Music Trade Review -- © mbsi.org, arcade-museum.com -- digitized with support from namm.org
THE MUSIC TRADE REVIEW
6
REVIEW
EDWARD LYMAN DILL.
Editor and Proprietor.
J. B. JP1LLANE, Managing Editor.
EXCCVTIVE AND REPOKTORIAL STAFF:
GEO. B. KELLER,
W K . B. W H I T E ,
W. N. TYLER,
W. L. WILLIAMS,
A. J. NICKLIN,
BOSTON OFFICE:
ERNEST L. WAITT, 266 Washington St.
PHILADELPHIA OFFICB:
R. W. KAUFFMAN.
EMILIE FRANCIS BAUER,
GEO. W. QUMIPKI..
CHICAGO OFFICB
E. P. VAN IIARLINGEN, 1362 Monadnock Block.
MINNEAPOLIS AND ST. PAUL:
E. C. TORMY.
5T. LOUIS OFFICE :
CHAS. N. VAN BUEKN.
SAN FRANCISCO OFFICE: ALFRED METZGER, 485-427 Front S t
Published Every Saturday at I Nadiion Avenue, New York.
Entered at the New York Post Office as Second Class Matter.
SVBSCRIPTION (including pottage), United States, Mexico and Canada, $2.00 per
rear; all other countries, $4.00.
ADVERTISEMENTS, $2.00 per inch, single column, per insertion. On quarterly or
yearly contracts a special discount is allowed. Advertising Pages, $60.00; opposite
reading matter, $76.00.
REMITTANCES, in other than currency form, should be made payable to Edward
Lyman Bill.
On the first Saturday of each month The Review contains in its
THE ARTISTS' "Artists' Department" all the current musical news. This is effected
without in any way trespassing on the size or service of the trade
DEPARTMENT section of the paper. It has a special circulation, and therefore aug-
ments materially the value of The Review to advertisers.
w . . . . . _ . «._.._ _ _ „
NANVFACTUR.ER.S
The directory of piano manufacturing firms and corporations
found on another page will be of great value, as a reference for
dealers and others.
LONG DISTANCE TELEPHONE—NVMBER 1745 GRAMERCY.
NEW YORK, MAY 27, 19O5.
EDITORIAL
T
HE convention at Atlantic City, from every standpoint, must
be considered the quietest event of its kind which has occur-
red since the Association saw light down by the sounding sea at
Manhattan Beach. It was purely an association affair from the
beginning until the last of the oratorical pyrotechnics had been
exploded. There were no outside influences of any kind that could
work opposition in any way to the success of the association ideas
or rules.
If the piano manufacturers' organization did not receive a
fresh inspiration from the meetings then it must be considered that
the divorcement of the two organizations was a mistake.
T
HERE were some who did not hesitate to express the opinion
at Atlantic City that they would desire to see the dealers meet
with them. There were many, however, who maintained that if
the manufacturers' organization did not have enough of interest
to hold the manufacturers themselves for two days, then the lines
ought to be abolished and the two organizations blended in one, to
be known as the National Piano and Music Trade Association.
Another well known manufacturer said he believed that amalgama-
tion would be the future of the two associations. He supported his
statement by the argument that over one-half of the members of
the dealers' association to-day were either manufacturers, or manu-
facturers representatives. Therefore, he said, to claim it solely as a
dealers' association was wholly wrong and misleading. It was
simply a retail branch or extension of the manufacturers' organ-
ization.
H
OWEVER,, there are still some others who said that they
believed that the Piano Manufacturers' Association could be
wholly separated from the dealers. They did not believe, as was
proposed by some, to convene on the first days of the week at West
Baden and permit the dealers to have theirs the latter part of the
same week, thus devoting an entire week to association doings.
One man said that that was simply a makeshift, and would not help
affairs at all. He said that if the manufacturers did not have suf-
ficient matters of interest to meet once a year and discuss by them-
selves for a day or two, they had a mighty sight better disband
and call the organization useless, and have the individual mem-
bers join the dealers. As a matter of fact a majority of the mem-
bers opposed by their vote the attempt made to hold the conventions
at the same time and place. The vote stood eighty against ten in
favor.
T
HE social features which have hitherto played an important
part in association gatherings were wholly lacking, save for
the big banquet, and many who had anticipated a number of pleas-
ant diversions were disappointed.
The weather, however, was
beastly, and if excursions had been planned they could not have been
enjoyed under the opposing climatic conditions.
T
HE trade press and its various offshoots received considerable
attention at the hands of several members of the Association.
This annual denunciation of the whole trade press seems to be a regu-
lar part of the association duties, but would it not be a trifle more
consistent if the denunciators of the trade press would be more dis-
criminating in their statements? A blackmailing trade press can
only live through support, and if the men who* are so loud in their
condemnation of the papers of questionable character and value
would withdraw their support why the source of trouble would
speedily be annihilated. The great trouble is that the illicit portion
of the trade press has fattened through the jealousy entertained by
manufacturers toward each other.
EO. P. BENT in the course of his remarks spoke of blackmail-
ing papers. It is easy to suppress the existence of such
journals in this trade, for it is a mighty sight easier to prove black-
mail than it is to prove fraud.
To illustrate: Suppose certain
eulogistic articles were shown in court which appeared in a paper
when a manufacturer was advertising in that publication, and when
his advertisement was withdrawn defamatory articles appeared.
These to be shown in contrast with others. There would be no need
for great argument, or great legal ability, for constructive black-
mail would be clearly demonstrated, and an intelligent jury would
place no other interpretation upon such action. And still some of the
manufacturers who have howled the loudest about trade publications
for years have never dared to take an initiatory step towards sup-
pressing the evil, which they do not hesitate to denounce in most
emphatic and lurid terms about association time. They give out
patronage on almost equal terms unmindful of their own interests,
and without the slightest consideration of the fact that in so doing
they are paying a premium upon journalistic slothfulness and hold-
npism.
G
NE great trouble in this industry is that the estimates are not
fair which are placed upon the various publications. Too
many have fallen into the common way of classing the progres-
sive paper in the same list with the non-progressive pub-
lication, and include as well the paper which is conducted by a
single individual, who writes two or three humorous sketches, fills
his paper with a couple of columns of "hits" on his fellow-editors,
uses the paste-pot and scissors for half an hour and calls it a paper.
Others have "write-ups" of the most glaring kind from cover to
cover. They never had two hundred and fifty paid subscribers in their
lives, and these papers would not be permitted to enjoy the pound
privileges in the United States mail if the attention of the govern-
ment authorities were called to their general character.
These
paper critics include in the same list, papers which have a
splendid organization, reaching every city and hamlet in the
United States and foreign countries as well, which are edited from
a thoroughly practical newspaper standpoint, containing technical
and specialized articles distributed in every country on earth as well
as every city and hamlet in the United States, and gotten out weekly
at the expense of thousands.
O
I
T seems unjust and manifestly unfair to sneeringly class such pub-
lications with the other line—in fact it would be just as rea-
sonable to put a Chickering piano on a par with a cheap special
brand. There is a good deal to think about in the trade journal line,
and personally we had rather see such reports as the subjoined,
which demonstrates beyond power of argument that our adver-
tisers are receiving the largest kind of value for the dollar expended,
than to listen to expressions of insincerity regarding trade journal-
ism. This appeared in The Trade Review, a well-known commer-
cial paper published in Lincoln, Neb., on May 13th:
"The Duplexophone Company has purchased a good factory
building and will be able to turn out about 50,000 machines this year.