Music Trade Review

Issue: 1901 Vol. 32 N. 12

Music Trade Review -- © mbsi.org, arcade-museum.com -- digitized with support from namm.org
THE MUSIC TRADE REVIEW
THE PIANO TRUST,
Exists Not, Save in the Minds of Manipulators—Great Names have been Used In Connection
with the Scheme—Distinguished Houses Repudiate All Connection with It—The Review
Presents Facts and Settles the Rumor mil.
For some time past statements have been
circulating to the effect that, in a quiet way,
arrangements were steadily going on towards
the perfection of a piano trust. During the
past ten days reports have reached a certain
definiteness, and it has been stated that
prominent members of the industry had al-
ready given their consent to participate in
the combination.
We have placed but little faith in the cor-
rectness of these statements, as we have
viewed the matter -purely in the light of a
speculative scheme, concocted by a few skill-
ful manipulators in New York in connec-
tion with a man who was identified with the
former trust scheme, and who secured a
great many confidential reports concerning
the standing of individual concerns.
That these reports have figured in the pres-
ent trust scheme is positive. One man, a
manufacturer, stated to The Review that he
saw these papers while in Cincinnati this
week. He also stated that he was positive
that a number of the old-established Eastern
concerns had already become parties to a
tentative trust organization.
From another source it was stated to
us that the trust deal would go through this
time, and that the combination would be
composed of twenty of the largest houses
in the trade, the names of which were given,
and that E. S. Conway would be elected the
first president.
From another source it was stated that
Chas. H. Steinway would be the first one to
occupy the executive chair in the proposed
piano trust.
From a number of sources we have received
these statements, and we always consider
that it is the duty of the paper to ascertain
the correctness of such statements and to ef-
fectually kill ridiculous rumors which are be-
ing circulated. To that end we placed our-
selves in communication with many of the
leading houses in the United States, and have
received from them condensed reports con-
cerning their position regarding the trust.
NEW YORK.
Chas. H. Steinway:—"I will say emphat-
ically that this matter has not been considered
by Steinway & Sons, and we have no propo-
sition of any nature regarding a possible trust
now up for discussion."
A thorough canvass of the entire industry
in New York shows that the trust scheme
has obtained no foothold here.
It has been stated that a firm of promoters
—Davis & Co.—with offices in the Produce
Exchange, were behind the move, but no
such firm exists in that building.
Boiled down, the consensus of opinion of
the New York trade on the trust situation is
practically this : That if money were offered,
and enough of it, the piano industry could be
organized, but many consider a piano trust
absolutely an impossibility for the reason that
it would take so much money to purchase it
on a cash basis that that money could not be
found available, and even if it were, no soon-
er would men dispose of their properties than
they would shortly re-engage in the piano
business, and it would take more capital than
it did in any other of the trust combinations
to buy up the new concerns, who would con-
stantly be entering as competitors. Then
again, the dealers themselves would not fav-
orably entertain a trust proposition. They
would rather buy of a combination against
a trust than from the trust itself.
The statement, too, has been made that im-
portant dealers in various cities themselves
would become stockholders in the piano
trust.
That is too absurd for consideration. We
question if one dealer could be located who
would become an owner of piano trust stock.
BOSTON.
U
Starr Piano Co., Richmond, Ind.:—"Have
not joined any piano trust."
Packard Co., Ft. Wayne, Ind.:—"We have
not joined piano trust."
D. H. Baldwin & Co.:—"We have not
joined piano trust."
Krell Piano Co.:—" Know nothing of
trust."
PHILADELPHIA, PA.
Blasius & Sons Piano Co. deny the rumor
that they are to join a piano trust combina-
tion.
The Lester Piano Co. also deny the report.
*
*
*
*
So that even if a tentative organization
exists to-day it does not include the names
necessary to make it even a temporary suc-
cess.
It is the duty of a paper to give the inside
facts and expose fraudulent representations
made by certain schemers, who are plotting
the absorption of an industry. Our desire
in this matter is to show how the situation ex-
ists to-day, and to prick this trust bubble so
that it will not be heard from for some time.
