Music Trade Review

Issue: 1896 Vol. 22 N. 4

Music Trade Review -- © mbsi.org, arcade-museum.com -- digitized with support from namm.org
THE MUSIC TRADE REVIEW.
-gfr
EDWARD LYMAN
Editor and Proprietor.
PUBLISHED
EVERY
SATURDAY
3 East 14th St.. New York
SUBSCRIPTION (including postage) United States and
Canada. $3.00 per year; Foreign Countries, $4.00.
ADVERTISEMENTS, $2.00 per inch, single column, per
Insertion. On quarterly or yearly contracts. special dis-
count is allowed.
REMITTANCES, In other than currency form, should
tw made payable to Edward Lyman Bill.
Bntered at tfu New York Post Office as Second Cla ,s Matter.
"THE BUSINESS MAN'S PAPER."J
WHAT CONSTITUTES JOURNALISM.
T would not require the rays of Roent-
gen to show that the interior affairs of
trade are much improved over the week so
recently laid to rest. The trade back bone
has materially stiffened—there is an en-
largement of the vertebrae which is parti-
cularly emphasized in certain localities.
The Wheelock crash has not brought in its
wake the attendant dislocations which many
thought that the trade body proper would
suffer. However, the trade vaticinations
are not all fulfilled, as there are a few
counties remote from Edisonian connection
yet to be heard from.
There is, in strict reference to the Whee-
lock collapse, but little to report beyond
which was presented in these columns last
week.
Receiver' Wiliiam Foster has nothing
to say beyond giving the bare de-
tails which have been previously an-
nounced. Perhaps the most comprehensive
statement of the whole matter, in refer-
I
ence to the various companies involved, was
presented in THE MUSIC TRADE REVIEW of
last Saturday. Aside from the accurate
statement made in our reportorial columns,
there was an editorial which assuredly must
have struck a responsive chord in the trade,
if we are permitted to judge from the many
letters of a semi-congratulatory nature
which we have received anent our remarks
on the one great happening of the week.
When letters are sent to a paper under no
seal of privacy they are in a sense newspa-
per property, and we cannot give good rea-
sons why we should not publish the sub-
joined.
"Your editorial on the Wheelock collapse
was most excellent. You showed a fairness
in handling the subject which must have
commended itself to all readers. The trade
papers, as far as I have seen, have exhibited
a lamentable weakness in this matter. They
have seemed afraid to go into the matter at
length. On such an occasion the trade has
a right to expect something from its news-
paper exponents beyond the mere recording
of news. . . THE MUSIC TRADE REVIEW
did not fail; it proved itself, in the broadest
sense, ' the business man's paper.' "
Another writes: "Thanks to goodness,
one paper has an editorial opinion to ex-
press upon an important happening. THE
MUSIC TR^DE REVIEW resembles the Herald
in its reportorial columns, while its editorial
utterances make it the Sun of trade journal-
ism. "
Thanks, gentlemen of the trade, and
thanks once again. You will find that this
paper will never fail to deal in an exhaust-
ive manner with events of great moment
to its readers. It will always be fair and
just. It will by its policy hold to its sup-
port all fair and liberal minded people. It
will never become a journalistic nonentity.
It will always strive to be a live force, pen-
etrating with cathodic rays the darkest
spots in the trade. The time will never ar-
rive when we will be willing to sidetrack a
fair expression of opinion, for personal feel-
ings of any nature. This paper always has
a duty to perform to its constituency, and
it will loyally carry out its mission. In
hewing to the line, if the chips fly unpleas-
antly, what then ? Once upon a time that
Nestor of American journalism, Charles A.
Dana, remarked of his paper, '' That it was
first of all a religious paper, because it was
bound by religious obligations to the truth
and its own convictions." We are free be-
cause the truth makes us free. We are in-
dependent because our only master is our
own conscience.
shortly give way to a new order of things.
We refer to the fact that certain men think
that music trade papers have no right t a
publish trade news, if it is of a personal
nature, without first consulting the wishes
of the parties mentioned. This condition
has arisen from the fact that the papers
have been run, as a rule, upon narrow
lines. Some men have believed that
music trade papers have had no right to pub-
lish news simply because it was distasteful
to them; that they should first be con-
sulted ; that suppose it is news, their feel-
