Music Trade Review

Issue: 1899 Vol. 28 N. 21

Music Trade Review -- © mbsi.org, arcade-museum.com -- digitized with support from namm.org
THE MUSIC TRADE REVIEW
bellowings and intemperate ravings anent
stencil and individual members of the trade.
It reminds us of that time in the history of
our " once formidable " when it was at the
flood-tide of its triumph and it sent forth the
ultimatum to the trade to pay its advance
in advertising rates or get out. In other
words, it had dominated, dictated and con-
trolled until it believed that its demands
would never receive a check.
It is well to recall those former condi-
tions and contrast them with the present
day. It would seem to us that the decay
has been so pronounced as to be beyond a
question of argument. Many of the adver-
tisements of the most distinguished houses
in this trade appear no longer in its columns.
Others have refused to bow the head and
bend the knee to those orders, which in by-
gone years were listened to with the closest
attention. The long line of men waiting
their turn to reach the captain's desk and
settle at the crack of the lash was well
understood from the Atlantic to the Pacific.
There was one great dictatorial power which
must be appeased or the heavens would
fall and the welkin ring with the fierceness
of abuse delivered at the heads of those
who refused to pay the regular tribute.
What must the feelings of those men be
to-day who have been forced to pay tri-
bute ? Have they forgotten the unhappy
past, or do they now revel in the oppor-
tunity to give thrust for thrust before the
curtain shall have been rung down upon
the closing act of the drama ?
He is driven to the last ditch. His abusive,
egotistical and insane ravings only show
what desperate straits he has reached. The
mock heroic and the grandiloquent air
which he assumes little becomes his fallen
condition.
THEORIES AND FACTS,
"TRADE during the month of May has
been materially disappointing. On
the whole, we had expected better- things
for the month. With the advance of the
season we naturally expected a quickening
in the demand for pianos and allied prod-
ucts in all parts of the country. --^
In some other industries there is consid-
erable activity, and it is announced that in
the lines in which wire, brass and copper
figure, trade is not only good, but that
further advances will be made in prices.
This will interest piano manufacturers.
It is believed by some that the new con-
solidations which have taken place in al-
most every industry, have had much to do
to hamper trade in nearly all lines, in that
it continues to bewilder the trade and sug-
gests questions as to what the final out-
come is to be on this subject, on which
America seems to have gone mad. Some
expert financiers allege that the heavy cap-
italization of the principal consolidations
in the different trades involves great and
grave financial responsibilities to those
producers. It is argued that the fixed
charges in the way of interest on bonds
and dividends, or preferred stock, are an
addition to cost which gives rival produc-
ers in other sections opportunities for suc-
cessful competition.
It may be of interest to go over some of
the published figures to ascertain approxi-
mately what, on the face of the term, this
means:
Beginning with the Federal Steel Com-
pany we find that this concern have out-
standing $27,359,000 of 5 per cent, bonds
and $2,600,000 of 6 per cent, bonds, which
call for $1,523,450 interest annually. There
is outstanding $53,253,500 of 6 per cent,
preferred stock, which is not cumulative,
however. With a total annual output of
about 1,800,000 tons of finished and partly
finished material this would present a charge
of, say, $2.50 per ton. Since the company
must depend largely upon outsiders for
their coke supply, they must pay a profit in
that direction, and they must also pay
royalties on a considerable part of their
own products. On the other hand, there is
an income of some importance in the way
of subsidies.
The National Steel Company must meet
interest payments on $2,561,000 of bonds,
and provide for 7 per cent, on $27,000,000
preferred cumulative stock, a total of $2,
043,660 of annual charges. The company
have a rated capacity of about 1,800,000
tons of steel, so that this would represent
a charge of about $1.25 per ton. This
looks low, but it must be considered
that the product is the relatively crude
form of billets and sheet bars, and that the
ore supply and the coke supply are only
partly covered. On the other hand, the
close relation between the company^ and
the finishing mills of the American Tin
Plate Company and the American Steel
Hoop Company assures an outlet for up-
ward of 1,000,000 tons of product at re-
munerative rates. It is understood that
the company have long time contracts on a
low basis for Rockefeller ores, and have a
sixth interest in the Oliver Iron Mining
Company's output of iron ore.
The American Steel & Wire Company
have dividends to pay on $38,150,000 of
preferred stock and on about $700,000 of
bonds, making a fixed charge of about $2,-
700,00*0 annually, or, say, $2.75 per ton on
about 1,000,000 tons of finished products.
