Music Trade Review

Issue: 1898 Vol. 26 N. 23

Music Trade Review -- © mbsi.org, arcade-museum.com -- digitized with support from namm.org
THE MUSIC TRADE REVIEW
which in due time is bound to envelop
smaller towns, thus hastening the day
when we will be considered a musical
nation.
#
TELEPHONE
NUMBER.
I745.--EIQHTEENTH
STREET.
The musical supplement to The Review is
published on the first Saturday of each month.
An important move is now under way,
which has met with the approbation of
Secretary of War Alger, to increase the
army bands to thirty or thirty-six pieces,
and increase the wages to $30 a month for
the principal musician and $25 for the
members of the band. It is also pro-
posed that the bands should be officially
recognized by the Government.
The 'United States Military Band of to-
day consists of twenty-two men, made up
of two detailed from each company, one
to rank as a principal musician, and twen-
ty-one to rank as musicians. The former
occupies the position of leader and re-
ceives $16 a month as an extra, the prin-
cipal musician $22 a month, and the mem-
bers $13 a month, the usual allowance
made to enlisted men.
The present inadequate pay has com-
pelled army musicians to seek outside en-
gagements. This has occasioned consid-
erable opposition from bandsmen all over
the country. If the Secretary's^ ideas are
upheld, and Congress enacts a law increas-
ing the standing and wages of military
bands the friction which now exists be-
tween the army and civil bands will no
doubt disappear.
Why does the one air in a new opera
catch the taste of the multitude, and be
whistled all over the town before it is a
week old, while other airs in the same
composition, equally melodious—superior,
perhaps, from a musical point of view—
are never heard outside the theatre? What
causes the public to fix upon one tune in
a music hall entertainment and give it
preference over every other tune?
These questions are easier asked than
answered; the secret of musical popular-
ity will probably never be discovered.
Sometimes a song will owe its success to
the circumstances in which it is first heard,
having been composed for a special occa-
sion ; to the fact of its being introduced
by a favorite singer; or to some other
cause in no way connected with the music
itself.
As regards musical worth, it is
always impossible to tell beforehand what
will take the public taste, or how long a
favorite tune may retain its popularity,
often lost as unexpectedly as it was
gained.
#
Musical festivals are now going merrily
on in all quarters of the land, and the
programs show a great variety of choral
music. One thing in connection with
these festivals is worthy of observation,
and that is the continued improvement in
chorus work; it has been noticeable in this
as in all our large cities. This, in a meas-
ure, shows the growth of musical culture,
The Peoples' Singing Classes, elemen-
tary and advanced, under the leadership of
Frank Damrosch, demonstrated by their
brilliant, and in many respects, remark-
able choral work at Carnegie Hall last
week, that we have now " in our midst " a
chorus which is bound in due time to take
high rank and to give some of the older
and more distinguished organizations a
close race in artistic ensemble work.
The results achieved by Mr. Damrosch
in the training of the material at his dis-
posal would occasion surprise were we not
aware of the natural aptitude and talent of
the rank and file of the people who com-
pose these classes.
It is a good thing to know that when
the time shall come for singing
the
hymns of peace, after the war is over,
there will be at command a ready chorus
of thousands of well-trained, fresh and
tuneful voices, just as there was on the
President's call, a ready army of disci-
plined volunteers.
#
Standard musical literature is enriched
by a new volume which has been published
in a very excellent manner by Theodore
Presser, of Philadelphia, entitled " Masters
and their Music," by W. S. B. Matthews.
It is designed as an introduction to music
as a literature for the use of clubs, classes
and private study, and is divided into two
parts. Part I. opens with an able essay on
the "Moving Forces in Music," and deals
with ten of the most noted musicians, the
phases of their art, and explanations of
the typical musical forms.
In Part II. the modern masters and
American composers are treated of in
eight chapters. The opening essay is on
"Nationality in Music." The American
composers selected for comment are
Messrs. Gottschalk, Mason, MacDowell,
Foote, Beach, with minor references to
Kelly, Smith, Norris, Kroeger, Liebling,
Chadwick and Sherwood.
The foreign
musicians include Grieg, Brahms, Rubin-
stein and Tschaikowsky.
The book is ably written. There is an
absence of over-elaboration, and the author
has successfully succeeded in making the
book both interesting and authoritative.
The only criticism that might be made is
that the closing chapter might include
some other worthy names of American
composers in addition to those given.
*
Now that war songs are the order of the
day, it is interesting to note that the first
war song written during the Rebellion was