There is no question but that the names of
certain members of the industry have been
used as an argumentative drawing power to
win some men over into an acquiescence of
the trust proposition. As a matter of fact,
there are very few men indeed who have
thus far even given a tacit recognition of the
existence of the trust manipulators. It is a
scheme carried wholly along the lines of
bluff.
That the alleged piano trust has not ob-
tained a strong foothold in Boston will be
seen from the following:
Chickering & Sons :—"We have not joined
any piano trust."
Vose & Sons:—"We deny the report and
know nothing about the matter."
Mason & Hamlin Co.:—"Absolutely no
truth in the report that we have joined the
piano trust."
Poole Piano Co.:—"Have not joined pi-
ano trust, nor have we been approached."
Ivers & Pond Piano Co.:—"No truth in
Great Packard Prosperity.
report that we have joined piano trust."
[Special to The Review.]
Emerson Piano Co.:—"We know nothing
Ft.
Wayne,
Ind., March 21, 1901.
whatever about the piano trust."
A.
S.
Bond,
secretary
and general mana-
Hallet & Davis Piano Co.:—"Absolutely no
ger
of
the
Packard
Co.,
is back once more
truth in the report. Never even heard of
in
harness
after
one
of
the
pleasantest and
piano trust."
most
successful
trips
he
ever
had through-
BALTinORE, MD.
out
the
West.
Since
his
return
he has been
Wm. Knabe & Co., whose name has been
very
busy,
as
orders
have
crowded
up in
mentioned in connection with the trust, deny
both
piano
and
organ
departments.
The
absolutely the report, and say that they have
Packard
outlook
is
even
more
promising
for
not heard of the piano trust.
a larger piano and organ trade than at the
IN NEW YORK STATE.
same period last year. This, in view of the
Foster-Martin-Armstrong
combination, fact that 1900 was a banner year, speaks elo-
Rochester, deny the report and say that they quently of Packard progress.
have not joined any trust.
Chatting with Mr. Bond this week, he
Waterloo Organ Co.:—"We have not been said: "Everywhere I go the Packard piano
approached upon the subject."
is a favorite, not only with the men who buy
Wegman Piano Co.:—"Report absolutely them, but with the men who sell them. They
false. Know nothing about trust, have not are their best friends, and where a salesman
been approached on subject."
likes an instrument it is not difficult to get
CHICAGO.
the man who puts up the money to buy what
The Chicago piano manufacturers evident- the salesman wants, and I am pleased to say
ly do not believe in the trust proposition.
that this is our stronghold; in other words,
Smith & Barnes Piano Co.:—"We do not the Packard piano is an easy seller, and in
know of any trust."
many cases sells itself, and that is what sales-
The Cable Piano Co.:—"This company is men like."
not a member of any piano trust."
Geo. P. Bent:—Out of town, but his bro-
"Ricca & Son. »•
ther says: "Know nothing about a trust, but
can say positively, no, as far as we are con-
Hugo F. Ricca, son of Luigi Ricca, head of
cerned."
the L. Ricca Piano Co., is to become an ac-
Steger & Sons:—"Have not joined any pi- tive partner in this business. Hereafter, the
ano trust or combination except our own."
business will be conducted as "Ricca & Son"
OTHER POINTS IN THE WEST.
—a partnership instead of a corporation.
A. B. Chase, Norwalk, O.:—"We have not Mr. Ricca is a well-equipped piano man and
worthy of the honor bestowed on him.
jonied a piano trust."
Music Trade Review -- © mbsi.org, arcade-museum.com -- digitized with support from namm.org
THE MUSIC TRADE REVIEW
Artist and Instrument Praised.
The Melville Clark Piano.
Wareroom Notes.
Since the remodelling of the Everett ware-
rooms, the interior has undergone a marvel-
lous change. The grands and uprights have
been re-grouped and supplemented by numer-
ous examples of every leading style. There
is now on exhibition a splendid array of con-
cert and parlor Everett grands.
