Music Trade Review

Issue: 1904 Vol. 38 N. 2

Music Trade Review -- © mbsi.org, arcade-museum.com -- digitized with support from namm.org
8
THE
MUSIC TRADE! REVIEW
REVIEW
EDWARD LYMAN BILL.
Editor and Proprietor.
J. B. SPILLANE, Managing Editor.
EXECUTIVE STAFF:
THOS. CAMPBELL-COPBLAND,
A. EDMUND HANSON,
GEO. B. KELLER,
A. J. NICKLIN,
EMILIE FRANCES BAUER
GEO. W. QUERIPEL.
BOSTON OFFICE :
CHICAOO OFFICE:
W. MURDOCH LIND, 694 Tremont St.
E. P . VAN HARI INGEN, 36 La Salle St,
PHILADELPHIA OFFICE:
R, W. KAUFFMAN.
ST. LOUIS OFFICE :
CHAS. N . VAN BUREN.
Published Every Saturday at 1 Madison Avenue. New York.
Entered at the New York Post Office as Second Class Matter.
SUBSCRIPTION (including postage), United States, Mexico and Canada, $2.00 per
year; all other countries, $4.00.
ADVERTISEMENTS. $2.00 per inch, single column, per insertion. On quarterly or
yearly contracts a special discount is allowed. Advertising Pages $50.00; opposite reading
matter, $75.00.
REMITTANCES, in other than currency form, should be made payable to Edward
Lyman Bill.
THE ARTISTS*
DEPARTMENT
On the first Saturday of each month The Review contains in its
"Artists' Department" all the current musical news. This is effected
without in any way trespassing on the size or service of the trade
section of the paper. I t has a special circulation, and therefore aug-
ments materially the value of The Review to advertisers.
MANUFACTURERS
The o directory
of piano manufacturing firms and corporations
found
n
P a « e 31 w i l 1 b e o f * r e a t v a l u e a s a r c f e r e n « for
dealers and others.
, DISTANCE TELEPHONE-NUMBER 1745-EIGHTEENTH STREET.
NEW YORK, JANUARY 9. 19O4.
EDITORIAL
A 1L J HAT are trade conditions for the early months of the new
* " year? is a query oft propounded in piano circles during
these early January days, and a comparison of the conditions exist-
ing a year ago will be of interest.
In 1902 it was the universal custom of the dealers to order in
large quantities.
November trade started in with a rush and continued uninter-
ruptedly good until the close of the month. This condition of affairs
encouraged the belief that December would be as good, if not a trifle
better, consequently large orders for hurry shipments were placed.
Now the December trade in 1902 was bitterly disappointing.
In fact the sales of December including the late holiday orders did
not come up to the record of the previous month, and as a conse-
quence the dealers had on hand at the beginning of 1903 large stocks
of instruments.
H P HIS statement is verified not only from personal observations
*
gained by thousands of miles of travel, but through the re-
ports made by our correspondents in various cities and by the expe-
riences of traveling men as well.
Nineteen hundred and three opened badly from a business stand-
point, and orders were slow in coming in, and the fact cannot be dis-
credited that the year as a whole has fallen short of its predecessor.
The splendid crops saved the country from a serious depression.
Less pianos were manufactured last year than during 1902, which
now stands as the banner year of the industry in point of volume.
day trade than the merchants in the larger cities. And the dealers,
recalling their experiences of the previous year, placed light orders.
Therefore, having had a light holiday trade, the average stocks in
the warerooms are much lighter than those on hand in January, 1903.
F7ROM various figures at hand we are inclined to the belief that
1
there is a decrease in the wareroom stock approximating
twenty per cent, over that of a year ago. So we start in the new
year with better prospects from the stock standpoint. The record
which 1903 has made for itself is in some respects satisfactory, and
the various classes of trade have had a profitable business, but for
several months past there has been an evident hesitancy on the part
of the trade in placing large orders.
Dealers have recognized that there was little danger by wait-
ing, and thus the indications now point to livelier trade conditions
during the early months of the year than during the same period
of 1903.
'"T^HERE is a perceptible improvement in the general feeling of
*
trade.
With fair prospects and conditions in practically every section,
with the apprehension of financial trouble over, with the growing
export demand for our general products and with signs of recovery
in many of the departments of the metal market, the new year begins
with fair promise of a large volume of business and on the whole in
a very satisfactory condition.
