Music Trade Review

Issue: 1898 Vol. 27 N. 27

Music Trade Review -- © mbsi.org, arcade-museum.com -- digitized with support from namm.org
¥ HE MUSIC ¥ RADE REVIEW
3—+-EDWARD LYMAN BILL-* •< •
Editor and Proprietor
PUBLISHED EVERY SATURDAY
3 East 14th St., New York
SUBSCRIPTION (including postage), United States,
Mexico and Canada, |i.oo per year ; all other countries,
$300.
ADVERTISE/IE NTS, $2.00 per inch, single column, per
insertion. On quarterly or yearly contracts a special dis-
count is allowed. Advertising Pages $50.00, opposite read-
ing matter $75.00.
REMITTANCES, in other than currency form, should
be made payable to Edward Lyman Bill.
Entered at the New York Post Office as Second Class Matter.
NEW YORK, DECEMBER 31, 1898.
TELEPHONE NUMBER, 1745-EIQHTEENTH STREET.
THE KEYNOTE.
The first week of each month, The Review will
contain a supplement embodying the literary
and musical features which have heretofore
appeared in The Keynote. This amalgamation
will be effected without in any way trespassing
on our regular news service. The Review will
continue to remain, as before, essentially a
trade paper.
SPEAKING OF TRUSTS.
** 'TRUSTS and department stores," and
what in the world are departmen t
stores but limited trusts ? The absorbent
power of trusts is phenomenal, likewise that
of the department store.
A kind of a miniature trust is the depart-
ment store and it is that miniature trust
that the piano merchants of America must
grapple with and in the end one must be
defeated, for the trade cannot exist half
free, half trust bound.
One great factor which is on the side of
the piano merchant—a factor which has
decided every great contest — a factor
which has swept away thrones and demol-
ished dynasties—a factor which the poles
do not cool, or the equator diminish—pub-
lic opinion.
Public opinion, in the case of the depart-
ment store against the piano merchant,
will be of that peculiar consistency that
will cause purchasers to gravitate to the
regular stores rather than the department
stores when they wish to purchase such an
important auxiliary to home comfort as a
piano.
The impelling power will not be as much
a question of price as of pride, and therein
lies the key to the department store com-
petition and the reason why the regular
dealer will have the support of public
opinion. Not because the average citizen
is averse to buying from a department
store, for he is not, but because he is averse
to having all his friends acquainted with
the fact that he dropped into Racy's and
bought one of their Red Star pianos.
Why?
Because there is an unmistakable odor of
cheapness about them, that he is not de-
sirous of having scent up his parlor.
What an awful slump, too,his pride would
take should he happen to overhear one of
his guests remark, " S o Cheaplots bought
one of those ' Red Star ' pianos at Racy's?
I have seen them advertised for weeks for
a hundred and ten dollars."
Or if his friend Mr. Highnobs invites
a few intimates around to spend the even-
ing and one of the ladies should happen to
notice the name upon his piano and should
gushingly remark, "And so that is one of
those bargain ' Werven' pianos that
Gloomydalehas been offering."
How painful the pause would be.
Did you ever know a man to buy a pres-
ent in a department store, remove the
wrapper bearing the stamp of the store
and substitute another before sending?
We have, and what caused him to do it ?
Why, naturally he did not wish the one
for whom the present was intended to
know that he was patronizing the bargain
counters of a department store.
He could secure bargains at Tiffany's or
any other standard regular store without
laying himself open to the charge of secur-
ing cheap or unreliable wares, but once the
threshold of the department store is crossed
there is at once a taint of cheapness which
is most desirable to have disassociated with
an important purchase.
Now it is at this point the pride comes
in in a determining sense.
The one article in the average home that
its owner does not wish to smack of depart-
ment store cheapness is a piano. It is the
piece de resistance of home adornment.
No matter how old it is, he likes it to be
of reputable make, and there is an atmos-
phere of distrust about articles of a certain
class, purchased from a department store.
The name upon the fall board of a piano
has a value in the estimation of the public
and while there may be quantities of
pianos of a certain class sold from depart-
ment stores, that portion of the purchasing
public which we may designate as the
intermediate class will naturally gravitate
to the regular depots of supply.
The name upon the fall-board of a piano
is to a large degree an index of the charac-
ter of the instrument, and it is that name
that is hard to obliterate.
There are other factors which militate
against department store success.
Suppose the agency of a reputable piano
was placed with a department store.
