Music Trade Review

Issue: 1901 Vol. 32 N. 9

Music Trade Review -- © mbsi.org, arcade-museum.com -- digitized with support from namm.org
58 Pages.
THE
fflJflC TIRADE
NEW
V O L . XXXII. N o . 9 . Published Every Saturday Dy Edward Lpan Bill at 3 East Fourteentii Street, Mew YorK, March 2,1901.
HERBERT HEMINGWAY JOY.
T is quite unnecessary to state that the
best teachers of vocal music are those
who have come into it through having been
first instrumental musicians; for then the
voice is not treated as a thing apart and
distinct from music, but as a part of the
entire machinery, the beautiful result of
which is a well-trained voice and a musi-
cianly knowledge of what to do with it.
Herbert Hemingway Joy, who has re-
cently come to New York, has located at
Carnegie Hall in the capacity of vocal
teacher. Whereas Joy is not so well known
to the East as he is in other fields, two of
his pupils have become favorites in their
homes as well as in many musical centres
where they have sung with notable success.
These pupils are Mrs. Emma Porter Makin-
son, of Pittsburg, and Frank King Clark,
of Chicago, both of whom concede the sat-
isfactory results to be due to Joy's skillful
and conscientious work.
Joy commenced his career as pianist and
studied music under A. K. Virgil, when
this well-known instructor had his con-
servatory in Burlington, Iowa. He also
studied organ and harmony under James
H. Rogers, and taught at the Burlington
College. At the same time he held the
position of bass soloist in Dr. Salter's
church, and the success with which he met
in this field induced him to give himself to
vocal music entirely. Joy studied with L.
A. Phelps, in Chicago, and Gottlieb Feder-
lein, in New York. He taught at Burling-
ton, Keokuk, and at the Iowa College of
Grinnell, for some time, and then located
in Chicago, where he had much success as
teacher and as bass of the Evanston Pres-
byterian Church. Owing to ill health in
the family, Joy was compelled to make a
change of climate which took him to the
Pacific Coast, where it did not take long
for those seeking musical advancement to
realize the benefit that this man could be
to a community.
He was tendered the organ of the First
Congregational Church at Tacoma at the
largest salary given on the coast, and he
also was made director of the choral so-
cieties of Tacoma and Seattle, rival cities
in all save in appreciation of Joy's abilities.
During his sojourn there he gave such
works as Messiah, Elijah, Creation, Stabat
Mater and similar masterpieces with such
success that the musical life in the North-
west felt his presence forcibly. For six
years Joy was director of the Cecilia So-
ciety, an organization of women's voices,
I
which was notably one of the finest of its
kind in the country. Meanwhile he ac-
complished so much as teacher that many
of his pupils have branched out as success-
ful singers, and most of the salaried church
singers in Tacoma were his pupils.
Not satisfied, however, to remain in the
far West away from benefits and advan-
tages to himself, he went abroad to spend
some time with the best masters of Europe.
He studied with Garcia in London, with
Trabadello in Paris, and then gave him-
self over to the admirable training of
Delle Sedie, an exponent of whose work
he is.
Joy has given especial care to French
diction, and has entered thoroughly into the
work of the Yersin sisters, having been in-
terested in English diction through a cor-
dial sympathy with Mrs. Pollard, whose
work upon diction has made its way into
the public school system.
Among singers who are well-known on
the Pacific Coast and throughout the coun-
try are, Retta Johnston Shank, Guy Carle-
ton Evans, Harry Hanlon, Rosina Rosin,
Edith Russell, Wilfred Harrison, of Boston.
One of the best was Margaret Macintosh
Marvin, who died in St, Paul, where she
sang at the People's Church.
Among others occupying church posi-
tions in Tacoma are, Grace Clark, Kather-
ine Wentworth, Mrs. Hugh Manny, Paul
Shaw, Winifred Cummings and Edna
Avery. Joy's studio is chaperoned by his
talented daughter who also plays his ac-
companiments.
j*
DOHNANYI'S RECITAL.
C R N S T VON DOHNANYI, whose in-
^
terpretation of the great Beethoven
Concerto in E minor at the last Philhar-
monic Concert was the real attraction, is
to give a Beethoven recital in Mendelssohn
Hall, on this Saturday afternoon, at 3
o'clock. The program will be one of un-
usual interest to all real lovers of music.
No pianist in late years has ever attempted
such a recital, and this will be the first
given since the time of von Eulow and
Eugen d' Albert.
KOFLER IS RETIRED.
Leo Kofler, organist and choir master of
old St. Paul's Chapel, Trinity Parish, re-
tired on a pension February 1. He entered
the position in March, 1877, and won wide
recognition for his work. Mr. Kofler will
now devote his time largely to private
teaching.
Sd.oo FKR YEAR.
SINGLE COPIES 10 CENTS
OPERA FOR NEXT SEASON.
T H E air around the Metropolitan Opera
* House has been thick of late with ru-
mors as to the probability that there would
be no season of opera next winter. The
