Music Trade Review

Issue: 1900 Vol. 31 N. 11

Music Trade Review -- © mbsi.org, arcade-museum.com -- digitized with support from namm.org
THE MUSIC TRADE REVIEW
tion of the busy world, but the man who
sage to Garcia, the man who does has his
prototype in thousands of busy, industrious
No doubt we can all call to mind certain men, who are each day adding their quota
individuals whom we have met who are to the world's progress.
living on past records, and who are never
The history of this industry offers many
TWENTY-SECOND YEAR.
tired.of talking in season and out of sea- conspicuous examples of where young men
Jt j* EDWARD LYMAN BILL J* J* J*
son about the wondrous accomplishments from the humblest beginnings have worked
Editor and Proprietor.
which
they have possessed and the deals themselves up by their ability to com-
PUBLISHED EVERY SATURDAY
which they have made in days agone.
3 East Uth St., New York
manding positions in the institutions with
SUBSCRIPTION (including postage). United States, Mexico
There
is
still
another
class
who
are
al-
which they have been connected. There
and Canada, $2.00 per year ; all other countries, $4.00.
ADVERTISEMENTS, $2.00 per inch, single column, per
ways dealing in futures, and giving glow- is a splendid opportunity for the ambitious,
insertion. On quarterly or yearly contracts a special discount
is allowed. Advertising Pages $50.00, opposite reading matter
$75.00.
ing accounts of what they intend to do, energetic young men of this trade; for
REMITTANCES, in other than currency form, should be
made payable to Edward Lyman Bill.
and oftentimes to hear them talk one upon the faithful performance of each
Entered at the New York Post Office as Second Class Matter.
would imagine that they were about to days duties depends in a large measure
NEW YORK, 5EPT. 15, 1900.
wipe the earth, metaphorically, with all of what the world calls success.
TELEPHONE NUMBER, 1745-EIQHTEENTH STREET.
their competitors and that every deal that
T H E KEYNOTE.
The first week of each month The Review
was closed in the trade they had a hand in. T T will be remembered that The Review
oontains a supplement embodying the literary
and musical features which have heretofore
predicted at the inception of the labor
There is still another class which in-
appeared in The Keynote. The amalgamation
is effected without in any way trespassing on
cludes real workers and consists of men troubles in Chicago last year, that within
our regular news service. The Review con-
tinues to remain, as before, essentially a trade
who are not wholly content with their past the next twelve months a number of int-
paper.
record but are striving to improve, by appli- portant industries would be operating
The ONLY music TRADE paper which
auxiliary factories outside of Chicago,
received any award at the Paris Exposi- cation, their services to the institution with where they would not be subjected to auto-
tion of 1900 was The Husic Trade Review which they are allied. They are bending
which was given the GRAND PRIX, the all their efforts on the duties of to-day. cratic interference by labor agitators. It
HIGHEST official recognition obtainable What failures or successes they have made would seem as if our predictions were pas-
for any exhibit in any division of art, me- in the past, count as nothing, but they go sably correct.
chanics or industry.
forth to meet the shadowy future full of
THE COMMISSION EVIL.
"OPPORTUNITIES FORSUCCESS.
earnestness and determination to succeed T T is pretty generally conceded that the
\ 1 7 H I L E recently discussing certain trade along the lines of legitimate business com-
commission evil is somewhat of a com-
peculiarities with a local manufac- petition.
plex and difficult puzzle to solve satisfac-
turer, the question of traveling salesmen
For such men there is a great opportunity torily. There are so many elements enter-
was touched upon. This gentleman empha- in this industry.
ing into this commission problem that it is
sized the fact that comparatively few young
There is another class of men who de- almost impossible to make a general rule
traveling salesmen were being educated up vote more time in emphasizing how cold-
to the point of becoming fitting successors blooded and unappreciative their employers which will apply with justice upon all oc-
to some of the road veterans who have, are, when, as a matter of fact, they cannot casions.
It is also admitted that the commission
both in ability and time service, so cleverly
show on their order books enough business evil has reached a point where it is of the
won their distinctive medals of merit.
of a paying character to cover their salary utmost necessity that some remedial ac-
It is certain that there is a demand in
and expense account. In other words, tion be taken in order to lessen the num-
this industry for bright young men who do
they are not producers.
ber and variety of commission fiends who
not look upon traveling as belonging to a
It is true there are institutions where present their claims with almost unflagging
play-day era. In fact, there never was a
honest, capable work does not seem to re- regularity upon any and all occasions.
time in the history of this industry when
