Music Trade Review

Issue: 1882 Vol. 5 N. 12

Music Trade Review -- © mbsi.org, arcade-museum.com -- digitized with support from namm.org
January zoth, 1882.
THE MUSICAL CRITIC AND TRADE REVIEW.
177
monial to many piano makers, and am I not
"You see that the impulse to make too great
physical effort will prompt you to make a new
deprived of the gains that came to me for loafing
fault, when the movement of the exercise breaks
(Continued from page 175.)
outside of concert rooms whilst my wife played
up an old one.
the piano for shekels within?
exercises would only do harm, and that songs were
"So, all points must be guarded. So, the head-
"Where now is thy railroad paper scheme, and intended to acquire vowel sounds and consonants. throwing helps tongue protruding to lengthen the
thy peanut-trade paper scheme, and' thy other We began with the song "Sleep Well," by Abt. muscles that cover the distance from tongue to
I would be frequently interrupted and drilled on bone above the larynx, and from larynx to breast
schemes for ' playing the verdant sucker?' "
the proper pronunciation of the consonant, and bone.
And the Fraud sank into the dust, crying, sometimes no attention was paid to it.
"But head-throwing would not have a good effect
I continued trying, but could not succeed in in many movements for the control of respiration,
"Busted, busted!"
Then did they put on sackcloth and cover their getting the G near the close, and finally gave it and I noticed that your head-throwing was accom-
up and tried others, with not much more success. panied by a contraction of the back muscle, the
heads with ashes.
We had now reached the twenty-fifth lesson, and principle one the
, extending upward
And for the space of three days and three nights the improvement I noticed at first seemed to be through the neck.
gradually
diminishing.
they spoke not a word, which was a great relief to
"I will assure you I do not apply exercises hap-
hazard, but always with an especial object in view.
them that knew them.
ATTACKED BY A SORE THBOAT.
"I will also add that I do not think it possible
And on the fourth day the King spake unto the I was suddenly attacked with a sore throat in
the middle of August, with no signs of a cold, and for you to gain a good delivery by any other
Fraud and said:
means than the exact one we have been trying,
since then my voice has always been husky.
"Lo and behold, I've got it!"
This huskiness was accounted for in various and I do think that you will within a very few
lessons realize marked improvement, etc., etc.
And the Fraud said to himself, "Alas! my poor ways.
"I have only once before had this experience, and
friend!" But he spake aloud unto the King, and
The intercostal muscles were held too rigid; the
I do still think that you will very soon, say within
said unto him, "Thy grammar is defective. Thou diaphragm, abdominal muscles and chest were not a half dozen lessons, think differently," etc. etc.
properly employed; the vocal cords came too near
shouldst have said, 'I've got 'em again;*" and he together,
WASTING MORE TIME ON THE METHOD.
causing crackling qualities, etc.
wept bitterly.
During the winter I was troubled with a cold,
At the next lesson the matter was frankly dis-
Then said the King unto the Fraud, "Know, O probably through my own indiscretion, but sing- cussed, and I decided to try ten lessons more, hav-
Fraud, that my head is level, and it is an idea that ing went on uninterruptedly. I was inclined to ing made a satisfactory arrangement. But at the
think that the cold was causing the trouble, but end of thirteen lessons, making about eighty-three
I have got, and not the jams."
was told that this had only a very slight effect on in all, a whole year, I stopped, being utterly dis-
"Come, now, arise and gird up thy loins, and the voice.
couraged, as I saw very little or no improvement,
take off thy sackcloth, and brush the ashes out of
after having spent an immense amount of time in
PUT THROUGH WITH A VENGEANCE.
thy hair. Anoint thyself with sweet smelling per- I was then put through all kinds of exercises, practicing, and having tried my best.