While controlling only a moderate per-
centage of raw materials, and dependent
n
largely upon others for steel, the wire com-
pany market, besides large lines of staple
goods, very important amounts in value of
high priced specialties.
It is true that these great trusts have
enormous assets, but they also have gi-
gantic responsibilities. How will they all
stand the test of next year's great political
struggle? Will the strength which it is al-
leged unity possesses prove stout enough
to stand the strain?
DEMANDS UPON MANUFACTURERS.
DIANO manufacturers have to suffer a
great deal through unjust demands
made upon them from various sources not
onl)'- from parties who have purchased their
pianos at retail, expecting to expose the in-
struments to all sorts of climatic changes,
and bring them around to the factory in
the course of three or four years, and get
new ones in exchange, but there are many
dealers who will also make exaggerated
and unfair claims upon manufacturers.
In many instances manufacturers will
allow concerns all concessions in the way
of repairs, incidentals, deficiencies, in fact
acquiesce in all of the claims made by their
agents rather than have an open break
with them which means not only the loss of
customers, but indulging in considerable
correspondence of an unsatisfactory na-
ture, and the fear that a refusal on their
part to acquiesce will lead to a knifing of
pianos in their respective territories.
Now pianos, like all other combinations
of wood and metal, are extremely suscep-
tible to atmospheric influences, and it is
folly to suppose that a piano can be ex-
posed to radical changes without showing
the effects of the variations of temperature
through which it has gone.
We have had from time to time, our
attention called to ridiculous and unfair
demands made upon manufacturers. Re-
cently a point in mind:
A Southern house shipped back five
pianos to one of the old and reputable con-
cerns of New York. Some of these instru-
ments had been out over two years, some
in ebony casings and some in mahogany,
but invariably the exposed portions of the
cases were blistered by being exposed to
great dampness. An examination revealed
the fact that all covered portions of the
cases where the scarfs came across the tops
and on the inside of the fall-boards the
varnish was as smooth as polished glass.
The strings of all of these instrument were
badly rusted through exposure to damp-
ness.
All of us who have traveled in the South
know well that that is a most trying part
Music Trade Review -- © mbsi.org, arcade-museum.com -- digitized with support from namm.org
M
THE MUSIC TRADE REVIEW
of our country for pianos, and that last to meet the complacent reception among dry
winter during the unprecedented spell of goods men that has been awarded them in
cold weather, the surface of thousands of other lines. The continual price-cutting on
instruments in the South was injured dur- sugar and a few other commodities con-
ing- the cold snap. But for a dealer to ship trolled by trusts and carried on by the gro-
back five instruments out during a period of cery departments of large department stores
from four months to two years in such is not viewed by the combines that make the
condition is the sort of action we fail to goods with unalloyed pleasure. Perhaps it
understand as belonging to the appreciative is going to be the department store that
class. The manufacturer wrote the dealer, will be the Moses to lead the consuming
stating fairly that he did not consider him- public out of the wilderness of trusts and
self liable for damage caused to instru- monopolies, and those who were quickest
ments by the atmospheric changes and to condemn the department store will rise
exposure to the elements, neither did he up and bless it.
believe any other manufacturer would. He
DOTS AND DASHES.
. asked the dealer to name one manufacturer,
he would appoint another, while the two T H E policy of strict silence is maintained
by our once formidable, now discred-
would appoint a third who would adjust
ited,
contemporary as long as an adver-
the matter, and that he would abide by
tiser continues to pay the price, but the
their decision, be it what it may.
moment he refuses to acquiesce in the de-
To this the dealer demurred. He wished
mands of the editor and withdraws his ad-
all or nothing, no board of adjustment
vertisement, a bombardment of abuse at
would satisfy him. He claimed deductions,
once is inaugurated. "The rotten stencil"
and what is more he took them, and the
only affords a thin pretext for attack. If
result is, the manufacturer has on his
there were sincerity behind these attacks,
hands five instruments of uncertain worth
let us ask why those firms who are pro-
and has lost his representative as well.
nounced stencillers and who continue to ad-
Such incidents are certainly very trying,
vertise in the columns of our once formida-
and if they are to be carried to such con-
ble are free entirely from personal attacks?
clusion it is difficult indeed to determine just
Let any one who has a knowledge of
where the manufacturer's profit comes in.
trade conditions consult the columns of
. Another instance in mind: A gentleman