ceive the recognition which is its just due. Sometimes they appear in pairs, some-
the future of young men of an industrious
Still, the man who is always doing does not times in groups and there are instances on
turn was afforded the opportunities of ad-
worry about the past nor does he think record when as many as five commissions
vancement as at the present time.
very largely about the future, for he real- have been claimed on the sale of a single
This is the business man's, era, and a
izes that the present, if rightly cared for, piano. It has grown beyond a purely
man to represent a business institution
will result in the future taking care of it- commercial proposition and has reached
must be business from the ground up, for
self. He considers that the task at hand is that field which approximates closely busi-
his success depends, not upon his capacity
more important than anything which has ness blackmail.
for imbibing liquids and consuming per-
been or anything which the future may
Opinions gained from local piano men,
fectos, but upon his ability to present a
have in store. It is this class of traveling which appear in another part of this paper,
straight proposition, and impressing the
desirability of accepting that proposition men who will go ahead in the world and will serve to emphasize some individual
command the recognition which their capa- impositions to which piano merchants are
favorably upon a good piano merchant.
bilities deserve. They are the men who are subjected almost daily. No other industry
It is industry that wins—tireless, never-
giving the best product of their brains and submits to the exorbitant demands of
ending industry that reaches a goal—and we
skill and trusting not wholly to luck but commission fiends in the same way as does
know of both road and warerodm salesmen
to the judgment and discriminating quali- the piano trade. A commission for legit-
who have won success through that one
ties of the men who constitute their firm, imate work men do not object^to paying,
qualification. Perhaps they are not very
but when it reaches a point where, after
brilliant, but they keep everlastingly to the extent of appreciating their work.
does.
at it. Early and late finds no diminu-
tion of work on their part.
It is not the man with the past record or
a glowing future who attracts the atten-
What may seem to be a lack of recogni- almost every sale, one is confronted by
tion now may prove a stepping-stone to several commission demands, then it be-
larger and better appreciated results later comes a matter of trade interest to see that
on. Like the man who carried the mes- the commission evil, if not entirely uproot-
Music Trade Review -- © mbsi.org, arcade-museum.com -- digitized with support from namm.org
THE MUSIC TRADE REVIEW
ed, shall be at least reduced materially
in its influence.
The public, too, is not entirely unaware
of these existing conditions, and it is said
that in several states commission clubs
have been formed to bleed piano men so
that at least four individuals shall get a
commission slice off from certain sales,
whether they have the slightest influence
in effecting the sales or not.
A friend of ours outside of the piano
trade, recently related to us his experience
in disposing of a piano which he had se-
cured in a trade deal. A friend of his saw
the piano, admired it and decided to pur-
chase it. Incidentally this friend invited
a lady acquaintance to accompany him to
look over the piano. He stated that he did
this, because he wished to have the opinion
of some musical friend who was not inter-
ested in securing a commission on a sale,
which, as he understood, was the usual
practice in piano stores. Incidentally, he
made the lady a handsome present for call-
ing with him and examining the piano
which he purchased. He learned from
our friend, from whom he purchased the
piano, that three days after,the lady whom
he had invited called upon him at his of-
fice and demanded a commission for hav-
ing made the sale. To this, our friend ob-
jected, saying that he was not in the piano
business, he had nothing to do with her
calling and it was purely a matter outside
his province.
The lady persisted, claiming that she
had earned the commission, and added the
statement that the music stores paid a com-
mission to any one who [even handed in a
name.
So this evil, which has honeycombed the
trade, is well known to the public, and it
seems that there are commission demands
made galore solely upon the flimsiest of
allegations.
The agitation of this important matter
can only be of general benefit as it may
bring about some concerted action upon
the commission demands made upon piano
merchants which in many instances amount
to genuine blackmail.
C A I L U R E S in this country for the month
of August are the fewest reported in
any month for eleven months passed.
Such a condition of affairs is gratifying
from every standpoint, as it forms a sta-
tistical argument in favor of business
prosperity.
We know of some piano manufacturing
institutions which have enjoyed the busiest
times in August. In fact even by work-
ing full time they have not been able to
accumulate the smallest amount of fin-
