Music Trade Review

Issue: 1904 Vol. 39 N. 22

Music Trade Review -- © mbsi.org, arcade-museum.com -- digitized with support from namm.org
6
THE
Music
TRADE: REVIEW
absurdities and crudities which characterize many piano adver-
tisements.
I
EDWARD LYMAN
Editor and Proprietor.
J. B. SP1LLANE. Man**inrf Editor.
EXECVTIVE STAFF:
CAMPBILL-COFSLAND,
EMILIS
Gxo. B. K u x n ,
TBOS.
W . MURDOCH LlND,
CHICAGO OFFICE:
BOSTON OFFICE:
EMUI
L. WAITT, 856 Washington St.
PHILADELPHIA OFFICE:
R. W. KAUFFMAN.
FRANCES BAUER,
GEO. W. QUEEIPEL.
A. J. NICKLIK,
E. P. VAN HARLINCSN, SO La Salle S t
MINNEAPOLIS AND ST. PAUL:
R. J. LKFSBVRE.
SAN FRANCISCO OFFICE:
5 T . LOUIS OFFICE :
CHAS. N. VAN BUEEX.
ALFRED METZOBE, 426-487 Front St.
Published Every Saturday at 1 Nadison Avenue, New York.
Entered at the New York Post Office as Second Class Matter.
SVBSCRIPT1ON (including postage), United States, Mexico and Canada, $2.00 per
year; all other countries, $4.00.
ADVERTISEMENTS, $2.00 per inch, single column, per insertion. On quarterly or
yearly contracts a special discount is allowed. Advertising Pages, $50.00; opposite
reading matter, $75.00.
REMITTANCES, in other than currency form, should be made payable to Edward
Lyman Bill.
On the first Saturday of each month The Review contains in its
THE ARTISTS' "Artists' Department" all the current musical news. This is effected
without in any way trespassing on the size or service of the trade
DEPARTMENT section of the paper. It has a special circulation, and therefore aug-
ments materially the value of The Review to advertisers.
DIRECTORY at PIANfi > ^' ie directory of piano manufacturing firms and corporations
M*ii»fV/r.»»
found on another page will be of great value, as a reference for
MANVrACTUR.ER.S
dealers and others.
LONG DISTANCE TELEPHONE-NVMBER 1745 GRAMERCY.
NEW YORK, NOV. 26. 1904.
EDITORIAL
W
E are in receipt of numerous communications from manufac-
turers and dealers praising last week's issue of The Review.
It is true that viewed from any standpoint it was a remarkable
number. In the size of the publication, and in the variety and influ-
ence of its contents, it was indeed a record smasher. It was a notable
victory from the newspaper standpoint, and was certainly a greai
credit to our printing establishment, when one considers that the
entire paper, comprising one hundred and forty-two pages, was
gotten out inside of a week. The edition was a very large one, and
it will be seen that the physical accomplishment of producing such
a publication is worth commenting upon at least. It required cer-
tainly a good newspaper organization to complete such a gigantic
work within such a limited time. It was treated as an ordinary
number, and not, as what is colloquially termed, a special in any sense,
and we think that the arrangement and completion of such an enter-
prise emphasizes one thing above all others, and that is that the organ-
ization and general equipment of The Review is of such size and
character that we are enabled to toss off with comparative ease the
largest kind of a trade paper proposition. Such an organization
commands support because it merits it.
"W
T is pretty hard when a man has to work his intellect overtime in
order to produce some brand new, never heard of, brilliant
method, for attracting holiday piano buyers. While in the throes
of this strenuous task, he may come across a scheme, perhaps by
accident, which if worked out to the full satisfaction of the originator,
may mean success. Novelties in any line surely count, but we
should say to our western friend, that the first essential to secure his
share of the holiday trade, would be to have a clean, attractive store.
Dress it up in holiday attire. It costs but little. Potted plants and
some holiday novelties in the way of decorative effects add immensely
to the drawing power of the piano wareroom, too many of which
have a funereal aspect rather than a holiday garb.
HAT s ^ a ^ w e c ^° t o ^ e t OUr s n a r e °f t n e holiday trade?"
writes a dealer from a western town.
Well that problem has made many a good piano man hollow-
cheeked and sunken-eyed. For weeks before the season of good
cheer and good will, he had racked his brain to devise means to attract
buyers. He has gotten up new kinds of sales and has striven in
many ways to interest the public in his particular brand of pianos.
The striving for the new, the race after novelty has become a
shibboleth with most of us, and in our haste for ultra effects we get
tired, fagged out and weary.
Occasionally it is well to consider whether the profit underly-
ing the older devices tested and proven could not be applied to-day.
Pianos were sold years ago on the quality basis, and those selling
them succeeded fairly well. Why not emphasize the quality stand-
ard in pianos to-day, and clothe the idea, if you will, in a new garb,
give it a fashionable printers' raiment, omitting, of course, the
AKE the store attractive. Next see that a good, fresh, bright
stock is installed therein. Keep it attractive. Don't let dust
rest on the pianos until it actually fornis a coating, but keep the
pianos bright, spic and span, so that one does not have a sense of
depression when entering the store, and wondering whether only
second hand goods are sold. Then after making the store bright
and inviting, the stock clean *and attractive, the next thing is
publicity.
M
N
OW publicity to-day costs money for the newspapers are not
run on purely a philanthropic basis. No one is going to boom a
business enterprise or any other kind unless they receive money for it.
The World's Fair people learned that to their sorrow. Get up some
attractive musical entertainments. Bring in the piano players for
publicity, show them up, and get the local papers if you are in small
towns to write up the affairs in detail. The papers will not do it with-
out pay, because they are not noted for their unselfish benevolence,
