Music Trade Review

Issue: 1896 Vol. 22 N. 24

Music Trade Review -- © mbsi.org, arcade-museum.com -- digitized with support from namm.org
THE MUSIC TRADE REVIEW.
- ^ . E D W A R D L\MAN
Editor and Proprietor.
PUBLISHED
EVERY
SATURDAY
3 East 14th St.. New York
SUBSCRIPTION (including postage) United States and
Canada, $3.00 per year; Foreign Countries, $4.00.
ADVERTISEMENTS, $2.00 per inch, single column, per
Insertion. On quarterly or yearly contracts. special dis-
count ta allowed.
REMITTANCES, in other than currency form, should
0* made payable to Edward Lyman Bill.
Bntered at the New York Post Office as Second-Class Matter.
NEW YORK, JULY 4, 1896
TELEPHONE NUMBER 1745. — EIGHTEENTH STREET.
••THE BUSINESS MAN'S PAPER."
THE NECESSITY \FOR PROTECTION
LL fair-minded men — men w h o
rigidly adhere to lines of decency,
of honor, of truth and of self-respect—
need not carefully study the statutes in
order that they may not overstep the divid-
ing line between honesty and dishonesty.
They are governed by a certain feeling or
principle which we are prone to designate
as conscience. If all men possessed this
human attribute to even an ordinary
degree, there would be no need or necessity
for making our statute books overcumber-
some by steadily adding to their size and
unwieldiness.
The same rules apply to every sub-divi-
sion of employment in life. Business men
who conduct establishments make them-
selves respected and their names of weight
in the commercial world by adhering to
certain lines of principle and honor in the
conduct o( their affairs, so that they fairly
earn the respect and esteem of their con-
stituency.
Do they consult the statute books in or-
A
der that they may conduct their business
honestly ?
No. They are governed by conscience,
and what in the innermost depths of their
heart they consider to be the principles of
honor.
It is true there are instances wherein
men have overstepped those lines unknow-
ingty and unwillingly as well.
It is true also there is a class of men who
endeavor by certain sharp practices to gain
supremacy in their own peculiar walks in
life. Sometimes these methods succeed
temporarily. And again, men run the
whole gamut of life without once being
called to account.
The same laws and variations apply to
every sub-division in the commercial, and
we may add, in the journalistic world, hav-
ing as a sub-division of the latter—trade
journalism.
In the latter we find men who adhere to
certain lines which they believe fair, equit-
able and just. These by the conduct of
their business on legitimate lines have
fairly earned the right to the esteem of the
particular trades of which they are expo-
nents.
Unfortunately, this class as in the busi-
ness world, is invaded by men who seek
under the misapplied name of journalism to
carry on certain unfair, dishonorable and
oftentimes dishonest operations. Their
works have had an effect to taint what other
wise would be the pure stream of journalism.
Journalism, like manufacturing, is in it-
self a noble enterprise, but it has its abuses
as well as uses. But take as in the case of
the self-respecting business man, the honest
journalist does not consult the statutes of
the country or the mandates of any particu-
lar body of men. Why?
He conducts his business fairly, he is
guided by that inner consciousness—that
is, he is working on correct lines. Know-
ing this, and strong in his own convictions,
he works on for the right regardless of the
storms which beat around him, or the reso-
lutions which may have been passed to ex-
ercise a certain censorship over his craft.
He realizes, as in the case of statutes,
that all men are not fair men; that all men
are not honest men; therefore, it is neces-
sary to make laws for the law breakers and
to see that they are enforced for the protec-
tion of society.
Laws are not primarily made in a re-
vengeful spirit, they are made for the pro-
tection of society against evil doers; thus
we may consider that the resolutions of the
New York Association were passed not as
a menace to trade journalism, not as an in-
terference with the legitimate functions of
a paper, but as a matter of protection for
its members against the unwarrantable, in-
solent and dishonest methods which have
obtained in the past.
Is it not a wise protection?
We say most emphatically, yes.
This is precisely the position we have
taken unqualifiedly from the start. We,
with others, believe in honest, free,
independent trade journalism. We do not
believe in the supplicating, or in the men-
dicant style. We believe that journalism
when run on dignified lines dignifies the
trade which it represents.
We have expressed ourselves in no un-
equivocal language regarding this matter,