ished stock for future demand, Indica-
tions now point to an excellent September
and it is extremely probable that dealers
in certain lines will find it somewhat diffi-
cult to have their orders filled with any-
thing approximating promptitude. They
will have to take their turn.
tion of property by the rising waters of
the Mississippi.
'"THE trust movement in this country is
distinctly on the wane. Investors
are finding out that the promises of big
dividends are not working out in practice
and consequently they are withholding
THE TEXAS CALAMITY.
their support. In England, too, the trust
'T'HE nation's response to the needs of craze has materially subsided.
Galveston and the Gulf sufferers is
As a matter of fact, these combinations
magnificent. It has been purely Ameri- have worked disadvantageously to many
can—that is, spontaneous and generous— stock holders and to those manufacturers
and there never has been an hour in our who pooled their holdings in certain com-
country's history when the need of extend- binations. To-day it seems comparatively
ed charity was greater, or when it should easy to secure capital for competing fac-
be poured out more quickly, for the disas- tories when it can be demonstrated that
ter in Texas is not confined to any one there are large profits in the business.
spot, as at Johnstown. The loss of life Some of these great trust organizations
and the injury to property is appalling, have been unable to declare dividends on
while the isolated location of the city and their largely watered stock.
the torrid heat which now prevails there
makes it imperative that relief should not CONCERNING COMPETING WARES.
only be more abundant than it was in the A PIANO man of prominence, in the
terrible days in Pennsylvania in 1889, but
course of an interview last week,
that it should be more speedy.
touched upon a point which is frequently
At that time there was hardly a hamlet overlooked by piano men and their sales-
in the country that did not send its share, men, especially the latter.
and more than three million dollars was
The matter referred to is the assumption
raised for the Johnstown sufferers.
of a hostile attitude toward a compet-
There is need of even a greater sum at itor's wares and the practice of talking
Galveston. Music trade men have always against him or his goods. Happily, we
been liberal contributors to the wants of may say that this feeling has been gradu-
the needy, and, if our memory serves us ally simmering down, and to the credit of
correctly, William Steinway sent a check the Piano Manufacturers' Association it
for a thousand dollars to the New York may be said that it has been a powerful
fund for the Johnstown sufferers. Many factor in bringing about bettered condi-
other members of the trade gave also in tions.
generous proportions.
We all recollect not many years ago
Owing to the isolated situation of Gal- when the knives were always ready for
veston it has been almost impossible to get use, and hatchets always sharpened to a
authentic news from that town during the razor edge to slash competing wares.
week. There has been, too, much anxiety Neither the American business man nor
expressed in music trade circles regarding the American public has time or is in-
the safety of individual members of the clined to become interested in the quarrels
music trade houses of Galveston. One of of rival concerns. The piano salesman
the most important houses in the South- usually drops in the estimation of a cus-
west has its headquarters there, and from tomer when he runs down a certain com-
Galveston controls a series of branches peting piano and if he begins to tell all of
the mean and dishonorable things that so-
throughout Texas.
We refer to the house of Goggan, whose and-so has done the wandering eye of his
members are so well known in the North, prospective customer quickly betrays the
and who have extensive dealing with many weariness the subject creates in him.
leading houses in this section. It is almost
Or in the other case it interests him suf-
too early to decide -just what the future of ficiently to call upon the man whom the
that island, which was so recently the site of salesman has abused and ascertain just
a flourishing city, will be; but, notwith- what truth there is in the statement which
standing the fearful calamity which has has been made him.
overtaken it, Galveston will undoubtedly
If "the other fellow" must be spoken of
be rebuilt, for, notwithstanding the possi- at all it is the part of wisdom, either to
ble recurrence of the calamity of 1900, damn with faint praise, or better still, to
there will be plenty of business men who speak well of him and lead up to some
will take the risk, the same risk which the other topic as quickly as possible.
settlers in the rich valley of the Mississippi
Attacking a rival is a sign of weakness.
take when they face the. annual- deyastar. It indicates clearly enough that something

Download Page 4: PDF File | Image

Download Page 5 PDF File | Image

Future scanning projects are planned by the International Arcade Museum Library (IAML).

Pro Tip: You can flip pages on the issue easily by using the left and right arrow keys on your keyboard.