but they will tell their readers all about your musical entertainments,
if you will spend a little money. Get in with the reporters. If you
are clever you will find a way to work in some little features of your
entertainment in the papers in an interesting way. But don't attempt
to work the papers, pay them for what you get the same as you pay
for merchandise.
R
UNNING a paper is like any other business enterprise. It is
not a charity undertaking, but if properly patronized it is the
most forceful adjunct to every business in the world. The advertis-
ing force was strong enough to land Douglas in the Governor's
chair of Massachusetts with such a thud that the sacred cod fish on
the dome of the State capitol dropped a few scales.
"What shall I do to get my share of the holiday trade?"
Why, Lord bless you, do things. Be strenuous. Have a
bright store, bright stock. Have some lovely flowers here and there.
Geo. P. Bent has the only retail establishment in America that *
we have ever seen decorated on the outside with flowers, but the
versatile Geo. P. understands a thing or two about business, and he
adorned the windows of his building on Wabash avenue with beau-
tiful potted plants during the summer so that any one on the street,
and on the elevated road could see those lovely pinks and geraniums
trailing from his windows.
ORT of inviting, don't you know. It gave one an idea that
inside was refinement, taste, good music, good pianos, and
surely whenever you enter the Bent warerooms you will be sure to
find all of these attractive accessories. You will find a well-kept stock,
and a most inviting place in which to tarry. Clever salesmen are
there, too, to show you attractively environed instruments. We
would say to our friend, who asked what he shall do to get his share
of the holiday trade, don't employ poor salesmen. They are dear
at any price. Good men are not at all times easy to get, but they pay.
An investment in a good salesman brings good returns.
S
EVER mind the suicidal competition ot a dollar a week and
nothing down, let the fellows who desire that kind of busi-
ness go on with the dance. Let their joy be unconfined; unless they
have a mighty long bank account they will be tired of that business
some day. In the meanwhile stick to quality, stick to price; have it
the right price, and above all, advertise. Let the other fellows race
to see who can offer a piano for the least down and the smallest
possible payment, but keep in mind that opportunity for profit and
permanent business lies in emphasizing quality rather than price.
N
Music Trade Review -- © mbsi.org, arcade-museum.com -- digitized with support from namm.org
THE: MUSIC
TRADE,
In the purely price competition, the greater the deception, and inci-
dentally the greater the demoralizing of the business.
W
E are Hearing the holidays, and while it is getting towards the
close of the selling season for manufacturers, there will
doubtless be a big rush of business within the next two or three
weeks. Some retailers hold off until all possible uncertainties have
disappeared before making reasonable purchases, but there is a
danger in holding off too long.
O
F course the piano business needs fresh capital, plenty of it.
How could it be otherwise when the instruments are sold as
they are in many cases on such small time payments?
One reason why business has not been good for the past six
months is due to the fact that a good many dealers have seen that
their capital is becoming entirely locked up in their business through
the small payment system, and they have concluded to go a little
slower. A dealer who has not great capital behind him cannot do a
large business on the dollar a week system without tying up his
entire capital.
There is no doubt about it that a good many of them have seen
the result of this plan, and ar? going a good deal more cautiously
with the time payment system.
As The Review has stated before, we have reached the limit,
and a dangerous one, too.
It is easier to get a little more cash
monthly, provided that principle is instilled in the minds of the
salesmen than it is to get a smaller amount. More cash and fewer
small payments should be the slogan of piano merchants everywhere.
I
T may be that some people are attracted by the dollar a week
plan, but it would be just as easy to double the monthly install-
ment if it were insisted upon by the salesmen. It does not pay at
all times to harp upon the low prices, even if every woman is attracted
by this claim.
We know of one particular store which owes its success in a
large measure to its liberal treatment of customers. It is generally
known that the house always gets a good big profit, and yet its trade
is immense and growing. Thus far I hey have eschewed the dollar
a week plan, and the manager recently told us that all that kind of
trade he would gladly pass over to his competitors.
B
USINESS in the music trade line should be particularly good, for
there is no reason why our particular line should not feel the
inspiring effects of the settled conditions in the political world, which
are being felt in every other trade. Of course such a political tidal
wave, which actually occurred has its advantages and disadvantages.
The close or contested election is sure to cause some bitter feeling,
and it is likely to result with political trouble as well as financial and
commercial disturbances.
These possible disadvantages have been very thoroughly
obviated by the result of the presidential election, and now there is
no necessity for trade to adapt itself to any new conditions. Senti-
ment among the manufacturers and import retailers is highly buoy-
ant, and what Wall Street thinks of the outcome is attested by the
tape. In fact no better augury of stability of trade conditions
throughout the country can be furnished than is presented by the
overwhelming expression of the sentiments of the people.
I