The department stores presumably will
offer the instruments at cut rates.
Then the other agents will object and
probably will drop the instrument from
their lists.
Suppose the department store does not
cut prices?
Then it does no business or least not
enough to warrant devoting to a display of
musical instruments so much space, which
could be better utilized in other ways.
The department store, like its elder
brother the trust, is in business for money,
sells cheap, true, but in the main its stock is
cheap—people are beginning to learn it.
They are not all fools, neither are they
wholly ignorant of mercantile methods.
The thinking portion know full well that
business cannot be done without profit,
neither can large and elaborately equipped
establishments be conducted wholly on
glory and philanthropy. They have their
doubts about the numerous and stupendous
cut prices, they question the specialty of
the special sale.
They know that if a department store
offers a piano for one hundred and twenty
dollars the management of that institution
is losing no money on the transaction.
They know that no man in business can
afford to do away with a profit.
They know that while a merchant can
afford to place a few gross of gloves upon
a bargain counter at a profit of a few cents
per pair he cannot afford to place a large
number of pianos on sale at a price that
does not insure him a profit.
In the first case the handling is rapid,
the amount involved in the individual sale
is small and the sale is repeated in some
cases several times a year.
In the second case the handling is ex-
pensive and laborious, the amount involved
is considerable and the sale is not repeated;
hence a restricted distribution which is not
at all to the liking of the department store
magnate.
That pianos will always be on sale in
department stores is an assured fact.
That the department store will become
the dominant factor in the distribution of
pianos is the veriest fancy which will not
bear an analytical examination.
A TRADE PHANTOM.
'THE whole scheme of department store
dominancy has its origin in the schem-
ing brain of a trade editor who for years has
ridden rough shod over manufacturers at
will and who now seeks to frighten piano
men by asserting that the department
store means the destruction of the legiti-
mate trade. That the piano dealers are
doomed — that the manufacturers them-
selves are now upon their last legs, as it
were, and that the only panacea is a
TRUST ! !
Mark you, a trust will save everything—a
trust is the sheet anchor—the shining light.
Music Trade Review -- © mbsi.org, arcade-museum.com -- digitized with support from namm.org
THE MUSIC TRADE REVIEW
—the peaceful harbor—the sunlit glen—
the one haven of rest where the manufac-
turer, the dealer, the salesman, the office
man will all be taken care of. They can eat
lotos leaves all day, and sing hosannas of
praise all night. Such an entrancing pic-
ture is just too delightful for anything.
Cakes and ale, and ale and cakes.
A perfect piano man's heaven, and the
trust will save all and insure that peace
which is most desired, and that happiness
which was not considered until recently a
part of earth.
A nice little plan and how convenient
for selfish reasons? How opportune the
department store octopus?
One would deduce from his estimate
placed upon them that piano men were a
lot of cackling hens or frightened sheep to
be driven at the will of the man who now
seeks, as of yore, to dominate them.
A trust as a means to preserve the trade
against the (awful?) encroachments of the
department stores.
A trust, is it?
Better a cinch!
That is, if the scheme works, for it means
that the man who would betray the trade
will have first exacted his pound of trade
flesh. For, Shylock that he is, his part is
always assured; his price must be paid.
Now, piano men may understand clearer
the anxiety of the Judas who would betray
those who have supported him for years.
If there really was the least sign visible
upon the trade horizon which portended
trade disintegration, he would be the first
man to flee, for he is a moral as well as a
physical coward.
Trade disintegration, when this industry
in spite of the war has produced in one
year nearly one hundred thousand pianos
as a single item!
A record which has been marvelously
surprising.
What!—with the curtains parted, looking
outward upon a scene more dazzling than the
early founders of the industry ever deemed
the music trade capable of producing,
shall we turn aside for a narrowed future?
Shall the trade be betrayed by a Judas
kiss?
When America sweeps grandly forward
to world-wide industrial conquest, shall
this industry be even temporarily checked
in its expansion by the vile machinations
of a man whose whole career has been one
of selfish intrigue?
The trade needs salvation, does it?
Well, if it does, the salvation that it most
needs is complete isolation from contact
with the man who has tried to thwart its