I had such blind confidence in the Howard
fumes, the odors of Araby the blest, and oil thy often repeating many that I had before, with
Method, that even this time I did not doubt its
flowing locks, and put extra magnetism in thine numerous contradictions; sometimes the teacher efficacy,
although Mr. Howard could not account
almond eyes, and butter thy tongue as in the days would strike something that seemed favorable, and for my lack of progress, and explained that I was
express surprise that he had not thought of it before. an exception, and he felt sure I would come back
of old when thou wert 'a bric-a-brac young man,' I had practiced the head-swinging so much that
after having uselessly tried other methods.
'aoheque-dated-two-weeks-in-advance young man,' it became a habit.
A SENSIBLE CONCLUSION.
'a-seven - hundred - and - fifty - dollar - draft young I was now told that this exercise was harmful,
When I called his attention to the fact that sev-
man,' and go forth, and I will go with thee, for and the process was reversed, swinging the head eral
prominent teachers, whoso method he con-
forward and drawing the tongue in.
thou shalt again work
The larynx was now to be drawn down, and held demned, giving some very convincing arguments,
firmly down, the soft palate drawn up and the jaws had made a number of successful singers, I was
THE PIANOFORTE RACQUET,
lield rigid, while a very slight tone was produced. told that these were also exceptions. I often spoke
and I will help thte work it, for I need an organ
Mr. Howard was very anxious to have me under- to him of other methods and teachers, and after
so that I may again loaf at the doors of concert stand that the larynx was not to be held down in putting his answers and what is contained in his
singing, but that this was only to control certain pamphlets together, it appears that Mr. John
rooms.
Howard and Dr. Lennox Browne are the only ones
"Go forth, I say to thee, for it is a land flowing muscles, and that the larynx was drawn up too having any reliable knowledge on the subject.
much
and
had
not
enough
support,
something
he
with milk and honey, and with the shekels of had never suspected before.
Of course, everybody cannot expect to become
pianoforte and organ makers."
We finally reached the seventieth lesson, and I an artist, but go to our large churches, concerts,
And the Fraud said, "Surely I dare not do this still saw no improvement, although he predicted and society entertainments, and you will surely
hear singers who have been pupils of prominent
thing. My nerve is gone, and the wicked ones good results from this exercise.
I was very much discouraged, and wrote him a New York teachers, and whose singing reflects
would fall upon me and beat me by the wayside." long
letter, in reply to which, I received a letter credit upon their instructors.
But the King stretched forth his hand and dated January 17, 1881, which, in addition to This* is the way to prove theories. This is the
business of a private nature, contained the follow- best argument a teacher can advance, and these
touched the Fraud upon the cheek and said:
should be his testimonials. Where are Mr. How-
"Thy cheek is still sufficient. It is the toughest ing:
ard's Parepas and Santleys?
A CURIOUS LETTER.
cheek I ever touched. Yea, it is even tougher
BAD EFFECTS OF THE "HOWARD" METHOD.
"I
do
not
wonder
that
you
are
dissatisfied,
etc.
than mine. Its toughness is like unto that of the I will say that my own expectations have not been I consulted several other teachers, and all agreed
ancient omnibus horse; and thy jaw-bone is like realized, though f do think you are progressing, that my tone was nasal. Mr. Kofler, my present
unto the jaw-bone of an ass, even like unto that of and have radically gained very much since the teacher, found the same fault, but otherwise my
natural voice seemed to be good, and he thought
my jaw-bone. What fearest. thou? Is not the seat twenty-fifth lesson.
I would make rapid progress; but upon further
"I
still
think
the
A
natural
is
in
the
compass
of
of thy breeches lined with stout hide, even with your voice, and I have all the time thought that investigation with the laryngoscope, my throat
the hide of the alligator and the rhinoceros?"
the voice itself is excellent in quality and in power. was found to be very much inflamed, the cords
"The only point on which I had any misgiving relaxed and greatly debilitated. The pharynx was
So the King prevailed upon the Fraud, and to-
was the pitch, the singing in tune; but that you full of mucus. (Mr. Howard says catarrh does
gether they went forth
have made the most marked improvement in, and not affect the voice.)
