Music Trade Review

Issue: 1900 Vol. 30 N. 16

Music Trade Review -- © mbsi.org, arcade-museum.com -- digitized with support from namm.org
THE MUSIC TRADE REVIEW
TWENTY-FIRST YEAR.
• - ) . t EDWARD LYMAN BILL < •< -
Editor and Proprietor
PUBLISHED EVERY SATURDAY
3 East 14th St., New York
SUBSCRIPTION (Including postage), United States,
Mexico and Canada, fa^oo per year; all other countries,
l+oo.
ADVERTISErlFNTS, $2.00 per inch, singte column, per
insertion. On quarterly or yearly contracts a special dis-
count is allowed. Advertising Pages $50.00, opposite read-
ing matter $75.00.
RRMITTANCES, in other than currency form, should
De made payable to Edward Lyman Bill. *
1
Entered at the Nero York Pott Office as Second Clou MatUr.
NEW YORK, APRIL~21, 1900.
TELEPHONE NUMBER, 1745-EIGHTEENTH STREET.
THE KEYNOTE.
The first week of each month, The Review wil)
contain a supplement embodying the literary
and musical features which have heretofore
appeared In The Keynote. This amalgamation
will be effected without in any way trespassing
on our regular news service. The Review wilf
continue to remain, as before, essentially a
trade paper.
ern houses are fostering Eastern trade.
Eastern men are also interested in branches
throughout the West. Their interests in
promoting principles which tend towards
the up-building of the trade are one and
the same.
That the industry will constantly under-
go changes, no one can dispute who is
familiar with piano history. That the
future' means the disruption, or the de-
thronement of one particular center as a
piano manufacturing district is ridiculous-
ly absurd. Individuals who show no de-
sire to progress or to conform with the
constant current of changes are of neces-
sity destined to take a rear place in the in-
dustrial ranks. New men too will spring
up who will build vast enterprises and un-
doubtedly ancient institutions will under-
go the law of change and some will crum-
ble as well.
Taken altogether the piano industry is
full of hope and inspiration for those
whose capital and interests are involved in
the creation of the king of musical instru-
ments.
To talk of sectionalism in 1900 is like
digging up the skeleton of states rights
which was laid away to rest amid the dy-
ing echoes at Appomatox. It is a question
of organization—of discipline—of system—
of method—of intelligence—of a clear and
perfect conception of what the word com-
petition means in all its ramifications—
not sectionalism, that is in the saddle to-
day.
INFELLIGENCE NOT SECTIONALISM.
T H E R E appears to be no reasonable
doubt, but that the May meeting of
the piano manufacturers in Chicago will be
the. most notable ever held in this trade.
In the first place the membership of the
organization has materially increased dur-
ing the past two months. It includes some
of the largest piano manufacturing con-
cerns on earth and the western meeting
marks, too, a spirit of nationalization of the
entire trade which has never been before
well emphasized. That the attendance
VARIABLE LAWS.
will be large is already assured. That the
T
H
E
R
E
will
be a perfect Niagara of elo-
matters discussed will be of manifest in-
quence brought to bear on the trust
terest to the entire piano fraternity is cer-
question
during the coming Presidential
tain. It emphasizes, too, a new era in
piano politics, for it is the first time the campaign. We shall have the trust ground
national convention of piano men has ever thrashed over and over again. The leaders
of the majority in Congress have taken up
been held in the great West.
Passing aside the lesser advantages such for serious consideration the question as
as the cultivation of good fellowship, the to what shall be done in the way of leg-
extending of personal acquaintanceship, islation looking to federal regulation of
and of all those things which are instru- trusts and combinations. They have be-
mental in creating trade betterment, there come convinced that some action must be
will be. a discussion of those larger and taken if only to redeem party pledges, and
more vitalizing issues which are closely in- plans have therefore been formulated with
a view to initiating legislation that will
terlocked with trade future.
form a basis for the federal control of cor-
The men who have the business meeting
porations within conservative lines without
in charge have already listed a line of trade
making a radical attack upon the indus-
topics, which will interest every manufac-
tries of the country.
turer in the country, and after the May
At the beginning of Congress it became
meeting in Chicago the piano industry of
America .will be more closely welded than apparent that the trust question would be
a vexatious one for the majority to handle
ever before.
The talk of a division and the subsequent and makeshifts were resorted to in order
creation of an Eastern and Western asso- that bills might be disposed of when
ciation is the merest tommyrot, originating brought forward by minority members of
in the brain of the individual who has the house.
A proposition is now made in a bill
sought at all times to interject a destructive
to
suppress monopolies by declaring them
force into piano association growth. West-
to be unlawful and to control combinations
largely by prohibiting interstate traffic
in their products.
