Music Trade Review

Issue: 1899 Vol. 28 N. 3

Music Trade Review -- © mbsi.org, arcade-museum.com -- digitized with support from namm.org
THE MUSIC TRADE REVIEW
The acts of Mr. C. H. W. Foster are not
congealed by conventionalities.
He makes
premature, but it entirely lacks confirma-
tion.
The present arrangement between
Last
week we had an opportunity of
chatting with two former acquaintances,
this departure, believing, unquestionably,
the Chickering corporation and John Wan-
who have been successful in forming two
that it will result in an increased output of
amaker
trusts.
temporary.
As
a
natural
They are lawyers and they re-
If it proves success-
sequence, however, if both parties are satis-
marked to us that their commission in the
then undoubtedly others will follow
fied with the results accruing from their
deals would amount to enough to give
present arrangement, it would no doubt
them magnificent
become permanent, and the possibility for
that while some of the individual owners
an enlargement of territory would of course
of certain plants asked an extravagant fig-
be attendant upon what success is achieved
ure, yet it was their policy to pay it. That
by the existing understanding.
such a course simply means printing a few
Chickering pianos.
ful,
is
his lead.
IV A ANY ask, in the event of the success of
John Wanamaker in handling pianos,
to the extent that the Wanamaker piano
store, becomes a prominent adjunct to his
business, what effect will it have upon the
piano dealers over America ? Will it cause
other leading manufacturers to seek the
department stores as avenues of outlet for
their instruments ?
That, too, is a question that cannot be
answered at once.
We must await de-
velopments, and we prefer not to express
an opinion at the present time.
The Wanamaker case is a peculiar one.
For reliability no merchant stands higher
in America.
fortunes.
They
said
It may be that the piano business may
more certificates, while they, the promot-
not be prolific in results so that the great
ers, receive their commission in cold cash.
Philadelphia and New York merchant may
The difficulty of earning dividends upon
conclude that the space in his vast estab-
this enormously expanded capitalization is
lishments can be better utilized for the dis-
a source of inherent weakness.
play and sale of other wares.
And tbms
If we could
a trust has within it at its very inception
only part the veil which hides us from the
an element which is destined to cause its
uncertain future, we would probably all
dissolution.
accomplish greater results, and it is that
by the skill of its management to keep it
future which holds the secret of success or
afloat for further speculation.
Its career can be measured
failure of the Chickering-Wanamaker ar-
T A K E the case of the American Steel &
rangement.
Clean business methods, too,
Wire Co., who now propose to incor-
are interwoven with all his transactions.
porate a company of $90,000,000 to acquire
His wares are not what we colloquially
term "cheap goods," therefore in this one
particular
Wanamaker
differs
from
all
other department store merchants.
Can Boston show a merchant of
the Wanamaker type ?
Is there another
in New York, or Philadelphia, or Chicago.
The music dealers do not want to lose
their heads in this matter, and we would
counsel those who are indulging in lurid
pyrotechnics
to await
further
develop-
ments.
Evo-
lution, and some may say, revolution,
is just now working wonders in the indus-
trial and capitalistic world.
Let us glance hastily at the different
cities.
THE NEW " INDUSTRIALS,"
T^HIS is a history creating period.
The forma-
Washburn & Moen at first asked a price
which the promoters refused to pay.
They
Far
now find that in order to succeed they
from abating, the movement which is re-
must absorb all competing plants; hence
sulting in the combination of industrial
they wish to increase their stock a few
and commercial affairs continues with \\\\-
millions—it
abated activity—thus the rapidly changing
absorb all these industries. This stock is
tion of vast trusts goes steadily on.
events of welding small competing groups
of capital into vast non-competing aggre-
matters not how many—to
now being advertised, and the promoters
hope that the people will quickly purchase
the entire line of certificates.
gations.
It seems that the trading world is filled
D E S T assured whatever is the outcome
the Washburn & Moen and other compet-
ing wire-making plants.
with associations which are steadily regu-
of the Chickering-Wanamaker deal,
lating
the Chickering piano will continue to be a
goods.
the prices of
great factor in the piano industry.
tions in everything.
all
manufactured
This is the age of gigantic opera-
Is it not a
fact that the declared
intention of the
men
trust to
behind
the wire
absorb
more is an open admission of their present
weakness?
About the only im-
We are seeing expansion with a venge-
advertising which the Chickering instru-
portant industry in which genuine com-
ance in these great combinations, and to-