' ' The First Gun is fired; May God Protect
the Right,"by George F. Root of Chicago.
It never became popular. This was in
1861:
But the next one he wrote was an
inspiration. He was one afternoon lying
down, after having read President Lin-
coln's call for troops, and the words and
music of "The Battle Cry of Freedom"
formed themselves in his mind. The next
morning he composed that wonderful ral-
lying song, which is said to have been the
most popular of the many written during
the war. It was first published by Root
& Cady. William Lewis, who was with
them at the time, says that Oliver Ditson
gave an order for 5,000 copies, and in a
short time another order for 10,000 copies,
followed by a third for 20,000, and finally
an order for 50,000 copies.
"Tramp,
Tramp, Tramp, the Boys are Marching,"
by the same author, was_equally as popular.
Whether it is due to the temperament of
the people or the changing times, it is evi-
dent that the war songs written during the
present trouble have not made an endur-
ing impression, and the great war song has
evidently yet to come.
*
In this city we are now experiencing a
comic or light opera renaissance, and those
who predicted a speedy demise of operetta
as a form of amusement, are evidently
poor prophets. Company after company
are branching out in revivals and still the
public flock to hear them.
The Castle Square Opera Co., at the
American Theatre, have had a most suc-
cessful season and their really clever work
has been suitably appreciated.
At the
Harlem Opera House, Paul Steindorff is
entertaining our up-town friends in light
opera, with a good company, for the sum-
mer months.
Francis Wilson, with the
aid of many noted artists, has gone back
to his first love and the grand revival of
his old success " Erminie," at the Casino,
has made a big "hit." At the Star Thea-
tre, " Pinafore " and " Trial by Jury " and
other well-known operas of that calibre
have been filling the house during the
past few weeks at prices that are phenom-
enally low, while at the Knickerbocker,
"The Bride Elect " shows no intention to
abandon the scene of her triumph.
This is perhaps, an unequalled showing
of operatic ventures in New York, and
the managers will be fortunate if they can
hold public attention during the dual com-
bination of war excitement and torrid
weather.
*
Turin is proud of its new organ, which
local papers claim to be the finest in Italy,
if not in the world.
It is certainly
gigantic, taking up 138 square metres,
with a front of nearly forty yards. There
are 266 pipes and the motive power is
supplied by sixteen bellows worked by
gas.
The organ was built in Turin, and
before being placed in the Church of
Santa Maria del Cuore, will be used at the
Turin exposition for a series of concerts
by eminent organists from various coun-
tries, who have been invited to co-operate.
*
Emil Paur, formerly conductor of the
Boston Symphony Orchestra, and now of
the New York Philharmonic Orchestra,
has been secured by Manager Loewen-
stein, as conductor for the subscription
series of concerts at the Waldorf-Astoria
next year. The orchestra of sixty play-
ers will, it is said, constitute a permanent
organization for symphony and general
concert work.
Music Trade Review -- © mbsi.org, arcade-museum.com -- digitized with support from namm.org
THE MUSIC TRADE REVIEW
SONQS AND SINGERS OF TO-DAY.
Are the songs sung- to-day in our draw-
ing-rooms elevating? Are we, in fact, de-
teriorating? I regret I must answer in the
affirmative. It is a curious thing that the
further we advance in operatic music—the
more dramatic form our oratorio assumes,
the more inartistic, the more inane, our
drawing-room ballads become. It may be
that our dramatic music grows so difficult
both in the voice part and in the accom-
paniment that they practically prohibit
performance, and so the modern ballad
simply owes its existence to the inexorable
law of supply and demand. I have no
doubt, whatever, that there is a great deal
of truth in this; yet I think we are too
lazy rather than too unmusical to appreci-
ate a good song. It may be that singers
give listeners bad habits, or that listeners
give singers bad habits; there is a fault
somewhere. Who is responsible for the
incarceration of Schumann, Schubert,
Brahms, Franz, Berlioz and Sterndale
Bennett? Why is it that Sullivan, Cowen,
and most of the English composers are
represented by their worst, or at least their
less artistic, songs rather than their best?
Is it because of a big compass? Is it be-
cause of a difficult accompaniment? These
two reasons may, in some cases, have bear-
ing, but not always. The amateur singer,
as a rule, has no limits to his compass, and
unless he be an unusually cultivated ama-
teur, he is not particular how the accom-
paniment gets over his difficulties.
What is it that causes a song to become
popular? Of course you will say a good
melody—a "catchy" air. Yes, but what
gives an air that essential qualification—
" catchiness" ? It is rhythm.
Rhythm
forms the basis of all melody. The sim-
pler the rhythm of a song, the more chance
it has for popularity. Take a song, for
