Music Trade Review

Issue: 1904 Vol. 38 N. 22

Music Trade Review -- © mbsi.org, arcade-museum.com -- digitized with support from namm.org
THE
MUSIC TRADE
MFW
EDWARD LYMAN DILL.
Editor and Proprietor.
J. B. SP1LLANE. Managing Editor.
EXECVT1VE STAFF:
THOS. CAMPBELL-COPELAND,
W. MURDOCH LIND,
A. J. NlCKLIN,
BOSTON OFFICE:
ERNEST L. WAITT, 255 Washington St.
PHILADELPHIA OFFICE:
R. W. KAUFFMAN.
EMILIE FRANCES BAUER,
GEO. B. KELLER,
GEO.
W. QUERIPEL.
CHICAGO OFFICE:
E. P. VAN HARLINGEN, 36 La Salle St.
MINNEAPOLIS AND ST. PAUL:
R. J. LEFEBVRE.
5T. LOU 15 OFFICE :
Published Every Saturday at 1 Madison Avenue, New York.
Entered at the New York Post Office as Second Class Matter.
SVBSCR'PTION (including postag.), United States, Mexico and Canada, $2.00 per
year; all other countries, $4.00.
ADVERTISEMENTS, $2.00 per inch, single column, per insertion. On quarterly.or
yearly contracts a special discount is allowed. Advertising Pages, $50.00; opposite read-
ing matter, $75.00.
REMITTANCES, in other than currency form, should be made payable to Edward
Lyman Bill.
DEPARTMENT
On the first Saturday of each month The Review contains in its
"Artists' Department" all the current musical news. This is effected
without in any way trespassing on the size or service of the trade
section of the paper. It has a special circulation, and therefore aug-
ments materially the value of The Review to advertisers.
n i » i r r n o v . f PM«in
The
directory of piano manufacturing
firms and
found o n a c 7 2 wiU b e of
reat value a s a
l' S
dealers and others.
«
corporations
"^rence for
LONG DISTANCE TELEPHONE-NVMBER 1745 GRAMERCY.
NEW YORK, MAY 28, 19O4.
T
HE big convention of 1904 at Atlantic City has now become
history, and it ranks as a record breakei as far as attendance
is concerned, for there were more men identified with the various
departments of the music trade industry gathered together at Atlantic
City than were ever known before since the piano trade threw off its
swaddling clothes, and took rank as an industry.
T
HE Manufacturers Association has reached the high water
mark as far as membership is concerned, now numbering
eighty-three firms, and corporations. Surprising gains have been
made during the past year, and nearly all the concerns that withdrew
last year are back again in the Association field.
No one in scanning the membership roll can doubt the strength
of the Piano Manufacturers' Association or its permanency. It has
come to stay and to play an important part in the future of the
industry.
The dealers' organization has grown in membership in
a manner which is the strongest kind of testimony as to the efficiency
of the officers who have given much time during the past year to the
promotion of Association interest.
W
E are of the opinion that the two organizations will continue
to meet together for years to come.
There are many
reasons why the closest affinity should exist between the organiza-
tions. There are many interests which blend harmoniously by the
two associations holding their annual meeting at the same time and
place.
It is a question whether or no the serious work of the convention
is not hampered by the commercial or business influences which cause
many to hie themselves to the convention cities.
M
Judging from many opinions expressed during the week there was
some dissatisfaction as to the business coloring which the Associa-
tion gatherings are taking on. That is the hardest of all propositions
to regulate.
The two organizations were founded ostensibly for
business betterment, and if business can be promoted in several ways
by a good attendance, why then it is only logical that we should ex-
pect certain men to be mindful of the opportunities afforded by the
hand to hand contact during Association gatherings.
S
UME are not slow to embrace those opportunities and pursue
them to the utmost, and there is plenty of new business se-
cured as a result of the yearly convention gatherings.
That is all right from a business standpoint, but are the special
business subjects which are taken up at the convention gatherings as
helpful in every way to the association interests as they would be
under different conditions?
CHAS. N. VAN BUREN.
SAN FRANCISCO OFFICE: ALFRED METZGER, 425-427 Front St.
THE ARTISTS*
REVIEW
ANUFACTURERS meeting their representatives from the
various cities naturally desire to discuss with them certain
plans for the future, not forgetting, of course, the business end.
Then, there are always a goodly number of salesmen who are
anxious to embrace the opportunity afforded by the convention gath-
erings to talk business to the dealer a few moments, and business
appointments are quite the thing during convention days.
GOODLY contingent of the supply men and auxiliary trade
were also present in Atlantic City, nearly all of the leading
concerns being represented either by principals, or trade representa-
tives. It is a fact more and more apparent that the business possibil-
ities of the trade conventions are becoming generally recognized b)
members of the trade, so that the business part dominates, frequently,
some say to the detriment of association work.
A
OME excellent papers were read at the convention which appear
in this week's Review. They should be carefully read by all
dealers who were not present at the convention, and even those who
were there would get some valuable suggestions by refreshing their
memory upon the subjects treated.
One man, who has a national reputation, who was present at the
various meetings, said to The Review that he was much interested in
many of the topics treated, but that he gained no new ideas from
listening to the various readers. He said that he felt inclined to the
