Music Trade Review -- © mbsi.org, arcade-museum.com -- digitized with support from namm.org
THE
6
MUSIC TRADE
RE™
EDWARD LYMAN BILL,,
J. B. SPILL^NE..
Editor and Proprietor
id E41t«r.
EXECVTIVE AND REPORTORIAL STAFF:
Quo. B. KELLER,
WM. B. WHITH,
W. N. TXLBB,
L. J. CHAMBEBLIN.
F. II. THOMPSON.
EMILIE FBANCIS BAUHB,
A. J. NICKXIN,
GEO. W. QCERIPEL.
BOSTON OFFICE:
CHICAOO OFFICE
ERNEST L. WAITT, 173 Tremont St.
E. P. VAN HARLINGEN, 1362 Monadnock Block.
PHILADELPHIA OPFICBi
R. W. KAUFFMAN.
MINNEAPOLIS AND ST. PAUL:
E. C. TORBEI.
5T. LOU 15 OFFICE,
CHAS. N. VAN BUBEN.
SAN FRANCISCO OFFICE: ALFRED METZGKB. 425-427 Front. St.
CINCINNATI, O.: NINA PUGH-SMITII.
REVIEW
"There are many arguments, of course, which might be brought
against it, and to my mind the whole matter of the proposed exhibit
resolves itself into one of an open door to trade."
Mr. Mehlin's views are precisely in harmony with a number of
other manufacturers who have expressed themselves upon this sub-
ject. There is a strong opposition to the holding of a trade exhibit
in Washington which might be held in some of the larger cities.
O
NE manufacturer, while discussing the matter, remarked: "It
would seem to me that the cheaper men would profit at the ex-
pense of the manufacturers of high grade instruments. Suppose, for
instance, I have two or three special styles which my designer has
evolved at considerable expense and trouble, over comes a dealer who
is taken with my instrument, and rushes back to a maker of cheap
instruments and says, 'If you can copy that truss, or that pilaster, or
that panel, I will give you an order,' and so the work of the progres-
sive men will be copied, and they will receive no equivalent in
return."
. .
Published Every Saturday at 1 Madison Avenue, New York.
Entered at the New York Post Office as Second Class Matter.
SVBSCRIPTION (Including postage), United States, Mexico and Canada, $2.00 per
year ; all other countries, $4.00.
ADVERTISEMENTS. $2.00 per Inch, single column, per Insertion. On quarterly or
yearly contracts a special discount Is allowed. Advertising Pages, $50.00; opposite
reading matter, $75.00.
REMITTANCES. In other than currency form, should be made payable to Edward
Lyman DHL
On the first Saturday of each month The Review contains In Its
"Artists' Department all the current musical news. This Is effected
TIE ARTISTS' without
In any way trespassing on the size or service of the trade
DEPARTMENT section of the paper. It has a special circulation, and therefore
augments materially the value of The Review to advertisers.
M I r r m o v «/ »IANA T n e dlrec tory of piano manufacturing firms and corporations
DIKXCTUKi *f FIANO f oun
MANVFACTUR.ER.S
f or dealers and others.
LONG DISTANCE TELEPIONE-NVMBER 1745 GRAMERCY.
NEW YORK, OCTOBER 21. 19O5.
GOOD deal of discussion has been started through the argu-
ments presented in an editorial in The Review two weeks
ago regarding the proposed music trade exposition to be held next
year in Washington.
We have received a number of communications endorsing the
expressions of the paper, and many of the manufacturers have also
expressed themselves to our representatives in terms which have
strongly favored the arguments presented in The Review.
Thus far no one has taken up the other side of the question as to
how the trade would be benfited by the exposition which must neces-
sarily be expensive, and which would fail to increase the retail sales
by a single piano.
A
H
PAUL MEHLIN, president of the Piano Manufacturers'
• National Association, remarked to The Review: "I have
seen the exposition editorial, and perused it with much interest. The
points were well made, and clearly brought out, but I do not feel
that I should discuss the matter from an association standpoint what-
soever. It will come up at the proper time before the executive com-
mittee, and I feel that it would be unwise on my part to speak at all
on the subject from the association viewpoint. I may say, person-
ally, however, that the only kind of an exposition that would win
would be on a large basis, such as The Review has suggested, by
securing, say, Madison Square Garden. But even then I believe
that the enterprise would be a loser as far as returns for the invest-
ors were concerned. It would not draw like an automobile show,
while, of course, there might be some musical features, yet I do not
believe that it would be a pronounced success.
4
' A S far as the proposed trade exposition is concerned in Wash-
l \
ington, I may say," continued Mr. Mehlin, "that a number
of manufacturers have not viewed the proposition with favor. There
is not a suitable hall in Washington, and I believe that the whole
matter will resolve itself into what may be called a commercial
proposition. In other words, the dealers' association has opened the
door for publicity, and those who desire it may enter.
"A number of manufacturers may send on sample instruments
to Washington, but I do not believe that a general exhibft under one
roof will be favored.
A NOTHER Western manufacturer said: "I do not believe that
l \ any trade exposition can succeed, particularly during Con-
vention week; as The Review has said, there is a certain excitement
inseparably associated with trade gatherings, and if you are going
to interject any novelties other than the social functions which
have already eaten into Convention time, why it would change the
whole character of the meetings. I believe a convention should be
what its name signifies, and not an industrial fair. The expense to
carry it on in a fair way would be considerable."
A
NUMBER of other prominent men have taken similar views,
and we have not as yet received from anyone an opinion favor-
ing the proposed exposition. Now, as we have fairly started this
subject, it will receive serious consideration. Will not the whole
matter simmer itself down to sporadic trade exhibits? In other
words, the dealers' association has extended an invitation to manu-
facturers to exhibit their wares at Washington; those who desire
will take on a line of samples. But in our opinion there will be
no comprehensive exhibit in one general collection, but the men
who take pianos there will feel that they are encouraged by the
dealers to do so. This naturally will result in the business element
dominating at the association meetings.
I
T is possible that the manufacturers may decide to hold their con-
vention the earlier part of the same week selected by the dealers.
There seems to be a pretty general opinion that West Baden, the
famous gambling resort of Indiana, is not just the place for the
piano men to meet. It was selected on account of the fact that no com-
mercial influences could gain the ascendency in that city. But it is a
question in the minds of most of the piano men whether they will
meet there or not. It may not be definitely arranged until the execu-
tive meeting in January. The Eastern men do not wish to insist
that the Western trade shall come east. They prefer to have them
select some locality suitable to themselves, inasmuch as the last
gathering was in the East. We may add that there is a strong senti-
ment steadily growing which favors Washington just preceding the
dealers' convention.
From our knowledge of the situation, we should say that Wash-
ington will be the spot selected, and that there will be no large piano
exhibit but simply an open door and hearty greeting for all.
I
T is said that Dold and his associates have been bitterly disap-
pointed and have expressed chagrin and regret at the financial
condition of the Piano & Organ Workers' Union, and that when they
inserted a clause in their communication to the manufacturers which
might be construed as threatening to the piano men, they had not
carefully counted the numerical and financial strength behind them.
They demanded a closed shop, too, and the manufacturers propose
to maintain an open shop, therefore there could be no agreement on
that ground.
It may be said, too, that the reason why the piano workers of
this city have not contributed liberally to the union is due largely
to the fact that they are exceedingly well satisfied with their present
conditions. They are drawing splendid wages, the average wage
price is very high, and they are working with remarkably pleasant
environment when compared with some of the other industries. The
factories are all well arranged for health and comfort, and the men
have not only been drawing good wages, but they have been also