To our mind all of the bills which have
been before Congress regarding the regu-
lation of trusts are hopelessly inadequate
to cope with the situation. The Constitu-
tion will have to be amended in order to
enable Congress to legislate regarding cor-
porations which are at present the creations
of the several States. Congress is at pres-
ent without power to enact a law regu-
lating industrial combinations without a
constitutional amendment to that effect.
It may be said of the trust problem at
the present time, that there has been no
intelligent and well-directed effort made to
suppress the growth of trusts. There have
been volumes of incoherent talk, endless
abuse and all of that, but there has not
been an intelligent governmental effort
made with the direct intention of regulat-
ing the trusts, because in order to do so
there must be a constitutional amend-
ment. Without it we can do nothing, and
the best-posted constitutional lawyers will
agree with us. In very truth there are a
number of problems ahead for these loose-
ly-jointed states which constitute the
American union. Why should there be one
law for New Jersey and another for Maine,
or one law for New York and another for
Ohio in the matter of corporations? Why
not one national law operative in
every state ? Even in Honolulu and
Luzon ?
Piano manufacturers know of the com-
plicated and expensive legal machinery
which they encounter in the various states
in order to protect their rights. There are
so many different laws affecting the own-
ership of merchandise that it makes it ex-
pensive as well as annoying to carry on
business in certain states. It was only a
short time ago that we learned of the chase
of a piano which covered five states. The
manufacturer won in the end, and he pro-
posed to win his point no matter at what
expense, but, after all, it was simply main-
taining a principle for the ownership of a
piano, and to maintain that principle it
cost him ten times what the piano was act-
ually worth in cold dollars. It was not too
much for a principle, because a principle,
when right, should be maintained at any
cost, but at the same time a man should
not be compelled to pay out great big
golden dollars to support a piano principle.
The people of this country will learn
after a while that the best governed people
on earth are the least governed, and about
the time we learn that, the state laws will
become weaker and the national govern-
ment will become stronger.
Music Trade Review -- © mbsi.org, arcade-museum.com -- digitized with support from namm.org
THE MUSIC .TRADE REVIEW
What is the difference between a good
citizen of Ohio and New York? They are
both willing to meet all honest indebted-
ness to the full extent of their resources.
Then why should the law of evasion be
placed upon the statute books of the two
states? Why not have them mean one and
the same thing? A criminal in Maine
should be a criminal in New York and is
for that matter.
TONING DOWN OF TRADE.
'T'HERE has been a quieter tone to busi-
ness during the past month than had
been anticipated by many. Piano manu-
facturers do not complain, for thus far
they have been fortunate in having plenty
of orders on hand to keep' their factories
going at a good active pace, but if the re-
tail trade does not show speedy signs of
acceleration the manufacturing department
of the industry will shortly feel the slow-
ing down of trade throughout the country.
It is believed, however, that May will
show a marked improvement over April.
General conditions throughout the country
are excellent, labor being well employed,
the agricultural outlook promising and
trade should move along in fair, if not ex-
ceptionally large volume. Prospects too
for export business are excellent, and on
the whole the business outlook is satisfac-
tory. Textile mills which employ vast
armies of workmen are all running full
time and are crowded with work to get out
the orders placed some time ago. De-
liveries are late and in many cases in-
adequate to meet the requirements of buy-
ers. With the mills in almost every trade
running full time and filled with orders,
enough to keep them employed for many
weeks to come, any temporary quietness is
lacking of serious concern.
The quieter tone to business may be
accounted for in many ways—unsettled
roads, and all of that; then too, in the piano
trade we have nearly reached that date
which marks a general beginning of house-
cleaning and until that is well along, house-
wives are not anxious to place spick and
span new instruments in their parlors
until the rooms shall have undergone the
annual cleaning up, and again May moving
has almost arrived, so that there are a
number of reasons why the retail branch
of the piano business has been somewhat
slow during the past few weeks.
The sudden tumble in the stocks of the
American Steel & Wire Co., too, has had
somewhat of a depressing effect upon busi-
ness, for people are unduly susceptible to
scare head lines in the columns of the daily
papers. Meanwhile there seems to be no
escape from the conclusion, that the clos-
ing of the mills which led to this deprecia-
tion, was engineered or utilized for the
purpose of rigging the stock market. At
the company's last annual meeting in
March its directors assured the stockholdr
ers and the investing public that its net