belief that men who had been successful would not give to their
:ompetitors the secrets which contributed so largely to that success.
In other words, he believed that the best methods known to dealers
would be preserved by them, for, he added, why should a successful
man disclose to his neighbor the secrets which cost him a vast outlay
of money, time, and experimental work.
S
T
H E R E certainly is good food for reflection in these remarks.
It is a fact, the average business man has certain methods of
his own which he has evolved through years of study and application,
and the probability is, that he will guard them with as much secrecy
as possible. However, it must be admitted that a good deal of valuable
information can be gained by a careful perusal of the various asso-
ciation reports which are gathered together and presented to Review-
readers. All may not have been told but enough surely for some
interesting and instructive reading.
T is variously estimated from $50,000 to $75,000 were spent dur-
ing the week at Atlantic City by the visiting music trade men.
Perhaps the lower figure would come nearer the total expenditures,
but it must be conceded that piano men are liberal in their expense
account, and probably more money was left at Atlantic City than by
any other convention which has ever been held at that point. It cer-
tainly is a good deal of money for any industry to expend for conven-
tion purposes, but nearly every one had a good time, and what matters
the cost? The hotel men were happy, in fact jubilant, and long for
another piano meet.
I
T
H E helpfulness of the piano player as a valuable adjunct to the
regular piano business is becoming more and more apparent,
and recently we have had the opportunity of obtaining the views of a
number of prominent dealers upon this important subject.
It is
well to emphasize the fact that in every case where the piano player
business has been specialized, where the proprietors have had ex-
perts in charge of the department and have conducted the player
business in a fitting way, giving it the space and attention which it
has deserved, the investment has been most profitable.
It was only a short time ago when The Review presented
opinions from scores of dealers regarding the player business, and
there was a unanimity of opinion regarding the profitableness of the
piano player when its advantages were presented properly to the pub-
lic.
Music Trade Review -- © mbsi.org, arcade-museum.com -- digitized with support from namm.org
THE MUSIC TRADE
T
HERE are some dealers, however, whom we could name who
have made exceedingly large player sales, and still they are
decidedly lacking in enthusiasm upon the subject and are rather in-
clined to be modest in their statements as to the paying qualities of
che piano player department.
It is possible, if not probable, that this attitude of lukewarmness
on their part might be brought about through a desire on their part
to minimize the player possibilities in order to keep their local
competitors from entering the player field. The educational powers
of the piano player are becoming more and more recognized and
progressive dealers have been quick to grasp the advantage of secur-
ing an adequate player representation. We have seen it demon-
strated, and our observations cover practically every dealer in
America who handles players, that they have been successful in every
instance where they have given it the treatment which the subject
richly deserves.
T
HE player business cannot be treated indifferently. It must be
intelligently exploited and thus satisfactory results are quick-
ly realized.
It is rather amusing to note the mouthings of the paretic egotist,
who, unable to secure a sufficient piano player patronage in his declin-
ing sheet, tries to slur the entire business and discredit it in the eyes
of the dealers. This kind of tactics may have been successful in
forcing manufacturers in line some ten years ago, when the trade
paid some attention to the utterances of the alleged journalist, but
that time is now happily of the past, and whether he damns or praises
it amounts to practically the same thing. Men are now patronizing
papers more liberally on account of the value which they offer rather
than the Sheol they can raise.
IFTH AVENUE, which for many years has been recognized as
the "Piano Row" of New York, is being rapidly changed by the
encroachment of wholesale houses. Steadily the retail warerooms have
been forced northward by the expansion of the jobbing district and
as in the case of the Aeolian Co. upper Fifth avenue has been invaded.
But a serious obstacle prevents upper Fifth avenue from becoming
the future piano retail district of New York. The prices of real
estate in that section have advanced enormously during the past few
years, and to-day are almost prohibitive for certain trades. It would
seem, therefore, that another section must become ultimately the piano
retail district of this city.
Where shall it be?
F
T
HAT is the question that the heads of many piano concerns have
been actively revolving in their minds for many months.
There is no part of New York where there are more improvements
oeing made than on Fourth avenue, between 18th and 28th streets.
It is possible to purchase real estate in that thoroughfare to-day at
moderate figures, and this district would be easy of access, both for
town people and suburban residents. If one or two should select
this point and locate there, it is probable that there would be a gath-
ering of piano warerooms in that vicinity within the very near fu-
ture. Fourth avenue is broad, has splendid transportation facilities