and propose to the end to work on the same
lines to which we have closely adhered for
many years.
We never have hesitated to speak boldly
concerning any trade or firm. We never
have hesitated in the slightest when the
occasion has arisen for criticising work of
any one engaged in our particular field of
journalism when their work or expression
deserved censure. In fact, we have always
exercised a degree of fearless independence.
Possibly others may criticise our work.
They have that right and privilege.
If we interpret correctly the meaning of
the Association's resolutions, it is not to
bring to trial a publisher for alleged
offenses committed m the past, but that
the resolutions are to apply to any act
which a conductor of a trade paper may
make in the future which is offensive to
any member of the Association.
With this clearly in view we say this,
would not some of our contemporaries do
well by refraining from their attacks upon
the paper which they directly accuse of
being the cause of the action of the Associ-
ation?
Granting that this may be tiue, then
why not, as journalists, accept the ruling
of the Association in the same broad spirit
in which it is given and let the dead past
bury its dead. In other words, why rake over
the dying embers of the past to fan into
life some alleged offense committed years
ago?
It might be well for the one who is loud-
est in his denunciations of the past record
of the alleged offending paper to halt—to
consider that if the Association were to try
trade paper editors on their past record,
that about the first thing necessary here in
New York would be the purchase of a com-
petent disinfectant in large quantities.
The re-publication of the life of one of
those who is loudest, most persistent in his
abuse and mouthings would certainly not
read pleasant in all its varied phases, and
Music Trade Review -- © mbsi.org, arcade-museum.com -- digitized with support from namm.org
THE MUSIC TRADE KEViF*
we fear the uncovering of the past would
cause the arising of such a strong effluvia
that it would take an able bodied disinfect-
ant to neutralize its effect.
Again, the members of this trade to-day
are in the main fair men.
They have con-
the Hallet & Davis Co. from the decision
A. J. BROOKS, who travels in a dual ca-
of a lower court relative to the seizure of a pacity, that of representing the Sterling
piano in default of nonpayment of install- and Huntington pianos, arrived in town
Thursday from a long jaunt West.
ments, goods purchased on the installment
plan cannot be seized by the party who sold
W. B. TREMAINE, of the ^ o l i a n Co., New
them unless the money paid in is refunded
York, returned yesterday from a short
business trip to Buffalo and Rochester.
sidered the matter thoroughly, and do not —deducting, of course, a fair amount for
propose to try on past
issues.
They
A. E. OLNEY, of Holyoke, Mass., who
formerly had a music store in that city, has
just been granted a patent on a delicate
mechanism for ringing tunes on tubular
chime bells, for uses in houses and halls,
which is a perfect imitation of the chimes
in church towers.
the use of the wares.
believe, however, that there is a certain
virulent poison in the veins of music trade
journalism, and they propose if this poison
comes to the surface and forms an ulcer, to
at once remove it, even though a deep cut-
ting process is necessary.
JUSTICE FURSMAN, of the Supreme Court,
W. W. PUTNAM, the enterprising organ
Now, there are more cases than one in
manufacturer
who located in Staunton,
which that poison lurks. The members of
Va., several years ago, purchased the
the trade know this, and they are not to be
Staunton furniture factory, a large building
deceived. There is nothing in the fact situated a short distance east of the city,
that because the surface is smooth that last Monday, and will convert it into an
there may not lurk underneath a subtle organ factory. The work of remodeling
poison which may come to a head at any the building will begin at once.
on motion of the District Attorney, dis-
missed on Wednesday the indictment
against James J. Brady, former Superin-
tendent of Buildings, who was charged
with corruptly receiving a piano from John
J. Weser, of Weser Bros.
L. M. WATKINS, an experienced organ
maker, who was with M. P. Moller for a
time.
THE genial "Charlie" Parsons left last number of years, is about to organize a
They are not taking at the present time Wednesday on his annual European pil- company in Hagerstown -to manufacture
reed organs.
such a great amount of stock in the men grimage. His trip is not exactly one of
pleasure, as he will devote considerable time
J. H. HICKOK, dealer, of Poughkeepsie,
