Music Trade Review

Issue: 1901 Vol. 32 N. 17

Music Trade Review -- © mbsi.org, arcade-museum.com -- digitized with support from namm.org
THE MUSIC TRADE REVIEW
TWENTY-SECOND YEAR.
would be impossible to carry out a scheme
of this sort, but if a regular price were es-
tablished and adhered to with a moderate
amount of persistence, it would operate not
only to the advantage of a manufacturer in
maintaining a prestige for his instruments,
but to the advantage of the dealer as well
who retails them.
In England local dealers have brought
this matter before their association, and
some of the great English makers have in-
sisted upon a minimum price for their in-
struments, or in other words, have demand-
ed an agreement from the dealer not to sell
instruments below a certain fixed price, in
order that the reputation of the maker shall
not be depreciated. They do not state what
the maximum price is, for they figure that the
dealer may get what he considers a fair
profit, but they name a point below which
he cannot go, and retain the agency for their
instruments. The smaller English makers
are not in sympathy with this move. On the
Continent there is no possibility that any
such contract will be entered into in a large
way, but in England the idea of having a
fixed minimum price is steadily gaining
ground. Another topic for the meeting of
piano men to consider next month.
corporated are not meeting with the success
which their promoters fondly hoped. Sel-
dom has an occurrence stirred more comment
or aroused more widespread interest than
the recent great combination known as the
Associated Merchants Co., which was re-
EDWARD LYMAN BILL,
cently
launched in this city. The leading
EBITOR AND PROPRIETOR.
merchants of our town take no particular
J . B. S P I L L A N E , MANAGING EDITOR
stock in the success of this organization.
THOS. CAMPBELL-COPELAND
WALDO E. LADD
Executive Staff:
John Wanamaker said that such combina-
GEO. W. QUERIPEL
A. J. NICKLIN
tions—though the order of the day—may
not possibly be so effective as applied to dis-
Pifflflal Every Satnrflay at 3 East 14th Street, New
tribution as in the field of production. In
SUBSCRIPTION (including postage), United States, Mexico
and Canada, $2.00 per year; all other countries, $4.00.
ADVERTISEriENTS, $2.00 per inch, single column, per
the management of a successful department
insertion. On quarterly or yearly contracts a special discount
is allowed. Advertising Pages |;o.oo, opposite reading matter,
store, for example, is not the individuality
$75.00.
REfUTTANCES, in other than currency form, should be
of its controlling spirit an asset of the first
made payable to Edward Lyman Bill.
Entered at the New York Post Office as Second Class Matter
importance ? Being so, will not the purchase
and amalgamation of various stores eliminate
NEW YORK, APRIL 27, 1901.
TELEPHONE NUMBER, J745-E1QHTEENTH STREET.
those forceful factors to the corresponding
THE
On the first Saturday of each
impairment of their earning power and pros-
ARTISTS 1
month The Review contains in its
pective worth?
DEPARTMENT " Artists' Department" all the cur-
rent musical news. This is effected
Henry Siegel believes that that combin-
without in any way trespassing on the size or ser-
vice of the trade section of the paper. It has a
ation
can have no far-reaching influence
special circulation, and therefore augments mater-
ially the value of The Review to advertisers.
on the retail trade. Louis Stern states that
Claflins could buy a store, and stock, and
The directory of piano manu-
DIRECTORY OF
PIANO
facturing firms and corporations
MANUFACTURERS found on page 22 will be of great
presumably a name, but prestige is not trans-
value as a reference for dealers and others.
ferable.
A directory of all advertisers
DIRECTORY OF
Judge Hilton succeeded to the Stewart
The Review will be found on
ADVERTISERS
business, but of what value to him was that
page 6.
once priceless estate, when bereft of the
founder's genius? We quote these leading
GOING BEYOND SAFE DEPT HS.
EDITORIAL
men to show that even in the dry goods
TT HERE is no mistak-
trade the matter of individuality is strongly
Why the talk of a
ing the fact that
MAINTAINING A MINIMUM PRICE.
piano trust contin-
marked.
ues—Opinions of mer- the whole country has
THE
question of
question
If it is so in a trade made up of thousands
Should a minimum
chants—The strength
got the speculative fe-
price be maintained?
maintaining prices
of individuality.
of
small items, how much more is it in an
Methods of a class of
ver, and because this
is one always pregnant
customers—Of advan-
industry like the piano, where one name
tage to manufacturer
with deep interest for speculative fever is rampant, is one of stands for the entire product, and around
and dealer.
the manfacturer as well the best reasons in the world why the sub- that name is clustered a sentiment which
as the dealer. There are all kinds of in- ject of a piano combination, or trust, con- dates back, in many cases, for more than
fluences brought to bear upon the dealer tinues to be a live one in trade circles. The half a century!
to shatter his fixity of price. There are some stories of millions constantly made by pro- TRADE ORGANIZATIONS WISER.
people who will obtain prices from one deal- moters and operators of new corporations
Interests of employ- J N the consideration
er and employee mu-
er for a certain make of instrument, and capitalized at hundreds of millions, have
