Music Trade Review

Issue: 1899 Vol. 29 N. 26

Music Trade Review -- © mbsi.org, arcade-museum.com -- digitized with support from namm.org
10
THE MUSIC TRADE REVIEW
never have been found wanting in emer-
gencies of the past, and now that this
country is assuming a position as a world-
wide power the same characteristics will
be in evidence. Industrial America will
sweep on to more glorious conquests, and
the American piano will be the dominant
one in all lands. Our export trade in all
lines has developed at an astounding rate,
and within the next two or three years
marvelous accomplishments will also have
been made in the branching out for foreign
trade in this industry.
for the past year have had upon the
business.
In the first place, it has been demonstra-
ted to manufacturers who have been en-
gaged in making pianos for dealers under
TWENTY-FIRST YEAR •
their own trade-mark, that they have been
•EDWARD LYMAN BILL-
working against their interests in not hav-
Editor and Proprietor
ing their own imprint upon the instru-
PUBLISHED EVERY SATURDAY
ments manufactured. It has been proved
~~
3 East 14th St., New York
clearly that the manufacturer who makes
SUBSCRIPTION (Including postage), United States,
pianos
with his own name thereon is
Mexico and Canada, $2 $300,
building up nothing for himself of value
ADVERTISEriENTS, $2.00 per inch, single column, per
insertion. On quarterly or yearly contracts a special dis-
in the way of a trade-mark. No matter
count is allowed. Advertising Pages $50.00, opposite read-
ing matter $75.00.
if he has many years of successful business
REMITTANCES, in other than currency form, should
b« made payable to Edward Lyman Bill.
behind him, the value of his piano in the
THE STENCIL AGITATION.
Entered at the Few Tvrk Post Office as Second Class Matter.
T H E anti-stencil campaign has come in esteem of the public is nothing, whereas
NEW YORK, DECEMBER 23, 1899.
for but a small share of trade atten- the manufacturer who has been placing
TELEPHONE NUMBER, 1745~EIGHTEENTH STREET.
tion for the past few months. It is singu- thousands of his instruments in different
THE KEYNOTE.
The first week of each month, The Review will
lar, indeed, how this matter became tem- sections of the country with his own name
contain a supplement embodying the literary
and musical features which have heretofore
porarily obscured by the wave of prosper- or corporate stamp stencilled thereon, has
appeared in The Keynote. This amalgamation
ity which overspread the country during been building up a valuable property,
will be effected without in any way trespassing
on our regular news service. The Review will
the late spring months up to the present which it is indeed difficult to take from.
continue to remain, as before, essentially a
trade paper.
time. Manufacturers have been too busy Therefore, one of the great results of the
running their factories day and night to stencil agitation has been to generate a cer-
HOME AND FOREIGN Mr\RKETS.
tain resistance on the part of manufactur-
T H E enormous demand for pianos in our fill their orders with any degree of
home markets has reduced the efforts promptitude to give, at this juncture, ers to the stencil arguments made by deal-
on the part of manufacturers to prosecute further serious consideration to the sten- ers. It has, too, given them a clear idea
a vigorous campaign abroad. They rightly cil problem. It was obscured for the of their position in the stencil business. It
figure that the nearby market is the most time being by one whirl of prosperity, but, has been demonstrated to them by argu-
profitable from every standpoint, and dur- after all, the publicity, the arguments, the ment that the stencil piano has been the
ing the past few months the utmost manu- notoriety which the stencil problem has open door to much misrepresentation, and
facturing activity has failed to diminish to received during the present year has been that the piano industry would be much
an appreciable degree the demand for of infinite benefit to the industry, and it better off if it were practically devoid of
also removed from the hands of the news- stencil products.
pianos in this country.
All this has been healthy; there has been
These conditions, however, will change paper fakir a weapon which he has used at
will
to
bring
the
trade
to
terms.
There
is
no abuse, no bones broken, and we may
later on, for America's manifest destiny is
nothing
after
all
which
will
effectually
kill
say, no manufacturers mulcted.
to control the piano markets of the world.
an
evil
like
publicity,
and
some
reputable
Manufacturers to-day are more and more
This nation having grown greater and as-
manufacturers
who
for
years
had
been
impressed
with the. desirability of having
sumed larger responsibilities will adapt it-
making
pianos
for
some
dealers
had
been
their own or corporate imprint upon the
self to new circumstances. We have long
fed
on
the
theory
that
it
would
be
a
seri-
instruments sent forth. It is the genera-
been known as the world's granary and
ous
injury
to
their
business
if
their
con-
tion of this very spirit backed by the idea