Conservative optimism would seem to be an appropriate war cry
for the new year.
Suppose we adopt that as a slogan for 1904 and let common
sense dominate and control the reasonable processes of men. The
bursting of various industrial bubbles has tended to clarify the
atmosphere and should enable all business men to view the situation
through the natural eye and not through rose-colored glasses.
\ \ J HILE all the world was vibrant with song it was the saddest
'
New Year's Day which Chicago has ever experienced, and
the great heart of the Nation throbbed in sympathy with her people
in the great affliction which had befallen them through the horrible
catastrophe at the Iroquois Theatre.
It seemed hardly possible when the first news of the horror
reached New York that the death roll should not include some mem-
bers of the music trade, and some deaths were reported in last
week's Review. But the most fearful affliction was visited upon
E. C. Frady, president of the Strohber Piano Co., whose entire
family, including wife, son, mother, sister and nephew, were swept
away in the frightful holocaust.
A T hand are recent copies of papers published in such cities as
•* *• San Francisco, Los Angeles, Salt Lake, Montgomery,
Savannah, New Orleans and Atlanta, containing, in some cases,
entire pages devoted to the exploitation of pianos.
This demonstration shows beyond power of argument that the
piano merchants in the far West and South are beginning to ap-
preciate more and more the advantages of newspaper advertising.
They no longer propose to hide their business under the bushel of
It may be said that the trade during last fall in many of the indifference, but keep it brightly shining so that it may be a guid-
ing star to every one who is piano inclined in their vicinity.
large cities was extremely slow on account of building strikes, and
great depression in various kinds of stocks. The smaller towns were
That's the kind of spirit that will win big results in the new
not affected in the same degree, and the dealers enjoyed a better holi-
year, and any year for that matter, because a man who is a good
Music Trade Review -- © mbsi.org, arcade-museum.com -- digitized with support from namm.org
THE MUSIC TRADE
advertiser usually may be relied upon as being a good business man
because correct business methods are synonymous with up-to-date
advertising. Advertising is too powerful a leverage to modern
business enterprise to be ignored, no matter whether it be in the
wholesale or retail line, and we will find that the largest advertisers
are the most successful men.
' T * HE greatest piano manufacturing institutions in the country
*
are liberal patrons of the leading trade.publications. Of
course we will find some who have succeeded without expending
great sums of money in printer's ink, but times were different, and
it was possible years ago for men to advertise over the head of the
dealer, and ship pianos direct from factory.
REVIEW
as it proudly asserts, that here is an opportunity to at once demon-
strate its usefulness to the entire trade by immediately investigating
the causes which led up to Mr. Kidder's style of offensive advertis-
ing. By prompt action in this matter the Executive Committee
would show to dealers who have thus far refrained from joining
the organization that they were heartily in earnest and their sin-
cerity would win many new members by a single stroke.
Now this is just the time when the Association should act. While
officers cannot lay down iron-clad rules which every member is bound
to follow in his advertising plans, they can show to the entire world
their disapproval of such methods used by Kidder in a way that
will meet with the applause of the trade. Warm words, hearty
pledges to support the best interests of the trade are largely in evi-
That business to-day is not successful, and the few firms who
dence during Association days, but here is a time for something
are engaged in it will undoubtedly acknowledge their defeat by
more than words, it is a time for action.
its discontinuance within the near future. There is a feeling
OUND industrials are more appreciated to-day than ever, and
stronger than ever before among the dealers to refuse to handle the
the issuance of a half million debenture bonds by Steinway &
product of houses which advertise to sell direct to the customers,
Sons, which were over subscribed for in less than half an hour after
and not through established agencies.
the subscription books were open, shows how eagerly gilt edged in-
Some piano manufacturers, however, have performed splendid
