Music Trade Review

Issue: 1900 Vol. 31 N. 6

Music Trade Review -- © mbsi.org, arcade-museum.com -- digitized with support from namm.org
THE MUSIC TRADE REVIEW
BUSINESS TALKS WITH DEALERS,
OPINIONS OF BUSINESS MEN IN VARIOUS STATES REGARDING THE EFFECTS OF THE POLITICAL
CONTEST UPON TRADE THE CONDITION OF CROPS METHODS OF COMPETITION AND
POSSIBILITIES OF TRADE BETTERMENT
LIVE TOPICS DISCUSSED THE OUT-
LOOK AS SEEN THROUGH MANY EYES.
[FOURTH SERIES.]
The opinions of business men regarding the effects of the struggle for Presidential
honors upon business, is of keen interest to all. For a number of weeks The Review
proposes to gain such opinions from different dealers throughout the country who natu-
rally are in close touch with the local sentiment in their particular localities.
The interviews will be of great interest to manufacturers because they convey to
them intelligent presentations of live topics from every section of America. There
is no class of merchants in the world who work their respective territories as closely as
piano men. The dry goods houses do not drum for trade in the same systematic man-
ner that is followed out by the piano dealers, hence the latter have endless opportunities
in which to judge of the particular trend of political sentiment as well as the condition
of crops and the possibilities for business in the early fall.
These views, coming as they do from every section in the union, will afford a sub-
stantial platform on which to build the business edifice for the season which is now
rapidly approaching.
We have also gleaned a few opinions relative to the methods of competition used
in the piano line in different states and what possible encouragement there is for better-
ment. The views form a valuable symposium. The piano dealers of the country are
in close sympathy with their local environments, and what is more, know how to ex-
press their views in an interesting and forceful manner.
KOrlLER & CHASE, San Francisco, Cal.
in circulation, and as a consequence, we
We assure you in the first place that we are receiving numbers of inquiries for
have given but little thought to the com- deals on a spot cash basis. A month ago,
ing political struggle, for the reason that the prospects for fair crops of cotton and
we have been very busy attending to in- corn were a little doubtful, but the recent
creased trade and making preparations for showers we have had have changed all
still more; for, of course, McKinley and this and the prospects now are very favor-
prosperity will stay with us yet another able for good crops of all farm products.
four years.
We think that the good times prevailing
The California fruit crop promises to be during the present presidential term have
exceptionally good.
been so satisfactory to every one, that
Oil land's are booming and fabulous Mr. McKinley will succeed himself in the
stories are told of the wealth being de- presidential chair.
veloped in the oil industry in the middle
We trust that the above estimate will
and southern parts of the State.
soon prove to be history.
The calamity howler finds people too MORGAN MUSIC CO., Arkansas City, Kan.
busy to listen to his tale of woe, and on all
This city is located in the heart of the
sides are seen evidences of a prosperous wheat belt—draw a circle of thirty-five
season.
miles around this city, we have ten mil-
Political campaigns, in common with all lion bushels of wheat raised this year—no
promoters of public excitement, absorbs at- thanks to Mark or Mack. In regard to
tention to the detriment of trade in our methods of competition, we had a sample
line. At least, that is our experience.
of it three years ago here engineered by a
You inquire about methods of competi- Boston manufacturer selling pianos on
tion. There is too much that is bad about $5-a-month payments; the salesman curb-
them, as you can realize when we say that stoned here for two years, swamped the
advertisements are scattered broadcast of- Kansas City house for $14, and broke the
fering to sell pianos on installments of $3 factory. The prospects are good for a fine
per month.
trade this fall. Bryan will carry this state
Your piano man must indeed be a smart as he did four years ago by increased major-
one, if he can show his California brother ity.
anything new in the honorable vocation of
GARDNER & OSGOOD, Worcester, Hass.
selling three hundred and fifty dollar pi-
The business outlook for the fall in our
anos for five hundred.
particular branch of the piano business is
Evidently all the Eastern tricks of the very encouraging.
trade have been imported and improved
Although our competition is almost en-
upon here.
tirely of cheap and medium priced instru-
Bad competition is a business killer, but' ments, we have been able to place a very
honest competition is the life of trade.
sa'isfactory number of high-grade pianos
But whether good or bad methods are since we opened this branch last fall.
practiced, the piano man must hustle for Presidential elections in the past have had
his bread and butter.
a tendency to put a damper on the piano
Fortunately for us we have the agency business in this locality and although I
of the ^Eolian Co., whose ^Eolians and find a number of dealers complaining, we
Pianolas, of course, are not subject to any have been quite successful.
direct competition and consequently sell-
We find the farmers about here are a
ing becomes an unalloyed pleasiire.
little uncertain, but on account of the dry
CUMMINGS, SHEPHERD & CO.. Fort Worth, season and not the election.
