Music Trade Review

Issue: 1906 Vol. 42 N. 14

Music Trade Review -- © mbsi.org, arcade-museum.com -- digitized with support from namm.org
THE
6
MUSIC TRADE
RMFW
EDWARD LYMAN BILL, - Editor and Proprietor
J. B. SPILLANE, Managing Editor
*cut
Executive
and Reportorial Staff:
W. ] ] \ \ TY
TYLER.
F. H. THOMPSON.
EMILIB FRANCES BAUHR.
wy. . ] B. WHITE.
L. J. CHAMBERLIN.
A. J. NICKLIN.
icJL
CHICAGO OFFICE:
E. P. VAN HARLINOEN, 195-197 Wabasb Ave.
TELEPHONES : Central 414 ; Automatic 8643.
: MINNEAPOLIS and ST. PAUL: ST. LOUIS OFFICE
uont St.
fTKAUFFMAN.
E. C. TORREY.
CINCINNATI, O.: NINA PUGH-SMITH.
Published Every Saturday at 1 Madison Avenue, New York
Entered at the New York Post Office as Second Class Matter.
SUBSCRIPTION,(including postage), United States, Mexico, and Canada, $2.00 per
year; all other countries, $4.00.
ADVERTISEMENTS, $2.00 per inch, single column, per Insertion. On quarterly or
yearly contracts a special discount Is allowed. Advertising PageB, $50.00; opposite
reading matter, $75.00.
REMITTANCES, in other than currency form, should be made payable to Edward
Lyman Bill.
The directory of piano manufacturing firms and corporations
found on another page will be of great value, as a reference
and others.
f o r d e a lers
Exposition Honors Won by The Review
Grand Prix
Paris Exposition, 1900
Silver A/edaf.Charleston Expoistion, 1902
Diploma . Pan-American Exposition, 1901
Gold Medal. . St. Louis Exposition, 1904
Gold Medal.Lewis-Clark Exposition, 1903
LONG DISTANCE TELEPHONE—NUMBER 1745 GRAMERCY
NEW
YORK,
APRIL
7, 1 9 0 6
EDITORIAL
O
l'Iv business reports for the past week indicate a decided better-
ment in trade conditions, and unless the coal strike becomes
a greater menace there is every reason to believe that April will
be a splendid month in all departments of the music trade industry.
The West is decidedly optimistic, and while the disastrous pos-
sibilities of a long-continued strike are generally recognized in all
circles, there is a disposition to take an optimistic view of the
situation. Manufacturing and mercantile interests believe that the
lines of mine suspension are to be much narrower than at first
seemed probable.
In the Southwest business men are inclined to take a decidedly
happy view of the situation. Recent storms in that vicinity have
hurt trade considerably, as they have made country roads impossi-
ble and heavy, and have thus interfered with commerce and traffic.
Notwithstanding this, trade has continued voluminous.
M
ARCH was disappointing in some ways. Collections were
decidedly slow the first half of the month, and retail sales
in many of the large cities indicate a falling off. But there is no
reason to doubt a previous statement made in these columns that
1906 will be the best year that this country has ever enjoyed. Build-
ing operations are of an exceptionally promising character, which,
of course, means the distribution of large sums of money weekly
which will benefit every line of business.
Trade is healthy and flourishing. Manufacturers are enlarg-
ing and expanding, railroad traffic is heavy, and, what is most
indicative, enterprise is looking for capital, and capital is ready
for enterprise. The month opens with excellent prospects, and
there is no reason why the members of this industry should not
reap a splendid reward for their efforts. It is not the time to talk
pessimism, but it is the time for business.
T
have fixed prices at which their products must be sold by dealers
and jobbers, and to cut these prices in violation of fixed rules means
the loss of an agency.
In this way the talking machine people have been building up
an industry at a phenomenal rate. They have adhered to straight
business principles, and a dealer and jobber who is not in sympathy
with the policy of price maintenance is not considered a desirable
business alliance. The result has been that the talking machine
industry has become a profitable one, and in the minds of a good
many if the price cutting and slashing policy had been in-
dulged in at the start the business would have steadily disin-
tegrated. Besides, there is a fixed policy among the leading talk-
ing machine manufacturers not to create special brands for any
concerns, no matter how large an order may be placed as an in-
ducement.
CHAS. N . VAN BOREN.
SAN FRANCISCO OFFICE: ALFRED METZGER, 425-427 Front St.
Directory ot Piano
__
.
.
Manufacturers
REVIEW
H E habit of cutting prices is contrary to good business prin-
ciples. The prices must be maintained if one hopes to keep
his business up to a fixed standard, and to extend trade operations
at the same time. The talking machine people have adopted rules
which are of considerable interest to the piano industry. They
A
S a direct result of this policy, the talking machine business
has been built up and steadily enlarged. Of course it would
not be possible for this industry to adopt all of the rules which
have been found successful in an industry closely allied with it,
but it is safe to say that it could follow with profit the principles
of maintaining standard brands and fixed prices.
These matters are of vital importance to piano manufacturers,
and if talking machine men can fix prices, and men in all other
lines of trade can fix prices at which their products shall be offered
to the retail purchaser, why should piano men hold aloof from
participating in the pleasure and profit which comes from the
establishment of trade stability.
Some of our leading houses have already advertised retail
prices, at which their pianos shall be sold to the public, and there
has been no desire, when once this plan has been inaugurated, to
return to the old methods. Fixed prices and prices established by
the manufacturer will do more to rehabilitate the piano industry