vestments are sought for by investors. The Steinway house has a
work by giving their instruments national prominence and passing
rapidly developing trade both at home and abroad, which has made
over all local inquiries which come through magazine advertising
imperative the necessity of enlisting additional capital. Huge Stein-
to their agents in various sections of the Union.
way factory plants have been recently erected within Greater New
That is helpful wofk, no question about it.
York, which have necessarily required vast outlays. The develop-
'""INHERE is an advertising spirit more active than ever before,
ment of this business during the last few years has been phenomenal.
'
which means the cultivation of publicity. It is said that
k
when young Heinze, son of the Pittsburg pickle manufacturer, was
HAT was a very interesting statistical statement W. B. Price
in Yale he had two nicknames. One set of his classmates called
presented at the recent trade banquet in Chicago, showing
him "pickles;" another manifested a preference for "57 varieties,"
how our trade had developed so remarkably within recent times.
all of which goes to show the power of advertising.
The conditions are vastly different in our foreign trade relations
T
Now the Dealers' National Association, as well as its elder
brother, the Piano Manufacturers' Association, have gone squarely
on record as opposed to that form of advertising adopted by a few
dealers who advertise at practically wholesale prices, instruments
not regularly carried by them, but sold by their local competitors.
This sort of advertising has had not only an injurious effect upon
the local standing of pianos, but papers containing the offensive
than in 1902. At that time we were staggering under a heavy load
of indebtedness to foreign bankers. Now our foreign obligations,
which were enormous in 1902, have not only been discharged, but
the balance of trade has run so heavy in favor of this
country that our foreign customers have been compelled to make
large remittances in gold to meet their liabilities in the account
with us.
advertisements have been exhibited to kill competitive sales at far
away points.
R
ECENTLY a member of the Dealers' Association, A. A. Kid-
der, of Utica, N. Y., has been indulging in precisely the form
of advertising which was referred to and condemned by the Asso-
ciation resolutions. He has offered some leading makes of instru-
ments at prices closely approximating the wholesale rates with the
effect either of discrediting the real value of the instruments locally,
or of casting suspicion upon the dealers who sold them at higher
prices.
Henry Dreher, president of the Dealers' Association, as re-
ported in The Review last week, has written a personal letter to
Mr. Kidder, asking for an explanation.
Now Mr. Kidder is not a novice at the piano business. He
knew precisely what he was about when he prepared that form of
advertising, which appeared regularly in the Utica papers.
\ \ J E have seen practically the same form of advertising used
" *
in other localities, and it would seem to us that if the
Association really stands for trade betterment along advertising lines
HE November reports of merchandise were larger than those
of any other month except October, 1900. The great changes
in our international trade are of the highest importance, and the
business interests of the country, and the present conditions may
naturally be expected to have a wholesome effect in checking the
pessimism which has lately been inclined to increase in importance
in trade circles. While the quantity of gold imported is not itself
large enough to stimulate domestic trade interest to any great ex-
tent, it is important enough to give much encouragement to those
who believe that the depression in business is not likely to prove
of any long duration.
T
w
HEN our foreign trade is shown to be on such sound basis
a serious cause of apprehension is removed. We have ap-
parently nothing to fear now over our international trade relations,
and it remains with ourselves to put our domestic affairs in good
condition. It may require some little time, but the crisis of read-
justment of new domestic conditions is now progressing, and thus
far has not been accompanied by any serious failures. We are cer-
tainly in much better shape than we were one year ago.

Download Page 8: PDF File | Image

Download Page 9 PDF File | Image

Future scanning projects are planned by the International Arcade Museum Library (IAML).

Pro Tip: You can flip pages on the issue easily by using the left and right arrow keys on your keyboard.