in the future we will be known as the
nection
with
stencil
pianos
became
gen-
that there is the possibility of individual
world's factory. Goods of American manu-
erally
known.
This
was
held
up
to
them
fraud in the infinite variety of stencils that
facture are sold now all over the earth and
for
months,
and
was
used
as
an
argument
causes them to put the brakes pretty well
they are destined to become better and
to
gain
fat
contracts.
Insidious
remarks
on that department of their business. So
better known. Again, our expansion gives
us tremendous power, for our territorial and wily insinuations both in paper and after all while the good times seem to have
limits now extend half way around the by person were made to them and they obscured the stencil question in the haze
came really to believe that the very name of prosperity yet the truth should not be
world.
of stencil piano was tainted with illegality overlooked that the agitation brought about
Americans to-day may boast that the sun
and dishonor.
has been of vast benefit to the legitimate
never sets on the soil over which the
What has been the result of the cam- industry.
stars and stripes wave. As Lawton's
gallant men in the Philippines witness the paign of '99 ?
WAR AND TRADE.
golden effulgence, Porto Rico is bathed in
First, the power of the journalistic fakir
his dying splendor.
who for years had used the stencil purely T H E war in South Africa has cut off the
entire music trade shipments to that
No matter how the "Anties" cry against as a means to gain a personal end, is de-
expansion the majority of our citizens be- throned. All of the arguments made have country. America has found, for many
lieve in the world-wide destiny of America failed to bring out one point against the years, the South African field a fairly good
and they will not fail in the more difficult, men who have been manufacturing pianos one for organs, but war has put an end to
more conspicuous paths on which it has " for " some dealer.
it for the present. War is an imperious
entered.
Again it has been demonstrated con- monopolist; even in the newspaper world
Our people compel the admiration of the clusively that argument and not abuse will it brings all the news matter into signifi-
world by the ease with which they adapt bring about a decrease in the stencil traf- cance; it intensifies newspaper life and
themselves to varying conditions. They fic. Let us see what effect the arguments specializes its energies. It overshadows
Music Trade Review -- © mbsi.org, arcade-museum.com -- digitized with support from namm.org
THE MUSIC TRADE REVIEW
temporarily the social, domestic, artistic,
religious, scientific, amusement, and many
other ordinarily legitimate and important
interests. It stimulates purely news enter-
prise in one line, and feeds the craving for
the earliest information. The daily news-
papers at war times are greatly stimulated,
as evidenced by the immediate increase in
the price of common print paper. It seems,
at this rate, the whole world will be in a
war flame before the close of the century,
and so soon after the peace conference at
The Hague.
TRUSTS AND COMBINATIONS.
T H E position of the journalistic Judas,
who is advocating the formation of a
piano trust, is one not entirely devoid of
humor. Here is a man who for years has
maligned and abused individual members
of the trade. He has been openly accused
of being a thug, both in trade and in musi-
cal circles.
He early fell in with the scheme of a
man whose business ventures resulted in
colossal failure to organize a trust in this
industry. His aim in this, like everything
else with which he has been connected, was
purely selfish. The gain to him was to be
a fat commission. He advocated this and
became special envoy to interest manu-
facturers. The germs of success which
may have been lurking in the original
scheme were effectually killed by him
because the manufacturers have grown to
look with suspicion upon any matter with
which he was associated.
gives even a casual glance at the industrial
evolution which is steadily going on
can deny that the era of the jack-knife
method of doing business is past. The
piano industry of the future will be con-
ducted on broad and comprehensive lines.
More capital will be employed, because the
industry is capable of showing such returns
that it will interest capital, and there is
always capital to be employed when the
field can be shown to be remunerative.
The superfluities will be lopped off here
and there, certain excrescences which have
hung on will be removed and the business
will be conducted on clean, compact lines.
Changes, of course, will occur—marked
changes at that. The whole industrial
system of the country is rapidly undergo-
ing a complete metamorphosis and it is
only reasonable to expect that the piano
industry should conform to certain condi-
tions which exist in other lines.
That has been one serious draw-back to
this business. It was cumbered up with
antique ideas and principles; lately it has
burnished up a bit, and is glowing with a
good healthy color. Of course there will
always be trouble, labor troubles, price