ments will have received from the date of
petition still exists is that of the piano
day the leading bankers of the country
our last issue to the close of the year, in
manufacturing, and the efforts to combine
connection with this matter will be simply
this trade into a trust have thus far proved
beyond calculation in
futile.
cents.
cold
The
dollars and
in the Chickering
Thus the
moters and men who sell these stocks on
commission, will continue to become large
All of the talk and agitation will
stimulate an interest
are listing these ''industrials."
investing public, it is hoped by the pro-
\ \ 7HILE the figures which represent the
purchasers of the new "industrials."
trust deals of 1898 reach an enor-
This new condition involves dangers to
mous capitalization, it should be under-
the general financial situation, and there
complete metamorphosis, so that to-day
stood that a large amount of those figures
is already a development 011 the
one lmndred pianos a week can be shipped
represent merely the quantity of
paper
large financial interests to discourage the
from the Chickering factory without extra
certificates in the form of shares which
growing tendency of the market to devote
exertion.
Then too, the Chickering pianos
these trusts have caused to be printed,
itself to the industrial stocks.
from the date of their first manufacture to
hoping to dispose of them to an investing
product
The factory at Boston has been
thoroughly systematized, has undergone a
part of
What else does this mean than that the
the present time have in no period excelled
public.
It is a fact in the organization of
solid financial element of America consider
those of 1899.
most of these trusts that from three to four
that these colossal aggregations of stock,
TT has been rumored that the Philadelphia
arrangement would be followed by a
deal whereby the New York business would
dollars more in shares have been allotted
the value of which only consists of paper,
for every dollar of actual property em-
will some day go up like the South Sea
braced in the combination.
Bubble scheme?
And how that
vast watered stock is going to pay is a
be controlled in the near future by Wana-
problem which the best financial
maker.
in the country are vinable to solve,
This announcement is not only
experts
Of the twenty-one great industries which
have been incorporated in New Jersey and
launched in Wall street since May last less
Music Trade Review -- © mbsi.org, arcade-museum.com -- digitized with support from namm.org
8
than one-fourth, wise observers say, will
earn any dividends on their common stock
within three years, even should the present
period of prosperity continue that length
of time.
-
"' ' :
In many of the others the capitalization
is so much out of proportion to the earn-
ing capacity of the plants consolidated that
unless conditions greatly change there is
no hope of their ever paying dividends ex-
cept on their cumulative preferred stock.
Is not America reaching a point in her
over-inflation of the industrial plans that
will rival the schemes of Barney Barnato ?
The famous "Kaffirs" have been sup-
planted by American " Industrials."
A snug factory plant is preferable to a
lot of barney barnatoed stock.
COMMISSIONS AND OTHER THINGS.
TN taking up the subject of commissions
the National Piano Manufacturers'
Association is pointed the right way. We
shall be much interested in the outcome of
the meeting held in Chicago this week, no-
tice of which appears elsewhere in this
paper.
The commission evil has thrived in this
trade to an alarming extent, and there is
no question but that thousands and thou-
sands of dollars are paid annually to people
who are in no way entitled to any pay-
ment for services which have never been
rendered.
One reason why it has assumed large
proportions is the fact that piano men
have been imposed upon by allegations
made to them which were wholly false.
There has been a mythical influence which
should be quickly exploded at the beginning
of the year. The commissions, teachers,
and all others, must go. They belong to
a past age.
And while on this subject there is an-
other matter which might well receive the
attention of manufacturers, and that is the
use of pianos in music studios.
In no other profession in the world are
free accessories tendered professional peo-
ple. A physician does not have a case of
surgical instruments given him free. A
carpenter is compelled to purchase his
tools. A sculptor has nothing free ten-
dered him, and still a professional musi-
cian expects a piano free for all time, kept
in tune and everything, all for what?
Mythical services — influence—all of
which should be relegated to an unhappy
past.
There is no reason in the world why
professional musicians should not pay for
their instruments, just the same as a plain,
ordinary everyday citizen, and if they do
anything which honestly entitles them to
THE MUSIC TRADE REVIEW
ble and necessary, there are men who will
try to find a way for it even though they
are referred to by their fellowmen as anni-
hilating trade conditions. A start has to