*
*
*
*
The iEolian warerooms are constantly re-
ceiving new artistic touches. Among the lat-
est additions are desks of uniform size and
color for members of the staff, arranged along
the western side at the northern end of the
main floor. The general grouping of fur-
niture and pictures, and the blending of col-
ors throughout, combine to make these ware-
rooms at once elegant and attractive.
*
*
*
*
Hardman, Peck & Co. were exceptionally
fortunate in securing the whole first floor of
the new building at the corner of Nineteenth
street and Fifth avenue. In the matter of
area, light, ventilation and general fitness
for the purpose of exhibiting grand pianos,
the new quarters are probably the finest in
the United States. In fact, it is a question
if they are not the finest in the world.
*
*
*
*
Kranich & Bach do a large retail business
in this city at the headquarters on Twenty-
third street, many of the purchasers being
callers who have been recommended by their
friends. The retail stock on exhibition is
The Lesson it Teaches.
usually large and always choice. As The
The auction room is an excellent place to Review has had occasion to remark before,
glean an idea of the value of advertising. it is invariably well kept and methodically
For instance, last Tuesday night, Benjamin arranged, so that visitors may readily see the
S. Wise sold fifty pianos by auction at his various designs and woods. All of these
warerooms in West 125th street. The prices points tell in trying to make a sale.
realized for the different instruments seem to
Kranich & Bach.
*
*
*
*
have been proportionate to the value given
Shortly
after
the
Needham
Piano
& Organ
The business report of Kranich & Bach for the name stencilled thereon by advertising
Co.
moved
into
their
present
quarters
at the
the week shows healthy activity at the fac- on the part of the manufacturer.
southwest
corner
of
Fifteenth
street
and
Fifth
tory, and a good demand among the agencies
For instance, a Steinway upright that had avenue, the excellence of their window dis-
in all sections. Victor W. O'Brien, traveler seen service for a quarter of a century
for the firm, starts at an early date on a brought $305, and a Chickering practically as play was noted in The Review. This spe-
lengthy tour covering, along with other ter- old brought $290. A little later a piano of cial feature has been consistently maintained
ever since. The JSTeedham windows are to-
ritory, the Southern and the Pacific Coast.
an old-time maker, still in the trade, but who day among the most attractive on Fifth ave-
Among recent callers at the wareroomswas believes that advertising is a waste of money,
W. H. Keller, Kranich & Bach representative was put up. It was not in use for a year and nue. Every advantage is taken of the excel-
at Easton, Pa. Mr. Keller selected stock for should on the basis of actual merit have real- lent location to display tastefully and im-
early shipment. He is a firm believer in the ized almost as much as the old Steinway and pressively, the latest of the Needham prod-
Kranich & Bach products and has made an Chickering sold previously, yet the amount ucts.
*
*
*
*
excellent record in his territory.
realized was only $120.
At the Mathushek warerooms the exhibit
44
A cheap piano, made by a Harlem maker is large and very choice, in addition to being
Crown" Publicity.
who
stencils, yet believes in advertising, was artistically arranged and well kept. The
In the Chicago Tribune of Sunday last
put
up
after this instrument. It had been in Broadway warerooms are now much resorted
there was a very attractive full-page adver-
use
a
couple
of years, nevertheless it realized to by intending piano purchasers, many of
tisement devoted to Crown pianos. A num-
$145-
whom leave orders.
ber of the latest designs—extremely hand-
May Be Commissioner.
The deduction from these facts is self-evi-
some instruments, by the way—were shown,
dent.
The
buying
public
instinctively
value
It seems likely that Frederick J. Allen, of
accompanied by well-written and pertinent
reading matter. The following sample will pianos, nowadays, whether new or old, ac- Auburn, N. Y., will succeed Chas. H. Duell,
cording to the value created for them in the whose resignation as Commissioner of Pat-
give an idea of the general tenor:
ents is referred to elsewhere in The Review.