You ask
Texas.
about the methods of our competitors in
So far as we can judge, the prospects this locality.
for a good business year were never better.
I think it is no worse than other cities of
Basing our opinion from ten years' experi- its size, but should be pleased to see some
ence in Texas in the music business, we method adopted here, whereby all dealers
have no hesitation in saying that the con- would collect the same payments when
dition of the people in this State was never selling pianos on long time.
We have
better than it is this year. The extraor- dealers here that handle commercial instru-
dinary grain harvest which is now being ments and although they charge the price
marketed, and the good prices prevailing of a fair, legitamate instrument, make the
for cattle have put a large amount of money terms at $5.00 per month and many times.
n
nothing down. We do not handle such
trades and when it is necessary to sell on
time, our terms, $25.00 each, and no less
than $10.00 per month. We have no
trouble in getting our price and our terms
on high-grade pianos among the educated
people and do not try to sell the cheap
trade, as we carry no line of pianos in that
class.
Regarding the feeling here as to who
will carry off the presidential honors I
should say that at present it looks very
evenly divided. Although this county is de-
cidedly republican I find a good many favor
the democratic candidates.
WESTERN riUSIC CO., Seattle, Washington.
It is our opinion that the majority senti-
ment of the business men of Seattle as
well as the entire Puget Sound district,
maintains the present tariff and the gold
standard.
We are not posted as to the way the
matter stands with the farmers and busi-
ness men of the eastern part of the State.
Although the State of Washington went
Democratic in '96, we believe that owing
to the phenomenal change in times during
the past four years in the eastern part of
the State, as well as here in the Puget
Sound country, the approaching struggle
for presidential honors will favor de-
cidedly Wm. McKinley.
We have all confidence in the future
prosperity of the "Queen City'' as a com-
mercial city and shipping point as well as
the extensive agricultural districts in East-
ern Washington and the lumber industry
he e on Puget Sound
The crops in the
Eastern part of the State are reported
good and prospects in general look bright
and prosperous for the coming fall trade.
Taking everything under consideration,
the writer is under the impression, that the
method of competition in general in the
piano line is worked upon as honorable a
basis as any place in the United States.
There are about one hundred thousand
people in Seattle at the present time who
are being quite well supplied with pianos
and musical merchandise by the seven
local music dealers of this city.
Of course we have different kinds of pi-
ano men, some of whom show their char-
acteristic way of selling pianos very plain-
ly, and one of the most serious objections
to the piano business here is the fact that
there are being, and have been so many
cheap grade instruments sold, which at the
same time are being held at such ridicu-
lous high prices. Then when it comes to
a real case of competition they cut and
slash on the prices, giving of course the
man with a high-grade piano a disadvant-
age to a certain extent. There is one pi-
ano sold here whose factory home is sup-
posed to be in San Francisco or New York.
We have made an investigation in regard
to the factory, and we have finally come to
the decision that the piano must have in
its early youth got started astray, and has
ever since been homeless.
We wish your paper every success.
P. D. CARR & CO., Nashville, Tenn.
As a general rule a presidential year
usually affects business adversely.
In
this section for the last weeks the inces-
sant rains and high water have been very
damaging to our farmer friends and have of
necessity materially made business duller
than it otherwise would have been. Pros-
pects are brighter now, however, and we
are confident that business will speedily
resume its normal condition. We antici-
pate a good piano business this fall in this
section. The general returning prosper-
ity, which we of the south are feeling, the
universal desire for good money and a sub-
stantial and safe financial system as well
as the personnel of the tickets nominated,
we believe indicate that the voters of the
Music Trade Review -- © mbsi.org, arcade-museum.com -- digitized with support from namm.org
12
THE MUSIC TRADE REVIEW
iron district through Birmingham is in tion. We need " men " at the ballot who
very fine condition. Birmingham is grow- will vote on this basis.
