Music Trade Review

Issue: 1899 Vol. 28 N. 7

Music Trade Review -- © mbsi.org, arcade-museum.com -- digitized with support from namm.org
THE MUSIC TRADE REVIEW
\1
and fight for its enactment. The talk about
national legislation is rot. Everybody who
knows anything about national affairs is
well aware that at this time there are
measures of much greater importance
pending in Congress than one for the relief
of piano manufacturers from frauds in
stenciling."
Mr. Dutton inquired from Mr. Baus if a
compromise could be effected having in
view national legislation. He declared that
no two men—referring evidently to Messrs.
Spies and Baus—are strong enough to
carry/through effective legislation. "There
must be a combination," said he, " and it
must be strong. Mr. Baus has accused the
Association of frivolity and lack of effect-
iveness in its efforts. If he were acquainted
with the fact he would know that although
the members do dine together when they
meet, the process of dining does not in-
terfere but rather aids in carrying on
the practical work set out for it. We have
accomplished more practical work than is
credited to us by outsiders. There is to
be a meeting of the National Association
on April 6th, and if Messrs. Spies and
Baus care to attend, we shall see that they
are made welcome and will do all in our
power to further the interests of the trade
by framing a bill which shall be really ef-
fective and far-reaching. It is a very im-
portant subject and should be handled
very carefully. Mr. Spies has admitted
that he is but a novice in the piano busi-
ness. Members of the association, as a
rule, are men of wide experience, with a
full knowledge of all details of manufac-
ture. Experience has taught them many
useful things. Among other things, they
have learned to go slow in the matter of
legislation. In fact, laws should never be
enacted, or even proposed, until after
weighty consideration has been given to
all sides of the general question involved.
I would advise Messrs. Spies and Baus to
sec Mr. Redington and have the bill with-
dra .vn. This done, the Association here
could take up the subject, discuss it in all
its phases, make suitable representations to
the National Association, and then aid in
having a really good measure placed on
the statute books. But if those gentlemen
44
accept the views of the one man on a jury
who stood out against the other eleven.
Mr. Fischer closed his remarks by ap-
pealing to the supporters of the Redington
bill to withdraw the measure.
In a few brief words, Mr. Baus respect-
fully declined to act upon this suggestion,
thereupon Mr. Fischer proposed the fol-
lowing motion which was seconded by
William Dalliba Dutton:
Resolved: That a committee of five from
the organization and trade shall be ap-
pointed by the vice-president to go to Al-
bany at the proper time to present the views
of the organization in reference to the
Redington bill, and that this committee
shall be empowered to employ counsel if
considered necessary by them; expenses
of members of the organization and coun-
sel to be paid by the Association.
Before the motion was put Mr. Spies
took the floor and again vigorously empha-
sized the need for such a measure as that
introduced by Mr. Redington. "The bill
is constitutional," he declared, "and I have
legal advice on this point. I wish to make
this clear, as some speakers here to-day
have stated that this bill would not hold
in law." He closed by stating that he
would go to Albany on Feb. 21, and press
the measure to the end.
After some brief remarks by Mr. Ham-
ilton Gordon and Mr. T. La M. Couch the
motion was put to the house and declared
carried by the chairman.
Mr. Kammerer informs us that he has
appointed the following committee agree-
able to the motion passed to go to Albany
and oppose the measure: William Dalliba
Dutton, chairman; B. F. Fischer, Robt. A.
Widenmann, Henry Behr, T. La M.
Couch and Chas. H. Parsons.
A beautiful Chickering parlor grand
piano to be shipped to the Methodist
Book Concern's branch in Japan, which is
under the management of Mr. Co wen, was
sold last week by W. G. Woodmansee &
Co., of Cincinnati, representatives of the
Chickering piano in that city.
Andrew Carnegie presented his eleventh
pipe organ to the United Brethren Church
of North Braddock, Pa., last week.
It
will cost about $3,500.
The Factories of W . W . Kimball Co., Chicago, 111., U. S. A.
More than double the size and output of any similar institution in the world."—CHICAGO
Kimball Pianos.
»
insist on having the bill brought up in the
Assembly, the Association must take steps
to prevent its passage. A committee will
be appointed and sent to Albany."
Mr. Baus, speaking again as an advocate
of the Redington measure, figuratively
unsheathed his sword and called upon its
opponents to come forward and "fight it
out."
Mr. John Evans, of Newby & Evans,
remarked that he had heard Mr. Hamilton
