Music Trade Review

Issue: 1896 Vol. 22 N. 20

Music Trade Review -- © mbsi.org, arcade-museum.com -- digitized with support from namm.org
THE MUSIC TRADE REVIEW.
The Piano Industry in Canada.
PHENOMENAL DEVELOPMENT UNDER THE NATIONAL POLICY OF PROTECTION
ANNUAL PRO-
DUCTION OF PIANOS IN 1877 WAS 7 0 0 TO-DAY NOT LESS THAN 7 , 0 0 0
SOME OF THE
LEADING HOUSES WILLIAMS, HEINTZMAN, NORDHEIMER, HOERR BROS.,
MASON & RISCH, NEWCOMBE, MENDELSSOHN CO. AN INTER-
ESTING RESUME FROM A CANADIAN STANDPOINT.
deal of capital would be rendered unpro-
ductive, and a great many people would be
exposed to the misery of idleness and
poverty. The story of 1876 would be re-
peated in 1897.
Caught in our Drag-net.
C
not less than $600,000 per annum. Take,
as an instance, the industry built up by
Mr. R. S. Williams, the father of the Cana-
dian piano manufacturing business. In
1877 Mr. Williams employed seven or eight
men on pianos, and his output varied from
twelve to twenty a year. The people were
prejudiced in favor of the imported article,
and it was hard to establish a trade in
home-made goods. Since protection was
established his business has developed, un-
til to-day he turns out two or three pianos
Much as we would like to increase the every working day, employing 160 men,
volume of our exports to the Queen's and paying in wages the sum of $2,000 a
Dominion, yet it cannot be denied that week. Abovit two years ago he branched
the present policy of protection has done out into the manufacture of small musical
considerable for Canada. A study of t h e ' goods, such as mandolins, violins, banjos,
industrial enterprises which have flourished guitars, and other sundries, an entirely
and grown strong under the banner of pro- new industry in Canada. He has now
tection will convince the foreigner as well as twenty men at work on these instruments,
the native that this national policy is as and his trade in them is growing quite
beneficial to Canada as it has been in the rapidly. His entire industry is a fitting
past, and will be in the future, to this example of the.benefits of a policy of pro-
tection in this line. Another is the large
country.
The growth of the music trade industry firm of Pleintzman & Co., whose factory at
in Canada is due almost entirely to their Toronto Junction gives work to 125 hands,
protective policy. It has attained immense with a pay-roll amounting to $60,000 an-
proportions since 1877. At that time the nually; and there are besides many well-
production of pianos in the Dominion known firms, such as Mason & Risch, New-
amounted to something over 500, and the combe, Gerhard Heintzman, Nordheimer,
industry employed not more than 125 the Mendelssohn Co., Hoerr Bros., and
workmen. The trade was chiefly in the others, both in and outside this city, who
hands of the American makers, on whose are to-day producing better pianos and at
goods there was a duty of 17^2 per cent. cheaper prices than were ever before sold
The price of American pianos was some- in Canada.
what higher than in the United States.
The result of all this is that the Canadian
When the National Protective Policy came piano trade is now almost entirely supplied
into force factories were built in various by the home manufacturers. There is a
parts of Canada, and the small industries small amount of imports, which is about off-
already in existence rapidly increased their set by the exports to other countries. The
output. The price did not go up at any annual production amounts in value to about
time, but as competition became keener $3,000,000, and is taken up by Canadians,
was gradually reduced, until to-day, as who have lost much of their former prefer-
everyone knows, a piano can be bought at ence for foreign goods. Pianos are much
a much lower price and on better terms cheaper than they were under free trade,
than ever before. After eighteen years of and the purchasing power of the people is
protection, it is worth while noting the much greater. Besides, the extension of
change wrought in the piano industry. In the piano factories has given a new impetus
Toronto and Toronto Junction alone there to cognate industries. Two firms in Tor-
are eight or nine large factories, whose an- onto have started the manufacture of piano
nual output amounts to- 2 500 pianos, on a actions, all of which have heretofore been
low estimate. In other places in'Ontario imported, and the quality of their product
there are about a do^en more, who turn out is rapidly improving.
There is also a
from 2,500 to 3,000 instruments; and in piano keyboard industry in Toronto, and
Montreal there are several makers, who many other accessories, such as the iron-
produce about 2,000 pianos each year. work, the bolts, screws, varnish, and glue,
These figures are only approximate, but are made entirely in Canada for the Cana-
one of the most experienced gentlemen in dian piano men. Under a policy of "free
the piano business is authority for the trade on broad lines" these factories would
statement that the annual output of pianos be quickly wiped out. The piano market
from Canadian makers is not less than 7,- would be thrown open to American and
000 instruments, and prcbably more.
German competition at ruinous prices.
These industries represent a capital of at The money which is now spent among
least $2,000,000. They employ about I,TOO Canadian factories for Canadian goods
hands, to whom they pay in wages a sum would be sent out of the country. A great
ANADIAN manufacturers, like those