If our government was firmly estab-
ing very rapidly and values are increasing.
Competition in the piano line is very lished and maintained on a moral basis,
strong as the State is fully covered by sev- and moral issues the prime ones, the mon-
eral firms. I mail you a marked paper etary issues would take care of themselves
which will show you the feeling that a and the capital and labor questions would
competitor has for me. All music men I adjust themselves, but as long as men use
think, are doing a good business. For my- office for self aggrandizement instead of
self, I have had the best trade during the serving the people's interests we may not
last twelve months I have ever had during expect trade betterment only for the few.
the history of my business. I expect to WRAY BROS., Dallas, Texas.
remodel my store in this city and have as
YOUMQ BROS. CO , Salt Lake City.
We are away down here in one side of
We believe the political contest about to creditable a store as there can be found in the United States, in what we consider one
our
State.
begin will have a decidedly detrimental
of the greatest, largest and grandest states
effect upon business, until after the elec- LOS ANGELES PIANO CO., Los Angeles, Cal, in the Union, and as a matter of fact, a
We believe the Presidential Election has purely Democratic State, and as our coun-
tion is settled. After the contest, which will
result in the election of Mr. McKinley, we always a more or less unfavorable effect try is a farming and cattle raising one, at
will have four years of unprecedented pros- upon general business. This year we present, and only beginning to branch out
perity. As to the local outlook for crops, think it will be reduced to a minimum. in manufacturing, we do not believe, nor
on account of the drought, we will lose The outlook for business is very good. think that the heavy struggle for Presi-
The election will, undoubtedly, delay, but it dential honors, that is going to be made
about one-third of the crop.
can have but little effect upon the volume this time, will have very much effect on
BYRON r\AUZv, San Francisco, Cal.
The Presidential election does not affect of fall trade when it finally opens. With the our line of business, in this state. At
our business on the coast as much as it exception of the hay and grain crops, the least, we feel sure that it will be nothing
does in the East. We are expecting a country, we believe, is in a prosperous to compare with some of the middle and
good fall trade, and, as the crops are excel- condition; the above named crops suffered eastern states, that are depending very
lent throttghout the state and prices are somewhat from want of rain, otherwise nearly wholly on their manufacturing en-
very good, we see no reason why we should the farmers and ranchers appear reason- terprises.
ably happy.
Our experience in Texas is, that all we
not have the same.
In regard to methods of competition need is good prices for our farming prod-
The methods of competition in the piano
line here are probably the same as in al- here, they are, we presume, about the ucts and cattle, and good seasons, and we
most any other large city. We have a same as obtain nearer the rising sun, always have what we term good business,
large number of stores, and almost every though we hope the method of professing all of which we are surely blessed with
factory is represented here. Many dealers ignorance as to the address or existence of this year. We consider that we have the
in trying to further their business inter- a rival house and the method of selling best business outlook, in Texas for this
ests are offering all sorts of inducements, pianos at $6.00 per month—"nothing down fall's piano and organ trade, that we have
and are giving terms that are below that of and no interest"—is not in vogue there as had for many years, and expect to be able
rental. We have kept aloof from this kind here. We opine there is much more mean- to do ourselves a fair amount of business,
of competition, and do not offer anything for ness, or madness, in the methods cited but we are putting forth every effort possi-
sale less than the $10 a month installment, than business common.sense. Everyman, ble to do a more conservative business than
believing that it is better to do a conserva- in giving his opinion as to who will be the we have ever done heretofore.
tive business than to force pianos on peo- next President, would, undoubtedly, be
Our experience teaches us that most people
ple who cannot afford to pay for the same. biased to some degree by his personal pre- in this country who are in the piano and
In regard, to the election, we believe ference, but the signs, we think, point to organ business, are inclined to sell goods
that there is no doubt that McKinley will the present administration continuing in regardless of whom they sell them to, or
be re-elected, and that California will be office for the next four years. This, in what kind of paper they take, which is
fact, is our reason for believing that the detrimental in many ways to their busi-
upon the right side of the contest.
election
will cause little disturbance in the ness, and especially worrying and vexing
JOHN B^OWN, Wilmington. Delaware.
business world this year, as it is the un- to the factories, who have their men sell-
The building trades here are doing little certainty as to the result rather than the
or nothing, owing to advance in material, actual election "hurrah!" which is de- ing goods for them on a consignment
basis, and giving long winded terms on
mostly caused by "trusts."
trimental to business.
pianos.