TO WORK THE PIANOFOBTE BACQUET.
I consulted several physicians, who found the
I do not now have that feeling in regard to it.
"As regards the respiratory effort, you have sev- same trouble, and all agree in saying that the cords
SKLAH !!
eral times made it perfectly, through the latter do not come near enough together, which is generally
The burning of the King Theatre in Vienna has part of a lesson; for instance, the lesson before the the case, and they very seldom come too near together.
After a course of medical treatment, my voice
had the effect of diminishing the attendance at all last one.
"The trouble is, I have not succeeded in finding is much improved, but the cords are still inflamed,
German theatres, just as the Brooklyn tire did in
this country for a few weeks in 1876. In Salz- a routine of practice that would hold it. At the and my progress is, of course, much slower than
burg, two weeks ago, only thirty or forty persons last lessons you had in a slight measure lost the was expected.
composed an audience. At the Thalia Theatre in power of letting the whole chest and ribs be free In spite, however, of these great obstacles 1
Hamburg, where usually there is not even stand- from downward effort, except the downward heav- have noticed considerable improvement. The
ing room on Sundays, there were only fifty per- ing caused by the abdominal muscles and dia- nasal tone and huskiness have entirely disap-
sons present at a Sunday performance, three weeks phragm, and the vocal cords were again too peared, and I am convinced that I am not an
ago. This theatre is in an exceptionally bad condi- nearly approximated, and you made the crackling. exceptional case, and that the old Italian method
"It is always due to too great nearness of the is the only reliable one, and our great reformers,
tion. The gallery at the Stadt Theatre was almost
empty. In Breslau the fire had a similar effect, cords, and my saying that the cause was in the vocal Morses and Edisons, can only corrupt it.
and in Prague it was found necessary to close the chest was meant to refer to the muscular effort Before I began with the Howard Method my
local theatre because no one came to see the play. which constricted the chest and sympathetically voice was in a perfectly healthy condition, and as
The theatre in Presburg, an old, remarkable excited the cord-approaching muscles. In that I sang only a very little, and never took a lesson
before, my habits could not have been bad. I en-
structure, was closed by the police, who found sense the difficulty did lie in the chest.
that it was a regular man-trap. In Pesth there
"The exercises often contradict each other, but deavored to carry out Mr. Howard's instructions
were no audiences, and in Baden, near Vienna, they are changed to break up different faults. I to the letter.
one night not a single ticket was sold. A single make you raise the chest to loosen the contraction
During all this time our social intercourse was
reporter composed the entire audience.—If. Y. of internal rib muscles, that in, muscles uniting the very pleasant, but society and business are very
Sun.
ribs on the inside, for these muscles cramp the different matters.
chest down and in.
As a teacher, I found him very unsystematic,
Clara Louise Kellogg recently paid the peniten-
"I make you lower the chest, having first raised and I now feel just as anybody else would after
tiary and asylum at Lincoln, Neb., a visit, and it, so that you may relax or loosen external rib spending a whole year and a considerable sum of
J. BURHENNE,
sang for the inmates. She was escorted by Gov. muscles, which unite the ribs on the outside and money for nothing.
would raise the chest.
Nance.
No. 141 Bedford ave., Brooklyn, N. Y.
VOICE-TRAINING.
Music Trade Review -- © mbsi.org, arcade-museum.com -- digitized with support from namm.org
January 20th, 1882.
178
THE MUSICAL CRITIC AND TRADE REVIEW.
has received a most hearty welcome in Chicago,
and is pronounced by the papers and musical
critics to be one of the best violinists in the world.
The managers of the college some time since
opened a department of history of music, free to
all the pupils of the college, and placed it under
the competent charge of Mr. John J. Haltstaedt,
whose lectures are already among the most enter-
taining and instructive features of the college
course.