our contemporary and he will quickly real-
had purchased a piano of a well-known
ize that well-known stencillers still are rep-
New York make some five years ago. Last
resented in its pages, and they are given
winter he was away South with his family
immunity from abuse.
during the cold spell, and there was no fire
What are the deductions that we shall
in the room in which the piano was located.
draw
from this ?
When he came back in the Spring a rousing
Simply this: That our once formidable
fire was built for his reception, and a few
has
never for one moment been anything
days after to his astonishment he discov-
else
than hypocritical upon the stencil mat-
ered that the varnish on the piano, which
by the way was near the fire, had blistered. ter. It is true it has frequently referred
A closer examination showed that the to it in abusive terms, but only when some
strings were rusted. He at once reported advertiser refused to comply with its de-
the condition of his instrument to the man- mands. It is a disgrace and a blot upon
ufacturers and claimed according to his this trade that such conditions exist where
honorable, and reputable firms are sub-
warranty a new instrument.
jected to violent abuse simply through an
Think of that. And still there are those
expressed desire on their part to conduct
who claim that the piano-maker's paths are
their business as they chose.
those of peace and quietude. Well, they
Members of the National Piano Manufac-
may be, but the fact is not conspicuously
turers' Association are interested in this
apparent as we view it.
matter and every one in the trade is;
whether they manufacture stencil pianos
DEPARTMENT STORE ATTITUDE,
or not, there is at stake a vital issue which
L J E R E is an item which will interest
none can afford to overlook.
those who have been condemning de-
partment stores and their methods:
T H A T the leadership of the United States
in commercial and industrial matters is
The thread trust is being openly defied
in Chicago. Last week the Boston Store coming to be recognized by the more
of that city came out boldly and said that thoughtful men of Europe there is a grow-
the trust had refused to sell them, but ing amount of evidence to prove. The
that they would still continue to offer the latest dictum on this head is found in an
standard brands at 2 cents per spool. Evi- interview cabled to New York from Lon-
dently the trade combinations are not going don this week which a reporter had with
Lord Revelstoke, who is a director of the
Bank of England and a member of the
banking house of Baring Brothers & Co.,
Limited, and who has just returned from
a visit to the United States. The
last statement of the interview is as
full of meat as the postscript of a girl's let-
ter. "A visit to America," was Lord
Revelstoke's concluding remark, "is an
education in itself." In the course of ex-
pressing his views as to trusts Lord Revel-
stoke said:
"America probably will make things ex-
tremely uncomfortable, for British in-
dustry, but it is not through the trust idea
that America's greatness is coming. In
my own opinion this great and almost
fabulous consolidation of interests will re-
sult in the near future in a series of crashes,
from which it will take our cousins across
the water a long time to recover. While
consolidation holds some elements of
strength over individuals, yet it can be
carried to such an extreme point that it
at once becomes dangerous."
A MONG the recent important plays upon
the trade chess-board we may reckon
that of Knabe-Starr. It insures the Starr
piano a splendid representation in the East
in the cities of New York, Philadelphia,
Baltimore and Washington, and through-
out that vast territory in which the Jesse
French Co. operate the Knabe will be re-
presented by that concern in important
southern and western strongholds. This
will necessarily mean a transference of the
Knabe agency from some of the old ad-
herents to the Jesse French Co. The Starr
product will have a splendid foothold in
the East where it is rapidly gaining a strong
line of followers.
T F a piano stock is kept dusty and not well
displayed, or a window is dirty and
there is a general dilapidated and unkempt
appearance about the store, how in the
world do men suppose that an jesthetic
clientele will be attracted to such an estab-
lishment?
If a thorough and systematic attention
were given to the arrangement of ware-
rooms it would result, in our opinion, in a
much larger trade. Places which appeal
to public patronage must be kept neat and
attractive, and it pays a business establish-
ment to adopt some excellent rules and
business habits in relation to stock keeping.
Grand Larceny Charged.
William Tunstall, in the employ of the
Mutual Life Insurance Company, has been
arrested at Syracuse, N. Y., on a warrant
charging him with grand larceny. The
complainant is a member of the firm of
Leiter Bros., piano dealers.

Download Page 9: PDF File | Image

Download Page 10 PDF File | Image

Future scanning projects are planned by the International Arcade Museum Library (IAML).

Pro Tip: You can flip pages on the issue easily by using the left and right arrow keys on your keyboard.