ings must be first considered. Such a
course has had the direct effect to warp
and contract the policy of music trade
papers. Some men complain of trade
papers, and yet they are doing all in their
power to weaken their mission and lessen
their influence. Imagine Mr. Bennett, Mr.
Pulitzer or Mr. Dana first consulting the
wishes of McKinley or Tom Reed as to the
publication of some inner workings of
their campaign to win the nomination for .
the Presidency.
A paper, be it trade or secular, is a pub-
lic vehicle for the conveyance of news
matter. Who can dispute that in the con-
veying of legitimate news, a paper is only
fulfilling its proper functions ? An inci-
dent to mind, the recent publication of the
proposed Decker Bros. sale. It has been
known for some time that Mr. W. F.
Decker was desirous of retiring from the
piano field. A deal which considered the
disposition of the Decker business was
under consideration. A paper in New
York came out with the details of the
proposed sale, thereby terminating tempo-
rarily the negotiations then fairly under
way.
Was the course of the Courier unjust ?
We say unhesitatingly from a strictly jour-
nalistic standpoint its course was justified.
The matter which it presented to readers re-
lated to an important house. A great deal
was proposed; the members of the trade
were interested.
From a strictly personal view, was it
right to give an undesirable publicity to
certain matters, injuring greatly the
chances of an early conclusion of a dispo-
sition (M the Decker property ? If the
Courier had considered^ the interests of
W. F. Decker ahead of its functions as a
purveyor of news, then it should not have
given publicity to private affairs at such
an inopportune time.
Again, it is not impossible that the edi-
tor of the Courier believed that the editor
of a local trade paper was in the deal to the
extent of interesting Cincinnati parties.
While writing of trade papers, there
Of course, there are many ways of view-
comes to mind a condition which must ing the matter, but journalism shoul
Music Trade Review -- © mbsi.org, arcade-museum.com -- digitized with support from namm.org
THE MUSIC TRADE REVIEW.
always be criticised from a broad stand-
point.
No man should criticise the utterances of
a paper without first posting himself as to
just what constitutes legitimate journalism.
IMPORTS AND THE TARIFF LAW.
HE Treasury report of exports and im-
ports of musical instruments for the
past twelve months, ending December
31st, 1895, which appeared in this paper
last week, throws strong light on the work-
ings of the present tariff law.
For years the doctrine was disseminated
broadcast by one of our political parties
that it would prove to the interest of the
country to lower the import duties. It
was contended that a multitude of advan-
tages would accrue to mantrfacturers and
consumers alike; raw material could be
imported at a low price, and manufactured
articles could be sold cheaper—the people
would derive the benefit direct—and all
that.
The agitation was successful, and these
theories were put into effect when the Wil-
son Bill became a law.
What has been the result in the music
trade industry?
Duringthe year 1894-5 we imported $622,-
419 worth of musical instruments, against
$1,252,686 in 1895-6—an increase of over
50 per cent.
These figures are stupendous—alarming,
in fact—but they might be palliated did
our exports show as substantial an in-
crease.
What do we find ?
In 1895-6 we exported musical instru-
ments to the value of $286,082, as against
$231,256 in 1894-5—a puny increase com-
pared with the volume of our export trade.
And yet there can be found people who
proclaim in the face of these figures that
this condition of things is beneficial to our
industry and the country at large!
Beneficial, no doubt, to manufacturers in
Europe who have received during the past
year over six hundred thousand dollars
in increased trade from this country. A
large sum of money truly, which would
have kept our workingmen employed and
our factories busy.
The question arises, how are we to com-
bat this steady increase in our import
trade which is now evident month after
month?
It seems to us we must restore the
former, or, at least, increase the present
tariff duties, or otherwise cheapen the
cost of production by lowering wages,
quality, etc., in order to compete with the
foreign manufacturer.
T
This, however, opens up a wide field for
discussion, and will hold for a future time.
The interesting article on wool from
the pen of Mr. L. Cavalli, elsewhere in
this issue, bears on another phase of this
