C.O.C.A. Times

Issue: 2003-March - Vol 1 Num 1

geared toward character assassination than patent
rights. The defense attorney, Paul Paul, really
pinned back the ears of Ernest Chester. Chester tes-
~----.--------.,-,--.......,..,..---, tified that they took
no photos of the
Hoot Mon, but they
had already submit-
ted those photos they
took in an earlier
deposition! Chester
was forced to admit
December 1927. A man stopped into St. Paul
that he'd modified
(Minnesota) Recreation pool hall. It was Mr.
the Hoot Mon photo
Elsasser, a private detective working for Chester-
to make the ad for
Pollard. He had a proposition for Mr. Dunn, the pro-
their game. When
prietor. "Sell us this Hoot Mon golf game". A deal
Chester-Pollard real-
was struck. The machine was spirited away to a St.
ly got hurt was
Paul photographer who took the shots shown in this
where attorney Paul,
article and which were later introduced at the trial.
showed that little if
Then the machine was shipped out to New York for
anything in the
study.
Chester-Pollard patents applied to the Hoot Mon
Idea stealing in the coin-op business? Shocking! game. And whatever did apply was invalid due to
The problem was, Popular Games had the same prior art. Prior art is a patent related term that states
kind of lease deal as Chester-Pollard and when they if items from your patent application were used pre-
found the game gone they screamed bloody murder. viously in other patents, your patent is invalid
Dunn hustled off a telegram to Chester-Pollard say- because it copies this prior art (information). So
ing "I need the game back quick!" Chester-Pollard Paul essentially claimed they had no case. The
replied "stall them a little bit, it'll be back soon." judge agreed, and sent down a decision finding no
Chester-Pollard didn't even have a game ready yet, validity to the lawsuit, Chester-Pollard losing the
and the competition already has one on location! case. By the end of the trial Chester-Pollard had
What to do? On December 9th they filed a patent made only about 250 of the small cabinet game, and
infringement lawsuit against Popular Games Inc. still had no large cabinet game. They eventually
The on December 17th they ran another ad warning made one of course, in quantity. Popular Games had
patent infringers against making a golf game and orders for about 250 Hoot Mon games, but the com-
also touting their large cabinet game. Now the pany didn't last long. The lawsuit, general inexperi-
photo of this game's real treat. It has the Hoot Mon ence, and having no new game to sell would doom
cabinet with a Chester-Pollard Football marquee the company. Al Walzer would surface again to
and Football front. Remember the Football only has make more games, but that's another story.
two of the same controls on the front, so they called
it a two player game and showed 2 little golfers
inside! Adobe Photoshop would have been handy!
5¢ Coin Game.
They never made the game, but they had to do
Large cabinet.
something to stop the competition.
Built for
He was a bit of a rookie though, and spilled the
beans about the Chester-Pollard game, stating
"we're coming out with a game. It's nothing like
yours." Chester-Pollard's running scared. This large
game could really hurt them. So they ran a huge ad
in the October 1st Billboard promotion their small
one and five cent games. But in a small note in the
corner of the ad, they mentioned their "exclusive
large cabinet model".Their what? No such thing!
-~~~~~~~~
special locations.
Enclosing two golf
figures, realistic
golf course with its
hazzards, mounds,
lakes and colo,ful
golf course scent.
The trial started in the summer 1928. Chester-
Pollard claimed patent infringement. They had pur-
chased patents in 1927 related to golf games, the
earliest deal completed on July 21st, 1927. This is
almost two months after Popular Games started
making games. Coincidence? Probably not. They
bought two other patents later that year to back up
their claim. They all related to golf games, but were
they infringement? The case for Chester-Pollard
was argued by. Their testimony seemed more
29
SPRINGFIELD, OHIO
by John Carini
We took a short trip in September to Springfield, OH. I
had read about the Springfield, Oh flea market in the
Antique Trader and it sounded like a good one.
Especially on the dates we were going to attend - it was
labeled a flea market extravaganza, huge! I also figured
we would pass through Indianapolis where we had