troubles, installment troubles, all sorts of
troubles. We expect them in this queer
old world of ours.
U
Boston will decide to cross Twenty-third
street and be in the van of the up-town
piano movement, or whether John Wana-
maker will capture the Chickering prize, is
a secret which the future and the manage-
ment of the Chickering corporation have
not as yet revealed.
T H I S is just about the time when rumors
begin to fly thick and fast regarding
deals. If one's ear is pressed close to the
piano earth, sounds may be heard coming
from all directions. Just at present there
are distinguishable murmurs from Chicago
regarding an impending colossal deal
which threatens to overshadow anything
which has yet occurred. We shall await
developments with considerable interest.
One thing is sure, it takes combinations to
meet combinations.
T H E article which we present in this
issue, " T h e Piano Palaces of New
York," will show to the world just how a
portion of the retail trade of New York is
wareroomed. We are unable, however, to
cover the entire field, and then the Borough
of Brooklyn is left out entirely. Such im-
mense institutions as are owned by Free-
born G. Smith, the Sterling Co. and Otto
Wissner, will be treated of in a later issue.
Next week we propose to show a portion
of the piano manufacturing district of New
York, that portion of it which is compara-
tively new in the Harlem district. We are
now preparing views of important facto-
ries which will show some of the great
manufacturing establishments of New York
above the Harlem.
THE WALL ST. CRASH.
T H E crash which occurred in Wall street
Monday should serve as a warning to
innocent investors who are tempted by al-
luring prospectuses to invest their money
in certain industrials. The "highly wa-
Having failed in his lesser newspaper en- tered, over-capitalized trusts" are going to
terprise, and having lost control forever of pieces precisely as we predicted. The peo-
T N making the appropriations for the New
this industry, he seeks revenge in advocat- ple, that is the masses, have been led to
Year every manufacturer should count
ing a destructive scheme. Nothing would believe that these highly watered organi-
carefully whether a paper has been a con-
please him better than to see this trade in zations, whose directorate too often is filled
sistent supporter of trade honor and es-
a condition of complex chaoticness, from with men high in finance and politics, are
teem, and whether that journal has a circu-
which no amount of business talent would sure and safe. The result is not different
lation and influence which entitle it to a
extricate it for a term of years. Healthy than was anticipated by many. The trusts
business consideration. Patronage to the
combinations, the introduction of new cap- which are not healthy must go. Wall
traitor only adds fuel to the fires of black-
ital, are indicative of a healthy sign of street men will find it more and more diffi-
guardism.
trade, but an absorptive trust which con- cult to float these new organization as time
trols an industry is a degenerate move, and rolls on. The decline in the value of in- DEVIEWING trade conditions this week
has in many instances ended in failure to dustrial stock during the past week amounts
^ R. G. Dun & Co. say: "Never has
the men connected with it.
to many millions. Where would the infla- production been greater, the number of
There is a vast difference between a ted piano trust be in the flurry which over- hands employed larger, the wages dis-
healthy combination and an absorptive took us this week? These things will tributed higher, or the purchasing power,
trust. The whole tendency of the times cause thoughtful people to consider that a based upon earnings, greater than at this
is to conduct business on larger lines, to modest factory property is worth infinitely time, and never have conditions of trade or
returns of earnings and traffic given cer-
denude trade dealings of all superfluities; more than a lot of worthless trust paper.
tainty of greater business for transporters."
in other words, the age is more keenly
DOTS AND DASHES.
practical than any other since industry
T FRANK CONOVER has won a repu-
began. Combinations work effectively T H E R E is keen interest manifested over
* tation as an inventor. A detailed
the future of the Chickering piano in
provided there are the elements of success
in the organizations. A combination of New York. Only a few months will have account of one of his latest inventions
capital and business ability works advan- elapsed ere Chickering Hall as a retail relating to piano actions may be found in
tageously. This is the age of larger en- point for the Chickering pianos will be but the patents and inventions column in an-
terprise in everything, and no man who a memory. Whether the management in other portion of this paper.

Download Page 8: PDF File | Image

Download Page 9 PDF File | Image

Future scanning projects are planned by the International Arcade Museum Library (IAML).

Pro Tip: You can flip pages on the issue easily by using the left and right arrow keys on your keyboard.