be made which will gain force and sym-
"I"" HIS is the age of investigation, of evo-
metry as it progresses.
lution, of changes and of trusts.
There are ample opportunities for all, if
WHAT IS A DEPARTMENT STORE?
we are not grasping and do not attempt to
INASMUCH as the department store is
accomplish too much with limited resources.
now a live topic, it may be well to take
Don't blow hot and cold with the same
its principal features in review.
breath. Be content with doing one thing
What we oftentimes term a department
at a time and do that well. Try and do it
store is not, strictly speaking, a depart-
better than it was ever done before by
ment store. The term had its origin when
yourself or anyone else. Convince the
some merchant, finding dull seasons in his
mind, catch the eye, sell the goods.
original business, looked around for arti-
\ 1 7 E have observed in our travels that cles to fill in, in the hope of attracting cus-
the men who complain the most are tomers to his establishment. His added
the men who are the least progressive. lines were hardly complete, but used more
They shroud their business with a sort of as fillers. To-day the department store—
mystery which makes one almost suspici- a store of the Wanamaker type—is a colos-
ous of double dealing. It pays in this year sal combination of stores within a store.
of our Lord, 1899, to do a daylight busi- No one of these stocks overshadows an-
ness, flood all your methods with light, and other excepting in the respect that from
then call for more light—advertising light their very nature the investment and con-
—any kind of a light as long as your light sequent business of some must needs be
greater than those of others.
is seen by your fellow men.
But as to the stores which go to compose
T T OW many dealers work for a reputation
the greater stores. They are all equally
as well as for trade and profit ? Still,
important in their relation to the compact
when we come to consider the matter a
whole, each one being required to perform
store with a reputation is always sure of
its work of bringing customers to the store
trade; a store without one must trust
and swelling the profits of the general busi-
largely to chance and to scheming.
ness.
Honesty is the best policy and straight
It is a great problem to bring all of these
dealing always comes out ahead. The
dealer who will buy what is termed in the stocks under the one great merchandising
vernacular as a "thump box " for $75.00 policy which has been decided upon by the
and sell it for $300 or $350 is dishonest, manager-in-chief, who allows each sub-
and such methods are bound to work out manager to conduct the business of his de-
his destruction in the end. A man who partment on lines which are in conformity
pays $300 or $350 for a piano is entitled to with the principles laid down by the gen-
a good instrument. There is a demand for eral management. There must be no con-
pianos in this country—a demand which flicting or clashing of authority. A definite
we claim will absorb 200,000 pianos annu- policy is adhered to in every line, and there
ally if they are sold at the right figure. are, in strictly mercantile language, no pet
But what percentage of them are sold at stocks. Every department manager must
figures which approximate their real be systematic and unremitting in his efforts
to keep in touch with the public needs, and
values?
he employs methods which would confuse
The intermediate element, which is the
the average merchant by their intricate-
real backbone of the Republic, will be
ness and the amount of executive watch-
much larger purchasers if the cheap in-
fulness necessary for their successful oper-
struments are sold to them at an honest
ation.
price. The working man's dollar is just as
Back of all this vast machinery stands the
useful for bill-paying and profit-making as
proprietor
who exercises a general over-
the millionaire's, and he is entitled to
sight over every store which is gathered
receive just as good value for his dollar.
under his vast roof. It is results which he
/COMPETITION is a good thing in is seeking to obtain, and very little senti-
trade only so long as it is wisely ment ever enters into his calculations.
conducted, but it cannot be said that all With an eye always on the last year's fig-
competition is of this sort. Competition, ures, his is constant and steady advance-
however, forces others to follow, and so ment. The goal of his ambition is in-
the evolutionary work goes on. Wherever creased business. To stand still, in his
a betterment is recognized as being possi- doctrine, means retrogression.
compensation let them walk up to the
captain's office and show some definite ac-
complishments rather than this misty,
vagtie, overrated nonsensical influence.

Download Page 5: PDF File | Image

Download Page 6 PDF File | Image

Future scanning projects are planned by the International Arcade Museum Library (IAML).

Pro Tip: You can flip pages on the issue easily by using the left and right arrow keys on your keyboard.