Harmony and composition. This important
branch of musical education is under the manage-
ment of Mr. A. Ruff, who makes a specialty of
instruction in harmony, single and double counter-
point, canon and fugue. He has given much time
and study to the theory of music, and is considered
by the best authorities in Europe a competent and
conscientious teacher.
The department of elocution is in the excellent
hands of Mrs. Anna Cowell Hobkirk, a lady who
has a national reputation as an elocutionist, and
also many years experience upon the dramatic
stage, where she achieved wide-spread fame. The
readings of Mrs. Hobkirk's pupils at the college
GrEO. H . WlIiSON.
entertainments have been a special feature of the
BOSTON, January 9, 1882.
programmes, and many of her pupils have obtained
excellent and well-paying positions.
THE CHICAGO MUSICAL COLLEGE.
The best idea of the present standard of the
r
I "^HIS institution is the oldest school of musical school can be gathered from the remarks made by
_L culture in the West, and enjoys a reputa- Dr. F. Ziegfeld on the occasion of the last com-
tion second to no other in the United States. It mencement exercises:
"In connection with the graduating exercises of
was founded in 1867 by Dr. F. Ziegfeld, who has
from the first conducted the school on the plan this, the fourteenth annual commencement of the
favored by the best European conservatories, of Chicago Musical College, and as preliminary to
which he is a distinguished graduate. The insti- the awarding of the diplomas, gold medals and
tution first occupied rooms in Crosby's Opera teachers' certificates, it seems proper that I should
House, but soon outgrew its accommodations, and very briefly lay before you a few hints as to the
an entire building on Wabash avemie was fitted growth of the college, its methods and results
up in handsome style for its use. Surrounded It was established in 1867, commencing in a small
by an able corps of teachers, Dr. Ziegfeld had way; it has steadily grown and commended itself
already achieved a large patronage and great suc- to the public until now it can boast that nearly one
cess when the fire of 1871 swept away building, thousand pupils have studied within its walls dur-
furniture, pianos, organs, and a valuable collec- ing the school year which closes to-night, while in
lection of music. But this institution had a fu- the years which have passed it has sent out into
ture before it. Conflagrations could not burn up their spheres of usefulness many fine players and
its reputation or damp its managers. A new singers. I think you will all admit that such
building was at once secured at 493 Wabash ave- results prove that the college has secured the
nue, with branches in other sections of the city, services of the best teachers that could be found.
and a new career of prosperity began. As soon as The college occupies spacious rooms in Central
the Central Music Hall, the pride of our city, was Music Hall building, a branch at 44Loomisstreet,
erected, Dr. Ziegfeld secured elegant rooms in in the West Division of the city, and also addi-
this building, and to-day the school stands higher tional localities in the South and North Divisions
in public esteem than ever before. It is evident which are not publicly advertised, as they are for
that this esteem is not merely local. The presi- the personal convenience of pupils. Many pupils
dent and directors of the celebrated Leipzig Con- are also taught at their own residences. The ser-
vices of twenty teachers are employed to cover
servatory say:
this broad field. Pupils who have a thorough
"From Mr. Ziegfeld's artistic accomplishments knowledge of our method of instruction, and who
and his conscientiousness as a teacher, we feel safe manifest the ability to impart their knowledge to
in concluding that the instruction of the college others, receive, after a very strict examination, the
is of the most thorough description. The scholars teacher's certificate. The regular diploma and
who have come to us from this institution have gold medal are awarded to pupils who have com-
shown such careful and symmetrical development pleted the whole course prescribed by the authori-
that we are convinced that the Chicago Musical ties of the Chicago Musical College, after a very
College is a most reliable school."
searching examination, and these pupils leave the
Such praise as this is praise indeed, and yet from college as graduates of the institution. The regu-
our knowledge of this college and the many pupils lar graduates are also entitled to the teacher's
of surprising excellence it has graduated, we are certificate.