profits for the year 1899 had been $12,162,-
529, out of which it had paid $2,100,000 in
dividends, leaving a surplus of $10,062,-
529. Out of this surplus it set aside and
paid on April 2, quarterly dividends at the
rate of seven per cent, annually to both its
preferred and common stock holders. Yet
two weeks later, without any previous
warning, mills are closed down, the stock
declines $7 or more dollars a share, other
stocks fall with it, and the inside specu-
lators reap a handsome profit.
The general public, that is, the read-
ing public, do not know that the inde-
pendent wire manufacturers are formida-
ble competitors of the trust, and that new
mills independent of the combination have
been started in no less than ten different
states during the past twelve months. All
of these are now actively producing, they are
not closing up their institutions like the wire
trust. No doubt there will be further ex-
citement regarding the decline in the stocks
of many of these over-capitalized trusts.
This year or next, no doubt, will mark a tre-
mendous decline in this special line of in-
vestments, and when we are well through
with it, the country will be much better
off in every way. There is not the slightest
cause for alarm, for there is a healthy de-
mand for goods of all kinds. The only
cloud at present on the industrial horizon
is the question of strikes. Just how much
that may interfere with business during
the present year is problematical. There
can be no question, however, but that they
will cripple industry to a greater or less
extent.
There is yet a final and intelligent ad-
justment to be made which shall equalize
the existing conditions between capital
and labor.
OPERATING AUXILIARY FACTORIES
'T'HE Review has claimed since the labor
troubles first began in Chicago last
fall that, owing to the peculiar conditions
of the labor "element in that city, with-
in a very short period the leading manu-
facturers of Chicago would operate auxili-
ary factories located at points within easy
distance of Chicago where exceptional ship-
ping facilities could be secured.
Up to the present time our predictions
are proving true. The Smith & Barnes
Co., own and operate an auxiliary factory
at Rockford, 111., and in last week's paper
we announced the building of a new Cable
factory at St. Charles, 111., a town which
is about forty miles west of Chicago, and
the location of the Hamilton Organ Co. 's
plant at Columbia Heights. There will be
more to follow.
CONCERNING EXPORT TRADE.
A MERICAN piano manufacturers, par-
ticularly those who have organized
their factories to produce different grades
of goods, are now turning their attention
towards the development of export trade.
Already their travelers have visited the
important countries on earth. At the out-
set they should understand that exporters
of American manufactures have, in more
than one instance, wasted a great deal of
effort in misdirected enterprise, and have
attributed their inability to establish satis-
factory and profitable trade relations with
countries promising profitable markets, for
which their own errors of judgment were
responsible.
Consul Mahin, resident at Reichenberg,
Germany, in a recent report to the State
Department calls attention to one grave
mistake of many American exporters in
assuming that English is so generally em-
ployed as the language of internation-
al trade that circulars and catalogues
printed in English meet all the require-
ments of a successful trade propaganda.
Having made inquiries on this subject in
Germany, France, Austria and Italy, he
summarizes his conclusions as follows:
It is true that knowledge of the English
language is spreading, and it is possible
that in a generation or so it can be success-
fully used in doing business in any part of
Europe. It is also true that some people
in every town of considerable size have a
smattering of English, but few of these
people will take the trouble to read circu-
lars printed in English. It takes too
much effort. They talk a little, but will
not bother to puzzle out the technical
words in printed business matter, and the
waste basket is made use of by them as
well as by people who do not know a word
of English.
We can very well understand that for the
average American business man it is difficult
to realize that ' 'good straight English" lacks
the power of conveying an intelligible idea
to the average Continental merchant; but
that such is the fact is very well known to
those who have tried the experiment of
supplying their own wants in Continental
shops where window signs give assurance
that English is spoken within—a phrase
which experience teaches one to under-
stand as meaning that English is spoken
within very well defined and in con-
veniently restricted limitations.
Trade literature, to have value, needs
to be printed in the language of the coun-
try to which it is sent—not translated, but
recast so that it shall present the subject
to which it relates from the standpoint of
the merchant to whom it is addressed. In

Download Page 4: PDF File | Image

Download Page 5 PDF File | Image

Future scanning projects are planned by the International Arcade Museum Library (IAML).

Pro Tip: You can flip pages on the issue easily by using the left and right arrow keys on your keyboard.