in this country, are deeply interested
at the present time in the question of "pro-
tection," which is happily termed the
"national policy." They are advocating
its continuance, and it is one of the party
questions which will be decided at the
forthcoming elections in that country. In
the meantime, the development of contem-
plated enterprises will remain /// statu quo
until the result of the election becomes
known.
NEWHOUSE & LUETEKA, music trade deal-
ers, Terre Haute, Ind., have dissolved
partnership. The dissolution was brought
about through the Smith & Nixon assign-
ment.
A MOVEMENT is under way in Indianapo-
lis, Ind., looking to the establishment of a
large pipe organ factory in that city.
Some of the Boston organ houses are inter-
ested.
THE bill amending the copyright law to
permit criminal and civil suits for unau-
thorized performances
of musical or
dramatic compositions has been passed by
the Senate, and will no doubt receive the
President's signature. The measure is a
good one.
H. M. CABLE, vice-president of the Chi-
cago Cottage Organ Co., has been rusticat-
ing at his summer home in Walton, N. Y.,
during the past week. This has resulted,
as a matter of course, in the usual crop of
rumors of "big deals in the East," etc.
THE summer Autoharp trade promises to
be very satisfactory.
May business for
this year is reported to be considerably
ahead of the corresponding month last
year.
WILLIAM H. JOHNSON, of W. H. Johnson
& Co., Halifax, N. S., is expected in New
York to-day.
AMONG the members of the trade in town
during the week were E. W. Furbush,
of Vose & Sons, Boston; Alfred Schindler,
with Marshall & Wendell, Albany; A. G.
Wigand, wich the Starr Piano Co., Rich-
mond; W. C. Burgess, and Mrs. Wegman,
of the Wegman Piano Co., Auburn.
ALFRED MEYER writes the Newark, N. J.,
News to announce that all the piano stores
on Broad street will close Saturdays at 12
o'clock during the months of July, August
and the first Saturday in September. F.
R. Feehan, manager of the Bradbury piano
warerooms, informed him of this fact.
J. B. JENKINS, who for
years has been
the able representative of the Hobbie
Music Co., has now gone into business for
himself, and has formed a partnership with
W. W. Hamilton, a business man of many
years experience. The style of the firm is
Hamilton & Jenkins, and located at Bram-
well, W. Va. They are selling the famous
Conover, Schubert and Kingsbury pianos,
and the Chicago Cottage organs.
A MUSIC store has been opened in Coving-
ton, Ky., by E. B. Sanderson & Co,
Music Trade Review -- © mbsi.org, arcade-museum.com -- digitized with support from namm.org
THE MUSIC TRADE REVIEW. '
I
T seems that Henry Behr believes in the
doctrines advanced by Geo. P. Bent, that
a piano manufacturer cannot successfully
make two grades of pianos. Geo. P. Bent
says:
" I do not wish more trade than I can get
on one brand and one name—I do not need
to "stencil" goods, or make, or claim to
make, two or three grades in order to keep
my factory busy.
" I do not believe that more than one
grade can be made in the same factory, and
I do believe that where the attempt to do
so is entered into, the result will be, even
if honestly undertaken, that all grades will
sink, in that shop, to the level of the lowest
one."
Henry Behr evidently believed in sub-
stance the same, for had he and his associates
believed that it was possible to make suc-
cessfully a cheaper grade than the present
Behr piano, they would manufacture it in
their present factory without the retire-,
ment of Henry Behr from the corporation.
For my part, I must say that Mr. Bent
in his famous letter to the trade expressed
some very strong arguments logically told.
There is no question but that the odor of
cheapness will hang about a man if he is
associated in any way with the manufacture
of cheap pianos. It was one of the strong-
est factors in the downfall of the Weber-
Wheelock combinations.
Mr. Wheelock,
while in command of the Weber business,
could not separate himself from the odor of
cheap pianos as long as he maintained a
direct connection with his other enterprises.
In fact, salesmen all over the country fre-
quently remarked, in the vernacular of the
day, "that it was a dead easy thing to
come against the Weber piano in competi-
tion."
me that he thought it had not in the slight-
est, so it seems that in the wheel trade it
is possible to make a first and second grade
without the second grade lowering the
standing of the higher one.
I ascertained also that the Pope Manufac-
turing Co. sell the "Columbia" and "Hart-
ford" to only one dealer in a town. The
"Columbia" is sold under a written agree-
ment that it shall, during the continuance
of the contract, be sold exclusively as a
leader.
I think in the piano trade the matter of
making two grades of pianos without the
lower priced one detracting from the high-
er, is also a matter of business ability.
The success of both enterprises depends
clearly upon the manner in which the in-
struments are sold and kept before the
trade and public.
Take the case of J. V Steger, of Chicago.
While he manufactures the "Singer" as a
second piano made in a different factory, it
has not in the slightest affected the sale or
the standing of the ' ' Steger.'' On the con-
trary, it has rather assisted the Steger to
hold a first position. This cheap and high
grade piano talk, I think, is like everything
else, that no general rule will apply to all
cases.
present leases and cluster around No. 601
Washington street.
Casting a retrospective glance at the his-