conviced that the estimate of the Leipzig Conser-
"I have no hesitation in recommending to public
vatory directors is a just one. The method pur-
sued in this college is very thorough. None but patronage any graduates of this institution who
musical instructors of the highest order of merit have received the diploma and gold medal, or who
are employed as members of the faculty, and can show its teacher's certificate. You may rely
mediocrity in any department would not be suf- upon it that those entrusted to their care will be
fered for a moment. Dr. Ziegfeld is a compeer of in good hands. In this respect the college oc-
the leading musicians of the old world, and enjoys cupies a normal position, which entitles it to com-
the personal friendship of nearly all the great pare without prejudice with any similar institu-
artists of the day. His pride in the profession of tion even in the older Eastern cities. I have thus
his choice is so great that he could not be induced briefly set before you the prominent facts in rela-
to countenance a sacrifice of art to any financial tion to our school. As the president of the col-
lege, and, in behalf of its faculty, I thank you,
consideration.
and gentlemen, for the patronage you have
To this fact is due the artistic triumph of the ladies
upon it, and the confidence you have
Chicago Musical College. The soirees given by bestowed
in it, and I assure you, in the future as in
this institution are always musical events, and are reposed
shall be our joint endeavor to keep the
an important factor in the training of the pupils. the past, it up
to its present high standard and to
On these occasions the best class of music is pro- institution
improve every department, whenever and wher-
duced.
ever the opportunity occurs. It only remains for
The piano is under the personal direction of Dr. me to bestow the rewards of merit which have
F. Ziegfeld. The vocal department is in the been earned by faithful application—the diploma
hands of Mr. L. A. Phelps, a graduate of the Chi- and gold medal of the college—to twelve ladies,
cago Mnsical College, who returned in August, and the teacher's certificate to ten others, to all of
1879, from his five years' study abroad with Luigi whom I desire to extend the best wishes of the
Vanuccini, at Florence, and Francesco Lamperti, college for their future success."—Chicago Weekly
of Milan, Italy. Mr. Phelps has met with unpre- Herald.
cedented success in Chicago, and is without doubt
the most popular instructor of vocal music in the
Northwest, and unsurpassed by any in the United Verdi is spending the winter at Genoa.
Statos.
An amusing performance of "The Rat-Charmer
Mr. Louis Falk, whose reputation as a musician of Hamelin" was given at the Germania Theatre on
and skill as an organist, are well known all over December 17. Mr. Merton sang the title role
the country, has the organ department in charge. effectively and in an artistic manner. Some of the
Mr. Edouard Heimendahl, the celebrated solo vio- minor parts, however, could have been materially
linist, is at the head of the violin department. He improved in other hands.
PERFORMANCES
VOCAL METHODS.
rT^O the Editor of THE MUSICAL CRITIC AND TBADE
_L REVIEW—Dear Sir: I take the liberty of
sending you the circular of the most radical man
in Boston, as regards music in general, but partic-
ularly concerning the voice. You may find it in-
teresting, and I can tell you from personal ex-
perience how excellent are the results from his
sensible teaching: not agreeing with your editorial
in the present number of your review. I had the
misfortune to waste three years with one of the
so-called "best teachers" in Boston. I send this
for your edification without Mr. Davenport's
knowledge. The matter on the last page of the
circular does not need a defense, though it may
be less understood by the very class it ought to
benefit. Mr. Davenport is wholly impersonal in
his criticism, being a well-known writer on musical
subjects; he attacks a system rather than an indi-
vidual, and is always sure of a throng of readers.
I enjoy your paper, and think you ought to
know something of Mr. D.'s principle of teaching
and action.
Very respectfully,
PHILHARMONIC CONCERT.
r
T^HE third Philharmonic Concert of the present
JL season, and at the same time the one hun-
dred and ninety-sixth concert given by this society,
took place at the Academy of Music January 14.
Haydn's D major symphony (in the Breitkopf
and Hartel edition, the No. 2,) is an interesting ex-
ample of the regulation symphonies, as we may
call many of the works of some of the old com-
posers.