Crops are as fine as could be desired; BRYANT E. WADE, Battle Creek, nich.
It cost one and one-third as much ex-
the farmers are anticipating trouble in se-
curing sufficient freight cars for "peaches."
Business will certainly be materially re- pense to sell the poor class of trade that
Work is abundant at all the manufactur- tarded until after the presidential election is not able to buy pianos as it does to
ing plants, and no man need be idle. The and its duration will be determined by the sell parties who are able to make good pay-
result. In this location crops are always ments on instruments and pay them out
prospect for the Fall trade is very good.
As to the Presidential election, my em- good with occasional local exceptions but after they have bought them. In selling a
good class of customers there is no repos-
phatic opinion is that it is 16 to i against farther north they are very poor.
You haven't space nor would you care to sessing or taking back of pianos to be
Bryan; the people do not want the money
question changed but there is a growing print all the methods adopted in piano done which is very expensive to the fac-
unrest against the " t r u s t s " which I think competition. The stencil pianos play alto- tories and dealers, as it costs an average of
will be the downfall of the G.O.P. four gether too large a part and especially as from $20 to $30 to repossess a piano, after
you have put it out to parties who are un-
years hence, if permitted to grow, as they they are not represented as they are.
have done the last few years.
There has been an extreme demand for able to pay for them, consequently we are
E. E. FORBES, Montgomery, Ala.
cheap goods, which demand has lately been becoming more and more inclined to let
the other fellow have the cheap John trade
My opinion is that the election will not slowly decreasing but the coming election that cannot make a good cash payment
have the same bad effect upon business as may change matters either for better or when they buy their piano.
it did four years ago. It is generally con- worse as pianos are strictly a luxury and
As above stated, our opinion is, that we
ceded, I think, through our section of the not a necessity.
will
not be bothered very much this year
The
encouragement
for
trade
betterment
country, that the election of President Mc-
Kinley is assured.
Our state will vote depends wholly upon the election returns. with the presidential election or the agita-
For one in my position, it would be tion of same; at least we have not been up
Democratic. I think a great majority of
our business men are gold standard, there- either presumption or guessing to name to the present date. Our crops are fine,
fore, are not in sympathy with the policy the next president, but if you will allow it and are bringing good prices and our
of our party. Our crops have been very the latter, I will name the present incum- cattle interests were never better in this
much damaged by rains, and cotton seems bent, Honorable Wm. McKinley as his own State, or more profitable than they are at
the present time, which guarantees beyond
to be growing to stalk without fruit, that successor.
any doubt a good business.
Right
here
I
ask
the
indulgence
of
all
has been cultivated, and that which has
We believe that there is a constantly
not been cultivated has been consumed by readers for saying I should be delighted if
growing
determination among the repre-
this
could
be
the
outcome,
if
our
honored
grass. It is now dry here and very warm.
Should we have a drouth of two or three president had retained the dignity of his sentatives of the manufacturers and best
weeks, our crops will amount to very little. office, saved the lives of hundreds of our dealers of our State, for the betterment of
In the event that we have reasonable sea- brave soldier boys, and the souls of hun- the piano and organ trade, in this State
sons from now on until September, we dreds more by abolishing, as was his power and locality, and while competition is very
sharp and hard we feel that the time is
will, I think, have a good fall trade, as the and duty, the accursed "canteen."
indications are that we will get a good
We need presidents as well as men who nearing when the piano business in Texas
price for what product we raise and our will " stand " for principle and not re-elec- will be conducted on as fair and square a
country will not change the present re-
gime. If times were "hard" and business
bad and prospects less bright, such a
change might be desired. What, in our
opinion, brings private success, brings suc-
cess to a great commercial nation like ours
—honesty, integrity, large endeavor and
persistence. We shall be pleased to re-
ceive the copy of your paper containing
the sentiments of the dealers throughout
the country, as it and they will be very
interesting and helpful.

Download Page 9: PDF File | Image

Download Page 10 PDF File | Image

Future scanning projects are planned by the International Arcade Museum Library (IAML).

Pro Tip: You can flip pages on the issue easily by using the left and right arrow keys on your keyboard.