already discovered a few nice antique malls. We started
out at 3:00 am Friday morning, so we could get to the
flea market before it opened at noon. Unfortunately, it
was raining hard, and the weather report said rain all day.
So, we decided we should visit most of the antique shops
on Friday, and do the flea market on Saturday when it
was expected to clear.
way we saw signs for an antique town, not far off the
freeway, Waynesville. Waynesville is known for its
antique shops, but the town's main street has been
dubbed "America's Most Haunted." According to
Ripley's Believe It or Not, four sisters wee simultane-
ously killed by a ball of lightning that came down the
chimney of their farmhouse and struck them all, though
each was in a different room. We didn't find any ghosts
there, but we did visit a number of small antique shops
in town. Too bad there wasn't much coin-op to be found.
However, one shop - fashioned after an old drug store,
had some incredible chewing gum displays.
Unfortunately they were display only and not for sale.
First we stopped at Webb's Antique mall in Centerville,
In. We had visited this shop before and found it to be a
wonderful antique shop. I picked up a Mercury Marvel
Trade stimulator for $250 (see
photo). It's in nice original condi-
tion. The shop also had other coin-
op machines, such as Imp 's
($265.), 1940's stamp machines, a
Silver King ($145), cash registers,
juke boxes and old advertising
which were priced above book
value.
By the time we got to Springfield, it was almost 7:00 pm.
We knew the shops would be open late because of the
flea market. There are 2 huge malls within a mile of each
other, practically right across the street from where the
flea market is held. We start- r - - - - ----.-:=i.,,.,....,_,..,.
ed off at the Springfield
Antique Center. We spent
over an hour there and found
a number of coin-op
machines
including
a
Billiards
Automation
machine (see photo). This
1930's mini-pool table
machine was made by ABT Co. It was priced at $2195.
, __
We also found a 1960's aspirin machine
• ~ '
priced at $125. (see photo). In the last
I
"!~::.,,,,,
aisle, we found 2 coin-op machines -
Skeet Shoot and The Hunter, priced at
-c~ ... •
$150. and $225 . respectively. Near the
check out counters we found 2 old
~, .., •• tJ
~ 1930's Pinball machines, Ballyhoo and
. . . . . . .
a Five Star Final, priced at $750. each.
-· ,
- We wanted to save our cash for the flea
market the next day, but purchased a Sun peanut
machine, painted black.
After Webb's we decided to try the Brass Armadillo in
Cincinnati. My wife drove, and I awoke to find she had
stopped at an old school house that had been converted
to an antique shop on the side of the road. I told her and
my son to check it out, and continued to snooze in the
car. They came to get me, and told me I really should go
in. Inside, I found a Master, Regal hot nut, and a blue
Silver King all lined up next to each other on the count-
er. They weren 't priced. The store owner was on the
phone and looked pissed that we had actually interrupt-
ed his call to ask the prices. He threw out some ridicu-
lously high prices. I thought I could negotiate a fair price
on the Master, but he told me he could easily get $450.
down south. I stared in amazement, and told him I was a
dealer and had similar machines and would be glad to
sell them to him for a mere fraction of the price. We
moved on.
iii;'
We drove to the next mall, The AAA I-70 Antique Mall,
which was less than a mile away. It was 8:30, and the
~ - - - - - mall was scheduled to close at 9:00 so
we knew we didn't have much time.
There we found a 1940's Silver King
hot nut machine with a cracked globe
priced at $129. We tried to bargain, but
they wouldn't budge much. Then we
found a Pix Match machine (see photo)
priced at $880. In the case directly
~ ~ = ~ ~ = i J across from the match machine we
We stopped at the Cincinnati Brass Armadillo. I like this
chain of antique shops and have visited Brass Armadillo
shops in other large cities, like Denver, Des Moines, and
Phoenix. The shop was large and had lots of nice adver-
tising, but we only found a few common coin-op
machines. We decided to head to Springfield. On the
30

Download Page 29: PDF File | Image

Download Page 30 PDF File | Image

Future scanning projects are planned by the International Arcade Museum Library (IAML).

Pro Tip: You can flip pages on the issue easily by using the left and right arrow keys on your keyboard.