question has finally been settled, and those
who have been trembling lest they would
have no one to worship next year may now
possess their souls in patience. There will be
opera. A long conference of the Directors
of the Maurice Grau Opera Company was
held at the Opera House on Friday night
while the performance was in progress.
All those at the conference pledged them-
selves to secrecy, but it was learned Mon-
day that a season was decided on.
The season will last only ten weeks, in-
stead of fifteen, as at present, or seven-
teen, as heretofore. It has been seen that
the public is surfeited with opera, and
will attend the performances only when
the most prominent stars are in the cast.
The English season which preceded the
performances in foreign tongues in the
Fall did not aid the cheaper Saturday
night representations this Winter. Fur-
thermore, the company engaged for this
season grew to formidable proportions.
Mr. Grau finds himself overstocked with
sopranos and tenors. Mr. Salignac, for
example, has been heard only once on sub-
scription nights, and has been drawing his
salary for very little work. Mme. Nordica
has been idle, too, much of the time. Miss
Breval has a very limited repertoire, and
can be used only for a few operas. Mr.
Dippel has done substituting principally,
while Mr. Van Dyck has sung only Sieg-
mund and Tannhauser.
By reducing the season to ten weeks the
manager will be able to carry on his work
with a much smaller company. He will
find it possible to get on with a reasonable
number of tenors and sopranos. He will
be able to make stronger casts and to cen-
tralize more effort on his productions.
And the public appetite will be whetted by"
the prospect of having to get its fill in a
short time. Nothing has yet been decided
as to the date at which the season will
begin, but it will undoubtedly be as late as
the middle of December. Who will be in
the company must also yet be a matter of
conjecture. It may be surmised that only
the most attractive and useful members of
the organization will be re-engaged.
Mrs. Antonia Sawyer gave a song recital
at the Waldorf-Astoria. She was assisted
by Messrs. Paul and Franz Listemann and
Isidor Luckstone,
Music Trade Review -- © mbsi.org, arcade-museum.com -- digitized with support from namm.org
THE MUSIC TRADE REVIEW
ARTISTS'
DEPARTMENT.
EMILIE FRANCES BAUER, Editor.
TELEPHONE
NUMBER,
1745—E1QHTEENTH
STREET
The Artists' Department of The Review is
published on the first Saturday of each month.
have become fashionable functions, and to
make sure that they will be there they
are furnished with tickets in order that the
"small but fashionable audience" might be
present. It will be money in the pockets
of him who will be bold enough to ask 50
and 75 cents admission. Mendelssohn Hall
would not hold one-third of the people.
misunderstood, for at the present time
Gabrilowitsch is a most interesting and
skillful pianist; surely time must serve to
make him more valuable else what were
music if the height were reached at the
outset?
Toselli, a young Italian, is of more ten-
der years than any of them. He is too
mature to be termed a prodigy, yet he is
only seventeen. He has a fascinating per-
sonality and in those things which require
delicacy, poetry and naivete^ he has a charm
entirely and decidedly his own. The
Italian pianist is not a familiar figure to
American audiences, and Toselli brings
with him the sunny sky effect of his coun-
try, as also the conviction that he is differ-
ent in many particulars from other pian-
ists. Time is also a requisite to bring him
to the height which, by reason of his
talent, he is expected to reach. Further-
more, he needs transplanting, and he needs
it quickly. All that he has received from
Sgambati and Martucci, has been of rare
value to him and of keen delight to his
hearers, but he has need of Germany and
its rugged mountain roads over the heights
and depths of music, into the genuine
realm of the art. One must eat where
fall the crumbs of Bach, Beethoven and
Brahms; for after all, these represent the
bread, the meat, the life of music.
THIS SEASON'S PIANISTS.
'"THIS has been a remarkable season for
FREE TICKETS OR CHEAPER CONCERTS.
those who are interested in pianists
TN Germany the theatre is very expen-
and their art. Sometimes the lack of art
sive, the concert is very cheap; to this
gives a poignant lesson, so that to the
and to this only may be attributed the
piano student the pianist is worth hearing,
widespread love, appreciation and under-
for he always must have some good points,
standing of music. In America the theatre
and from his faults there is something to
or vaudeville is very cheap and music is
be learned, if only what to avoid.
an exotic, and those who need it do not
New York has had the first hearing of
get it. With few exceptions the general
most of the new artists, as is natural
run of concerts lose money for the man-
enough, although Boston had the first ap-
ager or for the artist as the case may be,
pearance of Harold Bauer, who is foremost