ind in many ways would be an ideal district. Boston music men
changed from Tremont to Boylston street. Why should not Fourth
avenue become the future piano row of New York? Its advantages
are worthy of careful investigation.
N ambitious young man from the South desirous of entering
the field of journalism, asks The Review if he should begin
by allying himself with one of those correspondence schools which
proposes to teach journalism by mail. While the schools cannot
do much harm we feel sure that they cannot do much good.
A successful newspaper man must learn things which can
never be taught by mail. The young man who proposes to take
up the journalistic field in these early century days should make
a special study of something so that he can discuss it in an in-
telligent manner. That is the first move.
This is the age of specialism, and a man should have a
technical knowledge of what he is writing about. He either
should be an expert story writer, technical writer, legal writer,
medical or business writer. He should cut out the corre-
spondence school entirely, and get if possible on some technical
journal or daily paper where ability, if he has any, will count for
something. There is no school like that of practice.
A
REVIEW
OME manufacturers state that their trade has exceeded that
of 1903. Yet these cases are unusual. While there is a
good volume of business in the aggregate, the market is without
the snap and life which are looked for at this season of the year
when climatic conditions are favorable. Most of the manufac-
turers, however, are well occupied with orders, but their order
books, as a rule, are not filled far in advance. To this, there are,
of course, some exceptions.
While the spring trade has been quiet owing to the backward
season yet the majority of piano men are optimistic regarding fall
trade, and hold that the year will average up fairly well.
S
T
HIS is indeed the age of advertising, and every business bows
to its power. A few years ago it was an uncommon thing
for a bank to advertise at all, and to-day leading banks are getting
more and more into the line of publicity. The trust companies,
too, are steady advertisers. In fact they have their agents travel-
ing in all parts of the country, soliciting deposit accounts. They
have cards in many of the cars in New York stating that they
will pay as high as four per cent, to secure deposit accounts, and
the trust companies are cutting tremendously into the business of the
banks.
T
HEY are less hampered by laws than the national banks, and
savings banks, and are pushing this advantage to the very
uttermost.
Some curiosity is excited as to how some trust companies
can pay as high as four and one-half per cent, on a deposit account
when call money is loaned at one per cent, in Wall Street, and when
time loans for the longest periods do not command over four per
cent. If the trust companies continue to adopt new methods to
secure new business and push ahead at the pace they are traveling,
they are fast becoming novel advertisers, and it would not be
surprising to see some of them introduce a free ice cream and tea
parlor in connection with their establishments.
F
OR some time past the competition of catalogue houses in
the piano trade has not been apparent, and it has not been
forced upon the attention of manufacturers.
There was a period when some of our piano men were cater-
ing with considerable persistence to a catalogue house trade.
They felt that it would afford them an easy avenue for wide dis-
tribution of their goods, but there is where the trade press stepped
in with its healthful influence. The makers could not well ride
two horses. In other words they could not sell to the regular
dealer, and sell to the catalogue house man who was cutting the
heart out of the dealer when he could, and expect to continue to
do business with both.
T
HERE were some of the makers who felt that but little should
be said about catalogue houses, that the subject should be
discussed only in a whisper, and let events take their course.
That was not the belief of The Review, and we did not pro-
pose for one moment to permit the catalogue house people to
come in and become a formidable opponent to the small dealer
without protest, and while there is still some business carried on
through catalogue house sources, yet its volume is small, and
there is no reason to apprehend that the catalogue house people
are being encouraged in a large way by piano manufacturers.
T
HE small grand is destined to play an important part in the piano
future of this country. Many of our firms are recognizing
this fact, and are bending their energies upon the production of small
grands, for which there is already a large demand, a demand which
is certain to increase as the wealth of the country accumulates.
There are a number of distinctive terms given the small grand
by various makers. Chickering & Sons originated and used the very
clever term of "Quarter Grand" by which they designate their small
grand product. In fact they have advertised the "Quarter Grand"
so well that whenever the name is mentioned even in remote locali-
ties one immediately associates it with the Chickering product. It is
a clever catchy phrase which has attracted others to the extent that
they are not willing to leave Chickering & Sons in undisturbed pos-
session of this name, a value for which the Chickering house has
created.

Download Page 4: PDF File | Image

Download Page 5 PDF File | Image

Future scanning projects are planned by the International Arcade Museum Library (IAML).

Pro Tip: You can flip pages on the issue easily by using the left and right arrow keys on your keyboard.