in the minds of the public and of the dealers themselves than any
other move which might be taken up for serious consideration.
A leading manufacturer, while discussing this matter recently
with The Review, expressed himself in terms of the warmest ap-
proval of the proposition. He said that he had followed a line
of articles appearing in this paper with a great deal of interest,
and he believes that, sooner or later, the trade, if the old plan is
followed, will be called to face serious problems—problems which
could be easily solved to-day by the establishment of the prices
at which pianos shall be sold by the manufacturer himself.
T
H E Washington piano dealers are strongly opposed to any
• kind of a trade exposition to be held in that city during the
dealers' convention next month. For months past there has been
a strong belief existing in the minds of the Washington piano
men that a trade exposition in their city might result in the dump-
ing upon the Washington market of a large number of instruments
which were placed on exhibit during convention days. They fear
that the results of the exposition might demoralize piano trade
conditions in Washington for some months following the show,
and would give rise to a number of "exposition sales."
Washington is not a large city, and if a great number of in-
struments were offered for sale by various exhibitors after the
close of the convention, it might seriously affect the trade of that
city, and there are many dealers who agree with the position
taken by the Washington Association.
E
DWARD H. DROOP, who is president of the Washington
Dealers' Association, said in last week's Review that the
protest of the Washington dealers against the proposed exhibit
was one of the causes which led to an adverse report from the
joint committee appointed from the Manufacturers' and Dealers'
Associations by President Werlein.
According to President Werlein's statement the Association
will in no way stand sponsor for the exposition, and he informs
the trade that the invitation to make an exhibit has not been with-
drawn. In other words, according to the president, the invitation
stands, and the National Association will in no way attempt to
control it, or stand sponsor for it. and is in no way responsible
for the show.
I
T would seem when the Washington dealers are to act in the
capacity of guests for the entire trade that their wishes in
this particular should be respected, more especially when it was
Music Trade Review -- © mbsi.org, arcade-museum.com -- digitized with support from namm.org
TH
MUSIC
TRADE
on account of their protest that the joint committee of manufac-
turers and dealers were appointed to consider the exposition mat-
ter. The report rendered embodied a rejection of the exposition
plan. Surely, unless the atmosphere is clarified materially the
result of this difference of opinion may have a far-reaching effect
upon organization work.
To begin with, the exposition idea was not at all popular with
the trade. It was hastily considered and rushed through at Put-in-
liay without due consideration, so many affirm. At least there
were many who strongly opposed it at that time, and their ranks
have steadily become augmented, and the manufacturers who nat-
urally would be the ones to support the exposition move have
strongly opposed it. They could not figure out just where they
would profit by a trade exposition, which must necessitate a con-
siderable monetary outlay on their part. They could not determine
just exactly where they could make good all of the expenses and
annoyances incident to an exposition outlay.
GREAT many dealers, too, were bitterly opposed to such an
exposition, and the more the matter was considered by the
Washington dealers the more unfavorably it was viewed. They
did not want an exposition, and said so plainly. Some dealers
figured that if the wishes of the Washington piano men were not
respected this year, and they suffered by reason of the convention
legacy, the following year, instead of bidding for the exposition,
there would be at once opposition developed to keep it away from
certain cities where the dealers would fear a repetition of the
Washington experience.
Viewed at this time, it must be considered that the exposition
idea in conjunction with the regular trade convention has fallen
decidedly to a low state. There has developed the strongest kind
of opposition to it at Washington, and the opposition is spreading
from that city, and it finds a responsive echo in all parts of the
country.
A
T
H E R E are many who believe that the only way to handle the
exposition is to separate it entirely from convention work
and make it an annual feature, the same as has been conducted by
the furniture and other trades.
It might be worth the while to try at least one exposition.along
broad lines, but in order to give it even a fair test there would
be required a considerable sum of money to secure the necessary
quarters and to pay the expenses incident to the gathering in and
the locating of trade exhibits.
The furniture men are heartily sick of the whole annual ex-
position scheme, and they for two or three years have been trying
to break it up entirely, and there are many of the leading furniture
men who assert that it will be dropped entirely within the near
future.
T
l I E formal opening of Wanamakers piano store did not occur
this week, owing to delays incident to the finishing of the
rooms. Next week, however, everything will be in perfect condi-
tion, and the entire second floor of the new Wanamaker building
will be given up to a most artistic display of pianos. Xo expense
has been spared in the equipment of the various rooms, which are