N the big vote there was no hint of restraint, or even of warning,
and the political leaders who, for some years past, have con-
trolled the Government, cannot be blamed for feeling that they have
received directly from the people what the politicians like to call a
''mandate" to continue for four years to come the policies which
they have hitherto adopted. Ours is and ought to be a government
by the majority, and so long as the will of the people continues to
find such frank and unmistakable expression as came out of the
election, there is little to fear even from "the big stick." We are
all DE-lighted with the business outlook, and every piano dealer
should make the most of the conditions.
E
VIDENCE has been rapidly accumulating in the Post Office
Department of late showing conclusively that a great many
carriers in the rural free delivery service have violated or evaded the
regulations with regard to soliciting for retail mail order houses and
prohibiting the furnishing of the names of patrons of rural routes.
Rural carriers have been subjected to every form of temptation
that could be devised to induce them to violate or evade the rules
of the Post Office Department.
REIVIEIW
Montgomery, Ward & Co., offered carriers eight cents a piece
to distribute their catalogues. Sears, Roebuck & Co., wrote car-
riers, saying that compliance with the above offer would mean in-
stant dismissal, then added, "if the time ever comes when you are
permitted to distribute catalogues, or you can get some relative,
friend, or neighbor to do so, we will pay you more liberally than any
one else."
These big catalogues contain illustrations of all kinds of musical
instruments including pianos, some of which are offered at $87.50,
but the Post Office Department will not permit the evasion of the
regulations to the extent of allowing its carriers to solicit for mail
order houses.
T
H E St. Louis Exposition authorities have paid back the United
States Government every dollai which was loaned them. So
the big fair cannot be called a financial failure any more than any of
its predecessors. The stockholders have lost in the St. Louis
as well as former expositions, all of the money which they have
invested. We say all, because the returns to stockholders have
been so slight as to amount to practically nothing, but one of the
foremost lessons of the St. Louis Exposition is that it is first of all a
triumph of business enterprise and achievement, and that this most
valuable influence will be exercised along the lines of commercial
progress throughout the world. The spirit of the business which is
predominant is an expression of our times, our own ideals, methods,
processes and performances, and its crowning glory will lie in the
fact that it has presented to the world more comprehensively than its
predecessors the triumphs of ingenuity, skill, energy and enterprise
in these fields of endeavor which contribute most largely to the daily
comfort and progress of mankind.
T
HE report of commercial failures for the month of October, as
collected by R. G. Dun & Co., indicates continued improve-
ment in business conditions. The number of failures for the month
was 888, against 1,086 in October, 1903. while the liabilities for the
month were only $10,500,000 this year, against $18,400,000 last year.
Alike in manufacturing, trading and banking the number of failures
for the month was less than in October, 1903, and this condition
was especially marked in the matter of banking suspensions. Alto-
gether the showing is a mighty encouraging one.
B
EFORE the election The Review stated that if Douglas were
elected Governor of Massachusetts the credit would largely
be due to the persistent advertising carried on by this candidate for
gubernatorial honors. He purchased a vast amount of space in the
newspapers of both parties in which he exploited his personal
charms in the most flamboyant manner. His election is perhaps
the strongest proof of the force of advertising that is supplied in
events of recent years.
H
IS manager while discussing his advertising campaign, said:
"Well, it was my business to whoop, and the dust hasn't settled
yet. I first proceeded to put a quarter-page 'ad.' in every paper that
would carry it, English, French, German, Portuguese. If there had
been a Laplander's organ I'd had it there. Next I got out twelve-
sheet posters and pasted them all over the State. There was noth-
ing on them but 'For Governor, William L. Douglas.'
Under-
stand, I left 'Democratic' off, and Governor Gaston said to me:
'Buchanan, my boy, that was a damned smart trick.' And you bet it
was. The poster also showed seven pictures of Douglas in the
seven ages. First he was a boy of seven, pegging on the bench.
That was devised to appeal to the workingman. The other pictures
showed Douglas in the cotton mill, driving the prairie, as an appren-
tice, an employer, in the Senate, and in the House. Any one, even
if he couldn't read, understood that poster.
"We counted more on newspaper publicity than anything else,
for I wrote the stuff myself, and I knew the platform. We socked
it to 'em on reciprocity, and that made a hit, for within the last year
60,000 Republicans petitioned the legislature to take action on that
measure. You mav know the State is keen for it."
D
OUGLAS is generally considered to be a strenuous business
man who appreciates the value of advertising and it is the first
time in the history of the nation when a man has been landed in so
high a position through such novel means, particularly when the
popular tide was set strong in the other direction. Shows surpris-
ing strength in advertising, does it not?

Download Page 6: PDF File | Image

Download Page 7 PDF File | Image

Future scanning projects are planned by the International Arcade Museum Library (IAML).

Pro Tip: You can flip pages on the issue easily by using the left and right arrow keys on your keyboard.