tory of the retail music trade in Boston, I
do not find that in the past they have fol-
lowed with apparent eagerness any loca-
tion or move which Mr. Scanlan may have
made. In fact, I think the Courier's article
in its entirety is a direct insult to the in-
telligence of the entire Boston trade.
I do not consider that it is necessary
while acknowledging Mr. Scanlan's shrewd-
ness and business acumen, to insult the in-
telligence of the men who constitute the
retail trade of the New England metropo-
lis; neither do I believe that it would be a
difficult task for the piano dealers offering
pianos of a similar grade to those sold by
Mr. Scanlan " to get on a basis of competi-
tion with him." Furthermore, Ido not be-
lieve that they will follow him any more
than they have in the past. The piano
trade of Boston do not stampede like a
flock of sheep to follow Mr. Scanlan or any
other man in a new business move or ven-
ture.
*
The Indicator is apparently as fully con-
fident as I am that William McKinley
will be the next President of the United
States, and in its last issue nominates Cal-
vin Whitney, president of the A. B. Chase
Co., as Secretary of the Navy.
Why not Secretary of the Treasury ? A
keen, level-headed business man, and a
sound protectionist like Mr. Whitney, is
badly wanted as successor to Mr. Carlisle.
He would put finances on a solid basis
and secure sufficient income to run the
Government without getting into debt.
Secretary of the Navy ? Perish the thought!
I nominate Calvin Whitney as Secretary
of the Treasury. What say you, dear In-
dicator!'
In commenting upon the recent move of
Thomas F. Scanlan, in securing a lease for
the building Nos. 597-601 Washington
street, Boston, The Musical Courier says:
The whole drift of the retail piano busi-
ness toward the direction of Park Square
and beyond that point on Boylston street,
is now suddenly arrested, and Washington
street, the greatest retail thoroughfare in
Boston, can no longer be ignored by the
piano trade as it has been since the invasion
of Tremont and Boylston streets.
It is extremely doubtful if this action of
Mr. Scanlan will not prove a serious blow
to the whole Boylston street piano scheme.
Our esteemed contemporary, the National
For years to come that street will not
be in condition on account of the city im- Recorder, of Washington, D. C., published
provements now in progress, and all traffic in its last issue a seven column "list of
is impeded, while the street is at times a
inventions," among which
I
most disagreeable thoroughfare.
With a needed
great retail piano business drawing its notice the following:
"An automatic attachment by which
trade in another direction, diametrically
opposite, and in a position not only acces- pianos can be played by the use of stenciled
sible, but the most accessible that can pos- paper rolls like those employed in organ-
The only practical device now
sibly be found, it will be a difficult task ettes.
for the piano houses on Boylston street to known costs $250, or almost the price of a
get on a basis of competition with Mr. piano.
Scanlan. He will be followed by other
It is very probable che National Recorder
Still, the ground is a debatable one.
piano firms. They must follow him to do is not acquainted with the fact that the Au-
Let us look at the bicycle industry, and business, and as he always and inevitably
we find the Pope Manufacturing Co. make does business all the time himself, it would tomaton Piano Co., of this city, are selling
attachments for $100, and that the Wilcox
two grades of wheels. Their "Columbia" be fatal to his competitors to ignore him.
&
White Co., of Meriden, Conn., are also
stands at the head of the list of the entire
I can hardly think just because Mr. Scan-
marketing
an attachment which they call
trade in this country—a trade in which at lan has leased the building on Washington
the
"Angelus,"
at a price considerably less
present there is a capital invested almost street that the Steinerts will stop work
than
$250.
Meanwhile,
if inventors can
equal to that invested in the manufacture from their new building and immediately
furnish
us
with
something
better in the line
of pianos. The "Columbia" is the best seek quarters near Mr. Scanlan; neither
of
attachments,
or
at
lower
prices than de-
advertised; and, perhaps, is really the can I think that Henry F. Miller & Sons,
manded
by
these
firms,
they
may stand a
standard of the bicycle trade. The second Ivers & Pond, the Merrill Piano Co., C. C.
chance
of
winning
"fame
and
fortune." I
of the Pope Manufacturing Co. is the Harvey, Mason & Hamlin, Chandler W.
am
of
the
opinion
that
we
will
have to wait
"Hartford," a wheel of much lower grade. Smith, on Boylston street; Wm. Bourne &
some
time.
I was desirous of obtaining the opinion Son, Chickering & Sons, Hallet & Davis,
of an expert as to whether the manufacture Vose & Sons, and others who are located
THE Knauff organ factory, at Newark,
of the " Hartford" in the slightest degree on Tremont street, and all the other firm
affected the trade or the standing of the who are interested in the retail piano trade Del., is reported to have been sold for $12,-
"Columbia." The dealer in question told in Boston, will hasten to cancel their 000.

Download Page 6: PDF File | Image

Download Page 7 PDF File | Image

Future scanning projects are planned by the International Arcade Museum Library (IAML).

Pro Tip: You can flip pages on the issue easily by using the left and right arrow keys on your keyboard.