instance, like Pinsuti's "Queen of the
Earth." The refrain of this contains—
first two phrases identical in rhythm, and
then a simple phrase containing one long
note followed by triplets is repeated over
and over again to the end. Another pop-
ular song known as "Say Au Revoir, but
not Good-bye," is a repetition of one rhyth-
mical phrase from beginning to end.
This is also the case in that music hall
atrocity, "Sweet Rosy O'Grady."
An
examination of these melodies will be
sufficient to demonstrate the reason why
songs and dance music become popular.
Our modern songs have too little nature
in them. The only elements introduced,
as a general rule, are moonbeams, star-
light and winds that blow from the south.
These effects of nature are introduced
much in the same way as limelight in a
theatre, to illuminate the artist on the
stage. Go into any music shop and look
through the parcel of "new music" spe-
cially laid out for your benefit. What will
you find? You will find that the songs are
continually harping on one string—I and
You, You and I, eternally ringing in your
ears to a waltz refrain. The sun never
shines in these songs. They are always
set "in the nickering firelight" "when
OVIDE MUSIN.
Earnest students of
the violin in the Unit-
ed States will be high-
ly gratified to learn
that Ovide Musin, the
celebrated violin vir-
t u o s o , has decided,
after strenuous solici-
tation, to spend six
months of every year
in New York City,
where he will establish
violin classes upon the
system pursued at the
Royal Conservatory at
Liege,
Belgium,
where he is now lead-
ing professor of the
violin. Mr. Musin will
be able to do this, as
his appointment with
the Belgian Govern-
ment allows him an-
nually six m o n t h s '
leave of absence, the
Liege musical season
being from February
ist to the middle of
July, and the musical
season at New York
from August ist to
February
ist.
The
characteristics which
have made the Liege
school of violin cele-
brated in time past (as well as at the
present day) were a perfect position,
gracefulness of bowing, purity of style,
and general brilliancy of execution—
qualities indispensable for a successful
violin virtuoso.
OVIDH: MUSIN.
Mr. Musin will return to this country
about the ist of August, for the purpose
of opening a representative virtuoso school
of violin affording American students who
cannot go abroad, a finished European
education, and preparing pupils to enter
the Liege Royal Conservatory.
It is his
intention to make this school a permanent
institution, and will be conducted on the
same principles as pursued by him at the
Liege Conservatory.
His headquarters
will be at Steinway Hall.
the lights are low," " when darkness deep-
ens," or "in the hush of the twilight."
Do we not long for a blaze of sunlight to
brighten these dark corners!—a thunder-
storm to clear this unhealthy atmosphere!
Most of these songs are positively silly;
others are ambiguous.
Harold R. White.
*
TOLSTOI AND WAGNER.
Literary faddists are notoriously "off"
when it comes to any remarks about musi-
cal matters. Count Tolstoi, who libeled
Beethoven in his morbid story, the
" Kreutzer Sonata," is now on record with
another exhibition of his weakness in a
treatise on art, in which he takes occasion
to show that he is unable to understand
Wagner. Hence he has joined the active
ranks of the anti-Wagner army, made up
of literary men of distinction.
Of course Tolstoi has been bored by the
usual chatter of irresponsible Wagnerians,
who prate of Bayreuth silence and the rest
of it, and the Russian novelist is not musi-
cal.
He has seen "Siegfried," and that
settled the matter. He was told, he says,
that Wagner's works could only be appre-
ciated amid the darkness, the concealed
orchestra, and other eccentricities of Bay-
reuth, and, therefore, he attributes the
Wagner craze to a species of musical hyp-
notism. Spiritualists, he says, hold the
same argument, for they aver that you are
not able to give an opinion if you have not
been present at seances and manifestations.
In other words, Tolstoi says, "you must
pass some few hours in the company of
people half mad, and repeat the experiment
a dozen times, and you will see what they
see.
In such conditions as these one sees
what one likes. But there is a much simpler
method of arriving at the same result.
You have only to drink alcohol or smoke
opium."
These cynical remarks are not over
clever. A London writer raps Tolstoi
over the knuckles in this wise: "Tolstoi
is doubtless an anti-Wagncrite for pre-
cisely the same reason that the average
'bus driver, or the average bricklayer, or
the average major-general for that matter,
is an anti-Wagnerite—for the simple rea-
son that he lacks the requisite musical
culture to hold any opposite views. Take
a railway porter or a cabman to witness
" Siegfried " and he would doubtless be
just as bored with it us Tolstoi was.

Download Page 4: PDF File | Image

Download Page 5 PDF File | Image

Future scanning projects are planned by the International Arcade Museum Library (IAML).

Pro Tip: You can flip pages on the issue easily by using the left and right arrow keys on your keyboard.