S. Gordon assert his belief that there is in
existence a federal law covering the sub-
ject and making any further remedial legis-
lation unnecessary.
Mr. Hamilton S. Gordon said that he
knew of the existence of a law which forbids
a man putting his name as manufacturer
on any article which he does not manufac-
ture.
Mr. Gordon declared himself as
being in favor of the Bill as a whole,
although he felt that it required revision.
Mr. Holmstrom, of James & Holmstrom,
wanted to know if there is any difference
between the stenciling of pianos and the
stenciling of goods along other lines in
manufacture. He was of the opinion that
this bill would not prevent stenciling,
which was bound to be practiced, law or
no law.
Mr. Baus rejoined, "there is a law
against thievery and yet thievery is prac-
ticed every day."
Mr. Adolpho H. Fischer said he objected
to the Bill and to the manner in which it
had been introduced at Albany. He said
he did not consider it a good measure in
any sense of the word and he would cer-
tainly vote against it. He felt that there
had been too much haste shown in its prep-
aration. Action in such matters should
be deliberate and could not wisely be un-
dertaken without interchange of opinions
among men who understood the business.
He said that the majority of manufacturers
in the Association are against the measure.
Those who were for it are not members of
the Association at all and were represent-
ed actively by but two, Messrs. Spies and
Baus. He felt that the sense of the man-
ufacturers was against it, and he could no
more think of accepting the views of the
small minority in this case than he would
Kimball Reed Organs.
TRIBUNE.
Kimball Pipe Organs.
Music Trade Review -- © mbsi.org, arcade-museum.com -- digitized with support from namm.org
THE MUSIC TRADE REVIEW
Exhibit.
Herman Krell is comfortably installed in
his new quarters at the Wanamaker store.
He is now a member of the Wanamaker
staff, and the piano department is practi-
cally in his charge.
Until the permanent piano department
on the fifth floor is completed, the exhibit
of Krell products will remain where they
are at present, in one section of the general
exhibition area on the fifth floor, facing
north.
The following announcement, the first
by the way, regarding the recent piano
move appeared in the Wanamaker adver-
tisement in last Monday's papers:
The Krell Piano Company has closed its
New York store, and we have taken the
entire business. Pending the preparation
of proper warerooms, the instruments are
on sale on the fifth floor, Tenth street, be-
tween the Dressmaking Rooms and the
Picture Gallery.
Why did they happen?
Why, why, why?
We mean the big blizzard, the unpre-
cedented cold, and the greatest number of
fires in the history of New York.
Again we ask why?
Of course the official authorities will ex-
plain it satisfactorily from their stand-
point.
To "the marines" perhaps but not to
the members of the music trade of this
city who know a thing or two.
They know for a certainty that Joe
Mann, the famous Joe Mann of Providence,
R. I., was in town.
He made his appearance in New York on
Friday with a big quantity of zero weather
in his grip, and he no sooner commenced
to diffuse his genial smile around the trade,
than, presto, we had one of the greatest
blizzards of the century, and fire-engines
seemed to be running around every corner.
And this continued almost up to the time
Joe Mann bade adieu to Manhattan.
At once Old Sol apologetically took the
centre of the stage and taking the cue from
the popular "Joe " proceeded to make one
and all feel happier (?) by frying the pearly
snow.
History records that Mann must be "in
it " whether at the blowing up of the
"Maine," the greatest railroad wreck of
season, or anything that is extraordinary.
Why did they happen?
Is it necessary to ask?
Storm Interferes with Business.
Business among the Harlem manufac-
turers is active all along the line, but the
recent heavy storms have blocked traffic so
severely that shipments have been brought
almost to a standstill. In the Harlem
thoroughfares snow is standing in drifts
from four to eight feet high and, even on
the level, is almost impossible fordrayage.
Now that a thaw has set in, wagons are
beginning to move slowly, but a week or
ten days will elapse before normal con-
ditions are again reached.
13
Hugo Sohmer Talks of the Stencil Matter.
One of the most interested listeners at
the meeting of piano manufacturers on
Tuesday was Hugo Sohmer, of Sohmer
& Co. Mr. Sohmer is not at present a
member of the Association, but this does
not stand in the way of a warm welcome
whenever he visits the members individu-
ally or in meeting assembled.
Like many other members of the trade,
Mr. Sohmer is willing to express his opin-
ions freely when asked to do so, but rarely
ventures to address an audience voluntar-
ily. On Wednesday, The Review, when
making the usual round of visits, called at