finished in accordance with the forms of various art periods, and
every piano man visiting New York will be well repaid by an
inspection of these new palatial piano quarters, which must be
viewed in order to be fully appreciated.
T
HE bacillus of jealousy seems to be universal. It is apparent
in every division of life, and this industry, in line with some
others, has been a splendid incubating ground for the engendering
of trade jealousies.
In professional life, perhaps, there are more feuds and jeal-
ousies existing than in any other lines. This is marked among
musicians, particularly among physicians and journalists—of course
eliminating music trade journalists, who have a tender and almost
affectionate regard for each other. Wherever there are sentimental
values existing there always seems to be cause for the building
iij) of a jealous feeling, and it cannot be denied that there is a
sentimental value attached to pianos.
Nor do we believe it is well to separate that sentimental feel-
ing from a consideration of the king of musical instruments. Men
carefully guard a good reputation, and sometimes absurd jealousy
REVIEW
is created in the minds of the opposing forces and differences of
opinion will always arise concerning the just means by which men
have achieved success.
To many people the fact that a man is successful in trade and
commerce is proof positive that he is a tyrant and a robber. At
least, unsuccessful men are prone to criticise him. l'ut strong
men everywhere make enemies. We find them not onlv in business,
but also in politics, in science and in literature.
M
OST minds are too small to see that we have led men into
the very conditions that are apparent in very many lines.
They have succeeded; but is not that the gospel every intelligent
man and woman is teaching? The market abounds with volumes
and titles on "Success," "How to Win It," "Success Is For You,"
"Famous Leaders," "Eminent Men," "Captains of Industry."
Years ago some of the successful men of those times read
these books, and they had a chance to try the advice, and now
we find it difficult to tolerate their presence. They are ahead of
us, and that is a condition that is as galling as it is true. So long
as we measure greatness by the amount of money a man possesses,
so long will there be millionaires. The hero in American life is
the man who has achieved the distinction in business operations.
And it is also true that in the struggle for commercial supremacy
we find exhibited some of our finest virtues of self-sacrifice, indus-
try and heroism—qualities that we would fain do without.
T
H E centralization of money in the hands of a few has received
immense encouragement from the insurance companies.
These companies are supported by the very people who condemn
the trusts. The insurance companies are the great depositories of
gold and silver, which they, of course, cannot use themselves, and
their profit lies in loaning large sums to the speculator, who uses
the money to enslave the people who supply it.
The people forget, however, that these trust organizers pay
good interest for the use of that money. It is comforting to know
that our millionaires have once been poor, but by a concentration
which is rare, by a perseverance that recognizes no defeat, and by
prudence that shames a Solomon, they have built tunnels into the
mountains of ignorance and dynamited the rocks of doubt.
I
T must be admitted that capital is necessary to carry on a big
business, and that articles of food become cheaper in propor-
tion as they are manufactured on a large scale. It is the same,
too, with articles of trade and commerce.
Compare what we term the commercial piano of to-day with
the high-grade piano of fifteen or twenty years ago; and compare
the prices of the instruments which were offered for sale twenty
years ago and the instruments of our time.
It must be at once admitted that the manufacturing on a
larger scale has benefited the people. It costs less to purchase
luxuries to-day than it did to buy comforts fifty years ago, and
wages are higher and comforts are more numerous.
The average citizen who has not achieved success is too prone
to criticise our millionaires (and we have some in the piano trade)
in the most superficial manner. In this country, where liberty
of thought and deed is strongly applauded, it is but natural that
some men through favored conditions should arise above the many.
A
S a matter of fact, while we may have some millionaires of
a mean type, yet the successful American business man,
broadly speaking, has never been neglectful of his debts to human-
ity. If he has made liberally, he has given liberally; and there are
few individuals who have protested against accepting "tainted
money." There was, however, a recent protest of some Boston
clergymen against accepting the one hundred million given by
Rockefeller for missionary purposes.
The protest recalls a story of Thaddeus Stephens, the Repub-
lican leader in the House at Washington during the war. The
great Radical was ascending the steps to the Capitol one morning
after "sitting in" all night at a poker game. He had a comfortable
roll in his pocket as the result of a fat "jackpot." He was met bv
a committee of pious folks from his district with the request for a
contribution to a fund for building a church in their town. Taking
out his winnings, this satirical old commoner handed them all
over, quoting grimly the lines of a familiar hymn : "God moves
in a mysterious way His wonders to perform."

Download Page 6: PDF File | Image

Download Page 7 PDF File | Image

Future scanning projects are planned by the International Arcade Museum Library (IAML).

Pro Tip: You can flip pages on the issue easily by using the left and right arrow keys on your keyboard.