growth, dwarf its energies, dry up its
founts of inspiration. Freedom from the
contaminating influence of the man whose
very person exudes a noxious poison com-
pared to which that of the Upas tree is ex-
hilarating elixir.
Disintegration, is it, with a brilliant vista
for our industry unfolding before us ?
The new era means the the disintegration
of the powers of the trade Judas who long
has cast his tentacles around the industry.
It means a brighter dawn for the reput-
able manufacturer.
It means that the retailing of pianos will
be done in conformity with those laws
which are operative in all other trades.
It means a broader and more remunera-
tive field for the ambitious, loyal salesman.
It means an advance for upright jour-
nalism, for no honest journalist will have
occasion to defend his profession from the
insult placed upon it by the blackmailer.
And no one realizes the truth of this
more than the blackmailer himself.
With his vocation gone, his journal power-
less, why should he not try for one more
grand swoop before the finale occurs?
Frighten the trade into a trust scheme
through fear of department store compe-
tition ! It would be funny were there not an
element of seriousness generated by reason
of the wily machination of the broken
blackmailer. That element of seriousness
obliterates the otherwise comic opera
effect.
The men who have listened to the oily
arguments of the trade disintegrator should
understand that with him now it is rule or
ruin.
For trade benefit!—the man who more
than all else has spattered the trade struc-
ture with deceit and deviltry !
Point to one honorable act, one unselfish
deed of the Judas, and we will be first to
acknowledge it.
No wonder he is alarmed at the future
of trade journalism—that is, his type of
journalism, God save the mark.
The honest journalist has no fear for the
future, he knows, or at least believes, that
blackmailing competition is something
which he nevermore will have to encoun-
ter, and the wonder grows how men have
endured it so long.
Was it individual rottenness?
Well, the disinfectant has been applied.
The atmosphere has been clarified—the
future is bright with the promise of better
things. Let us open the page for the new
year with hearts buoyant with hope.
" Ring out the old, ring in the new,
Ring, happy bells, across the snow.
#
*
*
*
" Ring out old shapes of foul disease,
Ring out the narrowing lust for gold,
Ring out the thousand wars of old,
Ring in the thousand years of peace ["
THOUGHTS AT RANDOM.
T H E holiday trade for 1898 is now a
thing of the past and it may be as-
serted with safety that the trade for the
past two or three weeks has in many ways
broken former records.
Piano merchants, in common with
others, have come in for a fair share of the
trade.
"Like old times" remark many of those
who have enjoyed deep draughts from the
cup of patronage.
On the whole the retailers of New York
have much to feel thankful for in the
patronage which has been given them
during the holidays. Eighteen hundred
and ninety-eight, the most remarkable
year in many respects that we have yet
seen, is now practically of the past and
when The Review next appears we shall
have formed an acquaintance with the year
which promises in many ways to eclipse
the remarkable record of its predecessor.
The time is here for the annual stock-
taking—the arranging of new plans—the
balancing of accounts—the January talks,
—the clearance sales—the changes in of-
fice, road and wareroom staff—the trust
phantom—the department store illusion.
These and a hundred more topics quite as
fruitful will now be in order for a time.
I T is with infinite satisfaction that we re-
cord the year now so near its close as
the banner year in Review history, which
covers a period of nearly twenty years.
It is gratifying, too, in that it proves
that our policy is in the end a winning
one.
The field of a trade paper is limited, its
circulation is confined to a class, its profits
like all restricted enterprises are small, yet
it is capable of doing much good and con-
siderable harm.
The Review has never been fawning or
sycophantic.
It has been run upon business lines.
It has fought for trade advancement and
trade honor.
It has fought the blackmailer and ren-
dered his blow harmless.
There is not a blot of dishonor upon The
Review escutcheon.
It has been a forceful, consistent publi-
cation.
And so it will continue, for we enter
ranks for the '99 contest in better fighting
trim than ever.
DIANO manufacturers are seeking to in-
terest the consumer more than ever.
For this they are moving tradeward.
They realize that, while the dealer is a most
important factor, an impelling demand.

Download Page 4: PDF File | Image

Download Page 5 PDF File | Image

Future scanning projects are planned by the International Arcade Museum Library (IAML).

Pro Tip: You can flip pages on the issue easily by using the left and right arrow keys on your keyboard.