of the whole labor
tual—No restrictions
then immediately confer with another deal- caused many people to lose their sound, com-
upon productive pow- question, as well as the
er-Hust be free from
er who represents the same piano in adjoin- mon-sense reasoning.
more concrete problem
labor dictation.
In many villages and cities throughout the
ing territory, stating to the latter that they
of dealing with the va-
land,
people
are
subscribing
for
the
circu-
have been offered such and such an instru-
rious organizations, it appears to be compar-
ment at a figure far below the price which lars of a horde of tipsters who, for a few atively clear that it is largely an educational
number two has placed upon the instrument, dollars, promise to get them rich. Enticing matter after all. Men themselves now see
when, as a matter of fact, possibly dealer tales are told regarding the stupendous rise the wisdom as well as the necessity of the
number one has made no reduction what- of certain stocks, like the Standard Oil, but use of clear and precise language in their
ever in his price. Recently we knew of a the reverse of the medal is never exhibited. agreements, and are more impressed with
lady who claimed that a ridiculously low The thousands who have lost their all in the idea* of excluding unreasonable and il-
figure was offered her on a
piano. The these South Sea bubble schemes are never logical demands. It is so evident a busi-
dealer stepped to the 'phone and a short brought out to view. The extravagant de- ness proposition that the consequent in-
talk with the dealer named convinced him lirium of prosperity is causing a number of crease in the cost of any manufactured ar-
that the lady materially elongated the truth people to go beyond safe depths in business ticle must necessarily be followed by an in-
affairs. Investors in sound properties that crease in its price, hence an immediate ten-
in her statement.
are
yielding satisfactory returns have nothing dency is created to curtail the demand and
If there were a regular price maintained
for certain standard makes of pianos in all to fear, but it is emphatically a time to ex- restrict the output, and the trade organi-
territories there would be less work of this ercise a fair amount of caution and discrim- zations must eventually recognize the fact
that their interest can never be served by
kind and the piano business would lose some ination in stock ventures.
REMEW
of its disagreeable and annoying features.
Of course with the cheap instruments, it
w
E understand that a number of the lat- creating an injurious or unfair condition to
est trust schemes which have been in- their employers. It is a trite but true say-
Music Trade Review -- © mbsi.org, arcade-museum.com -- digitized with support from namm.org
THE MUSIC TRADE REVIEW
ing that the interests of employer and em-
ployee are mutual, but both are too apt to
forget that any departure from this princi-
ple on the part of either, can but result disas-
trously; therefore, instead of an attempt to
restrict production, the trades unions should
confine themselves to a demand for reason-
able working hours, and a fair day's wage,
leaving the manufacturer at entire lib-
erty to adjust his cheap methods to the end
that there be no increase in cost of produc-
tion, or restriction of output.
If the piece-work system is a solution of
the problem, it certainly is neither proper
nor economically right to oppose them, for
the interests of the employer must be con-
served in order that a fair day's wage be
paid. In order to reap the highest results
there should be no restriction placed upon
the management or production of the shop
or factory. The relations between employer
and employee are stated succinctly in the
resolutions recently passed by the National
Metal Trades Association:
"We are willing to grant to our employees
all reasonable concessions in the matters of
hours of work and wages, but we deem it
our duty in our own interests, and for the
good of the public, who are practically de-
pendent upon machinery and its product, to
take every means to increase the productive-
ness of the American mechanic, and to pre-
serve freedom of employment to workmen
and freedom of management to employers."
This is the right kind of industrial free-
dom, and should be read by the officers of
all labor organizations in the land.
LACK OF COMMERCIAL MORALITY.
T will interest mem-
To prevent trade-
bers of the music
m.rkpoachin,-n M n.
whose trade-
other—Henry F. nil- mark
preserves have
ler's position.
been constantly poached
upon by imitators, to know that there has
been a concern organized for the substan-
tial protection of trade mark and copyright
owners.
The fact that there should be not only a
place, but the necessity for such an associa-
tion as this, demonstrates the lack of com-
mercial morality which exists among a cer-
tain class. After a concern has spent years
in building up a reputation for its trade-
mark, and giving a value to it, it is the mean-
est kind of thievery for a rival to attempt to
secure a business by appropriating a trade-
mark which the work and money of another
has made valuable.
The action of a competing firm who would
imitate such a trade-mark is as criminal as
that of the sneak thief, forger, or counter-
feiter of public money, and all true merchants
should aid in carrying out plans to prevent
such happening. There are concerns in this