the Sohmer warerooms and conversed
briefly with Mr. Sohmer concerning the
Redington bill and its chances of success.
Asked to define his attitude in the mat-
ter, Mr. Sohmer said: "My views on this
subject are well known, and it is therefore
hardly necessary to repeat them. I have
no sympathy with stenciling. Of course
there are two kinds of stenciling—one
where palpable fraud is conspicuous, the
other where it is not so conspicuous.
" To my mind there is no excuse what-
ever for the conduct of those dealers who
attempt to deceive their customers. The
stencilled instruments, they may pretend,
are made to their order, but it is not so.
Their only order is to place some name
that suits them on the fallboard. Pianos
are very rarely made to order, and then
they are very expensive.
"There should be a law, and it should be
rigorously enforced, that the name of the
manufacturer of every instrument should
appear on the fallboard. Let the dealer, or
other person who orders the instruments,
give them his own or any other name he
chooses, but under it, in plain lettering,
should appear the name of the person or
firm responsible for the putting together
of the ' box ' or whatever else it may
happen to be.
" That is practically what is most essen-
tial now. The sooner it is done the better.
Nor does it seem to me that much parley-
ing and deliberation are needed.
The
proposition is too simple to call for deep,
profound thought and solemn conclaves.
There are a good many others in this
trade who think, as I do, that more in the
shape of results along practical lines of re-
form should be forthcoming than have
been seen up to this time."
Milton Co. Reorganizes.
Pianos Damaged by Water.
E. M. BOOTHE BUYS OUT WM. F. BOOTHE's IN-
TEREST W. B. CRAIGHEAD, PRESIDENT.
Patrolman Fries, of the Tenth and
Thompson streets station, discovered water
running over the sidewalk at the north-
west corner of Sixth and Thompson streets
at 2 o'clock yesterday morning, and found
that it was flooding the premises of C. J.
Heppe & Son, piano makers. Policeman
Fries went to the Eagle Hotel and aroused
Manager W. H. Jacoby, who accompanied
him to the factory.
They found a pipe had burst, which led
to the workshop on the third floor, and
that the overflow had damaged several
pianos on the first floor. The loss was es-
timated at about $4000. — Philadelphia
Ledger.
Edward M. Boothe, of the Milton Piano
Co., has bought out the interest of William
F. Boothe in the firm. Walter B. Craig-
head, who is now a stockholder, has been
elected president of the Milton Co. and
Edward M. Boothe treasurer. The capital
stock of the company is $10,000, fully
paid in.
Dealers and the Vose.
The Vose advertisement on the cover page
of this issue is as usual interesting. It
will repay careful reading by progressive
dealers who are in the piano business to
make money and reputation.
"The makers of the Vose piano have
studied the needs of the business—they
are continually working with the view of
making the dealer's capital earn larger divi-
dends."
This is a truth which needs little empha-
sis in view of the magnificent propaganda
which Vose & Sons have been carrying on
in the dealers' interest for the past two
years. Turn where you will, in the mag-
azines or in the trade papers, no money has
been spared to place the Vose piano prom-
inently before the reading and purchasing
public. The advertisement well and cor-
rectly says: " T h e dealer who desires to
maintain a successful business will build
the structure of that business upon a good
and permanent foundation," and if any
one should ask how? we would say by be-
coming better acquainted with the superb
creations in piano making which the Vose
people have prepared for the trade this
year.
*
Robert Schlee.
Robert Schlee, who for a long period of
years had been connected with Wm. Knabe
& Co. 's New York establishment as expert
tuner, died on Feb. 15th, at his home in
this city. Mr. Schlee was accompanying
Emil Sauer on his tournee, in his capacity
as tuner, and left for St. Louis on Feb. 9th.
Shortly afterward he was taken quite ill
and it was thought best that he should
return home. He only lived two days
after reaching New York. The funeral
occurred yesterday.
Mr. Schlee was considered one of the
best tuners in this city. He was a great
favorite with Von Biilow, Griinfeld, Sta-
venhagen, Carreno, whom he accompanied
on their tournees of this country. Von
Biilow, especially, who was not an easy
man to please, paid Schlee many compli-
ments regarding his ability as a tuner. A
host of personal friends and visitors to the
Knabe warerooms will miss this modest
and always genial personality.

Download Page 10: PDF File | Image

Download Page 11 PDF File | Image

Future scanning projects are planned by the International Arcade Museum Library (IAML).

Pro Tip: You can flip pages on the issue easily by using the left and right arrow keys on your keyboard.