who in the past have been false to their
to looking after the Needham interests in N. Y., and Mr. Eastman, of Eastman &
friends—false to themselves and false to the
London, particularly at the Music Trade Ross, Newburgh, N. Y., were in town the
interests reposed in them. Disloyalty and Exhibition, which opens at the Royal Ag- early part of the week.
treachery are words which carry deep ricultural Hall on July 10th.
meaning and are not synonymous with suc-
HERMAN A. BRAUMULLER,
cess.
They do not consider that a mere
mock conversion to-day, because it pays,
you know, obliterates entirely the fact that
in the past men could not be trusted be-
cause they were traitors to their friends,
because like the fawning curs they turned
and bit the hands that fed them.
It is true, the conversion may be real,
may be genuine, may be lasting, but at the
same time we rather cherish the belief that
the leopard does not change its spots.
#
#
Owing to the fact that we go to press a
day earlier than usual, we are not able to
present the result of the adjourned meeting
of the creditors of Chase & Smith, Syra-
cuse, which occurred Wednesday.
It is
believed, however, that the concern will be
formed into a stock company in which the
creditors will take stock.
#
The investigation of the affairs of Craw-
ford,
Ebersole & Smith, Cincinnati, was
concluded on the 26th ult.
It will be some
time before the statement will be given out
to the public.
#
#
of
RUDOLF DOLGE, of Alfred Dolge & Son,
E. GABLER & BRO., New York, will have
their new piano catalogue ready for the
trade next week.
THEODORE
PFAFFLIN,
of
Chickering &
Sons, New York, received a visit from Mr.
Emil Liebling, the noted Chicago pianist,
on Thursday last. "Mr. Liebling left the
city yesterday to meet his family at Pine
Point, Me., where he will remain for the
summer months.
the assiduous road
representative for Marshall & Wendell,
Albany, N. Y., is in town, and will make
his headquarters in New York during the
summer months.
this week.
#
#
According to the decision of the Supreme
Court of Ohio, last week, in an appeal by
J
OHN O'CONNELL, agent for the Treat
& Shepard Co., Bridgeport, Conn.,
was arrested last Monday morning on a
warrant sworn out by Joseph Mills, of East
Setauket, L. I., who charges O'Connell
with forcibly seizing an organ without hav-
ing obtained permission from the authori-
ties to enter his residence for such a pur-
pose. Sheriff Brown made an effort to de-
tain O'Connell in Port Jefferson the day
the instrument was removed. Bonds were
furnished for the appearance of O'Connell
by Mr. Taylor, Treat & Shepard's manager.
It seems that Mills purchased an organ
in 1886, for which he agreed to pay $60 on
the installment plan, and agreed if the
amount was not paid within a certain time
to forfeit the sum he paid out and the or-
gan also. In ten years Mills arranged to
pay $32, and during the last four years has
absolutely refused to pay a cent.^
Mr. O'Connell will be given a hearing
next Monday, and if held the prosecution
will be obliged to secure extradition papers
to take him to Port Jefferson for trial.
Adolph fleyer's Affairs.
MR. AND MRS. GEO. B. JENNINGS, of Cin-
cinnati, O., have been spending a week in
New York. They left on Friday last for
Niagara Falls, where they will spend the
Fourth of July, prior to their return home.
On account of Saturday being a holiday,
THE REVIEW is published one day earlier
Seized an Oivan.
Otto
New York, made a flying trip to Philadel-
phia on Wednesday last.
ALFRED SCHINDLER,
#
son
Braumuller, president of the Braumuller
Co., left the city yesterday on a three
weeks' visit to his uncle, L. M. French,
with the John Church Co., Chicago. Her-
man A. is one of the brightest of the "com-
ing generation" in the New York piano
trade, and his visit to Chicago will doubt-
less prove both pleasurable and profitable.
ERNST KNABE, of
Wm.
Knabe
& Co.,
Baltimore, Md., was presented with a
bouncing baby girl on Friday last.
MESSRS.
EDWIN
and
Fred
Cluett, of
Cluett & Sons, Troy and Albany, were in
town the early part of the week.
W
E stated last week that a report had
reached us that a well-known dealer
of Omaha, Neb., was in financial difficul-
ties, but that particulais were lacking. It
was to the effect that Mr. Adolph
Meyer, of Omaha, Neb., was in financial
difficulties. This seems to be confirmed
by a later report, although in the East there
is but little known as to the general condi-
tion of his affairs.

Download Page 4: PDF File | Image

Download Page 5 PDF File | Image

Future scanning projects are planned by the International Arcade Museum Library (IAML).

Pro Tip: You can flip pages on the issue easily by using the left and right arrow keys on your keyboard.