and the cause is due to the fact that there
among the artists new to America this sea-
are so many concerts and they are so ex-
son.
pensive that music students can not go and
It is not extravagant to say that Bauer
society will not, except in rare cases.
is a pianist of colossal attainments; his
Then come the features that these con- poise, his authority and his knowledge are
cert rooms must be filled, even if the box vast; and his technic and touch are unsur-
office is not, and so the "free-ticket" busi- passed by any one who has played this sea-
ness is started and there is nothing more son—or last, for that matter. His is a
detrimental to the art, as an art or as a strong individuality where you would least
business. Between the free tickets and expect it, for he is an unassuming sort of a
the artists who give their services for the person that would not appeal especially to
appearance, music as a money-maker seems the general public, except through the
Dohnanyi is another youth, but another
to be at a low ebb. With no reference to straightforwardness of his art and the hon-
who makes one ask what have years to do
philanthropy it behooves the manager to esty and sincerity with which he gives
with art, for he is finished and thorough.
put money into his house, and to give to forth all that he has to impart. He has no
His first introduction to America occurred
the student the opportunity to hear the art trick to startle or amuse, but he has a deep
very late last season, at which time he won
that he has for sale.
intimate knowledge of music, and this he for himself the respect of all who know
Is it not apparent that this is the only is willing to share with his hearers in a and who admire the most earnest and the
way to create large audiences for the whole-souled manner that brings them face most intellectual in the art of piano play-
future and to put the business on a profit- to face with the music, even to the point of ing. Dohnanyi has figured strongly as
able basis? Reduce the price of concerts forgetting the interpreter. It takes the composer, and in the double role of com-
and fill the concert rooms with the sort of greatest art to be so unselfish. Bauer is poser-pianist he has been subject for much
people that music was created for. Bee- young—so young as to make one wonder admiration. His personality is a strange
thoven, Bach, Brahms, never wrote for the whether years count for anything.
one. He shows timidity which almost
kid-glove fraternity, but for the art itself
Gabrilowitsch is another incomer and seems indifference, and sometimes one
and for those who love and serve it.
newcomer. He comes as a pupil of Le- wonders whether more geniality in his
New York is the spot in America where schetitzky and of Rubinstein. Gabrilo- playing would not be the one point which
students "congregate. It is probable that witsch is very young, so that his career would bring him closer to his hearers.
the teachers they have left are as good as under Rubinstein cannot have been of
Ernest Hutcheson has been heard in
the teachers they have come to, but they very great duration. He shows the Le- Baltimore, but nowhere else. In that city
came that they might have the benefit of schetitzky stamp pre-eminently. Indeed, he has met with the greatest favor. I have
the concerts, and under the great expense one might wish that the Slav had not been not heard him and am unable to give a
of living in places that are fit to live in, so buried; not eradicated, however, for personal opinion.
and studying with teachers of any stand- there is no doubt that as Gabrilowitsch
Breitner comes as pedagogue, and a
ing, it is not very difficult to see that gets further away from his days of study
great one he is in addition to his artistic
concerts are entirely out of their financial the individuality of his country will super-
and refined pianism. Very sincere and
reach.
sede that of his teacher. He is an artist very unassuming, but above all he im-
Again, be it understood, that this is not of great attainments, with the emotional presses one as a deep scholar.
written as an appeal to the managers on side strongly developed. He is a senti-
Joseffy, he who is king of all pianists,
behalf of students, but to impress them mentalist and to this he gives up rhythm and who is dearer to the American than
with the fact that the thousands who want frequently. He is in the melo-dramatic any other (for does he not belong to us?)
to go to concerts cannot go, and the hun- period of his career and of his life. With has kept us hungering for an appearance
dreds who do not want to go, are once in a this over he will be more valuable to art this season, and now, owing to the recent
while seen there because, alas! concerts than he is at present. This must not be death of his mother and his departure for

Download Page 3: PDF File | Image

Download Page 4 PDF File | Image

Future scanning projects are planned by the International Arcade Museum Library (IAML).

Pro Tip: You can flip pages on the issue easily by using the left and right arrow keys on your keyboard.