Music Trade Review

Issue: 1903 Vol. 36 N. 24

Music Trade Review -- © mbsi.org, arcade-museum.com -- digitized with support from namm.org
6
MUSIC TRADE
TH
REVIEW
EDWARD LYMAN
BILL,
EDITOR AND PROPRIETOR.
J. B. S P I L L A N E
if it were not known that anything of the sort was quite out of the
question.
Basing the conclusion on these premises and on other reports
it may be said that the prosperity of the country at the present
time is on approximately a fifteen per cent, basis of increase which
is large enough to be satisfactory without being so great that it
can be construed as unhealthy.
A S the Dealers' National Association becomes stronger, it will
MANAGING EDITOR.
EXECUTIVE STAFF :
THOS. CAMPBELL-COPELAND
ftEO. TV KKLU.U
W. MURDOCH LIXD
A. EDMUND HANSON.
REVIEW
exercise a more important influence on the selling depart-
EMIL.TK FRANCES BAUER
(JEO. W. QUER1PEL
A. J. NICKL1N
Published Every Saturday at I Madison Avenue, New Y o r k . *
SUBSCRIPTION (Including postage), United State*, Mexico and Canada, | 2 . 0 0 per
year; all other countries, f-i.OO.
ADVERTISEMENTS, f 2.00 per Inch, single column, p*>> insertion. On quarterly or
yearly contracts a special discount la allowed. Advertising Pages $50.00 ; opposlU
reading matter, f 7R.00.
REMITTANCES, in other than currency form, should be made payable to Edward
Lyman BUI.
Entered at the New York Post Office as Second Class Matter,
ment of the industry, and it will undoubtedly bring about many
needed reforms in the retailing of pianos.
If a dealer through
surreptitious
methods
obtains
pianos
which are regularly carried by his local competitor and advertises
them at cut rate prices what shall be done with him?
Shall he be expelled from the Association, or shall his methods
be passed by without a protest?
NEW YORK, JUNE J3, 1903.
Will there be men who will say that they see nothing wrong
TELEPHONE NUnBER, I74S-EIOHTEENTH STREET.
THE
On the first Saturday of each month The Review contains in Its
ARTISTS'
"Artists' Dep^lrt^lent" all the current musical news, This U
nE-BKEt-ru
-r effected without In any way trespa«Hing on the size or service
DEPARTMENT of the trade section of the paper. Jt liax a special circulation, and
therefore augments materially the value of The lie view to advertisers.
The directory of piano manufacturing firms and corpora-
CIRECTORY
tlons found
on page 29 will be of great value as a reference for
d l
d
0F PIANO
h
MANUFACTURERS
in advertising a piano at any price provided the advertiser is will-
ing to sell the instrument at the prices named to the first caller who
comes to inspect it and expresses a willingness to purchase?
These rules are conceded to be correct in regular lines of
merchandising, but it would seem to us that stronger measures
should be taken to prevent occurrences of this sort.
The dealer
who finds that his competitor can procure instruments which he
sells regularly and can offer them at practically wholesale rates in
EDITORIAL
his territory, will grow lukewarm in his work in the interests of
J
U N E has opened fairly well notwithstanding many things which
have occurred to act as a detriment to business.
The drought
in the East, the floods in the West, tornadoes in the South and
the piano which can be secured so easily and offered at such prices
as to destroy the reputation which he has created for it.
HT* H E strict legality of a deal of this kind no one can question
*
various strikes and lockouts have all contributed to holding back
because whether there is a profit or not in selling a piano is
entirely the concern of the seller, and following out the same line
business.
The situation as a whole, however, is far from unfavorable.
of argument we might say that he has a right to advertise any
With all due allowance, the heaviest wheat yield on record is
merchandise which he possesses at whatsoever prices he may elect.
still possible and the average crops of corn, oats and cotton may
That might be true in many lines outside of pianos, but unless
be realized.
Higher prices for farm products of all kinds favor
more compensation to producers from this source.
The great West will require many pianos to keep up with the
there are strenuous measures adopted to remove this sort of
juggling from the retail department of trade, manufacturers will
find that their interests will suffer materially.
The dealer who is
The drought in New England and in New York hap-
doing his utmost to build up a name and reputation for his instru-
pily has been broken, and while cereal crops, hay and dairy products
ments locally must be supported to the extent of blocking avenues
have been injured yet the trade situation has materially improved
through which his opponent may obtain instruments of which he
in that section of late.
is the regularly accredited representative.
demand.
I
N the Northwest crop conditions have been almost perfect, and
Inasmuch as no retailer can afford to cut the life out of his
one advantage of this great big country of ours lies in the fact
regular staples, he is not going to be enthusiastic over instruments
that while some sections may be severely hit another may advance
which can be sold in his town at cut rates.
to such a point that it more than outweighs the losses which oc-
I
curred in sections that were hit by droughts or floods.
Railroads are busy, and the gross earnings for May were about
twelve per cent, over 1902.
T is time now for the regular dealer to get his thinking cap on,
and figure how he is going to turn the summer into one of
profit. '
What is the best thing to be done ?
This drift of gain is found to correspond with current reports
If business is to be obtained the usual method in the piano
from other sources including the United States Government Post
line is to force it, for it is conceded that in no other line of mer-
Office reports.
It is a curious fact that the gains and receipts of
chandising is there required the amount of work to develop sales
the post offices of the Union and the gains in gross earnings of
that is necessary according to the present methods of conducting
the railroads are so close to the same ratio of increase that one
piano retailing.
would thkik that there had been some juggling with the figures
Too frequently the way to force piano selling is found by the
Music Trade Review -- © mbsi.org, arcade-museum.com -- digitized with support from namm.org
TH
price cutting method.