"From the Clavichord and Harpsichord to public mind through advertising.
Notwithstanding the best efforts of the The latter will not leave office until April 30.
the Crown piano is a long step, embracing
years of continuous effort, which slowly but auctioneer, every instrument sold Tuesday
Thomas Nelson, secretary of the National
surely wrought out the development of the night maintained a price—not the estimate Musical String Co., is about to erect a hand-
piano. Each step retained the best of the placed upon it by the auctioneer—but the some residence at the corner of College ave-
achievements preceding it, combining them value which the name possesses in the pub- nue and Bishop Place, New Brunswick, JST.
with the highest attainments of the present. lic mind.
J. The house, in its style of architecture
Isn't there a moral in this ?
The Crown piano is the natural and logical
and general attractiveness, will surpass any-
result of the irresistible march of progress
Chas. H. Steinway will leave on the thing in that city. Mr. and Mrs. Nelson will
in the development of the piano."
'Deutschland" early in May for Europe.
occupy their new home next fall.
Ossip Gabrilowitsch, who visited Hartford,
Conn., last week, won a success unparalleled
in that musical center. "Not since Paderew-
ski's visit here," says the Post, "have we
heard a pianist with such a mastery of so
many varying styles. Technically, he has all
the transcendent skill, strength, accuracy and
variety of resource to be found in every great
pianist, and besides he has plenty of tempera-
ment and individuality which are of uncom-
mon beauty and attractiveness. He main-
tains a remarkable repose and assurance in
the face of besetting difficulties, and renders
with an adorning radiance the most compli-
. cated textures, never forgetting the necessity
of technical perfection. Free from all man-
nerisms, he is conscientious in his work and
is devotion itself to whatever be his undertak-
ing. He has an uncommon polish and finish
of style, with a keen feeling of rhythm and
a sensitiveness to all that is beautiful. His
faculty for inspiring his hearers with his
own temperament is the same as that of Pad-
erewski."
This paper then proceeds to give a lengthy,
well-written and critical analysis of the pro-
gram in which Gabrilowitsch's work com-
mands the highest possible praise. It is re-
lated that the concert closed with an exhibi-
tion of enthusiasm that "threw in the shade"
the reception accorded any artist who has
visited Hartford in years.
The following sentence in reference to the
superb Everett concert grand which he
played is a compliment well deserved: "His
instrument last evening was a songster of
almost human possibilities in such hands as
his."
The following letter, received by the Mel-
ville Clark Piano Co., Chicago, from Joseph
Bohmann, the world-renowned manufacturer
of stringed instruments, of that city, is an
eloquent and forceful tribute to the pianos
made by Melville Clark:
Dear Sirs:—Please find enclosed check
for balance due on piano I bought of you
December 24th.
I want to say to Mr. Melville Clark that
since I was nine years old I have studied mu-
sic and musical instruments for tone. It
took me forty-three years till I concluded I
would have a piano around me in my home,
because wherever I went to hear those artists
I never could be satisfied when the general
public was satisfied. The artist's expression
and technique was great, but that musical,
noisy, whiney, steel tone was always with it.
The tone of your piano is entirely differ-
ent from any piano I ever heard played be-
fore. When I have listened to pianos in the
past, and had the privilege, I always closed
them to deaden that twangy, rattling tone of
the strings—where most of the people think
that the noisier the instrument is the better.
The musical,- voice-like tone must first be
learned. Your piano has that round, big,
full singing tone quality which I have been
for so long a time looking for—where the
vibration of the body of the piano brings out
that tone—the same as a good violin, the tone
must come from the body and not from
the strings. The action of your piano in
combination with its light touch, is wonder-
ful.

Download Page 9: PDF File | Image

Download Page 10 PDF File | Image

Future scanning projects are planned by the International Arcade Museum Library (IAML).

Pro Tip: You can flip pages on the issue easily by using the left and right arrow keys on your keyboard.