trade that have sought to palm off the imi-
tation as the original brand, and one of the
firms who deserve credit for their action
in bringing offenders to justice is the Henry
F. Miller concern, of Boston.
We may add, too, that another long mark
that should be placed to the credit of this
institution is the fact that for years they
have stood the abuse of the blackmailer with-
out yielding or even flinching.
If there were more such concerns in the
industry who exhibited the right kind of
vertebrae, the exit of the blackmailer would
have been sooner. In fact, he would not
have stepped out, but he would have been
ejected with such violence that some time
would have elapsed before he would have
entirely recovered his equilibrium together
with his cast-iron nerve.
THE VALUE OF A GOOD NAME.
T" 1 HE value of a good
Honor valued even
name is. appreci-
among thieves How
appreciated by busi- 1
ness
men—Correct ated even among that
principles must back portion of society who
combination.
are known as the light-
fingered gentry.
The other day when a broken-down thief
negotiated the return of the famous Gains-
borough picture, which he had cut from its
frame during the days of his buoyant man-
hood, when his desire to steal ran strongly
within his veins, whom did he select as the
man to arrange matters? Strange to say,
he did not select either a lawyer, a business
man, or a clergyman, but a gambler—a man
who, in the opinion of most of us, had
never earned an honest dollar. This gam-
bler not only did not betray the thief, but
handed over several thousand dollars, paid
for the picture, nor even asked a cent com-
mission from either side of the case.
Here is a reputation for downright, un-
impeachable honesty where one would least
expect it.
The incident tends to prove how impor-
tant such a reputation is, even in proceedings
that are of a shady nature. How much more
is it true in the case of a legitimate busi-
ness? The value of a good name is being
more highly appreciated daily, and if a man
be connected with the trust move whose
actions are looked upon with distrust, and
whose entire history reeks with intrigue,
and who, even now, is accused of libeling
women, such a man is hardly the one of the
right kind of reputation to interest the piano
man, even if he be weary of carrying on the
competitive battle.
No, .it requires a reputation to establish
anything on a right kind of basis, and it re-
quires at least an honorable reputation to
make the inceptive move towards organiz-
ing a piano combination.
If it were not so, it would be indeed a sad
commentary upon the morality of the Ameri-
can music trade.
FLOTSAM AND JETSAM.
| T is said that the meeting of those inter-
ested in the formation of a piano trust
occurred this week in the St. James Building,
Twenty-sixth street and Broadway. A list
of all present and interested in the move in-
cluded : Marc Anthony Blumenberg, Marc
A. Blumenberg, M. A. Blumenberg, M.
Anthony Blumenberg, Anthony Blumenberg,
A. Blumenberg, and plain Blumie. Tre-
mendous enthusiasm in favor of the organi-
zation was reported, and all present signed
a document agreeing to any disposition
which the gentlemen represented might make
of their properties, so long as it was satis-
factory to themselves and all others whose
interests might be drawn in later on.
'T' WO weeks ago we referred to an exhi-
bition proposed by dickering & Sons,
which will illustrate a century's progress in
piano making and all interests closely allied.
This announcement should interest Chicker-
ing dealers all over America, who, no doubt,
will be able to add, through their customers,
many interesting as well as historical fea-
tures to the exposition.
It is proposed to amplify this scheme, so
that not only pianofortes will be included,
but all musical instruments of the past cen-
tury, so that the affair, which will be held
probably in Symphony Hall in Boston, will
be fittingly illustrative of the growth and de-
velopment of musical interests in America
during the century so recently laid to rest.
The date upon which the exposition
will open has not as yet been announced, but
it will probably occur some time during the
fall months. In the meanwhile it is desir-
able that all who can contribute to this inter-
esting event look to it that all historic instru-
ments within their bailiwick be rounded up
for the proposed exposition.
C LOODS and depressing weather have
had a serious effect upon all kinds of
business interests. During the month the
piano merchant has been forced with others,
to stand his share of loss in consequence of
depressed conditions.
]\]O financial embarrassment of any music
trade concern for years has created the
surprise in trade circles that has been caused
by the latest showing of the Rohlfing busi-
ness in Milwaukee. The condition of this
concern should furnish an object lesson to
those who are adhering to antiquated meth-
ods in the conduct of their business affairs.
No firm can afford to rest even for a brief
, period, upon past prestige. Every possible
avenue of progress must be forced to the
utmost. Dry rot means business disintegra-
tion.
formal opening of the Exposition
T HE at Buffalo
will be delayed until May 20.

Download Page 6: PDF File | Image

Download Page 7 PDF File | Image

Future scanning projects are planned by the International Arcade Museum Library (IAML).

Pro Tip: You can flip pages on the issue easily by using the left and right arrow keys on your keyboard.