In placing it in the Philharmonic programme,
Mr. Thomas must have been actuated by one of the
impulses of veneration which now and then
come over every musician. The intrinsic poetical
merit of such a symphony is comparatively small
now, but its value as a study, in counterpoint and
musical form, makes it attractive to the student,
and to the musician its historical position adds in-
terest to its production.
There is in every community a small band of
ardent admirers of old Father Haydn's works, who
will go into ecstacies whenever any of his too nu-
merous compositions are played. There was an
opportunity at the Philharmonic concert for a little
raving, especially as it was played nearly to per-
fection.
If a genius composes as much as Haydn did, no
doubt can exist that a good deal of bad and indif-
ferent matter will be sent down to posterity.
Taking only a few classes of his composition, we
calculate that he composed overtures to plays and
operas and also symphonies, in all combined, 125;
compositions for wind instruments with strings,
about 66; he composed 77 quartettes and 68 trios;
20 piano concertos and 53 piano sonatas.
These are only a portion of his instrumental
works, to say nothing of his vocal compositions,
consisting of his 14 masses, his oratorios, "The
Creation," '"The Seasons," etc., etc. Many of his
works were never printed, but remain in manu-
script. We welcome an occasional production of
a Haydn work for reasons above given, but feel
that much more real benefit cbuld be derived if
our modern composers were cultivated.
The interest in the concert was centred upon the
Beethoven's No. 4 piano concerto, Rafael Joseffy
soloist. The acknowledged high position which
Joseffy occupies has been disputed in only one di-
rection, and that is the claim his admirers made
that he was a Beethoven interpreter. It was until
this time generally admitted that he is exception-
ally skillful as a pianist, especially as a Chopin and
a Liszt pianist, but as an interpreter of the immor-
tal concertos of Beethoven, he failed to satisfy a
class of dilletanti. After his performance of the
No. 4 concerto at the Philharmonic concert, there
can be no further dispute as to Joseffy's position
in the rank of great living pianists.
This was an occasion where a Beethoven con-
certo really became imposing, and where the
profound idea was thoroughly and comprehen-
sively exposed. Every measure had its distinct
value, and the whole work became a symphony,
just as it was intended by the master. Josefty's
playing portrayed a clear, concise and intellectual
idea, presenting to our understanding in distinct
forms and with poetic intensity what a Beethoven"
concerto is. He selected the Rubinstein cadeuzas,
playing them, and, in fact, the whole work, with
perfect technique.
In the andante he showed us what effects legato
playing can produce. The most refined effects
that can be drawn out of the piano depend upon
the proper applications of the legato. Every great
teacher is constantly impressing a study of this
particular branch of pianoforte playing upon his
pupils; it is looked upon as the best means of pre-
senting the piano as a musical instrument, as the
technique is secondary when the legato is essential.
Joseffy gave us the most delicate and cultivated
example of it in the andante, and by means of it he
brought out the chiaoscuro which is usually hidden,
but which is so important to a perfect production
of a great concerto.
His recall was decidedly pronounced, and af-
ter vainly endeavoring to elude it, he was com-
pelled to play an encore, very properly selecting
a Bach aria e praeludium, arranged by himself, and
played with noble tone, broad phrasing, and, as a
matter of course, with his exceptional perfect
technique. The position of Josefl'y as a master
pianist cannot be successfully attacked after the
brilliant furore on the occasion referred to. It*
was an artistic success of the very highest order.
Schumann's No. 3 symphony, the Rhenish, was
rendered with splendid effect. The andante, and
especially the religioso movements, must be se-
lected as the best numbers played by the society

Download Page 11: PDF File | Image

Download Page 12 PDF File | Image

Future scanning projects are planned by the International Arcade Museum Library (IAML).

Pro Tip: You can flip pages on the issue easily by using the left and right arrow keys on your keyboard.