question, and is well worth perusal. It
demonstrates that wool growers are also
suffering from the effects of the "Cleve-
land millennium." Their bill of losses
amounts to $100,000,000 since the enact-
ment of the Wilson free wool bill.
No wonder we have had business depres-
sion, bond issues and governmental bank-
ruptcy !
important points in widely separated local-
ities were included in that morning's ship-
ment. Judging from indications all about,
this will be a Steinway year.
THERE is nothing new to chronicle re-
specting the Smith & Nixon reorganization.
"Progress has been reported," and details
will be forthcoming in due time.
JOSEF KUDER,
of Sohmer & Co.,
leaves on Tuesday with his wife, for a
short trip to Florida.
FRED. KRANICH, of Kranich & Bach re-
turned Thursday from a business trip
through the New England States.
HERE is no denying the fact that
WILLIAM DALLIBA DUTTON, of Hard-
the medium price piano—the cheap man, Peck & Co., New York, left the city
piano—call it what you will—is here to on Friday morning, on a short business
stay for quite a little time, judging from trip to Philadelphia. He will return early
in the week.
the number of manufacturers who are now
THE Mason & Hamlin Co. intend to open
entering upon the manufacture of "good
a
branch
house in Bangor, Me.
pianos at a low price."
CHAS. CLARK will be in charge of a branch
In this connection a most important duty
store of the B. Shoninger Co. in South Nor-
lays with the dealers handling these instru-
waik, Conn.
ments, and that is to tell the truth about
FRED. SCHLENDER'S music store, 145
them.
Gwinnett street, Brooklyn, was entered by
This is the duty of the hour.
thieves last Wednesday, who carried off
The public may be induced by misrep- $125 worth of musical instruments.
resentation to purchase instruments which
A. HOSPE, JR., the well-known music
are not in any respect worth the prices trade dealer of Omaha, Neb., has been
asked for them. It can be fooled.
elected president of the recently organized
But the honest dealer desirous of being Retailers' Club, of that city.
fair to his customers and fair to the manu-
WM. F. BOOTHE, of the Sebastian Som-
mer
Piano Co., left this week on a short
facturers, will sell the cheap piano at its
:
business
trip.
real value.
:'
There is a business principle in a matter
G. A. CHENEY, of Pratt, Read & Co., Deep
like this which should rise superior to River, Conn., was in town Tuesday.
sordid considerations.
LOOK out tor the A. M. McPhail Piano
A cheap piano sold at its real price can Co.'s catalogue, which will soon make its
in the end only tend to make customers appearance.
for high-grade instruments; cheap pianos
ALBERT T. STRAUCH, of Strauch Bros.,
sold abcve their value, however, will work returned last Saturday from a very success-
an injury to the trade at large and to the ful Western trip.
seller.
THE soloist at Thursday's ^Eolian con-
cert
was Jeanne Franko, violiniste.
It is the duty of the dealer to keep the
cheap piano in its proper place—to sell it
PRESTO made its appearance last week
at its real value. In this way he will with an artistically conceived cover.
reflect credit on himself and the industry in
AMONG the members of the trade in town
which he is interested.
this week were: C. H. Sweezy, Middletown,
N. Y., R. C. Forbes, Watertown, Conn.,
Edmund Cluett, of Cluett &Sons Troy, N.
ii P ) U S I N E S S , " said Nahum Stetson,
Y., Col. Harry Sanders, of Sanders &
\j
whom we saw at his desk yester Stayman, Baltimore, Md., P. J. Healy and
day, "has materially improved within the son, Chicago.
past few days; the satisfactory adjustment
J. R. MASON, secretary of the Sterling
of the bond matter has had a beneficial Co., will leave next Monday for the West.
effect all around, Now if people would He will journey as far as St. Paul, stopping
only carry their heads erect, throw a little at various points en route.
energy into their movements, the improve-
ALLEN T. DODWORTH, one of New York's
ment of trade would be greatly acceler- old time bandmasters, died last Thurs-
ated. Orders are coming in for Steinway day at his home in Pasadena, Cal. He was
pianos; here are orders for shipment this 74 years old.
E. E. ANDRUS, music dealer, Vassar,
morning." Looking at the tags as they lay
Mich.,
has sold out his business.
upon Mr. Stetson's desk we saw that many
T

Download Page 4: PDF File | Image

Download Page 5 PDF File | Image

Future scanning projects are planned by the International Arcade Museum Library (IAML).

Pro Tip: You can flip pages on the issue easily by using the left and right arrow keys on your keyboard.