer, yet we
shall give a second prize of $10 each to E. J. Delfrasse, New
()rleans, La., and Arthur Bissell, Chicago, 111.
We regret that we are unable to assigr. • rizes to others who
have sent in deserving contributions. The- would, too, be well
worthy of reproductions in the columns of '. lie Review, but inas-
much as we made no provision in our offer f jr their retention and
publication, we have been compelled to return the various manu-
scripts to all contributors.
BOSTON OFFICE:
CHICAGO OFFICE:
E. P. VAN HAHLINQHN, 195-197 Wabasb Ave.
TELEPHONES : Central 414 ; Automatic 8643
PHILADELPHIA OFFICE: MINNEAPOLIS and ST. PAUL: ST. LOUIS OFFICE
BJKNEST L. WAITT, 278A Tremont St.
R. W. KAUFFMAN.
A. W. SHAW.
CHAS. N. VAN BUKEN.
SAN FRANCISCO OFFICE: ALFRED METZGEB, 425-427 Front St.
CINCINNATI, O.:
LONDON, ENGLAND:
NINA PUGH-SMITH.
09 Baslnghall St., E. C.
W. Lionel Sturdy, Manager.
Published Every Saturday at 1 Madison Avenue, New York.
Entered at the New York Post Office as Second Class Matter.
SUBSCRIPTION,(Including postage), United States, Mexico, and Canada, $2.00 pec
year ; all other countries, $4.00.
ADVERTISEMENTS, $2.00 per Inch, single column, per Insertion. On quarterly or
yearly contracts a special discount Is allowed. Advertising Pages, $50.00; opposltp
reading matter, $75.00.
REMITTANCES, in other than currency form, should be made payable to Edward
Lyman Bill.
Directory ol Piano The directory of piano manufacturing firms and corporation
found on another page will be of great value, as a reference
Manufacturers for dealers and others.
Exposition Honors Won by The Review
Grand Prix
Paris Exposition, 1900 Silver Medal.Charleston. Exposition, 1902
Diploma.Pan-American Exposition, 1901 Gold Medal. .St. Louis Exposition, 1904
GoldMedol.Lewis-Clark Exposition, 1905
LONG DISTANCE TELEPHONE—NUMBER 1745 GRAMERCY
Cable address: "Elblll New York."
NEW
YORK,
SEPTEMBER
T,
1906
I
T was some years ago when The Review first began the con-
tinuous advocacy of one price, and at that time we offered a
series of cash prizes in order to stimulate interest in this subject by
arousing the argumentative element in the minds of our readers.
We offered a series of prizes amounting to one hundred dollars
and the publicity which we gave this subject created widespread
interest which has never been permitted to lag. This course has
been consistently held without resorting to flamboyant methods.
For over a year The Review has advocated the establishing by
the manufacturers of the prices at which their pianos should be
offered at retail, and in the advocacy of this subject we stood alone,
but persistency won and later the matter was considered of sufficient
importance to be taken up by the National Association, and the
retiring president did not hesitate to commend The Review for its
attitude, and as a result, resolutions favoring the absolute establish-
ment of a one price system fixed by the manufacturers in their
contract with the retailer, was unanimously passed before the
close of the Washington sessions, and we have no record of any
other publication urging its adoption.
T
EDITORIAL
T VACATIONS are nearly over, and next week thousands of
V
men in all parts of the country will have returned to their
respective business posts renewed in health and vigor, ready for the
active prosecution of business affairs.
Vacations are needed, for every man requires some rest from
the strain of business which grows more arduous and exacting each
year. Relief at the seashore and mountain side is necessary, and
when the vacationists return they go at their work with a determi-
nation and vigor which augurs well for the future of their enter-
prises.
This fall everything points to a most prosperous season, and
one which will begin very early. The'crops are assured, many of
them harvested. Good prices are certain and the business condi-
tions must be satisfactory to piano men in all sections of the country.
There will be from present indications a dearth of pianos—at
least appearances so predicate at the present time. The Middle West
will demand more instruments than ever before in its history. The
Southern call also will be emphatic, and from shipments which are
constantly being made to California, it is shown that earthquake
and fire in one locality did not in the slightest crush the onward
march of a great people. In New England there are evidences of
an early demand for pianos, the factories are going ahead at full
speed in the various manufacturing cities, which will mean that the
distribution of wages will be large and steady, therefore people will
be in a splendid position to purchase pianos and other articles of
home comfort.
W
E take pleasure in presenting in another part of this paper
an article written by C. S. Peregrine, a piano dealer of
Colville, Wash., to whom is awarded the $25 prize which The
Review offered for the best article embodying arguments in sup-
port of the one price system.
Mr. Peregrine is a practical man, having had many years of
experience in music trade affairs in various sections of the country.
He advances sound reasons why the manufacturers' interests as
O-DAY there are large numbers of manufacturers as well as
retailers who believe that the stability of the piano trade will
be best preserved by the manufacturers themselves fixing the prices
at which their instruments shall be offered at retail. One price in
all lines of merchandise is commonly accepted as meaning business
honesty, and there is no reason why the piano trade should fail to
recognize those principles which exist in all other mercantile lines.
It is generally admitted that there is no room for argument
on the one price system; and conceding that, who is better qualified
to fix the price than the man w T ho manufactures the product? This
sentiment favoring one price must and will grow, because it is right,
and correct principles in business are bound to survive.
PREACHMENT by Elbert Hubbard on "The Folly of Listen-
A
ing to the Credit Man" contains special reference to piano
buying. This has been used by one of the great department stores
which sells for cash only. Fra Elbertus says the credit system is
the most insidious form of borrowing money. We may quote a
part of his preachment, which is as follows:
"The evil to which I refer is the credit account and the 'easy
payment plan,' the siren song which lures us on to buying things
we do not need. Of all the snares to entrap mortals on their little
journey from the cradle to the grave I do not know of any that
cause more tears and heartaches than the credit account and the in-
stalment plan.
"A credit account is the most insidious form of borrowing
money. When you don't pay the merchant at once for the goods
you buy from him you arc borrowing money from him, and dis-
guised in the price is much more than the legal rate of interest.
"Better to borrow the actual cash and know how much you
have to pay for the accommodation.
"But it is better still to practice self-denial and go without the
thing you want till you have the cash to pay for it.
"I understand how one might buy food on credit, because food
is necessary to sustain life, but the fact that people buy pianos,
carpets, furniture and books on the instalment plan is only proof
of their gullibility.
"Debt is a rope to your foot, cockleburrs in your hair and a
clothespin on your tongue.
"The man in debt for things he could have done without is in a
continual ducking-stool of disgrace. The fact that if you should

Download Page 5: PDF File | Image

Download Page 6 PDF File | Image

Future scanning projects are planned by the International Arcade Museum Library (IAML).

Pro Tip: You can flip pages on the issue easily by using the left and right arrow keys on your keyboard.