MUSIC
TRADE
No retail piano merchant can slash prices
on his staples and expect to hold up his reputation locally.
There
REIVIEIW
It has been charged by the defendant in the case that Mr.
Dutton represented the Association at the now famous Herbert
are plenty of ways to develop trade without the necessity of re-
dinner.
sorting to price cutting on regular styles.
tinctly stated before his audience that he did not speak for the
There are plenty of
As a matter of fact he did nothing of the kind.
He dis-
specialties, plenty of "used" pianos which can be brought out and
Association, but purely as an individual.
served up so that they will become attractive to many purchasers.
Dutton has a strong case, and if it were possible for the defendant
We are facing a period which requires extra exertion, and
to create the impression in court that it was a colossal organiza-
there is nothing like action to carry the business
successfully
through the summer months.
It is plain that Mr.
tion representing millions which desired to crush the freedom of
the press, why it might operate to his advantage before an emo-
One thing the up-to-date dealer should not do, he should not
sail top closely to the business wind, and curb his fall buying to such
an extent that he will be left when the busy season opens.
Above all things, we should say, get stock in splendid shape,
tional jury.
However, thus far, Mr. Dutton's case has not been weakened
by any Association action, and attention cannot be diverted from
the real issues at stake.
do all the weeding out necessary during the summer, and have
plenty of fresh stock on hand to catch the full benefit of the fall
A N examination of the advertising pages of the leading maga-
zines will show that the nianufpxturers of piano players be-
trade.
lieve in exploiting their product before the purchasing masses, and
\ \
7 ITH the summer holiday season at hand, we usually expect
*
a lessening of business activity.
While this may be true
in other lines, there is very little of the relaxation traceable to the
piano man.
the great publicity which the players are receiving must be indeed
helpful to the interests of the dealers everywhere who also must
do their part in further accentuating this good work.
There are a number of piano merchants who have become
While the time is arranged sothat vacations are in order, yet
thoroughly impressed with the importance of interesting the public
in all well conducted establishments there are enough men on hand
in the player, not as a fad, but as a musical necessity in the home.
during the usually dull summer months to make the most of all
Tn order to do this properly they have created special departments
business opportunities, and prc. s to the limit the chances of secur-
which have been devoted solely to the exhibition and sale of
ing trade.
players.
There will be a fair business transacted during the summer
Neat invitations, enclosing interesting player programs have
and notwithstanding labor disturbances which exist in certain lo-
been mailed to prominent citizens of various localities, so that
calities there will be a greatly increased volume carried on in the
musicales which have been given have been attended by interested
fall.
people.
A recent inspection of hundreds of retail warerooms all over
In this way the musical possibilities of the players have
been brought before a select line of people whose attention per-
America induces us to say that dealers cannot expect to have their
haps would not have otherwise been called directly to these mar-
orders promptly filled for the fall trade, if they delay too long in
velous inventions.
placing them.
EALERS who have handled the players in an indifferent man-
H P HIS is practically the middle of June and it takes time to pre-
*
pare and complete wholesale orders for pianos.
The stocks as we view them over the country would average
from twelve to fifteen per cent, less in numbers than were visible
in the warerooms last year.
With a shrinkage in the stock, and a
possible increase of ten per cent, in business during the fall months
of this year over that of last it means that there must be activity
in the manufacturing department throughout the entire summer
in order to satisfactorily comply with the orders which dealers
will send in and expect to have promptly filled.
Now the dealers themselves should not delay too long in plac-
ing their fall orders. They should be made up at once, and placed
with the manufacturers so that they may also make preparations
to take care of their trade in a satisfactory way so that no time
may be lost or nerve force exhausted in telegraphing rush orders
at the last moment.
ner have not been satisfied with the results, and they never
will be.
To secure the agency for a piano player and expect that the
agency will develop into a splendid demand for these instruments
without special exertion on the part of the agent is ridiculous.
The only way the player business can be made to pay and pay
handsomely, is to exploit it along special lines.
Arrange an attractive department, conduct it in an interesting
way and have a player expert in charge.
We know of one dealer who decided upon this course with
evident reluctance.
He grumbled about the expense and regretted
at the outset in giving up so much space to the exhibition of what
he termed
a passing
fad.
Now he is one of the most enthu-
siastic men to be found in the business because his special work
has paid him handsome profits, and others can obtain like results
provided they push the business in the manner which the subject
W
H I L E there has been considerable said criticising the wis-
dom of the Association in passing resolutions offering to
merits
To develop the player business to splendid proportions special
bear the expenses of Mr. Dutton's suit, as a matter of fact the
treatment is imperative.
resolutions amount to nothing as far as a court argument is con*
the bushel of indifference and expected that its light will shine as to
corned, as long as the proposition was not accepted by Mr. Dutton.
attract liberal patronage.
The piano player cannot be hidden under

Download Page 6: PDF File | Image

Download Page 7 PDF File | Image

Future scanning projects are planned by the International Arcade Museum Library (IAML).

Pro Tip: You can flip pages on the issue easily by using the left and right arrow keys on your keyboard.